General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Wheat bread vs Whole Wheat Bread ???

Started by Will · · Last activity · 11 posts · 2,872 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
20 June 2005
Last activity
22 June 2005
Original author
Will
Posts
11
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
2,872
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–11 of 11
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Seems like I heard that most "wheat bread" at the store has processed the
    "good stuff" out of it... meaning the good stuff out of whole grain...

    But I'm not sure of this...

    I'm trying to eat more whole grains and want to understand this better...

    1 - Can anyone educate me on this subject?

    2 - Also, anybody know if the wheat bread buns at Subway has the good stuff
    in them... meaning all the value of whole grain or whatever?

    thanks for the help - Will

  2. In article <[email hidden]>, "Will"

    Quoted message said:

    Seems like I heard that most "wheat bread" at the store has processed the
    "good stuff" out of it... meaning the good stuff out of whole grain...

    But I'm not sure of this...

    I'm trying to eat more whole grains and want to understand this better...

    1 - Can anyone educate me on this subject?

    2 - Also, anybody know if the wheat bread buns at Subway has the good stuff
    in them... meaning all the value of whole grain or whatever?

    As Sheldon would post, what do you think white bread is made out of?
    Wheat! It's *all* wheat bread. What's the difference? The brown stuff
    labeled as "wheat" has food coloring added. Perhaps you want "whole
    wheat" bread?

    :-)

    --
    Dan Abel
    Sonoma State University
    AIS
    [email hidden]

  3. The wheat kernel has 3 parts:

    the germ (contains oil, vitamins)
    the endosperm (the part white flour is made from, has the gluten)
    the bran (has the fiber, makes a denser loaf).

    Depending on your diet and what constitutes good nutrition for you, you
    want flour made from one, the other, some, or all of the 3 parts. Whole
    wheat flour should mean flour made from all 3, and many consumers want
    bread made from whole wheat flour-- or rather, they think they want
    that. Then they discover that whole wheat bread is denser, chewier, not
    as light as the white bread they're used to. There are consumers who
    want to think they're eating whole wheat bread for the nutritional
    advantage when they simultaneously want a loaf that's exactly like the
    white bread they prefer.

    This provides a rich environment for advertisers to take advantage of
    the situation. By advertising "wheat bread," they can be telling the
    literal truth. The bread is made from wheat flour (as opposed to rye or
    corn or oat or any number of other grains or substances that can be
    ground into flour). But the bread is not made from the whole wheat
    kernel (or has only a little whole wheat flour in it). The word "wheat"
    conjures up the picture of "whole wheat" in the consumer's mind.

    Paydirt! The consumers get the light loaf they prefer to eat while
    getting the warm fuzzy feeling that comes with eating health food.
    Meanwhile, white flour is cheaper by far so the bakery (or Subway or
    similar company) saves money. I don't know the specific buns you're
    talking about at Subway, but I have seen bread that was made with
    processed refined white flour plus coloring to turn it brown. That's
    cheaper than using whole wheat flour in the first place.

    I should stress that white flour is not necessarily a bad or inferior
    product. This is one of those situations where the best bread for you
    depends on what you like and your specific nutritional needs.

    --Lia

    Will said:

    Seems like I heard that most "wheat bread" at the store has processed the
    "good stuff" out of it, meaning the good stuff out of whole grain, but I'm not sure of
    this. I'm trying to eat more whole grains and want to understand this better.

    1 - Can anyone educate me on this subject?

    2 - Also, anybody know if the wheat bread buns at Subway has the good stuff
    in them, meaning all the value of whole grain or whatever?

    Thanks for the help - Will

  4. In article <[email hidden]>, "Will"

    Quoted message said:

    Seems like I heard that most "wheat bread" at the store has processed the
    "good stuff" out of it... meaning the good stuff out of whole grain...

    But I'm not sure of this...

    I'm trying to eat more whole grains and want to understand this better...

    1 - Can anyone educate me on this subject?

