Sillyoldtwit said:Sorry Andy, but this statement begs a lot of questions.
1) What does 'on average' mean? Does it mean that there are exceptions?
2) What does a large volume mean?
3) What does 'moderately intense training' mean'?
4) What does 'much smaller volume' mean?
5) What does 'very intense' mean?
To my way of thinking, the meanings are very wide and one is likely to apply their own interpretation to each phrase.
I think Rapdaddyo would have said, whereas training at high intensity to one rider is endurable time after time (and dare I say actually enjoyable) to another it is pure purgatory. For the last 2 years plus since joining these forums, I would say I have trained (mostly for training sake) leaning towards shorter high intensity workouts. My improvement has been beyond my wildest dreams and is still continuing (approaching 66 years old). From 130W FTP to 315/320W. I will go on record now, as saying that before I race around Lake Biwa (140Km) in October my FTP will be closer to 340Watts! From what you and others are saying, I could possibly be way ahead of where I'm at present if I'd worked out at lower intensity - correct? Tyson
Tyson,
It isn't working out ONLY at a lower intensity - the plan that most top cyclists follow is one of building a huge engine through massive amounts of lower intensity endurance training in the off season - followed by a combination of quality intervals, hard racing and rest, to fine tune the engine and add the turbo, if you like. This engine gets run down completely, then rested, recharged and exhausted all over again over the years to create an efficient and powerful machine.
Ask any pro how they train and they'll tell you they ride hours every day, a few sprints once in a while to avoid losing explosive power, rest before races and use "B" races as training, then push themselves to the max in the "A" races. Racing at top level inflicts such a deep and powerful exertion on riders that through regular competition and appropriate resting they actually stress their bodies much harder than through interval training. This gives them those massive FTP numbers.
There are very few pros doing 2 x 20's, but these guys have the highest FTP.
I'm not knocking power training - If I worked full time or had family commitments it's what I'd do - But I am sure that riding fast needs a big engine - and you get a big engine from riding lots, and racing.