Road Cycling · Public discussion

Why do I get dropped?

Started by Email address hidden · · Last activity · 49 posts · 1,047 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Road Cycling
Published
12 June 2007
Last activity
17 June 2007
Original author
Email address hidden
Posts
49
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,047
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 49
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. The short answer is I'm not strong enough, but I'm trying to get a
    little more specific.

    What happens is I get dropped on hills in the 1-2km long at 4-6%
    range. In various circut races this always happens, usually on the
    second or third of 5 or 6 laps. It happens when a break is going away
    or similar and the pace picks up dramatically in the middle of the
    hill and I can't keep up. The group always calms down shortly after I
    get dropped, so it's really just a case of being able to hold on for
    another 10-30 seconds.

    I could lose about 10lbs I suppose, but I'm never going to be below
    205lbs, so I need to boost my power, and more specifically my ability
    to keep it redlined for a few more seconds. What is my limiting
    factor? What should I do about it?

    Joseph

    PS: No doping jokes unless they are really funny.

  2. email hidden said:

    The short answer is I'm not strong enough, but I'm trying to get a
    little more specific.

    What happens is I get dropped on hills in the 1-2km long at 4-6%
    range. In various circut races this always happens, usually on the
    second or third of 5 or 6 laps. It happens when a break is going away
    or similar and the pace picks up dramatically in the middle of the
    hill and I can't keep up. The group always calms down shortly after I
    get dropped, so it's really just a case of being able to hold on for
    another 10-30 seconds.

    I could lose about 10lbs I suppose, but I'm never going to be below
    205lbs, so I need to boost my power, and more specifically my ability
    to keep it redlined for a few more seconds. What is my limiting
    factor? What should I do about it?

    I doubt that someone that's 200 lbs will EVER be able to develop
    enough strength to stay with climbers. Knock off 25 lbs and you'll be
    able to ride along with them as if they were dawdling.

  3. email hidden said:

    What happens is I get dropped on hills in the 1-2km long at 4-6%
    range.

    Quoted message said:

    to keep it redlined for a few more seconds. What is my limiting
    factor? What should I do about it?

    The pat answer is train your weakness and race your strengths. If it's
    the sudden surge uphill that you can't do then you have to train to do
    that by doing pick ups in the middle of climbs and focus on the short
    duration power generation needed to hang on.

    In terms of strategy, perhaps you can change your positioning in the
    pack. If you know a longish climb is coming up where you are likely to
    have trouble then get near the front for the climb. If you can set the
    tempo others might blindly follow in your comfort zone. Worse case as
    you get shuffled back in the surge you'll end up at either at the tail
    toward the top or perhaps have a chance to bridge back on when the
    group settles. But at least try something different from what is not
    working.

    Obviously at your size you need to change your power to weight ratio
    to climb better and you are unlikely to ever to climb like a 120
    pounder. It's usually easier to drop weight but if you are already a
    lean but large guy it's going to take specific training and time.

    FWIW - for some reason a lot of folks want to do well at certain races
    that really don't suit them. Sprinters doing hill climbs and 120
    pounders trying to race crits banging away with the big boys. Rather
    than worrying about circuit races with long climbs perhaps you'd be
    better focusing on races where your size (and presumed power) would be
    an advantage as opposed to a liability?

    Mark

  4. email hidden said:

    What happens is I get dropped on hills in the 1-2km long at 4-6%
    range. In various circut races this always happens, usually on the
    second or third of 5 or 6 laps. It happens when a break is going away
    or similar and the pace picks up dramatically in the middle of the
    hill and I can't keep up. The group always calms down shortly after I
    get dropped, so it's really just a case of being able to hold on for
    another 10-30 seconds.

    That's your race, right there. So, don't do any work before that.

    Simple, huh?

    The weight thing is crucial, of course. Any extra you're carrying,
    this is where it matters. As you well know.

    Motorpace on those same hills, is another suggestion. --D-y

  5. Quoted message said:

    On Jun 12, 1:41 pm, "[email hidden]"

    Quoted message said:

    The short answer is I'm not strong enough, but I'm trying to get a
    little more specific.

    Quoted message said:

    What happens is I get dropped on hills in the 1-2km long at 4-6%
    range. In various circut races this always happens, usually on the
    second or third of 5 or 6 laps. It happens when a break is going away
    or similar and the pace picks up dramatically in the middle of the
    hill and I can't keep up. The group always calms down shortly after I
    get dropped, so it's really just a case of being able to hold on for
    another 10-30 seconds.

