"Doug Freese" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Quoted message said:
"Tony S." <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:TTRRi.2251$HU1.742@trndny07...
Quoted message said:"Charlie Pendejo" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Quoted message said:Care to elaborate - what's good or bad for you?
Specifically no, generally, refined foods, particularly refined
carbohydrates, seem to produce an inflammatory state if eaten to excess.
I've browsed many books on diet/health, though never follow any of the
prescribed programs fully. Inflammation seems to have many causes in
modern life. Refined foods and how the body handles them seems to be a
common theme in many of those books, as is the theme that so-called
healthy fats are very good for you, etc.
Tony, you're going to help me with this position. I have been following
nutrition for a lot of years and I have never heard of the relationship
with inflammation and refined carbs. We all know that simple and most
refined carbs are poor nutrition in general and for diabetics or those
susceptible to high glycemic foods definitely a poor choice. OTOH I don't
relate GI and insulin with inflammation but if you have a book or web page
I'd like read about it.
If it were only that simple. I'm sure you'd agree that biology is one of the
most complex topics mankind has ever studied. Patterns with multiple causes
are very hard to prove. Comparisons between countries and dietary tendencies
between countries may be the most useful in some ways, though population
specific genetics and other causes for diseases and condtions besides diet
must be taken into account. Even this comparison technique is changing now
as western-style diets are available worldwide.
Even inflammation as a condition and possible precursor to many diseases is
a fairly new concept, but it's this kind of wholistic view that, in my view,
has the most potential to figure out why affluent societies have much higher
percentages of certain types of diseases, for example. As I'm sure you know,
it's the wholistic view of health that is missing in most doctor's offices,
and in the modern medical system.
Quoted message said:And we both know that the aid stations in a ultra are loaded with
simple/unrefined carbs.
Yes, and that's fine with me. During and after exercise is when the body can
suck them right up and put them to best use. You want fast absorption at
such times.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:When I eat a diet balanced in protein/fats/carbs, of the right kinds,
with refined carbs strictly limited to post-exercise periods, I tend to
feel healthy and balanced and more supple.
Is it really physical or just knowing proper eating and it makes you feel
better mentally? 😉
Yes, and yes. I can notice a physical difference, and I also feel better
about it.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:OTOH, when I get busy sometimes and forget what I eat, I tend to be
stiff, the joints often feel sore, and I don't recover as well from
exercise; that is, my body gets into a sustained state of inflammation.
What exact balance of foods will work for any one person is an
experiment. Even then, as with many areas of life, knowing and doing are
very different things, and experimenting takes time and discipline.
Since we are all experiments of one and you find negative effects with
improper balance, then do what works for you. I'm simply looking for a
scientific connection plus I have never had the same experience. Maybe
the Heineken really is my salvation, after all it is the first thing down
the pipe after a race and training run. And you thought I was just nuts.
🙂
-Doug
Experiments of one, I agree. As far as the science goes, as you know,
nutrition science is all over the place. OTOH, there seems to be broad
general agreement that refined foods aren't natural to the human diet, and
that high-glycemic foods can lead to yo-yos in blood sugar levels and
problems. The extent of the latter is under debate. That it can be a
contributing cause of eventual obesity, pre-diabetic syndrome and perhaps
even type II diabetes is also under debate.
Inflammation is also a buzz word that means different things in different
contexts, and, like the other conditions just mentioned, has many causes.
But, in my reading of these matters, and in my personal experience, the
refined and high glycemic foods can cause direct symptoms that I experience
whenever I 'forget' to eat right.
A few of the books I've browsed on the topic -- not to include Atkins books
I read years ago, which were followed by south-beach and others, moving from
low-carb to right-carb thinking, most of which I think also pointed to
inflammation as an outcome of eating the wrong foods, which include
refined/high glycemic foods -- are (and they of course don't agree entirely
and have different points of view on some matters):
The Anti-Inflammation Zone, Dr. Barry Sears
Stop Inflammation Now, Richard M. Flemming, M.D.
Inflammation Nation, Floyd H. Chilton, Ph.D.
-Tony