    Look for at least 3g of dietary fiber per slice. Sara Lee makes some
    "Heart Healthy" breads that fill that bill.
    --
    -Barb, <http://www.jamlady.eboard.com> 6/17/05 Pictures & story
    from Notable Women's Dinner at the Governor's Residence.

  5. Will said:

    Seems like I heard that most "wheat bread" at the store has processed the
    "good stuff" out of it... meaning the good stuff out of whole grain...

    But I'm not sure of this...

    I'm trying to eat more whole grains and want to understand this better...

    1 - Can anyone educate me on this subject?

    2 - Also, anybody know if the wheat bread buns at Subway has the good stuff
    in them... meaning all the value of whole grain or whatever?

    thanks for the help - Will

    "wheat" bread is dark colored "wonder" type bread. If you want whole
    grains, look at the ingredients. The first one should be "100% whole
    {whatever grain}"

    --

    saerah

    "It's not a gimmick, it's an incentive."- asterbark, afca

    aware of the manifold possibilities of the future

    "I think there's a clause in the Shaman's and Jujumen's Local #57 Union
    contract that they have to have reciprocity for each other's shop rules."
    -König Prüß

  6. "sarah bennett" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    "wheat" bread is dark colored "wonder" type bread. If you want whole
    grains, look at the ingredients. The first one should be "100% whole
    {whatever grain}"

    True. There are some commercial 100% whole wheat breads that are not as
    dense/dry/chewy as others. The lighter, fluffier 100% whole wheat
    breads (such as those made by Wonder or Schmidt's) use added ingredients
    to lighten the bread. I find these loaves to be a good compromise; you
    might not be getting as much whole grain per slice as you do in a
    heavier loaf, but it's still a whole grain product and is more like
    white bread than the heavy/chewy type w/out the added ingredients.

    Also, beware of "multigrain" or 7-grain, 9-grain, 12-grain or 15-grain
    bread. Read the label. Sometimes these loaves are 100% whole grain,
    but sometimes the first ingredient is "Enriched wheat flour" (not a
    whole grain -- that's white flour with vitamins added).

    Chris

  7. "Will" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Seems like I heard that most "wheat bread" at the store has processed the
    "good stuff" out of it... meaning the good stuff out of whole grain...

    But I'm not sure of this...

    I'm trying to eat more whole grains and want to understand this better...

    1 - Can anyone educate me on this subject?

    2 - Also, anybody know if the wheat bread buns at Subway has the good
    stuff in them... meaning all the value of whole grain or whatever?

    thanks for the help - Will

    Pasty white Wonder bread is wheat bread. It is made from wheat after all but
    just poart pof the wheat with the germ and bran removed - white flour in
    other words. You need whole wheat bread which uses flour made from the
    entire wheat kernel.

    --
    Peter Aitken
    Visit my recipe and kitchen myths page at www.pgacon.com/cooking.htm

  8. Chris said:
    sarah bennett said:
    Quoted message said:

    "wheat" bread is dark colored "wonder" type bread. If you want whole
    grains, look at the ingredients. The first one should be "100% whole
    {whatever grain}"

    True. There are some commercial 100% whole wheat breads that are not as
    dense/dry/chewy as others. The lighter, fluffier 100% whole wheat
    breads (such as those made by Wonder or Schmidt's) use added ingredients
    to lighten the bread. I find these loaves to be a good compromise; you
    might not be getting as much whole grain per slice as you do in a
    heavier loaf, but it's still a whole grain product and is more like
    white bread than the heavy/chewy type w/out the added ingredients.

    Also, beware of "multigrain" or 7-grain, 9-grain, 12-grain or 15-grain
    bread. Read the label. Sometimes these loaves are 100% whole grain,
    but sometimes the first ingredient is "Enriched wheat flour" (not a
    whole grain -- that's white flour with vitamins added).