    Quoted message said:

    I could lose about 10lbs I suppose, but I'm never going to be below
    205lbs, so I need to boost my power, and more specifically my ability
    to keep it redlined for a few more seconds. What is my limiting
    factor? What should I do about it?

    I doubt that someone that's 200 lbs will EVER be able to develop
    enough strength to stay with climbers. Knock off 25 lbs and you'll be
    able to ride along with them as if they were dawdling.- Hide quoted text -

    Andy Paulin climbed pretty well at over 200 lbs.

    Anyway, this is the standard fatty question: Joe has to lose weight.

    Not sucking is necessary, and perhaps sufficient.

    Where is Warren to talk about increasing power instead of losing
    wieght?

    Warren? Warren? Warren? Whither are thee?

  6. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Mark said:
    email hidden said:

    What happens is I get dropped on hills in the 1-2km long at 4-6%
    range.

    Quoted message said:

    to keep it redlined for a few more seconds. What is my limiting
    factor? What should I do about it?

    The pat answer is train your weakness and race your strengths. If it's
    the sudden surge uphill that you can't do then you have to train to do
    that by doing pick ups in the middle of climbs and focus on the short
    duration power generation needed to hang on.

    Quoted message said:

    FWIW - for some reason a lot of folks want to do well at certain races
    that really don't suit them. Sprinters doing hill climbs and 120
    pounders trying to race crits banging away with the big boys. Rather
    than worrying about circuit races with long climbs perhaps you'd be
    better focusing on races where your size (and presumed power) would be
    an advantage as opposed to a liability?

    Mark

    I think Joseph has previously posted about the rather uniform nature of
    the races where he lives: there aren't a lot of races that don't have
    hills in 'em.

    FWIW, I think the advice here is all pretty much correct: lose weight,
    train on the hills where you get hurt, and I always figure it doesn't
    hurt to remind people that intervals are always the right answer. In my
    opinion, few tactics can compete with simply being able to keep up. The
    only other contribution I might have is yes, do your best to hang onto
    the back of the pack, but if you really do have the performance to be at
    the front of these races, then you should be able to catch up on the
    back side of the hill. After all, you are relatively heavy!

    Ryan needs to work on his excess 18 pounds...

    Oh, and here's my funny doping reference: You should take kenacort.

    --
    Ryan Cousineau [email hidden] http://www.wiredcola.com/
    "I don't want kids who are thinking about going into mathematics
    to think that they have to take drugs to succeed." -Paul Erdos

  7. Mark said:

    On Jun 12, 4:41 pm, "[email hidden]"

    Quoted message said:

    What happens is I get dropped on hills in the 1-2km long at 4-6%
    range.
    to keep it redlined for a few more seconds. What is my limiting
    factor? What should I do about it?

    The pat answer is train your weakness and race your strengths. If it's
    the sudden surge uphill that you can't do then you have to train to do
    that by doing pick ups in the middle of climbs and focus on the short
    duration power generation needed to hang on.

    I suppose I should ride more hills. The problem is the island I live
    on has only short ones, so I have to drive (only 30 minutes or so) to
    where some longer hills are and thus that doesn't happen that often.
    How often do you suppose I should do these not-getting-dropped
    simulations?

    Quoted message said:

    In terms of strategy, perhaps you can change your positioning in the
    pack. If you know a longish climb is coming up where you are likely to
    have trouble then get near the front for the climb. If you can set the
    tempo others might blindly follow in your comfort zone. Worse case as
    you get shuffled back in the surge you'll end up at either at the tail
    toward the top or perhaps have a chance to bridge back on when the
    group settles. But at least try something different from what is not
    working.

    We have races just about every Tuesday so I have tried a few different
    stategies, all to no avail so far. The races have been on courses that
    have been new to me, so that didn't help. Later in the season some of
    the races are on the same courses and I'll at least know what is
    coming. I do position myself toward the front before climbs and I end
    up sliding backwards. Over the top, I keep the effort up and work my
    way up toward the front again. Often this can only be done by going up
    the open windward side of the road which has backfired a few times as
    I have already got my HR up high just as we roll into another (bigger)
    hill. On these hills where I have been getting dropped, a few strong
    climber types go clear, and the group goes like Hell to keep up. If
    the climbers go clear, the fast guys in the group (several of whom do
    10km TT's in the 12 minute range) set up a rotation and hammer to
    catch the break. In those situations, the chances of me being able to
    bridge is pretty much zero. I usually pick up a few other stragglers,
    but they rarely have my speed on the flats, so it turns into a
    training ride where we try to see how narrow we can hold the gap.

    Quoted message said:

    Obviously at your size you need to change your power to weight ratio
    to climb better and you are unlikely to ever to climb like a 120
    pounder. It's usually easier to drop weight but if you are already a
    lean but large guy it's going to take specific training and time.

