john_childs said:You learn skills, not tricks. Skills are what you learn. Tricks are what
you do to impress. 😉
Riding and idling one footed is a good skill. You can add variations
like riding with the foot extended out front (like you're doing a high
kick) instead of on the frame. Or idling with one leg crossed over the
other.
I'm somewhat fuzzy when it comes to differentiating between a trick and
a skill. Time to don my full-face helmet, as not everyone will agree
with what I'm about to say.
At first I thought that mister childs had the same opinions of tricks
vs skills that I had, but then he goes on to say that "riding and
idling one footed" is a "skill".
In my book a "skill" is a technique which gives you the ability to get
your unicycle over terrain or obstacles or dealing with unexpected
situations without a UPD. For instance, hopping is a skill because you
can get up steps etc. Idling is a skill because you may need to stop
briefly at some point, as is riding backwards.
A "trick" is something which looks impressive but isn't necessarily
useful. I really do question why john_childs puts one-footed riding
into the "skill" pigeonhole, how exactly does one footed riding help
when it comes to riding in general situations? It's a little more
unstable and you spread your arms out, and somehow I doubt you'd be
able to do it on rough terrain.
Until recently, the pinnacle of my definition of a "trick" was a
unispin. Sure it does look impressive, but otherwise isn't really
useful. Defect has tens of clips of people doing unispins whilst
jumping on, over and off obstacles. Doing that with the unicycle
straight is good enough in itself; adding a unispin seems harder and
yet at the end of the day still gets you over obstacles the same way.
In other words, the same obstacle clearance ability as just hopping
over it. So why bother unispinning?
At the Dartmoor muni weekend, 'Paul Royle did a unispin off-road on a
29er' (http://flippet.fotopic.net/p29823633.html). Why? Just rolling
over the terrain to get over it would have been fine for me.
The most pointless trick I know is the crankflip; (as I understand it)
you rolling-hop the uni forwards whilst jumping, kicking the pedals so
they spin round and then land back on them. Again I've seen many videos
of people jumping on, over and off stuff whilst crankflipping. You've
put in all that time and effort into hopping and jumping over stuff, so
why make it even harder by vastly increasing the risk of being
pedal-whacked in the shins and then missing the pedals for the landing
with resulting injury?
A couple of tricks are intermediate towards learning skills. Such as
riding with stomach on the seat, it looks ridiculous and at first
pointless. But from there you "graduate" to seat-out riding, then
seat-out hopping, then finally to the skill of jumping seat-out onto
ever higher stuff.
Another example is wheel-walking; again not much point apart from
showing off, but then comes one-footed wheel-walking and then the grand
skill of gliding downhill at speed giving your feet a rest. In a way.
Does anyone else think that many tricks are just for showing off? Or am
I missing the point?
--
gkmac
"It's a marvellous thing to see, someone in full flight on the
unicycle." - Stuart Maconie, Radio 2
"Oh no! Both my toes have gone numb!" - Joe Hodges
"You also met me gk! I was the one eating the sandwich!" - Adam Gayne
"Act your tyre pressure, not your age." - rob.northcott
------------------------------------------------------------------------
gkmac's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/4577
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/52519