Road Cycling · Public discussion

what would you choose?

Started by lowkey · · Last activity · 18 posts · 610 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Road Cycling
Published
30 September 2005
Last activity
1 October 2005
Original author
lowkey
Posts
18
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
610
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–18 of 18
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. One route I frequent takes me out Stone Rd. It is a multi-lane east/west
    city street that abruptly narrows to a single lane east of Gordon St. as you
    pass through, first the university proper, and then the arboretum on the
    north side and residential followed by undeveloped land to the south.

    At the next major intersection - Victoria Rd. - the street has recently
    been rebuilt into a luxurious multi-lane intersection with incredibly wide
    bike lanes with nary a storm grate. Those have been built integral to the
    curb so that the bike lane is a smooth strip of pristine asphalt almost a
    car width wide.

    The narrow single lane stretch in-between the multi-lane intersections is
    the problem. the lanes are very narrow and quite busy. the should is unpaved
    and very broad - easily a kar lane wide. but while the surface is broadly
    smooth it has the herringbone texture of heavy equipment tires and treads
    making for a vibrating ride. For residential stretch the shoulder abuts on
    to a very broad grass strip, followed by a usually deserted sidewalk
    followed by more lawn before the residential part begins. They could easily
    have 3 more lanes with the space they have.

    [The reason it has not been so widened involves a lot of municipal
    politics. I don't doubt the entire stretch will eventually be widened but
    for now that is the nature of the street.]

    Now here is the problem: Driving on the single lane is dicey. I am quite
    experience and comfortable riding in traffic but this narrow and busy single
    lane makes me nervous. Kars do not give you much space. The shoulder is
    ridable on a mtb or sturdy hybrid/utility but I wouldn't want to ride it on
    a skinny tire road racer. Even on a full suspension mtb the ride is
    unpleasant given the surface texture.

    The lawn strip is similarly ridable on an mtb but soft and mushy. It isn't
    part of the residential properties so riding it would not be a trespass.

    Then there is the sidewalk. As I said it is pretty much deserted since
    decent people drive kars to go 100 meters. A good surface, no pedestrians,
    no kars....

    What would kona do?

    -busy dicey narrow single lane asphalt?

    -rough broad shoulder

    -broad grass strip

    -the rarely used sidewalk?

  2. lowkey said:

    What would kona do?

    -busy dicey narrow single lane asphalt?

    -rough broad shoulder

    -broad grass strip

    -the rarely used sidewalk?

    Sidewalk.

    Although some will say "take the lane" (which at times I agree with and
    do), that would be option 2 in my book, since another empty 3' wide
    paved "lane" is available that impeeds noone. Of course, if there were
    people on the walk then I'd probably forgo it that day.

    Rich

    P.S. My "road" bike is an old MTB so I have no experience with going on
    and off sidewalks on a real road bike. Maybe it's a bad idea.

  3. "lowkey" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    What would kona do?

    -busy dicey narrow single lane asphalt?

    -rough broad shoulder

    -broad grass strip

    -the rarely used sidewalk?

    If your bike is physically uncomfortable in the rough, the choice is
    between the sidewalk and the narrow road. I face such a choice on the
    way between Atlantic Beach and Long Beach; I take the road and everyone
    else can pass me, wait for me, or get a bike. I only hop the sidewalk
    if a road (not this one, it never gets that jammed) is so crowded that
    not even a bike can get through. NYS law allows sidewalk riding except
    where prohibited, for example, all of NYC. If you think riding the
    sidewalk makes life easier for everyone, do it. If you get nabbed, go
    to court with a bunch of 8x10 color glossies with circles and arrows and
    a paragraph on the back explaining what each one is. You could get a
    precedent allowing the practice.

    --ag

  4. In article <[email hidden]>,

    lowkey said:

    The narrow single lane stretch in-between the multi-lane intersections is
    the problem. the lanes are very narrow and quite busy. the should is unpaved
    and very broad - easily a kar lane wide. but while the surface is broadly
    smooth it has the herringbone texture of heavy equipment tires and treads
    making for a vibrating ride. For residential stretch the shoulder abuts on
    to a very broad grass strip, followed by a usually deserted sidewalk
    followed by more lawn before the residential part begins. They could easily
    have 3 more lanes with the space they have.