    I've got about 10lbs extra which is slated to be gone. That's the plan
    at least...

    Quoted message said:


    FWIW - for some reason a lot of folks want to do well at certain races
    that really don't suit them. Sprinters doing hill climbs and 120
    pounders trying to race crits banging away with the big boys. Rather
    than worrying about circuit races with long climbs perhaps you'd be
    better focusing on races where your size (and presumed power) would be
    an advantage as opposed to a liability?

    I dream of the day one of the local races is tailor made for me. There
    is some punishment to be dispensed! The strong guys around here would
    of course dominate these races as well, but I wouldn't really be on
    their radar so anything could happen. The races so far have been from
    60 to 80km long with none less than 400m of ascent. I might suffer the
    same fate from all the short bursts in a crit, but I reckon I'd do
    better there no matter what.

    Joseph

  8. SLAVE of THE STATE said:

    Warren? Warren? Warren? Whither are thee?

    Probably in the gym, if only so he can beat up our CSO.

  9. email hidden said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    What happens is I get dropped on hills in the 1-2km long at 4-6%
    range.
    to keep it redlined for a few more seconds. What is my limiting
    factor? What should I do about it?

    Lose as much of that ten pounds as you can while keeping your
    strength. (easy to type, at least)

    Hill repeats can be short; all you need is a few more seconds of burn
    time, right? Highly radioactive, use caution with dosing your hard
    efforts training and racing.

    Repeated/prolonged chases after getting dropped in a race might be
    negative for body and mind-- making you tired, not faster, and not
    exactly polishing your psych, either.

    Better might be doing your absolute best to hang in these hilly races
    (incl. all aspects of saving energy and using it to best effect), then
    uncoupling from the race when your efforts start to go backwards, and
    having a nice, steady (not too easy or too hard) ride home, arriving
    perhaps a little tired but not beat up. IOW, burn some calories, then
    get some good rest. --D-y

  10. Quoted message said:

    I suppose I should ride more hills. The problem is the island I live
    on has only short ones, so I have to drive (only 30 minutes or so) to
    where some longer hills are and thus that doesn't happen that often.
    How often do you suppose I should do these not-getting-dropped
    simulations?

    If you have a power meter you could try racing with the power meter and
    see at what wattage you're getting dropped. Then in training try to hold
    at a wattage below that wattage that you can hold for the required time.
    Repeat over a period of weeks gradually increasing the wattage until you
    get to the wattage where you were dropped (and hope the other guys haven't
    improved and moved the goalposts). Of course the above assumes you have
    some time, if you're racing weekly you might not get instant results.

  11. in message <[email hidden]>,

    (') said:

    The short answer is I'm not strong enough, but I'm trying to get a
    little more specific.

    What happens is I get dropped on hills in the 1-2km long at 4-6%
    range. In various circut races this always happens, usually on the
    second or third of 5 or 6 laps. It happens when a break is going away
    or similar and the pace picks up dramatically in the middle of the
    hill and I can't keep up. The group always calms down shortly after I
    get dropped, so it's really just a case of being able to hold on for
    another 10-30 seconds.

    I could lose about 10lbs I suppose, but I'm never going to be below
    205lbs, so I need to boost my power, and more specifically my ability
    to keep it redlined for a few more seconds. What is my limiting
    factor? What should I do about it?

    How tall are you, Joe? 205lbs is a lot of weight. I'm fifty-mumble years
    old and six foot one tall and at least twenty pounds overweight, but I'm
    only 180lbs. I think I'd be faster up hill - no, I know I'd be faster up
    hill - if I could make it down to 165lbs.

    The alternative is to go for a lot of power, but then you have to worry
    about joints and cartilage. I've a friend who is 250lbs and ten years
    younger; until recently he was much faster than me uphill, because he's
    enormously strong. He isn't faster any more because his knees have gone,
    and he can't even walk without a stick. The materials of your body are
    just engineering materials like any others, and if you take them out of
    specification they fail pretty quickly. Humans aren't evolved to be
    205lbs.

    --
    [email hidden] (Simon Brooke) http://www.jasmine.org.uk/~simon/

    A message from our sponsor: This site is now in free fall

  12. email hidden said:

    The short answer is I'm not strong enough, but I'm trying to get a
    little more specific.

    What happens is I get dropped on hills in the 1-2km long at 4-6%
    range. In various circut races this always happens, usually on the
    second or third of 5 or 6 laps. It happens when a break is going away
    or similar and the pace picks up dramatically in the middle of the
    hill and I can't keep up. The group always calms down shortly after I
    get dropped, so it's really just a case of being able to hold on for
    another 10-30 seconds.

