General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Things that are cheap to make from scratch

Started by Email address hidden · · Last activity · 80 posts · 3,535 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
10 September 2005
Last activity
15 September 2005
Original author
Email address hidden
Posts
80
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
3,535
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 80
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I started making cornbread a while ago and found it's very cheap to
    make from scratch. You get a 4 lb bag of cornmeal for $4 and 4 pound
    bag of flour for $2 and some other stuff and you can make many big pans
    of cornbread.

    I just bought a can of Hershey cocoa powder for about $4.19, and OMG it
    goes a long way. You can make a cup of hot cocoa with only 2 or 3
    teaspoons of cocoa. That's a helluva lot cheaper than Swiss Miss, isn't
    it? I wish I had found this out a long time ago, cuz I would've had hot
    cocoa more often. I made a couple of batches of chocolate pudding and
    still have most of the cocoa left.

    Can you guys name other stuff?

  2. Quoted message said:

    Can you guys name other stuff?

    I don't know about cheaper but making fresh pasta is DEFINITELY more fun
    than boxed!!!

    Andy

  3. Andy said:

    I don't know about cheaper but making fresh pasta is DEFINITELY more fun
    than boxed!!!

    Andy

    Making just about anything from scratch is more fun than buying it
    pre-made.

    -Mike

  4. Mike Pearce said:
    Andy said:

    I don't know about cheaper but making fresh pasta is DEFINITELY more fun
    than boxed!!!

    Andy

    Making just about anything from scratch is more fun than buying it
    pre-made.

    That's not true... when was they last time you ate meat that you
    gutted... I don't consider preparing a package of chicken quarters from
    scratch... I don't see the fun in gutting a chicken and then an hour
    later eating same. A package of chicken parts is more like cooking in
    kit form, same as paint by numbers. Today most all foods are purchased
    nearly prepared... you must be very young. I'm willing to bet most
    folks reading rfc have never gutted a chicken, many have never cut one
    up, or even touched one with bare hands. I've been invited to dinners
    where I was served reheated rotisserie deli chicken, served with the
    pretence of home made from scratch... the only from scratch was
    transfering it to a fancy serving platter, with tongs.

    Sheldon

  5. Sheldon said:
    Mike Pearce said:
    Andy said:

    I don't know about cheaper but making fresh pasta is DEFINITELY
    more fun than boxed!!!

    Andy

    Making just about anything from scratch is more fun than buying it
    pre-made.

    That's not true... when was they last time you ate meat that you
    gutted... I don't consider preparing a package of chicken quarters
    from scratch... I don't see the fun in gutting a chicken and then an
    hour
    later eating same. A package of chicken parts is more like cooking in
    kit form, same as paint by numbers. Today most all foods are
    purchased nearly prepared... you must be very young. I'm willing to
    bet most
    folks reading rfc have never gutted a chicken, many have never cut one
    up, or even touched one with bare hands.

    I've never plucked and gutted a chicken but my dad sure did, many times.
    It's no wonder people prefer packaged chicken - I let the butchers deal with
    their job, which is butchering.

    I have most definitely cut up whole (purchased) chickens - it's much cheaper
    to buy a whole chicken than it is to pay for a package of chicken breasts.
    (The back, neck and wings go in the freezer for stock.) By the same token,
    it's cheaper to buy a package of bone-in skin-on chicken breasts and skin
    and bone them yourself than it is to buy the boneless ones. (Said bones
    also go in the freezer for stock.) Now if I could just figure out how to
    bone chicken thighs, which I prefer, neatly (a.k.a. not mangling them).

    I've been invited to dinners

    Quoted message said:

    where I was served reheated rotisserie deli chicken, served with the
    pretence of home made from scratch... the only from scratch was
    transfering it to a fancy serving platter, with tongs.

