General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Weight loss with elliptical

Started by Misael · · Last activity · 161 posts · 6,912 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
16 August 2005
Last activity
23 September 2005
Original author
Misael
Posts
161
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
6,912
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 161
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. First of all, sorry for my english, I'll try to explain what I need to
    know

    I have to lose weight and don't know if elliptical cross trainers are
    ok. I know that a low intensity program is ideal to lose weight (about
    60-70% of max cardio rate for at least 30-40 minutes). With this type of
    machine, can I remain within this range? Is it recommended for weight
    lose? Thanks a lot
    Nando, Italy

  2. Misael said:

    First of all, sorry for my english, I'll try to explain what I need to
    know

    I have to lose weight and don't know if elliptical cross trainers are
    ok.

    They're very good.

    Quoted message said:

    I know that a low intensity program is ideal to lose weight

    No. The more calories you burn, the better.

    Quoted message said:

    (about 60-70% of max cardio rate
    for at least 30-40 minutes). With this type of

    More like 80-90%. Only do less than that if you're tired from previous workouts.

    Quoted message said:

    machine, can I remain within this range?

    Yes (within 60-70 or 80-90)

    Quoted message said:

    Is it recommended for weight lose?

    Yes (the elliptical machine is), and no (not at 60-70% max heart rate)

    Cheers,
    --
    Donovan Rebbechi
    http://pegasus.rutgers.edu/~elflord/

  3. Misael said:

    First of all, sorry for my english, I'll try to explain what I need to
    know

    I have to lose weight and don't know if elliptical cross trainers are
    ok.

    Yes, ellipticals are great for losing weight. One way to get a great
    workout is to listen to an mp3 player (or any other music source that's
    permissible in your gym), really get going for the fast/energetic songs
    and then ease back down for the slower songs. Being able to adjust your
    tempo that easily is one of the things I like about the elliptical -
    unlike the treadmill where you'd have to guess: hmm, is this song 7mph or
    7.5?

    Quoted message said:

    I know that a low intensity program is ideal to lose weight (about
    60-70% of max cardio rate for at least 30-40 minutes). With this type of
    machine, can I remain within this range? Is it recommended for weight
    lose? Thanks a lot

    I don't know what the optimimum range is, although Donovan has already
    provided some input on that. My own target is to push as hard as I can
    over the course of the hour so that I can get through the hour but also I
    really know I've done something when I lock the gym back up.

    Martha
    --

    This
    is
    just
    to
    get
    around
    this
    newsreader's
    requirement
    that
    you
    have
    more
    lines
    of
    new
    text
    than
    quoted
    material.

  4. "Martha S. Gallagher" wrote

    Quoted message said:


    This
    is
    just
    to
    get
    around
    this
    newsreader's
    requirement
    that
    you
    have
    more
    lines
    of
    new
    text than quoted material.


    What
    newsreader
    are
    you
    using?

  5. Lee Michaels said:

    "Martha S. Gallagher" wrote

    Quoted message said:

    This
    is
    just
    to
    get
    around
    this
    newsreader's
    requirement
    that
    you
    have
    more
    lines
    of
    new
    text than quoted material.

    What
    newsreader
    are
    you
    using?

    A
    [censored]
    one

    --
    spammage trappage: remove the underscores to reply

    I'm going to die rather sooner than I'd like. I tried to protect my
    neighbours from crime, and became the victim of it. Complications in
    hospital following this resulted in a serious illness. I now need a bone
    marrow transplant. Many people around the world are waiting for a marrow
    transplant, too. Please volunteer to be a marrow donor:
    http://www.abmdr.org.au/
    http://www.marrow.org/

  6. Donovan Rebbechi said:
    Misael said:

    First of all, sorry for my english, I'll try to explain what I need to
    know

    I have to lose weight and don't know if elliptical cross trainers are
    ok.

    They're very good.

    Quoted message said:

    I know that a low intensity program is ideal to lose weight

    No. The more calories you burn, the better.

