General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Pain! Is it the shoes?

Started by NA · · Last activity · 16 posts · 415 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
19 November 2005
Last activity
26 November 2005
Original author
NA
Posts
16
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
415
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–16 of 16
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. For a year I ran in Saucony Grid Vantage TR shoes. They were great shoes,
    the best running shoes I have ever owned. I am a neutral runner with bad
    knees so I like alot of cushion.
    So when the Saucony Grid Vantage TR's died after a year, I went out to buy
    another pair of the exact same shoes but they had no more in my size and the
    store was not getting anymore in.

    So I was forced to go out and look for new shoes for the right price. I
    tried on Saucony, Asics, Adidas, Nike etc. The pair of shoes that I liked
    the best were the:
    Adidas Meadows Trail Control Shoes (809582)
    http://thestore.adidas.com/cgi-bin/adilive/b2c/product.w?style=E3488&nocache%3D63039

    Description:

    Fly through meadows and forests silently and effortlessly in these
    incredibly functional trail shoes. If you want to get the most out of your
    trail run without spending most of your paycheck, this feature-rich trail
    shoe is for you.
    -Mesh upper
    -3D TORSION® provides adaptive midfoot support
    -adiPRENE® insert under the heel for superior cushioning at impact
    -TRAXIONT outsole for maximum grip in all directions
    -Carbon rubber outsole
    -Trail Control
    -Imported

    Yes, I know they are trail shoes and I run on the treadmill and outdoors on
    asphalt, I do not participate in trail running, but these shoes felt GREAT.

    I went for a 30 minute run on the treadmill and about 5 min into the run I
    got a weird pain on my right calf muscle, but after awhile it went away. The
    day after my run, I noticed a few minor blisters on top of a few of my toes,
    my knees were very sore, quads very sore. Could this be the shoes and these
    are my adjustment pains while "breaking them in"? or could this mean that
    the shoes just aren't meant for me? or could this mean?

    Thanks,
    NA.

  2. NA said:

    . Could this be the shoes and these
    are my adjustment pains while "breaking them in"? or could this mean that
    the shoes just aren't meant for me? or could this mean?

    Could be either, but it's always a good idea to wear shoes just
    walking around for a few days first, just to break them in. It lets
    them stretch, and lets your muscles get used to them, as well as
    giving you some rub marks on places like your toes where you might end
    upo blistered, therefore letting you cover those areas ahead of time.
    You DID buy them a size or two larger than your atreet shoes, right?

  3. I will take your advice and wear them for a few days thank you.

    I can't buy them one or two sizes larger than normal because I wear size 13
    shoes, it is difficult to find size 14.

    Thank you for taking the time to answer my question,
    NA.

    "TheBillRodgers" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    NA said:

    . Could this be the shoes and these
    are my adjustment pains while "breaking them in"? or could this mean that
    the shoes just aren't meant for me? or could this mean?

    Could be either, but it's always a good idea to wear shoes just
    walking around for a few days first, just to break them in. It lets
    them stretch, and lets your muscles get used to them, as well as
    giving you some rub marks on places like your toes where you might end
    upo blistered, therefore letting you cover those areas ahead of time.
    You DID buy them a size or two larger than your atreet shoes, right?

  4. NA said:

    I will take your advice and wear them for a few days thank you.

    I can't buy them one or two sizes larger than normal because I wear size 13
    shoes, it is difficult to find size 14.

    Hmm, that is a problem, but it is very important that your running
    shoes be at least a size larger than your street shoes, so this maybe
    your blistering problem.

    Quoted message said:

    Thank you for taking the time to answer my question,
    NA.

    You're welcome.

  5. Did you try finding them online?
    That's what I've done when I know the exact size & model of shoe I want.
    bj

    "NA" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    So when the Saucony Grid Vantage TR's died after a year, I went out to buy
    another pair of the exact same shoes but they had no more in my size and
    the store was not getting anymore in.

  6. I am in Canada so my options are kind of limited due to duties/taxes. I
    think I will just go to my local mall and get another pair of Saucony's.

    Thanks,
    NA.

    "bj" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:IiNff.5372$BC2.217@trnddc04...

    Quoted message said:

    Did you try finding them online?
    That's what I've done when I know the exact size & model of shoe I want.
    bj

    "NA" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    So when the Saucony Grid Vantage TR's died after a year, I went out to
    buy another pair of the exact same shoes but they had no more in my size
    and the store was not getting anymore in.

  7. "NA" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    For a year I ran in Saucony Grid Vantage TR shoes. They were great shoes,
    the best running shoes I have ever owned. I am a neutral runner with bad
    knees so I like alot of cushion.
    So when the Saucony Grid Vantage TR's died after a year, I went out to buy
    another pair of the exact same shoes but they had no more in my size and
    the store was not getting anymore in.