    I could lose about 10lbs I suppose, but I'm never going to be below
    205lbs, so I need to boost my power, and more specifically my ability
    to keep it redlined for a few more seconds. What is my limiting
    factor? What should I do about it?

    Joseph

    PS: No doping jokes unless they are really funny.

    Dumbass,

    The problem is you suck, but you already knew that.
    Anyway we all do, the question is how to suck less.
    One thing you should not forget is how close the
    difference is between being dropped and not. If
    your climbs are on the order of 2-5 minutes long
    and you need to hold on for an extra 10-30 secs
    (or are getting dropped by 10-30 sec) that's about
    10 percent. Losing 10 pounds is 5% of your weight
    so that's half the difference right there if you
    lose it and keep the power up. I also think that unless
    you're really, really tall, 205 lbs is a lot for
    someone who races regularly, but I don't know your
    body shape. Also, putting in extra riding to take
    off weight has benefits itself.

    Other people already suggested that you basically
    need to train the specific thing you're having
    trouble with. I usually got popped on short hard
    hills or accelerations and probably a major reason
    is that I was never particularly devoted to doing
    intervals. Intervals suck, but one nice thing if
    you actually have a job or life is that they are
    fairly efficient in terms of training load per
    clock time.

    Another reason is that I rode with people faster
    than me. This is a pretty good way to improve,
    if you live.

    Ben

  13. On Jun 13, 3:27 am, "[email hidden]"

    Quoted message said:


    I suppose I should ride more hills. The problem is the island I live
    on has only short ones, so I have to drive (only 30 minutes or so) to
    where some longer hills are and thus that doesn't happen that often.
    How often do you suppose I should do these not-getting-dropped
    simulations?

    I would make the drive to get to the right terrain if it's tolerable
    to you to do so. I absolutely hate driving my bike somewhere to ride
    but when I lived in Salt Lake City I'd often go up to Park City to
    ride (mtn bikes). The extra couple thousand feet of altitude mattered
    and access to really long climbs made it worth the car time.

    How often to do intervals is up to you and your ability to recover.
    The training plan I follow has killer intervals no more than once a
    week. You need to put out the effort and then recover in order to get
    the max effect. I like to do three days of work followed by two days
    of recovery but everyone is different and you need to experiment.

    My advice, worth exactly what you paid for it, is to get on a plan
    that makes sense to you, that you will stick to and enjoy and then
    give it a good season to see how it works. If you get into a
    disciplined training regimine and give it time you'll get better. Lose
    the weight too :-)

    One thing to avoid is expecting to improve too much too fast. If you
    ride with tired legs all the time you just slide backwards in fitness
    and get frustrated.

    Quoted message said:

    I've got about 10lbs extra which is slated to be gone. That's the plan
    at least...

    Good start. All you have to do is look at watts / kg to see that
    lighter is typically going to be better.

    Quoted message said:

    I dream of the day one of the local races is tailor made for me.

    As long as it's fun keep moving forward. It'll feel great that one day
    when you don't get dropped and are there for the field sprint.

    Mark

  14. On Jun 14, 3:40 am, "[email hidden]" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    Dumbass,

    The problem is you suck, but you already knew that.
    Anyway we all do, the question is how to suck less.

    I think he should suck more. In the long run, he needs to lose weight
    and raise power--but in the short run, he needs to hide in the pack,
    sucking wheels, for as long as possible. A lot of rouleurs (and it
    sounds like Joseph is a rouleur) spend too much time exposed. All in
    all, I'd say:

    1. Lose weight
    2. Know the course
    3. Suck more
    4. Do intervals
    5. Lose weight

    It's possible to train for hills even if you don't have hills -- it's
    harder and not as much fun, but it's still possible. What you want to
    simulate is the power and the duration needed, not the angle of the
    bicycle above horizontal. You can train power on the flat, or on an
    indoor trainer.

  15. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Quoted message said:

    On Jun 14, 3:40 am, "[email hidden]" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    Dumbass,

    The problem is you suck, but you already knew that.
    Anyway we all do, the question is how to suck less.

    I think he should suck more. In the long run, he needs to lose weight
    and raise power--but in the short run, he needs to hide in the pack,
    sucking wheels, for as long as possible. A lot of rouleurs (and it
    sounds like Joseph is a rouleur) spend too much time exposed. All in
    all, I'd say:

    1. Lose weight
    2. Know the course
    3. Suck more
    4. Do intervals
    5. Lose weight

    It's possible to train for hills even if you don't have hills -- it's
    harder and not as much fun, but it's still possible. What you want to
    simulate is the power and the duration needed, not the angle of the
    bicycle above horizontal. You can train power on the flat, or on an
    indoor trainer.

