Doug Freyburger said:Annie said:
I've been on and off the Atkins yo-yo for the last 2 years or so (I'm
silly!).
Have you remained on Induction each time or have you followed the
basic instructions by moving on to OWL on day 15 each time?
There is an asssortment of reasons why I ask that question.
Actually I've tried to stay on induction as long as I could handle it.
After that, I would slowly introduce things like low carb berries and a
small amount of nuts. Definately no chocolate, potatoes, bread or any of
the other stuff generally high carb.
Quoted message said:One reason is that if you've been on and off the plan several times,
what's kicking you off plan? Staying on Induction can be using
Mostly things like the occasional latte at Starbucks, or wanting my
favourite alcohol beverage (scotch/whiskey).
Quoted message said:Atkins as a fad diet, or it can be an attempt at all-or-nothing. The
most common result of an all-or-nothing approach is nothing. When
I know 🙁
Quoted message said:it comes down to it folks who stay on the fad variation have a higher
drop-out rate than folks who continue into the process and move
towards making it a permanent system they can live with.
I see what you mean. I sometimes feel that I don't lose that much weight
with induction, so I figure as it is most effective, its best to stay on
it for as long as possible.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:My biggest downfall has always been special occasions
(birthdays, holidays etc) so this time I am going to try triple hard
because I know that after I've been on it a while, I always feel
healthier, more energetic and spend less money on food. Oh yeah.. and
sometimes I lose weight 🙂
Another reason is the crash-and-burn effect. One of many points of
OWL and the carb ladder is to learn your trigger foods. Once you've
learned those you know exactly what foods are and aren't a risk
What is a trigger food? And even if you know what it is, how can you
resist it all the time? I don't think I could follow any WOE that says
"you can never, ever have french fries again"
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:FYI I am 29 years old, around 71 kgs, about 5'3" and on my second week
of induction (with strips showing purple)
At that height and weight you're not particularly overweight. Have
I am a UK 16, sliding slowly downwards. I'm quite short and carry all my
weight on my thighs, stomach and a little on my butt. It really really
shows. I feel like I look pregnant half the time!
I'm not expecting miracles, but to be honest for my height I should be
less than 70kg. More like 55kg.
Quoted message said:you considered just going with no junk food and as natural as you
can pull off? That is, a non-extreme system that should be easy
to live with that should have you drift down in weight?
Even when I was eating carby stuff I rarely ate junk food. Maybe once a
fortnight I'd have McDonalds. I also rarely snacked on biscuits,
chocolate, chips etc. My biggest problem was that I always had to have
a carby "side" with every meal. Mashed potatoes is my alltime favourite.
Sometimes rice, rarely pasta. But mostly potatoes. Chipped, mashed,
roasted. Breadcrumbs on schnitzels.. that sort of thing. Still loads of
salad though (which I still can't give up!)
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:In addition I try to get a few glasses of water in a day, but mostly I
have to say (somewhat sheepishly) that I drink around 3-4 cans of Diet
Coke a day.
Note that aspartame is the artificial sweetener with the highest
rate of problems. None of them have zero problems but aspartame
is the worst. Have you considered switching to Diet Diet and moving
down in the number of cans?
I haven't seen any diet drinks available here in the UK which don't use
aspartame 🙁 But you're right, it is too much. I will try to replace
fizzy drinks with fizzy soda water (the only water I really like)
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:So.. thats it. I love the plan above but if theres anything in it that
I am seriously doing wrong, please tell me.
The biggest issue is the aspatame followed by the caffeine. Plenty
of people have no problem with either but your history of falling
off plan is worrisome.
Sorry for my ignorance - but what does aspartame and caffeine have to do
with falling off plan?
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:My biggest worry is my
vegetable intake - I eat a LOT of salad and I know you're only meant
for 2 cups on induction but I can't keep to this.
Are you deducting fiber? If you are then the cup guidelines are
Err no. To be honest I've been slack with those carbs. I have not
limited myself with vegetables - lettuce, cucumber, tomato, spring onion
are all incorporated into lunch and almost always dinner. I don't count
the carbs, the cups nor the fibre. I think I am fooling myself into
thinking "vegetables are good for you, therefore eat as much as you
need"
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:I'd be happier losing
weight slower but still getting the salad veggies I love so much.
Yup, switch to the net counts and ignore the obsolete cup guideline
that only applied to total counts.
Would that mean weighing everything?
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:So thats about it.. any comments would be very appreciated!
Consider carefully exactly why you fell off plan previous times. Would
you have been able to stay on-plan if you had followed the basic
directions, moved on to OWL, used the carb ladder, learned your
trigger foods, and known exactly what you can and can't eat during
a splurge? Because the problem sure isn't your gourmet food.
Well the original problem was me asking if the food I had listed was OK
or too much.
As it is, I now eat 3 times a day and thats it. No snacking or feeling
hungry between meals. I wanted to make sure this result was not because
the foods I listed were either "bad" or the quantity was too much. I'd
hate to put myself through a period of semi-deprivation (I really do
miss mashed potatoes) only to find I wasn't doing it right in the first
place and it was all for nothing.
I thank you for your comments as they are really helpful. This group is
fabulous and very supportive!
Annie