    Sheldon

    Lots of people do that. I don't really understand why. I mean, I
    understand the convenience. But by the same token, I've never had anyone
    serve up a spiral-sliced ham and pretend they did the spiral slicing
    themselves. In fact, it's usually announced - hey, we got a spiral-sliced
    ham! 🙂

    Jill

  6. jmcquown said:

    But by the same token, I've never had anyone
    serve up a spiral-sliced ham and pretend they did the spiral slicing
    themselves. In fact, it's usually announced - hey, we got a
    spiral-sliced ham! 🙂

    Jill

    Jill,

    We served a spiral-sliced honey-baked ham at a party and nobody ate it
    because they were all waiting for it to be carved! Once the word was
    out, it went fast. 😄

    Andy

  7. jmcquown said:
    Sheldon said:


    I've been invited to dinners

    Quoted message said:

    where I was served reheated rotisserie deli chicken, served with the
    pretence of home made from scratch... the only from scratch was
    transfering it to a fancy serving platter, with tongs.

    Sheldon

    Lots of people do that. I don't really understand why. I mean, I
    understand the convenience. But by the same token, I've never had anyone
    serve up a spiral-sliced ham and pretend they did the spiral slicing
    themselves. In fact, it's usually announced - hey, we got a spiral-sliced
    ham! 🙂

    Well, then those boneheads need to learn how to bone a ham. duh
    They'd save a lot of money, and it would be better ham too... spiral
    cut is
    low grade ham at a high grade price.

    Btw, serving ANY smoked ham is never from scratch, not unless you
    smoked it yourself. Smoked ham is strictly a convenience food... all
    preserved foods are... you mean like opening the lid on a can of tuna
    makes that tuna salad a from scratch creation, no way... then you may
    as well call your morning flakies from scratch because you poured in
    the milk and sugar yourself.

    Sheldon

  8. "Sheldon" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:

    jmcquown wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Lots of people do that. I don't really understand why. I mean, I
    understand the convenience.

    I'm not being a snob, I really don't get the convenience at
    all. What's to making a good roast chicken, even if you don't
    have a rotisserie? The chickens I've had from supermarkets
    are really sucky, but I don't know where else I'd get one.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    But by the same token, I've never had anyone
    serve up a spiral-sliced ham and pretend they did the spiral slicing
    themselves. In fact, it's usually announced - hey, we got a
    spiral-sliced
    ham! 🙂

    I bring them to my mother's at Easter, all the better to avoid
    the can o' ham. This way, also, I can just heat it up and bring it
    warm to the house.

    Quoted message said:

    Well, then those boneheads need to learn how to bone a ham. duh

    Why would I want to bone a ham? Something weird about a
    boneless ham, I guess it's canned ham flashbacks.

    Quoted message said:

    They'd save a lot of money, and it would be better ham too... spiral
    cut is
    low grade ham at a high grade price.

    Depends. I've had some very good ones, but I've also had really
    crappy unspiral sliced hams. Hams are iffy in my opinion.

    Quoted message said:

    Btw, serving ANY smoked ham is never from scratch, not unless you
    smoked it yourself. Smoked ham is strictly a convenience food... all
    preserved foods are... you mean like opening the lid on a can of tuna
    makes that tuna salad a from scratch creation, no way... then you may
    as well call your morning flakies from scratch because you poured in
    the milk and sugar yourself.

    Now, now, not all of us have a smokehouse and months to cure
    hams ... never mind the pig!

    nancy

  9. Sheldon said:

    That's not true... when was they last time you ate meat that you
    gutted... I don't consider preparing a package of chicken quarters from
    scratch... I don't see the fun in gutting a chicken and then an hour
    later eating same. A package of chicken parts is more like cooking in
    kit form, same as paint by numbers. Today most all foods are purchased
    nearly prepared... you must be very young. I'm willing to bet most
    folks reading rfc have never gutted a chicken, many have never cut one
    up, or even touched one with bare hands. I've been invited to dinners
    where I was served reheated rotisserie deli chicken, served with the
    pretence of home made from scratch... the only from scratch was
    transfering it to a fancy serving platter, with tongs.

    Sheldon

    Only some of what you say is true. Depends where you live. There is
    nothing better than a "fresh" chicken, IMHO. Used to have them all the
    time when I was a teenager... And yes, I do touch raw meat with my "bare
    hands". These days, most people do go to the local butcher or fish
    monger for their "fresh" meat, poultry or fish, but that is still much,
    much, better/healthier (and cheaper) than buying those pre-made dinners
    or having "fast-food" every day.

    --
    Cheers
    Cathy(xyz)

  10. Sheldon said:
    jmcquown said:
    Sheldon said:


    I've been invited to dinners

    Quoted message said:

    where I was served reheated rotisserie deli chicken, served with the
    pretence of home made from scratch... the only from scratch was
    transfering it to a fancy serving platter, with tongs.

