General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Which would you buy?

Started by Darkginger · · Last activity · 42 posts · 1,206 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
5 July 2004
Last activity
5 July 2004
Original author
Darkginger
Posts
42
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,206
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 42
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    may be) which of the following would you buy, given a
    free choice?

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5
    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10
    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    Does your answer depend on how you intend to cook the bird,
    or do you have other criteria for making your choice? Just
    wondering what factors people take into consideration when
    shopping for chicken. For those who aren't in the Euro zone,
    substitute US$ for ?!

    Jo

    ---
    Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-
    virus system (grisoft.comgrisoft.com). Version: 6.0.708 /
    Virus Database: 464 - Release Date: 18/06/04

  2. Darkginger said:

    Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    may be) which of the following would you buy, given a
    free choice?

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5
    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10
    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    So what you're really trying to do is find out if there's a
    market for a "seaweed nourished chicken"?

    Where do you plan on obtaining organic seaweed? Certainly
    not from the ocean.

    -sw

  3. Darkginger said:

    Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    may be) which of the following would you buy, given a
    free choice?

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5
    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10
    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    Does your answer depend on how you intend to cook the
    bird, or do you have other criteria for making your
    choice? Just wondering what factors people take into
    consideration when shopping for chicken. For those who
    aren't in the Euro zone, substitute US$ for ?!

    Jo

    I'm in the US and before I answer your question about
    chicken, I have one for you, Jo. Does the entire
    continent use Euros now? Are Britain and Scotland still
    doing pound sterling?

    Now, onto your chicken question. I seriously have never
    thought much about what my chicken was fed or how it was
    raised. This will probably get me a few flames, but chickens
    are, for me, a food product, not a pet. I go for the
    cheapest chicken per pound. A whole chicken is usually about
    29-39 cents/lb USD. A four pound roaster or stewing hen will
    get you plenty of meat as well as bones and giblets for
    making a nice gelatinous stock.

    Jill

  4. "Darkginger" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    :"]news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    may be) which of the following would you buy, given a
    free choice?

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5
    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10
    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    Does your answer depend on how you intend to cook the
    bird, or do you have other criteria for making your
    choice? Just wondering what factors people take into
    consideration when shopping for chicken. For those who
    aren't in the Euro zone, substitute US$ for ?!

    Jo

    ---
    Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-
    virus system (grisoft.comgrisoft.com). Version: 6.0.708 /
    Virus Database: 464 - Release Date: 18/06/04

    Depends on the government regs on the word organic and the
    word free range.

    --
    Once during Prohibition I was forced to live for days on
    nothing but food and water.
    --------
    FIELDS, W. C.

  5. In article <[email hidden]>, "Darkginger"

    Quoted message said:

    Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    may be) which of the following would you buy, given a
    free choice?

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5
    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10
    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    Does your answer depend on how you intend to cook the
    bird, or do you have other criteria for making your
    choice? Just wondering what factors people take into
    consideration when shopping for chicken. For those who
    aren't in the Euro zone, substitute US$ for ?!

    For soup, I'd buy the free-range birdy and have tasty
    chicken meat for salad or spread. For other use, I'd buy the
    chicken with the unknown lineage. I believe hell would
    freeze over before I'd spend $16 on a seaweed-nourished
    birdy, UNLESS I'd already tasted same and its succulence and
    deliciousness could barely be described in words. Then I
    actually might if it were that good.
    --
    -Barb, <www.jamlady.eboard.com> Sam I Am updated 6/20/04.

  6. "Darkginger" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    :"]news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    may be) which of the following would you buy, given a
    free choice?

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5
    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10
    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    Does your answer depend on how you intend to cook the
    bird, or do you have other criteria for making your
    choice? Just wondering what factors people take into
    consideration when shopping for chicken. For those who
    aren't in the Euro zone, substitute US$ for ?!

    Jo

    ---
    Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-
    virus system (grisoft.comgrisoft.com). Version: 6.0.708 /
    Virus Database: 464 - Release Date: 18/06/04

    "B" I don't like not knowing the source and I don't like
    anything to do with seaweed. Cost is not all that much of an
    issue, and I would be cooking it myself.

