General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Beijing Shenanigans

Started by Email address hidden · · Last activity · 12 posts · 287 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
21 October 2005
Last activity
23 October 2005
Original author
Email address hidden
Posts
12
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
287
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–12 of 12
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Have you all been reading about this race from a week ago? Fortunately
    only 1 death, the male Kenyan winner circumvented the course at the
    finish by 800 meters near the finish and was not DQ, his time was
    tossed but he still was awarded as the winner. The female winner?...oh
    she got busted for steroids the next day in a 10K she was racing in.
    She passed her drug test after the Marathon on Sunday, Failed her drug
    test after the 10K on Monday. (she kept her Marathon win recognition).

    I've never heard of a Marathon where both the male and female winners
    were caught up in shenanigans.
    ___

    ONE of China's star female runners, Sun Yingjie, has been stripped of
    her 10,000 metres silver medal at the China National Games after
    testing positive for the steroid androsterone. Sun, 26 and a bronze
    medallist in the 10,000 at the 2003 world championships, tested
    positive after finishing second to Athens Olympic 10,000 champion Xing
    Huina on Monday, Xinhua news agency reported. The indefatigable Sun ran
    the National Games 10,000 the day after winning the Beijing marathon
    for the fourth straight time last Sunday. Her winning time was two
    hours 21 minutes one second, the fourth-fastest in the world this year.

    Question: Ya think she ran the Marathon "clean" and the masking agent
    just "worked", where it did not in the 10K?
    ____

    Benson Cherono of Kenya won the Beijing International Marathon on
    Sunday despite mistakenly running off the course and shortening his
    route by 800 meters.

    __

    I thought Marathons rules & regs were like "Golf" or other sports where
    the integrity of the event goes to the letter. Michelle Wie last
    weekend was DQ'ed for not adhering to a minor detail of the letter of
    the rules (golf).

  2. lance said:

    The female winner?...oh she got busted for steroids the next day in
    a 10K she was racing in.

    My god, I don't think even M Wardian in this country could medal in a
    high level 10k the day after winning a marathon. C'mon, no testing
    needed here to answer the question "steroids?" - but maybe someone
    should study her, find out what the hell she was taking, how much, and
    how she tolerated it without spontaneously combusting. I mean, that's
    just an impressive feat even allowing for "anything goes"
    chemically/medically.

    Or maybe this chick just really knows how to taper...

  3. Quoted message said:

    Have you all been reading about this race from a week ago? Fortunately
    only 1 death, the male Kenyan winner circumvented the course at the
    finish by 800 meters near the finish and was not DQ, his time was
    tossed but he still was awarded as the winner.

    Man, you should take up tabloid journalism.

    http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/2005/more/10/16/beijing.marathon.ap/index.html

    He just followed the broadcast van. Simple mistake. You make it
    seem like he intentionally circumvented the course. Why would he
    do that? He was already more than 5 minutes ahead of the second guy.
    And if he wanted to do a Rosie Ruiz, don't you think he'd be smart
    enough NOT to try it right behind a broadcast van and NOT right
    near the end when he's more likely to get caught?

    So, they gave him the win but not the time. Fair enough, especially
    after having run 2 hours and 5+ minutes and all but 0.5 mile. If I
    were the second place guy, I'd not be complaining.

    jobs

  4. Quoted message said:

    Man, you should take up tabloid journalism.

    Knot his fawlt, he's still werkin' on his GED.

  5. <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    jobs, i stated fact, that's all. i then went further opened for
    discussion how rigorous marathons are in adhering to the letter of

    you did state the facts but the tabloid journalism crack came into play when
    you categorized what he did as 'shenanigans'. it was an honest
    mistake...which doesnt mean he doesnt get DQ'ed IMO but it certainly changes
    the flavor of the infraction.

  6. Gee, this story is just one in a long line of similar tales, which
    contradicts the "We're runners, and we're great people!" vibe you all
    keep trying to perpetuate here.

  7. THE VICAR said:

    [who cares; I'm just happy to see THE VICAR]
    [and no, that's no banana in my pocket]

    VICAR,

    I realize it's poor form, but if you'll allow a running question: are
    you still (or were you ever... I was 70% convinced you were serious at
    the time) planning to run Filthydelphia's marathon? How's that going?

    I was there last weekend for a wedding, not having been in over a
    quarter century. Nice town, at least the center city. And it shows
    especially well at 5:30 AM, just me, a few other assorted miscreants,
    and the rats. A weekend or two's exploration is now on my agenda.

    Yr pal,
    Pendejo

  8. Quoted message said:

    jobs, i stated fact, that's all. i then went further opened for
    discussion how rigorous marathons are in adhering to the letter of the
    law/rules as applied to the professionals in the field, _no excuses_.

    Lance, if you'd ever had any experience being near the front of a race (for
    more than the first 5 seconds, that is), I'm sure you'd see things
    a little differently. But you haven't, so let me try to explain it to you.