    So I was forced to go out and look for new shoes for the right price. I
    tried on Saucony, Asics, Adidas, Nike etc. The pair of shoes that I liked
    the best were the:
    Adidas Meadows Trail Control Shoes (809582)
    http://thestore.adidas.com/cgi-bin/adilive/b2c/product.w?style=E3488&nocache%3D63039

    While I've loved Adidas trail shoes, they are not your Sauconys. IMO,
    these trail-trainers are overrated or at least overhyped w.r.t the
    difference between them and a semi-normal training shoe. They don't provide
    much extra traction, but they do generally have more sturdy soles that
    handle sharp rocks better.
    I would try them another day, and if they don't soften to your feet get
    rid of them. Go back to what works, or maybe a Saucony similar to your last
    pair but with a slightly more aggressive sole tread.

    Dave

  8. David Geesaman said:

    While I've loved Adidas trail shoes, they are not your Sauconys.

    Correct, Saucony is a few notches lower in quality that Adidas,
    generally speaking.

    Quoted message said:

    IMO,
    these trail-trainers are overrated or at least overhyped w.r.t the
    difference between them and a semi-normal training shoe. They don't provide
    much extra traction, but they do generally have more sturdy soles that
    handle sharp rocks better.

    Traction is highly overrated unless you're running on mud.

    Quoted message said:

    I would try them another day, and if they don't soften to your feet get
    rid of them. Go back to what works, or maybe a Saucony similar to your last
    pair but with a slightly more aggressive sole tread.

    It takes more than a few days to test a new shoe. The muscles can take
    as much as 2 weeks to adjust.
    All the above is assuming that the shoes are at fault. I believe the
    change in surfaces is a much more likely cause. Stay running on the TM
    with the new shoes for a week, then take another look at the
    situation.
    TheBillRodgers

  9. "Franky" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    David Geesaman said:

    While I've loved Adidas trail shoes, they are not your Sauconys.

    Correct, Saucony is a few notches lower in quality that Adidas,
    generally speaking.

    Adidas is not superior to Saucony. The Adidas last just happens to fit
    my goofy foot better. These brands are equal in quality IME. Nike is the
    only brand I've had problems with as far as construction and durability, but
    only one or two pairs. Some of you people need to quit worrying about shoes
    and focus on running. Find a pair of trainers and racers that work for you,
    and just keep buying more as you wear them out. There is no need to
    constantly swap from brand to brand or model to model, or suspect you're
    "missing out" on something by using what you have.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    IMO,
    these trail-trainers are overrated or at least overhyped w.r.t the
    difference between them and a semi-normal training shoe. They don't
    provide
    much extra traction, but they do generally have more sturdy soles that
    handle sharp rocks better.

    Traction is highly overrated unless you're running on mud.

    And I should note, that in mud, these trail shoes aren't particularly
    better than another shoe. When it's slick, it's slick, period. Only racing
    spikes can alter that situation. I like the trail shoes mostly for running
    on loose footing, where your feet benefit from a little more stability and
    foot protection.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    I would try them another day, and if they don't soften to your feet
    get
    rid of them. Go back to what works, or maybe a Saucony similar to your
    last
    pair but with a slightly more aggressive sole tread.

    It takes more than a few days to test a new shoe. The muscles can take
    as much as 2 weeks to adjust.

    That's ridiculous. There should be no need for your muscles to adjust
    to a training shoe. If it fits, it fits and I can tell within minutes if it
    will rub me raw or work well. The only time I find my muscles making
    adaptation is when I change the weight of the shoe - racers do put different
    muscles to work, but this discussion is about trainers and trail shoes.

    Dave

  10. Thats seems to be one of the unfortunate situations of running.
    A manufacturer will either discontinue or change a brand enough
    that you have to consider looking at new brands. Also you may
    change running terrains or your biomechanics slowly change
    over the decades. About half the time I switch models I buy
    incorrectly and buy twice. I estimate I've gone through about 84
    pairs since 1977 with about seven model changes.

  11. Franky said:
    David Geesaman said:

    While I've loved Adidas trail shoes, they are not your Sauconys.

    Correct, Saucony is a few notches lower in quality that Adidas,
    generally speaking.

    Quoted message said:

    IMO,
    these trail-trainers are overrated or at least overhyped w.r.t the
    difference between them and a semi-normal training shoe. They don't provide
    much extra traction, but they do generally have more sturdy soles that
    handle sharp rocks better.

    Traction is highly overrated unless you're running on mud.

