Treefrog said:I found walking with crampons to be no challenge at all
The problem with stuff like cramponing is the basics really /are/ very
easy: you just walk around, but with crampons on! But that easiness
leads to sloppy technique that can, very literally, trip you up when
things get trickier. There's more to crampons than walking in crampons,
which is not to say you can't teach yourself but you must be aware that
flatfooting a steep slope of hard nevee safely is a non-trivial game and
making it up as you go along isn't the most Cunning Plan.
Quoted message said:and practising self
arrest with an axe was/is great fun (just make sure we wear full water
proofs and gaiters) and take a friend incase you don't quite make the arrest
The problem with teach yourself is you don't have an objective eye to
tell you what you're doing less well than you might. If you've got a
friend along that knows what they're at then they can provide this, and
it's probably more useful than a "catching service", especially if
you've got a good spot where worst case is getting buried in a drift at
the bottom.
Quoted message said:The chances are that if you're wearing crampons, you wont need the axe
If the terrain you're travelling through is all gentle gradients and
there's little but hard nevee and water ice down then maybe, but IME
terrain changes on many walks and there are places you need an axe
(steep ground, generally) where crampons alone are no substitute, and in
fresh, deep snow in UK conditions crampons usually ball up terribly and
are more trouble than they're worth.
IME an axe is considerably more use than a pair of crampons in the UK hills.
Quoted message said:Finally, a little foot note. If you don't have any friends that understand
the need to subject yourself to hours of cold and wet, but still want to
practice the self arrest, you could get yourself a 50/60m length of rope,
setup a bomber anchor (or three) and tie into the other end of the rope,
that way, if you fail to stop yourself after 50m, the rope will do it for
you, albeit quite abruptly.
As it stands that information is potentially very dangerous. This sort
of thing needs a rope designed to take dynamic loads, like a climbing
rope, and they aren't cheap. If you use any other rope you'll stop
/very/ abruptly and quite possibly hurt yourself badly, and maybe break
the rope too. Not too clever. You'd be much better off just looking
for a safe runout.
You don't need a winter skills course for this sort of thing, but
working with someone who knows what they're at (note this does /not/
necessarily mean professional guide) will get you up to speed quicker,
and probably a higher level. One thing self teaching requires is
confidence in your own ability to do it, and if you're not sure then it
may be worth throwing some money at it and take a course at PYB or
Glenmore Lodge. Sort of thing that you can put on your Christmas Wish
List, in fact.
Pete.
--
Peter Clinch Medical Physics IT Officer
Tel 44 1382 660111 ext. 33637 Univ. of Dundee, Ninewells Hospital
Fax 44 1382 640177 Dundee DD1 9SY Scotland UK
net [email hidden] http://www.dundee.ac.uk/~pjclinch/