    [...]

    Quoted message said:

    Now here is the problem: Driving on the single lane is dicey. I am quite
    experience and comfortable riding in traffic but this narrow and busy single
    lane makes me nervous. Kars do not give you much space. The shoulder is
    ridable on a mtb or sturdy hybrid/utility but I wouldn't want to ride it on
    a skinny tire road racer. Even on a full suspension mtb the ride is
    unpleasant given the surface texture.

    Quoted message said:

    What would kona do?

    -busy dicey narrow single lane asphalt?

    No idea who/what kona is, but this is the one I'd pick. Take the lane,
    if there's no oncoming traffic for a bit move over to let cars behind
    you pass, otherwise they can wait.
    How long a stretch is it? If it's only from one major intersection to
    the next, I'd guess not long. If somebody has a problem with slowing
    down to half the normal traffic speed for two or three minutes because
    it's not safe to pass a bike, they can take an alternate route. If two
    minutes is going to make the difference between being on time and being
    late, well, their lack of planning ahead isn't your problem.

    dave

    --
    Dave Vandervies [email hidden]
    [I]f I really did not possess a sense of humour at all, then I would not get
    *any* jokes on comp.lang.c, would I? I have a distinct memory of getting some
    jokes in the last few months. --Joona I Palaste in comp.lang.c

  5. lowkey wrote:
    <snip>

    Quoted message said:


    What would kona do?

    -busy dicey narrow single lane asphalt?

    -rough broad shoulder

    -broad grass strip

    -the rarely used sidewalk?

    Depends on the law where you live, and your attitude to it.

    Most places, riding on the sidewalk is illegal. It may be safe, it may
    be deserted, you may be unlikely to be stopped/fined etc., but it's
    probably illegal. I'd guess that the grass strip probably counts as
    part of the sidewalk. Do you care about doing somthing illegal (albeit
    illegal at a very minor level)? That's up to you.

    Likewise, there may or may not be a compulsion on cyclists to use a
    cycle lane if one exists. If there is, and you care about such things
    (as above), ya gotta use it - unless you can reasonably make a case
    that the surface is so bad that it's unsafe, and you're forced to use
    the road.

    If there's no such compulsion, you are entitled to use the road
    regardless of whether the bike lane exists or not. Most places, you
    have to ride as close to the kerb as is resonably consistent with
    safety. That includes positioning yourself to prevent someone from
    overtaking you dangerously. If that means in the middle of the road
    lane then that's where you need to be. If others are held up by you
    for a few seconds, tough. It's a short stretch, your safety comes
    before their inconvenience.

    The worst place to be is trapped on the road surface between the kerb
    and the passing traffic. Be part of the traffic flow, not an
    obstruction to it.
    If you need to use the road lane, and you're not legally obliged to be
    in bike lane, then take posession of the traffic lane.
    Be awake and concious of your surroundings, clear about your
    intentions, firm and polite. Look back well in advance, spot your gap,
    indicate before you pull out, keep your speed reasonable, indicate back
    in, then give a wave of thanks as you pull back in.

    I'm not being a zealot. I'm not suggesting that you hold people up
    just beacause you can, or that you flick in and out of the traffic flow
    on a whim and put yourself in danger. It's not always possible to get
    out, or maybe the next guy in the traffic is an a**h**e and accelerates
    to block you, or is asleep. There's a million exceptions, but it's
    common sense that'll keep you safe. It's also easy for me to preach at
    you about what you should be doing, especially from out here in
    usenet...

    Cyclists who bumble along semi-concious, ride on kerbs, or worse,
    against the traffic, break lights etc. give us all a bad name, and
    reinforce the idea among cagers that we're not entitled to fair use of
    the road, and are just an obstruction to be bypassed as quickly as
    possible.

    Just my 2c. worth...

    bookieb.