    Quoted message said:

    I would try them another day, and if they don't soften to your feet get
    rid of them. Go back to what works, or maybe a Saucony similar to your last
    pair but with a slightly more aggressive sole tread.

    It takes more than a few days to test a new shoe. The muscles can take
    as much as 2 weeks to adjust.
    All the above is assuming that the shoes are at fault. I believe the
    change in surfaces is a much more likely cause. Stay running on the TM
    with the new shoes for a week, then take another look at the
    situation.
    TheBillRodgers

    WRONG!

    If your new running shoes don't feel right, supporting and protecting
    you on the first run or two, then, if possible, return them and get a
    different brand/model.

    There are enough brands producing enough models to provide comfortable
    shoes for nearly anyone.

    You should not have to adjust to blisters. It means it a bad fit. Some
    muscle aches might happen, but real pain should not.

    So to answer the subject question, IMHO, YES it is the shoes.
    Whether it is the fit, or the model, it seems to me the root problem is
    the shoes.

    TheBill's suggestion of walking in them is not really going to help.
    Funny, but if NA had come here with the exact same story, except
    replace the brand Adidas with Nike, TheBill would have been screaming
    for NA to get rid of the new shoes.

    Your body is more precious than a pair of wrong shoes. Listen to your
    body.

    Ed

  12. Franky said:
    David Geesaman said:

    While I've loved Adidas trail shoes, they are not your Sauconys.

    Correct, Saucony is a few notches lower in quality that Adidas,
    generally speaking.

    Quoted message said:

    IMO,
    these trail-trainers are overrated or at least overhyped w.r.t the
    difference between them and a semi-normal training shoe. They don't provide
    much extra traction, but they do generally have more sturdy soles that
    handle sharp rocks better.

    Traction is highly overrated unless you're running on mud.

    Quoted message said:

    I would try them another day, and if they don't soften to your feet get
    rid of them. Go back to what works, or maybe a Saucony similar to your last
    pair but with a slightly more aggressive sole tread.

    It takes more than a few days to test a new shoe. The muscles can take
    as much as 2 weeks to adjust.
    All the above is assuming that the shoes are at fault. I believe the
    change in surfaces is a much more likely cause. Stay running on the TM
    with the new shoes for a week, then take another look at the
    situation.
    TheBillRodgers

    WRONG!

    If your new running shoes don't feel right, supporting and protecting
    you on the first run or two, then, if possible, return them and get a
    different brand/model.

    There are enough brands producing enough models to provide comfortable
    shoes for nearly anyone.

    You should not have to adjust to blisters. It means it a bad fit. Some
    muscle aches might happen, but real pain should not.

    So to answer the subject question, IMHO, YES it is the shoes.
    Whether it is the fit, or the model, it seems to me the root problem is
    the shoes.

    TheBill's suggestion of walking in them is not really going to help.
    Funny, but if NA had come here with the exact same story, except
    replace the brand Adidas with Nike, TheBill would have been screaming
    for NA to get rid of the new shoes.

    Your body is more precious than a pair of wrong shoes. Listen to your
    body.

    Ed

  13. Ed Prochak said:

    WRONG!

    You're a moron Prozac, so why should we listen to you?

    Spodosaurus
    ------------
    I'm going to die rather sooner than I'd like. I tried butt sex from my
    neighbours, and became the victim of AIDS. Complications in
    hospital following this resulted in full blown (pun intended) AIDS. I now need a boner
    transplant. Many people around the world are waiting for a boner
    transplant, too. Please volunteer to be a boner donor:
    http://www.IGotAidsFromButtSex.org.

  14. Ed Prochak said:

    WRONG!

    You're a moron Prozac, so why should we listen to you?

    Spodosaurus
    ------------
    I'm going to die rather sooner than I'd like. I tried butt sex from my
    neighbours, and became the victim of AIDS. Complications in
    hospital following this resulted in full blown (pun intended) AIDS. I now need a boner
    transplant. Many people around the world are waiting for a boner
    transplant, too. Please volunteer to be a boner donor:
    http://www.IGotAidsFromButtSex.org.

  15. Thank you everyone for the input 🙂

    NA.

    "rick++" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Thats seems to be one of the unfortunate situations of running.
    A manufacturer will either discontinue or change a brand enough
    that you have to consider looking at new brands. Also you may
    change running terrains or your biomechanics slowly change
    over the decades. About half the time I switch models I buy
    incorrectly and buy twice. I estimate I've gone through about 84
    pairs since 1977 with about seven model changes.

  16. NA said:

    About half the time I switch models I buy

    Quoted message said:

    incorrectly and buy twice. I estimate I've gone through about 84
    pairs since 1977 with about seven model changes.

    Of course, Rick's an idiot.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.