    It is the responsibility of the race organisers to provide lead vehicles to
    direct the runners. This is not supposed to be an orienteering race. It is
    hard enough to lead without having to bring a map with you. If you are either
    leading, or in a top place in a spread-out field, you absolutely *will* get
    lost on most road courses, unless the race officials provide some assistance.

    If the race organisers didn't provide lead vehicles and didn't keep the media
    from obscuring them, it's their fault, not the runners.

    Quoted message said:

    i also gave an example of how in the sport of Golf....professionals are
    DQ'ed for the most minor of mistakes...

    It's a question of responsibility.

    You don't get disqualified for someone elses mistake.

    Quoted message said:

    I think 3-4 years ago...in the elite women's field....in the NYC
    Marathon....one elite woman received a cup of water (or gatorade) from
    another runner...this all happend in stride and was a clear violation.

    Is it ? What's the rule in question ?

    Cheers,
    --
    Donovan Rebbechi
    http://pegasus.rutgers.edu/~elflord/

  9. Quoted message said:

    It is the responsibility of the race organisers to provide lead vehicles to


    direct the runners.
    ___

    i don't think that's right donovan. i believe the professional receive
    a listing of the event (rules/course, etc.) and no where in their is it
    stated the lead vehicles "direct" course direction. i don't know this
    as fact however do you know as fact what you're asserting?

    and i'll have you know i have lead a race before and it was more than 5
    seconds. in fact it lasted a whole 25-30 seconds!

    and i sense you're further wrong in your view because the elites in big
    city marathons are told to FOLLOW THE LINE....you forgot about that one
    donovan didn't you? In NYC, the Blue Line...don't know Chicago's
    color....but Beijing likely had a line too. So even if you are in the
    lead....in Big Marathons there's always a line. It's not too hard to
    follow the line on the road now is it Donnie?

    So are you running in the NYC Marathon Donovan or what? Yes, No? if
    so, what color is your start?

  10. Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    It is the responsibility of the race organisers to provide lead vehicles to


    direct the runners.
    ___

    i don't think that's right donovan. i believe the professional receive
    a listing of the event (rules/course, etc.)

    You received a course map of the new york city marathon in your packet too,
    right ?

    Quoted message said:

    and no where in their is it stated the lead vehicles "direct" course
    direction.

    I just checked this. USATF are very thorough and require at least the
    following:

    (1) Monitors at all turns and major intersections
    (2) The route should be free as possible of vehicular traffic (so as not to
    interfere with the runners!)
    (3) a lead vehicle and other vehicles should be provided

    The IAAF rules only require the line.

    Quoted message said:

    and i sense you're further wrong in your view because the elites in big
    city marathons are told to FOLLOW THE LINE....you forgot about that one
    donovan didn't you? In NYC, the Blue Line...don't know Chicago's
    color....but Beijing likely had a line too. So even if you are in the
    lead....in Big Marathons there's always a line. It's not too hard to
    follow the line on the road now is it Donnie?

    But we don't know if there was a line. Either way, having the lead vehicle
    making wrong turns does make it confusing. Television crews should not
    interfere with the race in this manner.

    Quoted message said:

    So are you running in the NYC Marathon Donovan or what? Yes, No? if
    so, what color is your start?

    No, not this year.

    Cheers,
    --
    Donovan Rebbechi
    http://pegasus.rutgers.edu/~elflord/

  11. Miss Anne Thrope said:

    Gee, this story is just one in a long line of similar tales, which
    contradicts the "We're runners, and we're great people!" vibe you all
    keep trying to perpetuate here.

    At least we're better than you pseudo-intellectual golfers.

    tkb

  12. "Charlie Pendejo" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    THE VICAR said:

    [who cares; I'm just happy to see THE VICAR]
    [and no, that's no banana in my pocket]

    VICAR,

    I realize it's poor form, but if you'll allow a running question: are
    you still (or were you ever... I was 70% convinced you were serious at
    the time) planning to run Filthydelphia's marathon? How's that going?

    hey brother! Yes. i'm signed up and ready...well...as ready as i'm going to
    be. been working like crazy so squeezing in the running has been tough and
    the anti-bill guy that was flooding the group was a little annoying...its
    unbelievable but trolls are like onions. there are layers and when one layer
    gets worse than another layer it all starts to smell...or something...the
    metaphor gets stressed.

    i was in philly yesterday. my niece was swimming at la salle u. i live
    outside of the city but i rarely get in. i love going to center city
    although i've never run there. i take the kids in a couple of times a year
    so they can hear how Ben Franklin invented just about everthing worthwhile
    including x-box.

    Quoted message said:

    I was there last weekend for a wedding, not having been in over a
    quarter century. Nice town, at least the center city. And it shows
    especially well at 5:30 AM, just me, a few other assorted miscreants,
    and the rats. A weekend or two's exploration is now on my agenda.

    Yr pal,
    Pendejo

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.