Old Mother Ashby said:Bob (this one) said:Old Mother Ashby said:Bob (this one) wrote:
> Rolled out a crust and put it into a 10-inch, deep-dish pie plate.
> Chopped up some large Gala apples, tossed them with cinnamon,
> ginger, nutmeg, cloves and allspice, and a couple tablespoons corn
> starch. Dumped them into the shell. Cut a couple huge Honeycrisp
> apples into wedges and laid the over top of the chopped galas.
> Sliced some thin and laid them in a circle in the center to be the
> "flower" decoration. Sprinkled the spice mixture over the outer,
> apple-wedge pattern; left the center plain. Put dabs of butter all
> around. Baked at 375°.
>
> When it was done, I melted some homemade (very pale-colored) grape
> jelly (1/2 white grapes, 1/2 ruby grapes), added a good bit of
> Applejack and apple juice, and corn starch. Cooked it to thicken
> into a shiny glaze. Poured some into the spaces and brushed the
> whole top with it. Total of 8 apples. Lasted through dinner. Warmed,
> vanilla ice cream.
>
> <http://i1.tinypic.com/mwcglc.jpg>
>
> Pastorio
Looks great, but if I would call it a [censored], not a pie. What do you
call the version that has a lid on?
A two-apple pie. This one was about 3 inches deep. My sense of [censored]
is that they're generally rather shallow. Lids aren't what define
pies; there doesn't seem to be a definitive meaning. Lemon meringue
pie. Pumpkin pie. Boston cream pie.
Pastorio
Ah, the joys of a common language! Lemon meringue pie is a specific dish,
like shepherd's pie, and they neither of them have a pastry lid.
Mine was a specific dish - a "two-apple pie" - with the same
characteristics as the ones mentioned. Hence, a pie. And Boston cream
pie is actually a cake. The point is that it's rather an arbitrary
nomenclature at work here.
Quoted message said:It's
just that around here [censored] denotes something open, never has a lid on
it. [censored] are not usually any shallower than pies apart from the extra
layer of pastry.
I don't know where "around here" is. This two-apple pie was this deep:
you could stick your index finger in it all the way to the knuckle and
part way up the palm. It's a deep-dish pie in USan terms. Here, [censored]
are usually upscale, hoity-toity things with fruits and berries glazed
to a gelid fare-thee-well and maybe up to the second joint of that finger.
My earliest culinary training is French where [censored] are generally thin
things; single layers of fruit, sometimes on a cheese or other base also
in the crust. Some rustic, free-form ones can be deeper, but never are
they as deep as this two-apple pie I made.
Quoted message said:Next stop the great Anglo/American confusion about "pudding"! (If memory
serves me, Americans think it's a cold dish, Aussies think it's hot and
the Brits use the term for desserts of any sort.)
Not confusion, merely different usages. Cleave and cleave. Pot roast and
oven roast.
Pastorio