    Chris

    You really haven't a clue about bread, and how I know is that you
    mention "added ingredients", twice... but never give even one example.
    "Added ingredients' is a STUPID term, EVERY ingredient in EVERY recipe
    is ADDED! DUH Nothing you've written is accurate, in fact from reading
    each post in this thread, not one gives accurate information (100%
    "whatever" morons). Stick to bakery stuff yooose know, like how to open
    a bag of Oreos.

    Sheldon

  9. Dan Abel said:

    In article <[email hidden]>, "Will"

    Quoted message said:

    Seems like I heard that most "wheat bread" at the store has processed the
    "good stuff" out of it... meaning the good stuff out of whole grain...

    But I'm not sure of this...

    I'm trying to eat more whole grains and want to understand this better...

    1 - Can anyone educate me on this subject?

    2 - Also, anybody know if the wheat bread buns at Subway has the good stuff
    in them... meaning all the value of whole grain or whatever?

    As Sheldon would post, what do you think white bread is made out of?
    Wheat! It's *all* wheat bread. What's the difference? The brown stuff
    labeled as "wheat" has food coloring added. Perhaps you want "whole
    wheat" bread?

    I would never say any such thing, everything you wrote is 100%
    incorrect.

    Sheldon

  10. Will said:

    Seems like I heard that most "wheat bread" at the store has processed the
    "good stuff" out of it.

    Not 100% necessarily so... plain old white wheat bread (like Wonder)
    may contain far more nutrition than many typical 100% whole wheat
    breads. Often *enriched* flours contain more nutrition than whole
    grain flours (in almost all cases, ounce for ounce, any enriched flour
    contains more nutrition than the natural whole grain flour
    counterpart). About the only dietary component one can be fairly
    certain of receivng more of from whole grain bread is bran (which of
    course contains 0% nutritional value - bran is a dietary component, not
    a nutritional component). To know the nutritional value contained in
    commercailly prepared breads you need to read the label... with
    homemade breads there is no way to make such a determination, leastways
    no practical way... for the vast majority of home bakers they'd need
    access to a food testing laboratory. Typically commercially prepared
    breads (especially the big brands) contain greater nutritional value
    than homemade.

    Most of the vitamin nutrition in grains is contained in the germ,
    whereas most of that nutrition is lost just by the milling process,
    more is lost simply by being around awhile, and then most of what
    manages to remain is lost from exposure to heat in baking. I'm sure
    some of you have noticed that wheat germ is packaged in glass jars,
    vacuum packed... and clearly state to refrigerate upon opening. I've
    yet to see any whole grain flours sold in the refrigerated case... so
    by the time you buy it it's already too late to preserve it's nutrition
    by refrigerating.

    The big commercial bread companys purchase their wheat before it's
    planted, and then oversees its treatment every step of the way,
    monitoring it constantly from seed to finished product. Flours yoose
    buy off the stupidmarket shelf is typically already well past it's
    prime. One of the best ways for the home baker to obtain full
    nutritional value is to include some whole *unprocessed* grains in
    their bread... and find a source where there is good turnover and
    proper storage (preferably refrigerated). Of course one can always
    mill their own flours, but still include some whole unprocessed grain
    because heat generated from milling destroys/evaporates much vitamin
    nutrition.

    Sheldon

  11. "Sheldon" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Dan Abel said:

    In article <[email hidden]>, "Will"

    Quoted message said:

    Seems like I heard that most "wheat bread" at the store has processed


    the

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    "good stuff" out of it... meaning the good stuff out of whole grain...

    But I'm not sure of this...

    I'm trying to eat more whole grains and want to understand this


    better...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:


    1 - Can anyone educate me on this subject?

    2 - Also, anybody know if the wheat bread buns at Subway has the good


    stuff

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    in them... meaning all the value of whole grain or whatever?

    As Sheldon would post, what do you think white bread is made out of?
    Wheat! It's *all* wheat bread. What's the difference? The brown stuff
    labeled as "wheat" has food coloring added. Perhaps you want "whole
    wheat" bread?

    I would never say any such thing, everything you wrote is 100%
    incorrect.

    Sheldon

    Exactly.

    Shaun aRe

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.