Break down, go ahead and give it to me.

UniBrier said:

*JC's and TB's Profile hubs were unscathed. My SH splined hub and
cranks held up to my lame drops.*

The KH splined hub on my Summit also held up well to the 4-foot-ish
drops it did from St. Ed's pedestal. In hindsight, I was nuts to let
Harper try that after the total lack of care he showed for his own
unicycle.

Here are some more shots from the day:
http://www.unicyclist.com/gallery/albux49

--
tomblackwood - Registered Nurtz

Tailgate at your own risk.....

------------------------------------------------------------------------
tomblackwood's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/3762
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

jenn kept askin' if anyone made a free hub.
i can now say i do...
-g3o

--
g3orge - stupid git

happiness is a warm unicycle...
------------------------------------------------------------------------
g3orge's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/5477
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

I broke the first axle.
I made the first pedestal drop.
I did it on a borrowed, unfamiliar unicycle.
I get no respect.
JC has already broken a Profile crank, but he's JC.

The two pansies with the cameras can't even break their own lenses.

Actually, watching Tom Blackwood chug up the lake trail was a
spectacular sight. Gee, I wish I were only 41 again. Kids...they can do
anything.

--
harper - Statuesque

-Greg Harper

B L U E S H I F T

"Stoke your own thread as much as you see fit, no problem." - Klaas
Bil

"Ugh, the Harpers; The worst neighbours in the world" - Tony Micelli
------------------------------------------------------------------------
harper's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/426
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

harper said:

*
JC has already broken a Profile crank, but he's JC.
*

if you buy me a profile setup, i am more than willin' to break them for
you!
yes, you made the first pedestal drop, but my first pedestal drop was
the pre-death drop. 😄
as far as respect, should we just start callin' you "Rodney D"??
i still like "Eustace"... 😎
-g3o
{smug git}

--
g3orge - stupid git

happiness is a warm unicycle...
------------------------------------------------------------------------
g3orge's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/5477
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

Harper, is that the same hub that Ryan couldn't break in Moab?

--
Ben Plotkin-Swing

www.benps.com

"Every truly great accomplishment is at first impossible" -Fortune
cookie.
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Ben Plotkin-Swing's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/378
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

harper said:

*Gee, I wish I were only 41 again. *

Me too.... 😎

--
tomblackwood - Registered Nurtz

Tailgate at your own risk.....

------------------------------------------------------------------------
tomblackwood's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/3762
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

Ben Plotkin-Swing said:

*Harper, is that the same hub that Ryan couldn't break in Moab? *

No. The difference is that this one was on its maiden voyage so it was
essentially brand new. Also, it used crank bolts rather than cranks
nuts. the threads on the axle Ryan couldn't break were male threads. The
ones on this new axle are female threads. As seen in the photo, the axle
break point is slightly inside the bolt-axle interface. I would have
expected it to snap right at the interface and certainly not after just
a two foot drop. Of course, I'm much tougher than Ryan.

Did the girls ever give you a call?

--
harper - Statuesque

-Greg Harper

B L U E S H I F T

"Stoke your own thread as much as you see fit, no problem." - Klaas
Bil

"Ugh, the Harpers; The worst neighbours in the world" - Tony Micelli
------------------------------------------------------------------------
harper's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/426
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

Based on all of this, it looks like bolt-on cranks may not be a good
idea for unicycles. I was surprised at the size of the hole in that
first picture. There's a lot less metal there to take up the stress
compared to a solid axle.

What do you engineers think?

--
johnfoss - Walkin' on the edge

John Foss, the Uni-Cyclone
"jfoss" at "unicycling.com"
www.unicycling.com

"Hey, could I have some of that spinach? I need to get this pork rind
taste out of my mouth." -- Ryan Atkins to Kris Holm, on the way back
from Moab after sampling some of my pork rinds. They grossed out the
whole van!
------------------------------------------------------------------------
johnfoss's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/832
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

johnfoss said:

*

What do you engineers think? *

Engineers don't think. We over-analyze and then have knee-jerk
reactions. Here's my knee-jerk reaction. The shear point is at the
interface of the crank surface and the axle. The axle is clearly
weakened inward beyond that point because of, as you point out, the
depth of the drilling. The crank interface provided the shearing surface
at a weak region in the axle.

