"Andre Jute" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Hank said:Andre Jute said:On Mar 16, 5:44 am, Michael Press <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted message said:*****
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:Andre Jute <[email hidden]> wrote:
TOWARDS A NORMATIVE CASE FOR BICYCLE LIGHTS
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:1. Bicycle lights are for seeing and being seen.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:2. In my opinion, bicyclists are not lesser human beings than
motorists. It should be stressed that bicyclists have responsibilities
to motorists as motorists have to cyclists. To meet their
responsibilities, I think cyclists presently require two sets of
lights:
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:3. One set of lights, driven by batteries, for making a lot of light
that permits the cyclist to see and, more important, to be seen by
motorists.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:4. The other set of lights, powered by a hub dynamo, will be always
available as an emergency backup. If these dynohub-driven lights are
LED they can be run constantly because their lifetime is for practical
purposes infinite; they may be used as daylight running lights.
Currently the best front dynohub light is the LED BUMM Fly IQ; it has
no flashing facility. German and Dutch rear bicycle lights, if used
outside their native milieu, need to be supplemented with a brighter
light, preferably flashing. See point 7 below.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:5. We can hope in the light of recent events that sometime in the the
next decade LED dynamo front lights will be powerful enough for both
functions, see and being seen. Unfortunately there seems to be no
impetus for mainstream dynamo light makers to make a brighter rear
light than currently available, and German and Dutch law, in their
major markets, forbid flashing lights. Decent rear dynohub lights (or
battery lights for that matter) with more output and flashing modes
will thus have to come from specialists and will accordingly be
relatively more expensive.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:6. It is my opinion that any cyclist who is not one of a mass of
cyclists in places where motorists routinely expect to see cyclists
should have flashing lights front and rear to establish his presence.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:7. The only rear lights that are good enough to be primary lights are
made by Dinotte and Cateyes (TL-LD1100). German and Dutch lights are
simply too limp, and in any event do not have a flashing facility.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:8. I'm working on finding front flashing lights; my current idea is to
add simple electronics to a BUMM Fly IQ to make it flash; the
Reelights may suit others but won't fit my bike.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:Thoughts, expansions, alternative ideas welcome.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:Andre Jute
If at first you don't succeed, try again.
Quoted message said:*****
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:I don't know the definition but `normative'
means "We're about to drop a barge load of
fertilizer on you. Bon appetit."
Quoted message said:Normative just means "what should be" or, when I use it and I'm
addressing the Krygo-Fogel School of Ignorance, "I'm telling you from
on high, sonny".
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:I'm outta here.
Quoted message said:I don't see that lights are particularly difficult, except for the
fascist fashion faction who want so much to belong to the crowd that
they will risk their lives to be seen to conform.
And this is why you're a jackass.
We'll see who is the jackass, anonymous Hank, when we've evaluated
your fulminations:
Quoted message said:You present the false dilemma that
one either:
a) believes in lighting overkill; or
Nope. "Overkill" is your subjective judgement.
Quoted message said:b) doesn't value his or her own life.
Where did I say that? I said some people will risk their lives so as
to be seen to conform to some pack mentality. That is how highly they
value their lives: to the total extent of belonging. If your peer
group is into dangerous activities, like having inadequate bicycle
lights, then it should be a free choice not to belong, not to be
bullied by your kind of sneering and jeering.
Quoted message said:Your position is the equivalent to one that people who don't wear both
belts and suspenders (or braces,if you're a Brit) are immodest,
because if you only use a belt, it might break and your pants will
fall down.
Nah, that's the position of the dynohub fanatics. They claim batteries
fail at inconvenient times. Me, I want to use my dynohub to operate
flashing lights front and rear, and just be there in emergencies, same
as you carry a spare tube. You do carry a spare tube, don't you,
anonymous Hank?
Quoted message said:Calling those who disagree with you suicidal makes you the fascist,
especially since you're on the "buy more stuff" side (classical
Italian fascism is also corporatism).
Let's take this bit of empty vituperation section by section:
Quoted message said:Calling those who disagree with you suicidal
I didn't. I don't care if you and your entire peer group want to
commit suicide by becoming automobile fatality statistics. It is your
right to choose the time and place of your death. I'm a libertarian. I
merely point out that your method will cause stress and expense to
motorists, which is anti-social and and counterproductive for the rest
of us. If you insist on committing suicide, opening a vein in your
bath leads to the least mess.
Quoted message said:makes you the fascist,
especially since you're on the "buy more stuff" side
Actually, I probably have less invested in my bikes than most people
on RBT, and I bet each of my bikes cost less than 70 per cent of the
bikes ridden by RBTers. I have already pointed out elsewhere that the
dearth of good rear lights, and their prices, is a scandal. I have
explained how you can DIY good lights cheaply. Now you, anonymous
Hank, wants to tag me as the last of the big spenders. Put your mind
in gear, sonny, and stop making a fool of yourself.
Quoted message said:(classical Italian fascism is also corporatism).
What are you, anonymous Hank, some kind of an undereducated workshop
lecturer at a jumped-up tech now calling itself a "community college"?
Italian fascists were violent socialists, you moron, who wanted state
control of corporations; like [censored] they thought the corporation
should serve the State. You're thinking of the control of the state by
corporations, as in USA today. The two conditions are diametrically
opposed.
Quoted message said:For the first and only time in my life, I wish I was more like Michael
Press, who had the good sense to walk away from this thread.
You should have, for now we are in a position, as promised, to see who
is a "jackass", which is a packmule, bred by crossing an ass with a
horse, resulting in a dumb, sterile animal. You clearly don't have any
breeding, for you're trying to lay off the guilt of your suicidal
tendency on a stranger. You clearly are a loser who will be no loss to
the gene pool, and in the scheme of things those soon suffer a
darwinian accident. and you clearly are dumb, anonymous Hank. Looks
like you're the jackass.
If you have anything sensible to say about lights, please do feel
welcome.
Andre Jute
Policies not personalities -- Edmund Burke
Andre,
A jackass is a male ass. A mule is the (usually sterile) offspring of a male
donkey and a female horse. A hinny is the (usually sterile) offspring of a
male horse and a female donkey. None of the three mentioned immediately
above (jackass, mule, hinny) are particularly dumb, either in intelligence
or in ability to make sounds.
Kerry