    Correct, but you'll burn more over the course of the day if you do a
    long, slow run of one hour.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    (about 60-70% of max cardio rate
    for at least 30-40 minutes). With this type of

    More like 80-90%. Only do less than that if you're tired from previous workouts.

    Quoted message said:

    machine, can I remain within this range?

    Yes (within 60-70 or 80-90)

    Quoted message said:

    Is it recommended for weight lose?

    Yes (the elliptical machine is), and yes (not at 60-70% max heart rate)


    I corrected his ignorance above.

    TBR

    "As democracy is perfected, the office of president represents, more and
    more closely, the inner soul of the people. On some great and glorious day
    the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the
    White House will be adorned by a downright moron."
    H.L. Mencken (1880 - 1956)
    "Anyone with degrees from Yale and Harvard is presumed to be intelligent,
    but George W. Bush has managed to overcome that presumption."

  7. Martha S. Gallagher said:

    One way to get a great
    workout is to listen to an mp3 player

    Yes idiot, that'll help you lose weight SO MUCH BETTER.

    TBR

    "As democracy is perfected, the office of president represents, more and
    more closely, the inner soul of the people. On some great and glorious day
    the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the
    White House will be adorned by a downright moron."
    H.L. Mencken (1880 - 1956)
    "Anyone with degrees from Yale and Harvard is presumed to be intelligent,
    but George W. Bush has managed to overcome that presumption."

  8. Martha S. Gallagher said:

    Yes, ellipticals are great for losing weight. One way to get a great
    workout is to listen to an mp3 player (or any other music source that's
    permissible in your gym), really get going for the fast/energetic songs
    and then ease back down for the slower songs. Being able to adjust your
    tempo that easily is one of the things I like about the elliptical -
    unlike the treadmill where you'd have to guess: hmm, is this song 7mph or
    7.5?

    So, to qualify your statement. How much do you weigh? And try not to
    scare us.

    TBR

    "As democracy is perfected, the office of president represents, more and
    more closely, the inner soul of the people. On some great and glorious day
    the plain folks of the land will reach their heart's desire at last and the
    White House will be adorned by a downright moron."
    H.L. Mencken (1880 - 1956)
    "Anyone with degrees from Yale and Harvard is presumed to be intelligent,
    but George W. Bush has managed to overcome that presumption."

  9. spodosaurus said:
    Lee Michaels said:

    "Martha S. Gallagher" wrote

    Quoted message said:

    This
    is
    just
    to
    get
    around
    this
    newsreader's
    requirement
    that
    you
    have
    more
    lines
    of
    new
    text than quoted material.

    What
    newsreader
    are
    you
    using?

    A
    [censored]
    one


    No
    argument
    there.

    I'm
    using
    pine
    on
    my
    university
    shell
    account.

    On
    my
    normal
    shell
    account
    it
    doesn't
    have
    the
    requirement
    about
    new
    text
    being
    more
    than
    quoted
    material,
    but
    this
    one
    does.
    Since,
    I'll
    only
    have
    this
    account
    for
    a
    few
    more
    weeks
    it
    hasn't
    been
    worth
    it
    to
    set
    up
    something
    better.

    Since
    I
    use
    a
    proper
    ..sig
    delimitor,
    my
    ..sig
    shouldn't
    cause
    problems
    for
    people
    whose
    newsreaders
    are
    set
    up
    properly.

    Martha

    --

    This
    is
    just
    to
    get
    around
    this
    newsreader's
    requirement
    that
    you
    have
    more
    lines
    of
    new
    text
    than
    quoted
    material.

  10. The Bill Rodgers said:
    Martha S. Gallagher said:

    Yes, ellipticals are great for losing weight. One way to get a great
    workout is to listen to an mp3 player (or any other music source that's
    permissible in your gym), really get going for the fast/energetic songs
    and then ease back down for the slower songs. Being able to adjust your
    tempo that easily is one of the things I like about the elliptical -
    unlike the treadmill where you'd have to guess: hmm, is this song 7mph or
    7.5?

    So, to qualify your statement. How much do you weigh? And try not to
    scare us.