--
harper - Statuesque

-Greg Harper

B L U E S H I F T

"Stoke your own thread as much as you see fit, no problem." - Klaas
Bil

"Ugh, the Harpers; The worst neighbours in the world" - Tony Micelli
------------------------------------------------------------------------
harper's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/426
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

harper said:

The
ones on this new axle are female threads. As seen in the photo, the axle
break point is slightly inside the bolt-axle interface. I would have
expected it to snap right at the interface and certainly not after just
a two foot drop. Of course, I'm much tougher than Ryan.

Am I visualizing this correctly: The bolt was shorter then the depth
of th crank? In other words, the bolt threaded into the axle to some
depth, b, and the crank arm sat over the axle to a depth, with c > b
(c closer to the axle center).

If that's the case, I wouldn't expect it axle to break at b because it
was being protected by the crank taper. It seems that stress would
naturally occur at c, so I'm not surprised the axle failed there.

A quick and easy way to beef up the design might be to lengthen the
crank bolt enough that it threads deeper than. That way the bolt
would also have to bend before the axle could fail there. Then again,
a bolt going through the center would only feel a small portion of the
stress - I don't know how much it would help.

Ken

I think the short answer on Harper's last post was yes.

I don't know how much help you'd get (if any) from a longer bolt. The
problem in the usual axle breakage is metal fatigue. With less metal to
work with (the bolt is a separate piece), I figure a taper with a hole
through it is going to weaken and break sooner.

On bikes this doesn't appear to be an issue. But for heavy duty
unicycling, it sounds to me like the old crank nut is the better way to
go for long-lasting axles.

Or could it just be a defect in that one axle?

--
johnfoss - Walkin' on the edge

John Foss, the Uni-Cyclone
"jfoss" at "unicycling.com"
www.unicycling.com

"Hey, could I have some of that spinach? I need to get this pork rind
taste out of my mouth." -- Ryan Atkins to Kris Holm, on the way back
from Moab after sampling some of my pork rinds. They grossed out the
whole van!
------------------------------------------------------------------------
johnfoss's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/832
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

johnfoss said:

Based on all of this, it looks like bolt-on cranks may not be a good
idea for unicycles. I was surprised at the size of the hole in that
first picture. There's a lot less metal there to take up the stress
compared to a solid axle.

Oops. Should have read this before my last post. In response to your
question, I calculated the (relative) strength of the axle.

The short answer is tubes are really quite strong and you only lose
about 8% of the strength by hollowing out the axle. Any loss of
strength of standars square taper axle may be unacceptable for
hardcore use, but then the square taper (in standard materials) may be
unacceptable anyway.

Now, the question I have is whether cutting threads into the axle
weakened it.

[GEEK WARNING: Read on at your own risk]

The long answer is that bending strength is limited by the maximum
stress exterted on the axle, which will be at the outside of the bend
(in a smooth walled tube). For hollow axles, that stress is
proportional to

T / (od^4 -id^4),

where T is torque (from the crank), od is the outside diameter and id
is the inside diameter of the axle. For solid axles, it is just
1/od^4. Looking at the picture of the failed axle, I estimate od=4.3w
and id=2.3w, where w is the wall thickness at its narrowest. Fixing
maximum stress and cancelling terms yields:

T_solid/0.0029 = T_hollow/0.0032, so

T_hollow = 0.92*T_solid

The maximum torque for the hollow axle is 92% of that for the solid.

In reality, the situation for the hollow axle is even better. This
calculation is for a round axle, and doesn't take into account the
extra material forming the square taper. That material effectively
increases the outside diameter, making the max torques even closer.

Cutting threads inside the hollow axle is an unknown to me. But I
know for sure that stresses love to concentrate at sharp corners and
if the threads go deep and are sharp, they could easily weaken the
axle. My earlier suggestion of using a longer bolt might actually
make matters worse if threads have to be cut as deep as the crank
sits.

Ken

P.S. I'm Chief Inspector of the Climbing Physics Police (ret.), not an
engineer.

It is foretelling that all of the square tapered unicycles met with some
sort of failure in the hub or the cranks. Since all of this happened at
an old Catholic seminary, I can only conclude that it is a message from
God that an upgrade to a splined hub for these folks will be divine. Of
course, this same park is where my Profile crank broke in half so I
could be interpreting the days events all wrong.