    --
    Wayne in Phoenix

    If there's a nit to pick, some nitwit will pick it.

  7. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Darkginger said:

    Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    may be) which of the following would you buy, given a
    free choice?

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5
    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10
    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    Does your answer depend on how you intend to cook the
    bird, or do you have other criteria for making your
    choice? Just wondering what factors people take into
    consideration when shopping for chicken. For those who
    aren't in the Euro zone, substitute US$ for ?!

    Jo

    I used to belong to a poultry farming list, and there are a
    lot of urban legends about mass produced poultry that are
    just not true...

    They are not fed growth hormone, their size and fast growth
    rate is due to the BREED, not drugs.

    They are also not inundated with antibiotics and when a
    flock is treated due to illness in the flock, they have a
    mandatory withdrawl period prior to slaughter to eliminate
    antibiotic residue in the meat.

    I don't go out of my way to purchase organic chicken, but
    will purchase free range chicken (Buddy's) when it is on
    sale simply because there really is a difference in flavor.
    Most of the time I just buy the regular cheap chicken from
    the grocery store.

    I like to buy parts personally unless I want a roasting
    bird. Boneless skinless thigh meat is my favorite and I
    spice it lightly and either put it into the foreman grill or
    use it in stir fry.

    For fried chicken, I buy drumsticks and wings.

    The richest, most flavorful chicken that I get to eat once
    in awhile are culled excess roosters from my own free-range
    flock. They get a lot of green stuff and are usually culled
    at about 4 months of age.

    K.

    --
    Sprout the Mung Bean to reply...

    Quoted message said:

    ,,<Cat's Haven Hobby Farm>,,<Katraatcenturyteldotnet>,,<

    cgi6.ebay.comeBayISAPI.dll
    &include=0&userid=katra

  8. [email hidden] :

    || b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10

    Yep

    || For those who aren't in the Euro zone, substitute US$
    || for ?!
    ||
    Not in Euro or US...

    --
    "Pooh," said Rabbit kindly, "you haven't any brain." "I
    know," said Pooh humbly.

  9. Quoted message said:

    From: "Darkginger"

    Quoted message said:

    Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    may be) which of the following would you buy, given a
    free choice?

    Quoted message said:

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5

    See here's the thing. I can look up online the "brand" of
    the $5 chicken - review that way that is has been raised
    and processed and make a decision based on that
    information. Most of the $5 chickens are locally processed
    so I know I'm getting a product that is the type of breed I
    prefer (different breeds have different flavor) plus it's
    fresher than one that has traveled 1000's of miles that may
    be less fresh.

    Quoted message said:

    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10

    Even Smart Chicken, which is processed differently doesn't
    cost $10. Around $8. for a 3 lb chicken. Very tasty.

    Quoted message said:

    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    No.

    Ellen

  10. "Darkginger" .

    Quoted message said:

    Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    may be) which of the following would you buy, given


    a

    Quoted message said:

    free choice?

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5

    Here it would cost about $8 dollars at our local
    supermarket. My first choice.

    Quoted message said:

    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10


    Here it would cost about $14 dollars. Second choice.

    Quoted message said:

    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16


    Dont have these. But wonder what they would taste like.

    Quoted message said:


    Does your answer depend on how you intend to cook the
    bird, or do you have other criteria for making your
    choice? Just wondering what factors people take into
    consideration when shopping for chicken. For those who
    aren't in the Euro zone, substitute US$ for ?!

    Im not in the Euro or US zones.

    Given that we dont buy many chickens raw (since all above
    are raw) I usually wait chickens are on special for $5 each
    and buy them hot and already cooked.

    Nik

    Quoted message said:

    Jo

    ---
    Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-
    virus system (grisoft.comgrisoft.com). Version: 6.0.708 /
    Virus Database: 464 - Release Date: 18/06/04

  11. Darkginger said:


    Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    may be) which of the following would you buy, given a
    free choice?