    Sheldon

    Lots of people do that. I don't really understand why. I mean, I
    understand the convenience. But by the same token, I've never had
    anyone serve up a spiral-sliced ham and pretend they did the spiral
    slicing themselves. In fact, it's usually announced - hey, we got a
    spiral-sliced ham! 🙂

    Well, then those boneheads need to learn how to bone a ham. duh
    They'd save a lot of money, and it would be better ham too... spiral
    cut is
    low grade ham at a high grade price.

    Sheldon

    It's usually been in a company party "pot luck" type setting where the
    company provides the ham, generally around the holidays. Unless it's set up
    in a fancy hotel banquet room there isn't the professional staff to be
    boning ham for up to 200 people. And you wouldn't want to trust some of the
    employees with sharp pointed implements 😉

    Jill

  11. kr_gentner said:

    Most baked items are cheaper to make than to buy. You can also use the
    flour and cocoa to make cake. A good selection of staples allows you to
    make a wide variety of things. Add yeast and you can make all sorts of
    breads cheap too.

    Some things just aren't worth the work. We have an Italiian bakery in our
    town that makes wonderful and sells it for $1.40 per loaf. With just two of
    us in the house, and my wife not eating bread, it just isn't worth all that
    work to make a batch of bread if I can pick up a loaf that is better than I
    can make. However, their cookies as pies aren't very good. I can do much
    better at home. Most Nanaimo bars are much cheaper to buy than to make, but
    the real thing home made is far superior.

    I make most of my own jam, and I can get 6-7 jars out of a batch. It would
    cost me as much for one jar of good jam as it costs me to make the whole
    batch. Good Seville orange marmalade is very expensive, and I can make more
    than a dozen jars of it for less than it would cost to buy one jar of the
    good stuff.

    Ice cream is another matter. By the time I buy the cream, eggs, milk and
    flavourings I could easily get a quart of a premium brand, and I come out a
    little ahead because I get almost 1 1/2 qt. in a batch.

    Most home made pies are a bargain compared to bakery prices, and if you find
    pie making easy it is well worth it to do it yourself.

    It does pay to have a good supply of staples and other ingredients, and it
    really pays to buy in bulk. I used to buy flour in 5 pound bags, and then I
    realized that for about 50% more I could get four times as much. Vanilla
    extract is much cheaper in larger quantities.

  12. <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    I started making cornbread a while ago and found it's very cheap to
    make from scratch. You get a 4 lb bag of cornmeal for $4 and 4 pound
    bag of flour for $2 and some other stuff and you can make many big pans
    of cornbread.

    I just bought a can of Hershey cocoa powder for about $4.19, and OMG it
    goes a long way. You can make a cup of hot cocoa with only 2 or 3
    teaspoons of cocoa. That's a helluva lot cheaper than Swiss Miss, isn't
    it? I wish I had found this out a long time ago, cuz I would've had hot
    cocoa more often. I made a couple of batches of chocolate pudding and
    still have most of the cocoa left.

    Can you guys name other stuff?

    Most baked items are cheaper to make than to buy. You can also use the
    flour and cocoa to make cake. A good selection of staples allows you to
    make a wide variety of things. Add yeast and you can make all sorts of
    breads cheap too.

    Kathy

  13. cathyxyz said:
    Sheldon said:

    That's not true... when was they last time you ate meat that you
    gutted... I don't consider preparing a package of chicken quarters from
    scratch... I don't see the fun in gutting a chicken and then an hour
    later eating same. A package of chicken parts is more like cooking in
    kit form, same as paint by numbers. Today most all foods are purchased
    nearly prepared... you must be very young. I'm willing to bet most
    folks reading rfc have never gutted a chicken, many have never cut one
    up, or even touched one with bare hands. I've been invited to dinners
    where I was served reheated rotisserie deli chicken, served with the
    pretence of home made from scratch... the only from scratch was
    transfering it to a fancy serving platter, with tongs.