George's broken hub was the most amusing. It broke between the bearing
and the flange rather than between the bearing and the crank. That
allowed the crank to spin independently. Check out the video in
'UniBrier's gallery' (http://www.unicyclist.com/gallery/albux48) to see
the effect.

The hub that Greg Harper was using is a prototype hub from Steve Howard.
Greg and Steve will have to look at it and try to figure out why it
broke so easily while the previous hub survived 6 foot drops by Ryan
without snapping. It could be that the broken hub wasn't heat treated
correctly, maybe the raw material was somehow inferior or forged
differently, maybe the way the internal threads were cut caused a stress
riser in exactly the wrong spot, lots of potential reasons why it
failed. That's why it's a prototype hub. You don't really know these
things until you go out and try to break it.

--
john_childs - Guinness Mojo

john_childs (at) hotmail (dot) com
Gallery: '' (http://www.unicyclist.com/gallery/john_childs)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
john_childs's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/449
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

john_childs said:

* You don't really know these things until you go out and try to break
it. *

But Harper wasn't even trying to break it and he did. He has a gift that
way....

--
tomblackwood - Registered Nurtz

Tailgate at your own risk.....

------------------------------------------------------------------------
tomblackwood's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/3762
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

UniBrier said:

*... profile hubs were unscathed*

It warms my heart... I've laready gone over 6' multiple times on them
without even hearing a creak. I'm happy. Sadly, I no longer have an
excuse for not doing the 10 footer near my house, though.

Hey, does anyone else think that the Kooka crank rotated on the taper
causing it to round out before it broke for Harper? It looks like that
kooka's now trash. Shame, I reme mber Harper talking at moab about how
hard he looked for it. It even matched his frame.

edit: Are those profiles that uniskier/pete bent?!🙁 😕

--
gerblefranklin - Trials Unicyclist

Don't you think it's a cruel irony that acting like a G.I. Joe in the
army can get you a Medal, while playing with one can get you thrown out?
------------------------------------------------------------------------
gerblefranklin's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/4295
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

gerblefranklin said:

*Hey, does anyone else think that the Kooka crank rotated on the taper
causing it to round out before it broke for Harper? It looks like that
kooka's now trash. Shame, I remember Harper talking at moab about how
hard he looked for it. It even matched his frame.

edit: Are those profiles that uniskier/pete bent?!🙁 😕 *

The cranks that Pete bent are Odyssey Black Widow Euro's. Nice
lightweight cranks for road use and XC, but not really meant for
drops.

It does look like Greg's Kooka rotated on the taper, but that could also
be the hub rotating before snapping. We won't know until Greg takes it
apart. I'm guessing that it was the hub rotating before snapping and
that the Kooka's are going to be fine.

Greg managed to accomplish what Ryan could not -- breaking a Steve
Howard hub. I don't think Greg is ever going to let us forget that now.

--
john_childs - Guinness Mojo

john_childs (at) hotmail (dot) com
Gallery: '' (http://www.unicyclist.com/gallery/john_childs)
------------------------------------------------------------------------
john_childs's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/449
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

42.7% of all statistics are made up on the spot.

--
elmer - uniimpaired

"At 40 life begins...to show."
------------------------------------------------------------------------
elmer's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/5193
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

gerblefranklin said:

*

Sadly, I no longer have an excuse for not doing the 10 footer near my
house, though.

*

Except for......YOU'RE ON A UNICYCLE!

🙂

--
Sofa - you - pee - dee

'Unicycle Product Reviews' (http://tinyurl.com/368h6) *107* reviews on
*72* products

'London Unicycling Club Website ' (http://www.brianmackenzie.com/LUC/)
version 3.02

------------------------------------------------------------------------
Sofa's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/706
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905

http://www.unicyclist.com/gallery/albux50

i took some photos o' the nubbin. looks like the cranks are totally
intact.
-g3o

--
g3orge - stupid git

happiness is a warm unicycle...
------------------------------------------------------------------------
g3orge's Profile: http://www.unicyclist.com/profile/5477
View this thread: http://www.unicyclist.com/thread/31905