    Is the idea of varying the intensity during the course of a workout really
    so out there? It seemed pretty much like the idea of fartlek that Mistress
    Krista describes on her site, except that I use the lineup of songs on my
    playlist to determine when I speed up or slow down rather than a stop
    watch. I find it makes my workout more enjoyable than just setting the
    treadmill for a steady pace for an hour and chugging along, but maybe
    that's just me. I find I do the same thing when I'm swimming - one lap of
    butterfly can really get my heart going and then I'll do a lazy
    backstroke back.

    147.5 this morning. I'm 5'6" and maintaining a 60 lb loss for over 2
    years. I'd still like to lose another 20 lb of fat, but at the same time
    I've recently started working w/ a trainer and my goals are to increase my
    strength and LBM. Since I'm quite sure I still qualify as a newbie, I'm
    hoping that I can do those things while still losing fat or at least
    maintaining my status quo. My weight is almost exactly the same as it was
    when I started strength training, but some of my measurements are down an
    inch or so, so I think everything is trending in the right direction.

    When I get to the point where I don't seem to be able to make any more
    gains in strength while following my current diet/cardio program, then I'm
    going to have to make a decision as to how to proceed, but so far I seem
    to be making progress.

    Martha

    --

    This
    is
    just
    to
    get
    around
    this
    newsreader's
    requirement
    that
    you
    have
    more
    lines
    of
    new
    text
    than
    quoted
    material.

  11. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Martha S. Gallagher said:

    This
    is
    just
    to
    get
    around
    this
    newsreader's
    requirement
    that
    you
    have
    more
    lines
    of
    new
    text
    than
    quoted
    material.

    Try changing your quoting character to something other than >, perhaps
    | or }. Then your newsreader (actually poster) won't realize you're
    quoting at all.

    Seth

  12. Misael said:

    First of all, sorry for my english, I'll try to explain what I need to
    know

    I have to lose weight and don't know if elliptical cross trainers are
    ok.

    They are ok.

    Quoted message said:

    I know that a low intensity program is ideal to lose weight (about
    60-70% of max cardio rate for at least 30-40 minutes).

    Try 75%+ instead.

  13. Seth Breidbart said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,

    Martha S. Gallagher said:

    This
    is
    just
    to
    get
    around
    this
    newsreader's
    requirement
    that
    you
    have
    more
    lines
    of
    new
    text
    than
    quoted
    material.

    Try changing your quoting character to something other than >, perhaps
    | or }. Then your newsreader (actually poster) won't realize you're
    quoting at all.

    Good thinking. I was sitting here trying to think of an interesting
    tag line if I needed to solve this problem, but Seth has it nailed I
    believe.

    - bc

  14. Martha S. Gallagher said:
    spodosaurus said:
    Lee Michaels said:

    "Martha S. Gallagher" wrote

    > This
    > is
    > just
    > to
    > get
    > around
    > this
    > newsreader's
    > requirement
    > that
    > you
    > have
    > more
    > lines
    > of
    > new
    > text than quoted material.
    >

    What
    newsreader
    are
    you
    using?

    A
    [censored]
    one


    No
    argument
    there.

    I'm
    using
    pine
    on
    my
    university
    shell
    account.

    Pine wouldn't care. It's the news server that does the checking,
    As already suggested you can try changing the quoting character.

    Edit the file ".pinerc" in your home directory. Find
    "reply-indent-string" there and edit it, like

    reply-indent-string="] "

  15. Misael said:

    First of all, sorry for my english, I'll try to explain what I need to
    know

    I have to lose weight and don't know if elliptical cross trainers are
    ok. I know that a low intensity program is ideal to lose weight (about
    60-70% of max cardio rate for at least 30-40 minutes). With this type of
    machine, can I remain within this range? Is it recommended for weight
    lose? Thanks a lot
    Nando, Italy

    I'm an older woman and I found that long-slow cardio didn't help me lose
    fat. Doing intensive cardio, like intervals or working at a very hard
    pace helps, and so does weightlifting. There's nothing wrong wiht
    elliptical machines but listen to Donovan: go hard and fast on it - at
    least in spurts, i.e., intervals.

