Post number two to this forum I think, corresponding to...broken clavicle number 2!! Uggh. I can't find any response to my original post, so here's a quick synopsis, because now I'm past two years recovered from my first break, and one week into my second break (other arm good for comparison!)
.
My ortho this visit last week told me of a recent study of as many clavicle cases they could find (as reported in Journal of Orthopaedics or something) revealing three important points to consider when considering the healing/union potential of a clavicle break such as is common:
1. If you're 18 or under it will ALWAYS fuse back together
2. If you SMOKE chances of healing back together are significantly decreased
3. No method of measuring distances of separation have been identified as indicative of chances of fusing back together
Now my story:
I snapped my left clavicle playing Shaun White during my first experience going super big in a super pipe snowboarding. The healing took longer than I wanted, but my ortho kept pushing a 'wait for it' approach. Here is a 15 degree x-ray at two months, no surgery, and I was weak but mostly ROM and strength felt like it was returning. Yikes it looked bad! But...
So first, a recap: it's two years later and I never got surgery. I am a big swimmer so was quite aggravated at this break, which really impeded my swimming, bringing along with it a nice 'click and strain' feel when I first got back in the pool. Two or three months from this moment I had my first triathlon (olympic distance) scheduled. By this time I had not gotten back to swimming I think. But at the three month mark, I was able to get back in the pool and slowly build up swimming form/confidence again. I ended up finishing the tri without trouble, way out of shape relative to what I had hoped, but no matter: finishing a tri with a recent break and without surgery was pretty exciting.
Since that time I've regained full motion, strength, alignment, and swim form. I've even gotten back my butterfly stroke (didn't have pre-break lol). On those grounds, I'd say that not getting surgery was for certain the right call. I do have a nice bump on my shoulder from it, but it's a great story, and serious bragging rights for still being really active/athletic and having recovered naturally. My thoughts: if you aren't a professional (i.e. paid, sponsored, funded) athlete and you have a choice (from your ortho, NOT a forum!), try naturally first. It took me three months of being unsure before my bone 'took' (and it was about 2cm of separation). Now it's 100% and I swear it feels stronger because of the 'extra bone plating'
.
NOW! Fast forward (lol): last weekend, enjoying my second snowboard trip out this season, topping off a great day in the park with a few runs down the back side of the mountain. A less exciting circumstance, I got run into from behind as I rode down a mostly empty slope (granted I was the one flying and the guy might not have seen me/been able to avoid me..whoops). An otherwise simple fall turned into some lever action I think I knocked me quick onto my shoulder, and snap!
Anyway, only 1cm of separation this time, but I have matching collarbones now!
Going the same route: eat lots of broccoli (much more calcium than milk!), keep in sling even at night for a couple weeks (otherwise your body forgets and you will try to roll over with it), and probably three weeks til I start trying to jog, ride bike machine. Like previous break, bone length looks like it'll be unaffected and recovery will be to 100%. I'm optimistic, amazed what the body can do on its own, and am only preaching my anecdote
. I'm 30 by the way (strike findings #1 against me =/).
Here's latest break (right) at day three:
I'll try to remember to post follow ups!