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5
    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10
    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    Does your answer depend on how you intend to cook the
    bird, or do you have other criteria for making your
    choice? Just wondering what factors people take into
    consideration when shopping for chicken. For those who
    aren't in the Euro zone, substitute US$ for ?!

    Jo

    B most likely, depending on the size of the chicken.
    Probably not C; I've had chicken which was fed on fish meal
    and it was terrible and fishy-tasting. Doesn't the seaweed
    leave a seaweedy taste in the flesh too?

    Of course most of the chickens we buy are in the A category!
    But as long as they aren't injected with water or salt
    solution they are usually OK.

  12. Darkginger <[email hidden]> wrote:
    : Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    : acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    : being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    : may be) which of the following would you buy, given a
    : free choice?

    : a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5
    : b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10
    : c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    : costing ?16

    : Does your answer depend on how you intend to cook the
    : bird, or do you have other criteria for making your
    : choice? Just wondering what factors people take into
    : consideration when shopping for chicken. For those who
    : aren't in the Euro zone, substitute US$ for ?!

    I'd try each of them once and stick with the type
    that had the most taste--my guess is that would be
    b), which is the type I buy here--locally grown
    free range chicken, sometimes labelled organic,
    sometimes not. --thelma
    : Jo

  13. "Darkginger" wrote in message

    Quoted message said:

    Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I


    thought I'd ask you lot. All things being equal, and with
    your current income (whatever that may be) which of the
    following would you buy, given a free choice?>

    My food budget, some weeks I have more to spend on meat
    than others.

    Quoted message said:

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5

    This is what I mostly buy, I eat alot of chicken and fish.
    More likely 3-4 dollars

    Quoted message said:

    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10

    When I can I buy these, usually less expensive, 7-8 dollars.

    Quoted message said:

    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    Nope, why would I do that?

    Quoted message said:

    Does your answer depend on how you intend to cook the
    bird, or do you have


    other criteria for making your choice? >

    It's a cash flow decision though I'd like to always buy the
    free range, I can't always afford to.

    Quoted message said:

    Just wondering what factors people take into consideration
    when shopping


    for chicken. For those who aren't in the Euro zone,
    substitute US$ for ?!

    Quoted message said:

    Jo

    Suzan in San Diego

  14. Darkginger said:


    Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    may be) which of the following would you buy, given a
    free choice?

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5
    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10
    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    Does your answer depend on how you intend to cook the
    bird, or do you have other criteria for making your
    choice? Just wondering what factors people take into
    consideration when shopping for chicken. For those who
    aren't in the Euro zone, substitute US$ for ?!

    Jo

    ---

    For chicken, A. Much of the time it is cooked in a way that
    adds ethnic or other strong flavor. Chicken is a tabla rasa
    to decorate as you will.

    gloria p

  15. Darkginger said:

    Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    may be) which of the following would you buy, given a
    free choice?

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5
    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10
    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    Does your answer depend on how you intend to cook the
    bird, or do you have other criteria for making your
    choice? Just wondering what factors people take into
    consideration when shopping for chicken. For those who
    aren't in the Euro zone, substitute US$ for ?!

    Depends how thick (or thin) my wallet is and how they look.

  16. Darkginger said:

    All things being equal, and with your current income
    (whatever that may be) which of the following would you
    buy, given a free choice?

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5
    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10
    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    A, primarily for economic reasons. However, if I *could*
    afford 2 or 3 times the price, I'd wonder whether the actual
    or perceived benefit was worth the tariff.

  17. Darkginger had something important to tell us on Sat,
    26 Jun 2004
    18:43:54 +0100:

    Quoted message said:

    Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    may be) which of the following would you buy, given a
    free choice?