    As usual, Mr. Chung has some good points. I feel like I need a chart,
    but oh well.

    That said, hey, you think we could convince Joseph to train with a
    parachute on his back?

    http://www.timeforfitness.com/running/pro_power_chute.htm

    You'll need the big model Joseph, because you're a big guy.

    (This is going to be so cool!)

    --
    Ryan Cousineau [email hidden] http://www.wiredcola.com/
    "I don't want kids who are thinking about going into mathematics
    to think that they have to take drugs to succeed." -Paul Erdos

  16. Simon Brooke said:

    Humans aren't evolved to be
    205lbs.

    This particular one was ;-)

    Joseph

    PS: Ok, 200 maybe.

  17. Mark said:

    If you can set the tempo others might blindly follow in your comfort zone

    That's Armstrong's advice, "pull or get dropped"

    Jenko

  18. Quoted message said:
    Simon Brooke said:

    Humans aren't evolved to be 205lbs.

    This particular one was ;-)

    Take up rowing. Open class (the only sensible class) crews average
    about 200 lb or 90 kg. (With 10% fat at most.)

    --
    E. Dronkert

  19. Quoted message said:

    On Jun 14, 3:40 am, "[email hidden]" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    Dumbass,

    Quoted message said:

    The problem is you suck, but you already knew that.
    Anyway we all do, the question is how to suck less.

    I think he should suck more. In the long run, he needs to lose weight
    and raise power--but in the short run, he needs to hide in the pack,
    sucking wheels, for as long as possible. A lot of rouleurs (and it
    sounds like Joseph is a rouleur) spend too much time exposed. All in
    all, I'd say:

    1. Lose weight
    2. Know the course
    3. Suck more
    4. Do intervals
    5. Lose weight

    It's possible to train for hills even if you don't have hills -- it's
    harder and not as much fun, but it's still possible. What you want to
    simulate is the power and the duration needed, not the angle of the
    bicycle above horizontal. You can train power on the flat, or on an
    indoor trainer.

    I'm only exposed when I change in the parking lot. I find the wheel of
    the best sprinter guys (who know how much leeway to give the skinny
    guys on the hills) and try to hang on. No wind for me unless I end up
    on the wrong side in a sidewind, but I'm good at pushing so that
    doesn't last long.

    I suppose for point 1 I could eat less, and point 5 I could buy a
    lighter bike. That's an approved FM solution, right?

    I think I may try some more structured interval training on my trainer
    and occasionally out on a hill. In the pre-season before there were
    events I was doing long easy rides, and intervals on my rollers. 5x8
    minutes at 93% max HR. Maybe I should do shorter but harder? Now that
    there events (average 2 per week) I only ride long rides and the races
    but no intervals.

    Joseph

  20. Ryan Cousineau said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,

    Quoted message said:

    On Jun 14, 3:40 am, "[email hidden]" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    Dumbass,

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    The problem is you suck, but you already knew that.
    Anyway we all do, the question is how to suck less.

    Quoted message said:

    I think he should suck more. In the long run, he needs to lose weight
    and raise power--but in the short run, he needs to hide in the pack,
    sucking wheels, for as long as possible. A lot of rouleurs (and it
    sounds like Joseph is a rouleur) spend too much time exposed. All in
    all, I'd say:

    Quoted message said:

    1. Lose weight
    2. Know the course
    3. Suck more
    4. Do intervals
    5. Lose weight

    Quoted message said:

    It's possible to train for hills even if you don't have hills -- it's
    harder and not as much fun, but it's still possible. What you want to
    simulate is the power and the duration needed, not the angle of the
    bicycle above horizontal. You can train power on the flat, or on an
    indoor trainer.

    As usual, Mr. Chung has some good points. I feel like I need a chart,
    but oh well.

    That said, hey, you think we could convince Joseph to train with a
    parachute on his back?

    http://www.timeforfitness.com/running/pro_power_chute.htm

    You'll need the big model Joseph, because you're a big guy.

    (This is going to be so cool!)

    --
    Ryan Cousineau [email hidden]://www.wiredcola.com/
    "I don't want kids who are thinking about going into mathematics
    to think that they have to take drugs to succeed." -Paul Erdos

    The hard-core adventurer ski-types around here go running on trails in
    the woods in the summer with a car tire attached to their belt
    dragging behind them. I suppose I could attach my kiddie trailer to my
    race bike and fill it with rocks.

    Joseph

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.