    Sheldon

    Only some of what you say is true. Depends where you live.
    These days, most people do go to the local butcher or fish
    monger for their "fresh" meat, poultry or fish,

    *Depends where you live*... not in the US... in the US the vast
    majority shop for meat at stupidmarkets, and almost always not out of
    choice, very few locations have butcher shops, poultry markets, and
    fish mongers anymore.

    Must you in every post remind everyone that you live in a third world
    country... WE HEARD YOU... everyone else participating in this thread
    lives in more advanced circumstances and is commenting from that
    general consensus... you on the other hand obviously have nothing
    appropriate to contribute, you're just being a juvenile pest with a
    desire to barge into adult conversation... your "Depends where you
    live." comment has long ago lost its novelty, its no longer
    appropriate, it's a put-down, it's ignorant, it's RUDE! If you want
    people to respect your life style choice stop harping on it... self
    praise is no recommendation. I for one have long ago figured out from
    your snide sideways comments that you are not happy with where/how you
    chose to live, you'd return in a flash if only you had the means. Only
    the wealthiest of Americans can adapt to retirement living in Central
    America, and even many of the wealthy cannot, they are too used to
    those common comforts that most Americans enjoy and take for granted
    that are just not available anywhere there, not at any price. The
    wealthy that do adapt fly backwards and forwards on a weekly basis for
    major shopping and all medical needs. I know of what I speak, I lived
    in Central America and traveled there extensively. I was one of those
    who could have afforded to live there financially and almost did but
    decided at the last hour that I didn't want to spend my retirement
    going without the niceities I've grown accustomed to. I know a number
    of Americans who did choose to retire to Central America, who became
    elderly and frail and had to return anyway, they are in US nursing
    homes, couldn't survive but a few months in what Central America calls
    a nursing home, those are much closer to very crude hospices. Central
    Americans don't go to hospitals to get cured, they go to hospitals to
    die.

    Sheldon

  14. Dave Smith said:


    kr_gentner said:

    Most baked items are cheaper to make than to buy. You can also use the
    flour and cocoa to make cake. A good selection of staples allows you to
    make a wide variety of things. Add yeast and you can make all sorts of
    breads cheap too.

    Some things just aren't worth the work. We have an Italiian bakery in our
    town that makes wonderful and sells it for $1.40 per loaf. With just two of
    us in the house, and my wife not eating bread, it just isn't worth all that
    work to make a batch of bread if I can pick up a loaf that is better than I
    can make.

    And then there are school bake sales,
    where you can often find a REAL bargain . . .
    :-)

  15. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Sheldon said:

    cathyxyz wrote:


    <snip>

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:


    Only some of what you say is true. Depends where you live.
    These days, most people do go to the local butcher or fish
    monger for their "fresh" meat, poultry or fish,



    <snip>

    Quoted message said:

    I for one have long ago figured out from
    your snide sideways comments that you are not happy with where/how you
    chose to live, you'd return in a flash if only you had the means. Only
    the wealthiest of Americans can adapt to retirement living in Central
    America, and even many of the wealthy cannot, they are too used to
    those common comforts that most Americans enjoy and take for granted
    that are just not available anywhere there, not at any price. The
    wealthy that do adapt fly backwards and forwards on a weekly basis for
    major shopping and all medical needs. I know of what I speak, I lived
    in Central America and traveled there extensively. I was one of those
    who could have afforded to live there financially and almost did but
    decided at the last hour that I didn't want to spend my retirement
    going without the niceities I've grown accustomed to. I know a number
    of Americans who did choose to retire to Central America, who became
    elderly and frail and had to return anyway, they are in US nursing
    homes, couldn't survive but a few months in what Central America calls
    a nursing home, those are much closer to very crude hospices. Central
    Americans don't go to hospitals to get cured, they go to hospitals to
    die.

    Sheldon

    Hey Cathy(xyz), welcome to Central America! Say hi to Sandi while you're
    there. (snicker)

    Regards,
    Dave W.

    --
    Living in the Ozarks
    For email, edu will do.

    Regardless of what doesn't happen, there's always someone who knew it wouldn't.
    R. Henry

  16. Mark Thorson said:


    And then there are school bake sales,
    where you can often find a REAL bargain . . .
    :-)

    LOL. Let's not go there again :-)
    I only go to them to buy things these days. I refuse to contribute to them.