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5
    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10
    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    I have no idea what difference a 'seaweed-fed' chicken has
    to the ordinary sort. If possible I buy free-range chicken
    because I hate to think of birds being caged up and at least
    the free-range birds have some kind of freedom of movement.
    Organic is better for you, but I can't afford it... (and
    yes, we use common-or-garden chicken breasts too - the
    organic free-range ones are too hard to get and too
    expensive!)
    --
    ~Karen AKA Kajikit Lover of shiny things...

    Made as of 22 June 2004 - 83 cards, 51 SB pages (plus 3
    small giftbooks), 59 decos & more!

    Visit my webpage: kajikitscorner.comkajikitscorner.com Allergyfree
    Eating Recipe Swap:
    groups.yahoo.comAllergyfree Eating Ample
    Aussies Mailing List:
    groups.yahoo.comampleaussies

  18. Darkginger said:

    Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    may be) which of the following would you buy, given a
    free choice?

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5
    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10
    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    Does your answer depend on how you intend to cook the bird,
    or do you have other criteria for making your choice? Just
    wondering what factors people take into consideration when
    shopping for chicken. For those who aren't in the Euro
    zone, substitute US$ for ?!

    Jo

    At those prices: a.

  19. "jmcquown" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:

    I'm in the US and before I answer your question about
    chicken, I have one for you, Jo. Does the entire continent
    use Euros now? Are Britain and Scotland still doing pound
    sterling?

    Now, onto your chicken question. I seriously have never
    thought much


    about

    Quoted message said:

    what my chicken was fed or how it was raised. This will
    probably get me a few flames, but chickens are, for me, a
    food product, not a pet. I go for the cheapest chicken per
    pound. A whole chicken is usually about 29-39 cents/lb
    USD. A four pound roaster or stewing hen will get you
    plenty of meat as well as bones and giblets for making a
    nice gelatinous stock.

    Jill

    Thanks for that, Jill. No, the UK (England, Wales, Scotland
    and Northern Ireland) is still using GBP - and there are a
    few other countries in Europe which don't use the Euro - not
    sure which, as I don't travel much nowadays! In case there's
    any confusion, I used to live in the UK, but moved to
    Ireland (the Republic of) some 5 years ago.

    As a chicken keeper, and also an occasional buyer of 'bog
    basic' chicken, I certainly wouldn't dream of flaming you
    for your choice, although I would say that I've found a
    marked difference in taste between *some* free range
    chickens and their intensively reared equivalents. Until
    there's some standardisation in chicken labelling, it's
    difficult to know just how free range your free range chook
    actually is!

    Jo

    ---
    Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-
    virus system (grisoft.comgrisoft.com). Version: 6.0.708 /
    Virus Database: 464 - Release Date: 18/06/04

  20. "Steve Wertz" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Darkginger said:

    Just doing a bit of a survey amongst friends and
    acquaintances - so I thought I'd ask you lot. All things
    being equal, and with your current income (whatever that
    may be) which of the following would you buy, given


    a

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    free choice?

    a) a chicken, of unknown provenance, costing ?5
    b) a free-range chicken, costing ?10
    c) a free range, organic, seaweed-nourished chicken,
    costing ?16

    So what you're really trying to do is find out if there's
    a market for a "seaweed nourished chicken"?

    Where do you plan on obtaining organic seaweed? Certainly
    not from the ocean.

    Actually, no. It's just that this is the choice which my
    local supermarket gives me (our chickens are for eggs only -
    we don't eat 'em). I buy all 3 types of chicken, depending
    on what I'm intending to do with them - I was just wondering
    how many people would look at me aghast if I told them that
    I regularly pay ?16 for a chicken!

    As for 'organic' seaweed - well, I eat seaweed from our
    local Blue Flag (ie, they meet a certain standard for
    cleanliness) beaches, and I'm still in one piece, and don't
    glow in the dark.

    Jo (apologies for mailing you directly, Seve - hit the wrong
    button, then had to copy 'n paste back to the group - argh!)

    ---
    Outgoing mail is certified Virus Free. Checked by AVG anti-
    virus system (grisoft.comgrisoft.com). Version: 6.0.708 /
    Virus Database: 464 - Release Date: 18/06/04

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.