Australia and New Zealand · Public discussion

QR for windtrainer

Started by DaveB · · Last activity · 9 posts · 520 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Australia and New Zealand
Published
19 April 2006
Last activity
19 April 2006
Original author
DaveB
Posts
9
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
520
Views / 30 days
0
Topics

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–9 of 9
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I've been using my windtrainer on and off for the past few weeks but the
    most annoying thing is that I need to switch QR systems when I go from
    the road to the trainer. The std QR with the OCR2 (in the photo below)
    doesn't fit in the mount system on the trainer because it is too wide.
    But the thin QR (in my fingers in the picture) has the release bit out
    the side so is no good in the bike for normal use because I can't
    tighten it correctly. Is it just the OCR2's that have this problem. Is
    there a QR that is somewhere in between?

    http://www.flickr.com/photos/22133260@N00/

    Hope this works, first time on flickr.

    daveB

  2. DaveB said:

    I've been using my windtrainer on and off for the past few weeks but the
    most annoying thing is that I need to switch QR systems when I go from
    the road to the trainer. The std QR with the OCR2 (in the photo below)
    doesn't fit in the mount system on the trainer because it is too wide.
    But the thin QR (in my fingers in the picture) has the release bit out
    the side so is no good in the bike for normal use because I can't
    tighten it correctly. Is it just the OCR2's that have this problem. Is
    there a QR that is somewhere in between?

    http://www.flickr.com/photos/22133260@N00/

    Hope this works, first time on flickr.

    daveB

    This might seem like a dumb question, but can't you just
    rotate the QR so it is closed in the up position? Anyway,
    don't you have to have the QR tight for the trainer?

    No sure if I properly understand your problem. I had a
    similar difficulty with spouse's bike and just replaced
    her QR with the one provided with the trainer.

    DeF.

    --
    e-mail: d.farrow@your finger.murdoch.edu.au
    To reply, you'll have to remove your finger.

  3. DaveB said:

    I've been using my windtrainer on and off for the past few weeks but the
    most annoying thing is that I need to switch QR systems when I go from
    the road to the trainer. The std QR with the OCR2 (in the photo below)
    doesn't fit in the mount system on the trainer because it is too wide.
    But the thin QR (in my fingers in the picture) has the release bit out
    the side so is no good in the bike for normal use because I can't
    tighten it correctly. Is it just the OCR2's that have this problem. Is
    there a QR that is somewhere in between?

    flickr.com22133260@N00

    Hope this works, first time on flickr.

    daveB


    The QR in your fingers looks like the standard old school QR - I would have thought it could be tightened OK in your frame. What is it doing in the frame when it is in the trainer? Isn't it tight then? (I may just be thick and unable to understand 🙄 )

    I have a Minoura trainer and I put my commuterised MTB (slicks etc) in it. The QR is a Shimano XT one and it seems to fit without problem.

    Generally there are 2 types of QRs on wheel skewers. This is a good explanation here - sheldonbrown.comskewers.html.

    The 'internal cam' type seems to be the best for trainer use. My Shimano XT skewer is an internal cam type.

    If you don't get any joy with either of your QRs, try a different brand/design - I'm sure there is a brand/design out there that will suit.

    SteveA

  4. DeF said:

    This might seem like a dumb question, but can't you just
    rotate the QR so it is closed in the up position? Anyway,
    don't you have to have the QR tight for the trainer?

    No sure if I properly understand your problem. I had a
    similar difficulty with spouse's bike and just replaced
    her QR with the one provided with the trainer.

    DeF.

    The only way to tighten the silver QR is in the closed position and
    turning the other side, which isn't exactly ideal. Not having a tight
    fit doesn't worry me on the trainer, but on the road is a different
    story, which is why when I go on the road I need to swap back to the
    black QR that was std with the bike.

    DaveB

  5. DaveB said:

    I've been using my windtrainer on and off for the past few weeks but the
    most annoying thing is that I need to switch QR systems when I go from
    the road to the trainer. The std QR with the OCR2 (in the photo below)
    doesn't fit in the mount system on the trainer because it is too wide.
    But the thin QR (in my fingers in the picture) has the release bit out
    the side so is no good in the bike for normal use because I can't
    tighten it correctly. Is it just the OCR2's that have this problem. Is
    there a QR that is somewhere in between?

    I had the same issue and replaced my QR with the old style unit that you
    have in the picture - I can't understand why you can't get it tight
    enough? IMHO the old style is better because it's sealed better from the
    elements.