  6. "andy gee" wrote: (clip) a bunch of 8x10 color glossies with circles and
    arrows and a paragraph on the back explaining what each one is. (clip)
    ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
    "Thanks for the memory."

  7. lowkey said:

    What would kona do?
    -busy dicey narrow single lane asphalt?
    -rough broad shoulder
    -broad grass strip
    -the rarely used sidewalk?

    I don't know. I don't live around here.

    Art Harris

  8. lowkey said:

    One route I frequent takes me out Stone Rd. It is a multi-lane
    east/west city street that abruptly narrows to a single lane east of
    Gordon St. as you pass through, first the university proper, and then
    the arboretum on the north side and residential followed by
    undeveloped land to the south.

    At the next major intersection - Victoria Rd. - the street has
    recently been rebuilt into a luxurious multi-lane intersection with
    incredibly wide bike lanes with nary a storm grate. Those have been
    built integral to the curb so that the bike lane is a smooth strip of
    pristine asphalt almost a car width wide.

    The narrow single lane stretch in-between the multi-lane
    intersections is the problem. the lanes are very narrow and quite
    busy. the should is unpaved and very broad - easily a kar lane wide.
    but while the surface is broadly smooth it has the herringbone
    texture of heavy equipment tires and treads making for a vibrating
    ride. For residential stretch the shoulder abuts on to a very broad
    grass strip, followed by a usually deserted sidewalk followed by more
    lawn before the residential part begins. They could easily have 3
    more lanes with the space they have.

    [The reason it has not been so widened involves a lot of municipal
    politics. I don't doubt the entire stretch will eventually be widened
    but for now that is the nature of the street.]

    Now here is the problem: Driving on the single lane is dicey. I am
    quite experience and comfortable riding in traffic but this narrow
    and busy single lane makes me nervous. Kars do not give you much
    space. The shoulder is ridable on a mtb or sturdy hybrid/utility but
    I wouldn't want to ride it on a skinny tire road racer. Even on a
    full suspension mtb the ride is unpleasant given the surface texture.

    The lawn strip is similarly ridable on an mtb but soft and mushy. It
    isn't part of the residential properties so riding it would not be a
    trespass.

    Then there is the sidewalk. As I said it is pretty much deserted
    since decent people drive kars to go 100 meters. A good surface, no
    pedestrians, no kars....

    What would kona do?

    -busy dicey narrow single lane asphalt?

    -rough broad shoulder

    -broad grass strip

    -the rarely used sidewalk?

    Take the lane. Pretend you're a farm tractor, garbage truck, street sweeper, or
    other slow moving vehicle, because in the eyes of the law, *that's what you
    are.* Being hit from behind is extremely rare, but you can further minimize
    your risk by being as visible as possible -- don't hug the curb, wear bright
    colored clothing, use reflectors, etc.

    Matt O.

  9. lowkey wrote:

    I'd try it out both ways and see which made me happiest. I'll generally
    take the lane if the terrain is such that I can expect maintain a good
    clip (few stops, flat or downhill), and I'll take an unoccupied sidewalk
    if it's a good sidewalk and conditions are such that I would be
    travelling slower than my usual slower-than-traffic pace (uphill, lots
    of lights or stop signs, etc).

    I don't know if riding on the sidewalk is technically legal around here
    or not, but I think I see as many bikes on the sidewalks as I do on the
    street. I'm still not used to this dense suburban lifestyle, and I miss
    my midwestern wide open spaces!

  10. "lowkey" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    What would kona do?

    Got a google map or something?

    Thanks.

    --
    Warm Regards,

    Claire Petersky
    Personal page: http://www.geocities.com/cpetersky/
    See the books I've set free at:
    http://bookcrossing.com/referral/Cpetersky

  11. 30 Sep 2005 09:18:54 -0700,
    <[email hidden]>,
    [email hidden] wrote, in part:

    Quoted message said:

    Cyclists who bumble along semi-concious, ride on kerbs, or worse,
    against the traffic, break lights etc. give us all a bad name, and
    reinforce the idea among cagers that we're not entitled to fair use of
    the road, and are just an obstruction to be bypassed as quickly as
    possible.

