Road Cycling · Public discussion

Would these two ideas work?

Started by lazysegall · · Last activity · 8 posts · 438 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Road Cycling
Published
27 July 2004
Last activity
29 July 2004
Original author
lazysegall
Posts
8
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
438
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–8 of 8
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. First, secure communication between directors and racers. Currently, every director has a scanner so he can listen to what everyone else is telling the riders. It is possible to have secure communication (think nextel direct connect). It would seem to me an advantage to have secure communication. Would it be legal? The only other question is whether the teams would want to start a situation where they couldn't hear each other.

    Second, is it legal to use an aero helmet in a road race stage. Certainly, the aerodynamic advantage would not be overwhelmingly useful in the mountains, but some riders always seem to go on long breakaways. For a rider who wanted to go on a long break on a flat stage he might gain a good advantage by wearing an aero helmet. Is it legal and would there even be an advantage to this.

  2. in article [email hidden], lazysegall at
    [email hidden] wrote on 7/26/04 7:52 PM:

    Quoted message said:

    Second, is it legal to use an aero helmet in a road race stage.
    Certainly, the aerodynamic advantage would not be overwhelmingly useful
    in the mountains, but some riders always seem to go on long breakaways.
    For a rider who wanted to go on a long break on a flat stage he might
    gain a good advantage by wearing an aero helmet. Is it legal and would
    there even be an advantage to this.

    Even if it were legal (which I think it probably is), the drawback is
    comfort. Time-trials only take around an hour, and road stages can drag on
    for 6 hours. It would be absolutely agonizing to wear a big, bulky aero
    helmet for that long.

    -Sonarrat.

  3. Sonarrat said:

    in article [email hidden], lazysegall at
    [email hidden] wrote on 7/26/04 7:52 PM:

    Quoted message said:

    Second, is it legal to use an aero helmet in a road race stage.
    Certainly, the aerodynamic advantage would not be overwhelmingly useful
    in the mountains, but some riders always seem to go on long breakaways.
    For a rider who wanted to go on a long break on a flat stage he might
    gain a good advantage by wearing an aero helmet. Is it legal and would
    there even be an advantage to this.

    Even if it were legal (which I think it probably is), the drawback is
    comfort. Time-trials only take around an hour, and road stages can drag on
    for 6 hours. It would be absolutely agonizing to wear a big, bulky aero
    helmet for that long.

    -Sonarrat.


    Bike racing is a pretty agonizing sport in general though, and although it would not make sense to do it everyday, a rider could do it when he expected to be in a long break. If the rider missed the break then he might be able to drop it off at the team car...On the other hand is the improvement so minor that the pain would eventually offset any gains.

  4. lazysegall said:


    Sonarrat said:

    in article [email hidden], lazysegall
    at
    [email hidden] wrote on 7/26/04 7:52
    PM:

    Quoted message said:

    Second, is it legal to use an aero helmet in a road race stage.
    Certainly, the aerodynamic advantage would not be overwhelmingly


    useful

    Quoted message said:

    in the mountains, but some riders always seem to go on long


    breakaways.

    Quoted message said:

    For a rider who wanted to go on a long break on a flat stage he might
    gain a good advantage by wearing an aero helmet. Is it legal and


    would

    Quoted message said:

    there even be an advantage to this.

    Even if it were legal (which I think it probably is), the drawback is
    comfort. Time-trials only take around an hour, and road stages can
    drag on
    for 6 hours. It would be absolutely agonizing to wear a big, bulky
    aero
    helmet for that long.

    -Sonarrat.


    Bike racing is a pretty agonizing sport in general though, and
    although it would not make sense to do it everyday, a rider could do it
    when he expected to be in a long break. If the rider missed the break
    then he might be able to drop it off at the team car...On the other
    hand is the improvement so minor that the pain would eventually offset
    any gains.

    The painful part would be having the peloton make fun of you. Don't think you'll
    surprise anyone when you take off, either.

    The advantage is very minor.

    Ron

  5. lazysegall said:


    First, secure communication between directors and racers. Currently,
    every director has a scanner so he can listen to what everyone else is
    telling the riders. It is possible to have secure communication (think
    nextel direct connect).

    Yes, but how secure is secure? I don't know what specific products are available.

    Quoted message said:

    It would seem to me an advantage to have secure
    communication. Would it be legal?

    Knock yourself out:
    http://www.etsi.org/

    Quoted message said:

    The only other question is whether
    the teams would want to start a situation where they couldn't hear each
    other.

    You mean like turn the radios off?

  6. "lazysegall" wrote...

    Quoted message said:


    Second, is it legal to use an aero helmet in a road race stage.
    Certainly, the aerodynamic advantage would not be overwhelmingly useful
    in the mountains, but some riders always seem to go on long breakaways.
    For a rider who wanted to go on a long break on a flat stage he might
    gain a good advantage by wearing an aero helmet. Is it legal and would
    there even be an advantage to this.

    The presence of the helmet would telegraph the riders intentions and part of
    the effectiveness of the breakaway is the element of surprise.

  7. "Jim Flom" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<TZ7Oc.117866$Rf.70990@edtnps84>...

    Quoted message said:

    "lazysegall" wrote...

    Quoted message said:


    Second, is it legal to use an aero helmet in a road race stage.
    Certainly, the aerodynamic advantage would not be overwhelmingly useful
    in the mountains, but some riders always seem to go on long breakaways.
    For a rider who wanted to go on a long break on a flat stage he might
    gain a good advantage by wearing an aero helmet. Is it legal and would
    there even be an advantage to this.

    The presence of the helmet would telegraph the riders intentions and part of
    the effectiveness of the breakaway is the element of surprise.

    Kinda like showing up for your group ride with a disk, skinsuit and aerobars.

    "Say, Bob, what are you up to in that get up?"

  8. RonSonic <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>...

    Quoted message said:
    lazysegall said:


    Sonarrat said:

    in article [email hidden], lazysegall
    at
    [email hidden] wrote on 7/26/04 7:52
    PM:

    > Second, is it legal to use an aero helmet in a road race stage.
    > Certainly, the aerodynamic advantage would not be overwhelmingly


    useful

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    > in the mountains, but some riders always seem to go on long


    breakaways.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    > For a rider who wanted to go on a long break on a flat stage he might
    > gain a good advantage by wearing an aero helmet. Is it legal and


    would

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    > there even be an advantage to this.

    Even if it were legal (which I think it probably is), the drawback is
    comfort. Time-trials only take around an hour, and road stages can
    drag on
    for 6 hours. It would be absolutely agonizing to wear a big, bulky
    aero
    helmet for that long.

    -Sonarrat.


    Bike racing is a pretty agonizing sport in general though, and
    although it would not make sense to do it everyday, a rider could do it
    when he expected to be in a long break. If the rider missed the break
    then he might be able to drop it off at the team car...On the other
    hand is the improvement so minor that the pain would eventually offset
    any gains.

    The painful part would be having the peloton make fun of you. Don't think you'll
    surprise anyone when you take off, either.

    The advantage is very minor.

    Unless you road the TT of your life over the last 40 km of a flat
    stage while the sprinters teams cooked themselves chasing. Don't
    exepect them the peloton to be very happy with you next race.

    Reality is you'd be so marked, any jump would immediately result in a
    few guys sitting on your wheel.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.