    --
    ..dt

  6. quote='dtmeister'DaveB said:

    I've been using my windtrainer on and off for the past few weeks but the
    most annoying thing is that I need to switch QR systems when I go from
    the road to the trainer. The std QR with the OCR2 (in the photo below)
    doesn't fit in the mount system on the trainer because it is too wide.
    But the thin QR (in my fingers in the picture) has the release bit out
    the side so is no good in the bike for normal use because I can't
    tighten it correctly. Is it just the OCR2's that have this problem. Is
    there a QR that is somewhere in between?

    I had the same issue and replaced my QR with the old style unit that you
    have in the picture - I can't understand why you can't get it tight
    enough? IMHO the old style is better because it's sealed better from the
    elements.

    --
    ..dt[/QUOTE]

    Isn't the time difference between the eastern and western coasts useful? Ask a tech question when everyone is Bris/Syd/Melb has gone home for the day or is eating their dinner, and the Perth mob is there to answer it. 😄 😄 😄 .

    Dave, try getting an internal cam QR in the 'modern style' - could be the answer to your dilema.

    SteveA

  7. DaveB said:
    DeF said:

    This might seem like a dumb question, but can't you just
    rotate the QR so it is closed in the up position? Anyway,
    don't you have to have the QR tight for the trainer?

    No sure if I properly understand your problem. I had a
    similar difficulty with spouse's bike and just replaced
    her QR with the one provided with the trainer.

    DeF.

    The only way to tighten the silver QR is in the closed position and
    turning the other side, which isn't exactly ideal. Not having a tight
    fit doesn't worry me on the trainer, but on the road is a different
    story, which is why when I go on the road I need to swap back to the
    black QR that was std with the bike.

    DaveB

    OK, I've had a closer look at the photo and I think I now
    see your problem - there is a nut on the other side of the
    QR (mostly obscured by your hand) that protrudes too far and
    interferes with the frame. Is that right? If this isn't
    the case, I guess I still don't understand why you don't
    flip the QR open (up in your picture), rotate 180 degrees
    (so that QR lever is down and to the right of the axle) then
    fold lever up to get tension.

    If this doesn't work, another poster suggested getting a
    different QR which will work. It's pretty ordinary for a
    frame to be made that cannot accept standard QR levers!

    DeF.

    --
    e-mail: d.farrow@your finger.murdoch.edu.au
    To reply, you'll have to remove your finger.

  8. DaveB said:


    The only way to tighten the silver QR is in the closed position and
    turning the other side, which isn't exactly ideal. Not having a tight

    I don't get this bit - "The only way to tighten the silver QR is in the
    closed position". Can you explain why you can't open the silver QR,
    tighten the nut at the other end until it's tight, and then close the
    lever on the silver QR? You may have to play with the nut tension to get
    the right closing force, but it should work exactly the same way as the
    black QR?

  9. SteveA said:
    dtmeister said:
    DaveB said:

    I've been using my windtrainer on and off for the past few weeks but


    the

    Quoted message said:

    most annoying thing is that I need to switch QR systems when I go


    from

    Quoted message said:

    the road to the trainer. The std QR with the OCR2 (in the photo


    below)

    Quoted message said:

    doesn't fit in the mount system on the trainer because it is too


    wide.

    Quoted message said:

    But the thin QR (in my fingers in the picture) has the release bit


    out

    Quoted message said:

    the side so is no good in the bike for normal use because I can't
    tighten it correctly. Is it just the OCR2's that have this problem.


    Is

    Quoted message said:

    there a QR that is somewhere in between?

    I had the same issue and replaced my QR with the old style unit that
    you
    have in the picture - I can't understand why you can't get it tight
    enough? IMHO the old style is better because it's sealed better from
    the
    elements.

    --
    ..dt

    Isn't the time difference between the eastern and western coasts
    useful? Ask a tech question when everyone is Bris/Syd/Melb has gone
    home for the day or is eating their dinner, and the Perth mob is there
    to answer it. 😄 😄 😄 .

    Dave, try getting an internal cam QR in the 'modern style' - could be
    the answer to your dilema.

    I get to do the skewerswap a lot when doing bike fits. I suggest using
    the skewer that comes with the spin trainer (it will fit on your roady
    unless there's something *really* odd about your dropouts). Otherwise,
    the standard Shimano skewers work in both too.

    For what it's worth, I suggest getting a [censored] wheel and using that
    in the trainer, saves on having to swap tyres all the time and a heavy
    [censored] will feel better as the weight of it works like a big flywheel,
    smoothing out the trainer.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.