    Personally, I givafuk what cagers think. Their minds are already made
    up. I just don't do anything stupid that's likely to get me killed or
    cited by the police.

    [censored] on cagers. They're the most dangerous bunch of lawless [censored]
    anyway.
    --
    zk

  12. "Claire Petersky" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    "lowkey" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    What would kona do?

    Got a google map or something?

    Thanks.

    I don't think it would help much. If you Google map [or Mapquest or
    whatever] on

    1 Stone Rd. E. Guelph On Canada

    you can see the area. It is the stretch of Stone Rd between Gordon St and
    Victoria Rd. The Stone/Victoria intersection is the one that has been
    rebuilt this past summer.

    Checking... Ya even Google Earth doesn't really show much. Not only is the
    improvement too recent, Guelph is unfortunately just outside the high detail
    area of GTA for Google Earth mapping.

    I'll see if I can djinn up a diagram or something in MS paint after my
    ride.

  13. "Dave Vandervies" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,
    lowkey <[email hidden]> wrote:


    [...]

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    What would kona do?

    -busy dicey narrow single lane asphalt?

    No idea who/what kona is, but this is the one I'd pick.

    It's a literary affectation.

    Kona is a bike manufacturer. Some people pose the question; 'What would
    Kali do?' Some deists ask; 'What would Jesus do?' I ask the maker Kona what
    he would do.

    Quoted message said:

    Take the lane,
    if there's no oncoming traffic for a bit move over to let cars behind
    you pass, otherwise they can wait.
    How long a stretch is it? If it's only from one major intersection to
    the next, I'd guess not long.

    No, not long. Maybe 1 km before the sidewalk ends at the end of residential
    development.

  14. <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    lowkey wrote:
    <snip>

    Quoted message said:


    What would kona do?

    -busy dicey narrow single lane asphalt?

    -rough broad shoulder

    -broad grass strip

    -the rarely used sidewalk?

    Depends on the law where you live, and your attitude to it.

    My attitude towards laws is that they nice things in the abstract and they
    usually agree with my mores and ethos but I don't feel bound to follow any
    law because it is the law.
    [...]

    Quoted message said:

    The worst place to be is trapped on the road surface between the kerb
    and the passing traffic.

    Just to clarify: there is no kerb. From the road out it is:

    Road
    broad rough shoulder
    wide grass strip
    sidewalk
    more grass strip
    fence
    residential development.

  15. Zoot Katz said:

    Personally, I givafuk what cagers think. Their minds are already made
    up. I just don't do anything stupid that's likely to get me killed or
    cited by the police.

    [censored] on cagers. They're the most dangerous bunch of lawless [censored]
    anyway.

    Bicyclists with that attitude is what makes cagers think the way they do.

  16. lowkey said:

    "Claire Petersky" <[email hidden]> wrote in message

    Quoted message said:

    Got a google map or something?

    Quoted message said:

    I don't think it would help much. If you Google map [or Mapquest or
    whatever] on

    Got a digital camera?

  17. "Rich" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    lowkey said:

    "Claire Petersky" <[email hidden]> wrote in message

    Quoted message said:

    Got a google map or something?

    Quoted message said:

    I don't think it would help much. If you Google map [or Mapquest or
    whatever] on

    Got a digital camera?

    Nope. A regular camera. Too nice for my skills but it was a gift. I usually
    scan in the photos but I dunno if a ground level photo would really show the
    nature of the street.

    No matter. I djinned up a diagram. Note it is not too scale.

    http://www.geocities.com/siklelogical/map.stone.rd.bmp

  18. lowkey said:

    No matter. I djinned up a diagram. Note it is not too scale.

    http://www.geocities.com/siklelogical/map.stone.rd.bmp

    Great diagram! About the only thing it's missing are little animated
    cars and bicycles.

    Looks like the sidwalk only covers about 75% of the distance you need to
    travel on the two lane road. or is that a scale issue?

    And I can't beleive the city hasn't made the road 4 lanes all the way
    through...

    Rich

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.