  17. Mark Thorson said:
    Dave Smith said:


    kr_gentner said:

    Most baked items are cheaper to make than to buy. You can also use
    the flour and cocoa to make cake. A good selection of staples
    allows you to make a wide variety of things. Add yeast and you can
    make all sorts of breads cheap too.

    Some things just aren't worth the work. We have an Italiian bakery
    in our town that makes wonderful and sells it for $1.40 per loaf.
    With just two of us in the house, and my wife not eating bread, it
    just isn't worth all that work to make a batch of bread if I can
    pick up a loaf that is better than I can make.

    And then there are school bake sales,
    where you can often find a REAL bargain . . .
    :-)

    Um, don't you have to have children enrolled in the school in order to
    attend a school bake sale? This may not be the case all over. It wasn't a
    bake sale but in a fit of nostalgia when I was 30-something I stopped by my
    old high school to have a look around. I couldn't just wander around. I
    was directed to the office where I had to sign in and state my reason for
    being there. Long gone are the days of public "car washes" as fundraisers
    (at least not without a teacher or two or some parents present) and bake
    sales and "cake walks" open to the general public. There are just too many
    nuts running out there for whom schools are a major attraction.

    Jill

  18. kr_gentner said:


    Most baked items are cheaper to make than to buy.

    That's not true, not if equal quality... just lighting your oven most
    times negates any savings. And of course your time and effort are
    worthless, right... baking is generally labor intensive and time
    consuming... just a couple loaves of bread requires your attention for
    many hours. Bakeries buy in volume, they pay less than half for
    ingredients than you, and by baking in volume they can sell for the
    same price as your cost or less, and still turn enough profit to cover
    all expenses and show a profit. There is no way the homemaker can
    compete price wise with a successful bakery... some items you'll pay
    more for at a bakery, those that are labor intensive, like cookies, but
    with most items you'll pay less than your cost to produce the same at
    home... if you're willing to spend most of a day baking cookies and
    only compute ingredients but don't include your time and labor then you
    are saying your time and labor is worth nothing. If you're an
    exceptional baker you can probably outdo the quality available at the
    typical corner bakery, but the higher quality ingredients you use the
    greater the spread in cost in favor of the bakery if they chose to also
    up their quality... it's not that they can't out bake you, they choose
    not to. Businesses, sucsessful businesses, tend to produce what will
    sell at a price their market will bear. If the product at your local
    bakery is mediocre it's because mediocre is the price range most folks
    in your neighborhood are able/willing to pay... they are not going to
    produce Champagne in a Budweiser neighborhood. Bakeries are like any
    other business, they produce whatever will increase their volume.

    Sheldon

  19. Quoted message said:

    I just bought a can of Hershey cocoa powder for about $4.19, and OMG it
    goes a long way. You can make a cup of hot cocoa with only 2 or 3
    teaspoons of cocoa. That's a helluva lot cheaper than Swiss Miss, isn't
    it? I wish I had found this out a long time ago, cuz I would've had hot
    cocoa more often. I made a couple of batches of chocolate pudding and
    still have most of the cocoa left.

    YOu could probably use a lot less than 2-3 spoons of cocoa for one cup
    of cocoa. I make a cup often (microwave the milk) add 1 teaspoon of
    cocoa and some splenda. It tastes like milk, instead of just sugar like
    those instant things you were used to using. Blech.

    I'm just curious though... how come you never knew this stuff before?
    Goomba

  20. Sheldon said:

    Must you in every post remind everyone that you live in a third world
    country... WE HEARD YOU... everyone else participating in this thread
    lives in more advanced circumstances and is commenting from that
    general consensus... you on the other hand obviously have nothing
    appropriate to contribute, you're just being a juvenile pest with a
    desire to barge into adult conversation... your "Depends where you
    live." comment has long ago lost its novelty, its no longer
    appropriate, it's a put-down, it's ignorant, it's RUDE! If you want
    people to respect your life style choice stop harping on it... self
    praise is no recommendation. I for one have long ago figured out from
    your snide sideways comments that you are not happy with where/how you
    chose to live, you'd return in a flash if only you had the means.

    Cathy was born in Rhodesia and lives in South Africa. She can't return to
    a place she's never lived.

    Carol
    --
    http://www.manilowfund.com/

    "You Deserve a Break Today" by Barry Manilow

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.