    Dally

  16. Martha S. Gallagher said:


    147.5 this morning. I'm 5'6" and maintaining a 60 lb loss for over 2
    years. I'd still like to lose another 20 lb of fat, but at the same time
    I've recently started working w/ a trainer and my goals are to increase
    my strength and LBM. Since I'm quite sure I still qualify as a newbie,
    I'm hoping that I can do those things while still losing fat or at least
    maintaining my status quo. My weight is almost exactly the same as it
    was when I started strength training, but some of my measurements are
    down an inch or so, so I think everything is trending in the right
    direction.

    Welcome to the group, Martha, but immediately stop using your real name!
    You will live to regret it someday. Anonymous is the way to go!

    Dally

  17. Dally said:
    Martha S. Gallagher said:


    147.5 this morning. I'm 5'6" and maintaining a 60 lb loss for over 2
    years. I'd still like to lose another 20 lb of fat, but at the same time
    I've recently started working w/ a trainer and my goals are to increase
    my strength and LBM. Since I'm quite sure I still qualify as a newbie,
    I'm hoping that I can do those things while still losing fat or at least
    maintaining my status quo. My weight is almost exactly the same as it
    was when I started strength training, but some of my measurements are
    down an inch or so, so I think everything is trending in the right
    direction.

    Welcome to the group, Martha, but immediately stop using your real name!
    You will live to regret it someday. Anonymous is the way to go!

    Who said that?

    Must be some "anonymous" person!! ;o)

  18. Donovan Rebbechi said:
    Quoted message said:

    I know that a low intensity program is ideal to lose weight

    No. The more calories you burn, the better.

    Quoted message said:

    (about 60-70% of max cardio rate
    for at least 30-40 minutes). With this type of

    More like 80-90%. Only do less than that if you're tired from
    previous workouts.

    Yes, but you're a pretty well trained runner, Donovan.

    Do you really think that the typical "wants to lose weight"
    person can really stay at 80-90% of his max HR for 30-40
    minutes?

    I'd say you'd have to pretty near elite anyway to do that
    and if you were, you wouldn't be worrying about losing
    a few pounds or using an elliptical?

    I suspect that a chubby person who tried to lose weight
    your way would give up after 5 minutes or less and probably
    never try again.

    --
    Helgi Briem hbriem AT simnet DOT is

  19. Helgi Briem said:
    Donovan Rebbechi said:
    Quoted message said:

    I know that a low intensity program is ideal to lose weight

    No. The more calories you burn, the better.

    Quoted message said:

    (about 60-70% of max cardio rate
    for at least 30-40 minutes). With this type of

    More like 80-90%. Only do less than that if you're tired from
    previous workouts.

    Yes, but you're a pretty well trained runner, Donovan.

    Do you really think that the typical "wants to lose weight"
    person can really stay at 80-90% of his max HR for 30-40
    minutes?

    I'd say you'd have to pretty near elite anyway to do that
    and if you were, you wouldn't be worrying about losing
    a few pounds or using an elliptical?

    I suspect that a chubby person who tried to lose weight
    your way would give up after 5 minutes or less and probably
    never try again.

    What you say is absolutely correct Helgi! ;o)

  20. Hey Dally,

    Dally said:

    Martha S. Gallagher wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    147.5 this morning. I'm 5'6" and maintaining a 60 lb loss for over 2 years.

    Quoted message said:

    Welcome to the group, Martha, but immediately stop using your real name! You
    will live to regret it someday. Anonymous is the way to go!

    Thanks for the welcome.

    I've been posting to usenet using my real name since at least 1995
    (probably earlier, but that's as far as google can find me). So far, no
    one's hunted me down and killed me. I even used to post my contact
    information on the neijia list and *that* was a tough room. I'm afraid I'm
    just not interesting enough to get my own stalker.

    Sad, really, but there it is.

    <g>

    Martha

    --

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.