Quoted post said:Originally posted by Randybaker99
OK, what dhk and I are referring to is LTHR (Lactate Threshold Heart Rate) not LT, I will give you that. But, since most of us don't have access to a sports lab, and since a Heart Rate Monitor is 1/20th the price of a decent power meter ($50USD vs $1,000USD), most people are willing to use an *ESTIMATED* LTHR as a *ROUGH* approximation of the Lactate Threshold. Maybe they will be off by 5-10%, but, since most of us won't be in the Tour this year, I think we will get by!
Ric, first, thanks for providing accurate, detailed information. Second, I respect your recurring need to set the record straight. However, I think that the interests of folks who are simply trying to figure all this stuff out, are not always well served by your "clarifications". I guess what I am saying is - lighten up a little. You are making it sound like if you don't have access to advanced tools, then you shouldn't even bother - not true. Precision is great, but I would rather work with an estimate than have nothing at all. Unfortunately, those are my options - and I think my situation is representative of many others here.
just because the majority of us here (myself included) won't be riding the Tour de France (or similar) doesn't mean we don't want accurate, useful, reliable information. sure, it doesn't suit everyone, but, then inaccurate data doesn't suit everyone either.
by writing my clarification about LT, i was pointing out that a) LT is *NOT* TT power (it's less intense), and b) it *can't* be measured with HR.
i understand that many people don't have access to a power meter, and use HR. additionally, i further understand that *some* people use the expression LT incorrectly (i.e., for a HR that is elicited by riding a TT). however, in other parts of life where a word is used incorrectly we tend to correct the person. for e.g., if someone kept referring to a chair as a table we'd either correct them or be confused about what they were talking about.
in regards to HR being a proxy for actual intensity and what the error might be (i.e., you mentioned 5 to 10%), at TT power my HR can vary from ~ 165 to 180+ b/min (at the same power) due to differences in temperature, environmental conditions, and state of fatigue. that's ~15+ b/min difference, it's very difficult to set zones based on such varied data.
Ric