"Benjamin Weiner" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Quoted message said:B. Lafferty said:Quoted message said:That article made me want to puke about five different times when I
read it. No where does she express an ounce of remorse for the fact
that she cheated.
Quoted message said:Remorse comes from feeling that what you did was wrong. She believes
that
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:all top competitors are doping, therefore doping isn't cheating. While
she
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:has major mental problems, some probably drug induced, she does have a
point. There is an old debate in jurisprudence about the validity of a
law
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:that's on the books that nobody obeys. Off the top of my head, I don't
recall the precise legal term for it, but at some point the practice
becomes
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:the law. So *if* everyone at her level was doping, and that practice is
accepted by the participants, it is no longer cheating.
That's a [censored] excuse, or rationalization, on her part. She can't
_know_ that everyone else is doping.
You do recall that Dickey V. basically said that it was normal preparation
in cycling to use drugs. He didn't consider it cheating. It was
"preparation."
Quoted message said:She does know that it's still
cheating, and rationalizes her own weakness and abuse of herself and
the sport by the "everyone is doing it" defense.
It's only cheating because those in control of the sport have said it is.
Consider that some claim that those at the top of certain national sports
federations have turned a blind or complicit eye to the use of drugs (UCI
and US Track and Field, East Germany as a few examples)
Quoted message said:If everyone else is
cheating, quitting is more honorable than joining the cheaters - what
is the value of a goal achieved by cheating?
Or, do as everyone else and make big $$$$$$ which is really the goal. The
evidence would support the argument that "cheating" is quite effective in
acheiving the $$ goal.
Quoted message said:Other than getting
yourself on the Wheaties box, which I don't think TT was ever a prime
candidate for.)
The pecuniary rewards vary. In TT's case she would have been able to
continue making something resembling a "living" as a cyclist with that
lifestyle intact. With a Gold she might even publish as training
book---wouldn't that have been interesting?
Quoted message said:
It's widely claimed that clean riders retired in the early 90s because
they didn't want to keep up with the EPO abuse they suspected in the
peloton - I think you've cited Hampsten as one, and held him up as an
exemplar. That was more honorable than joining in the EPO blitz, IMO.
A number of riders did retire at the beginning of the 90s. Hampsten did not
retire because of EPO, IIRC. In an interview with Cycling Weekly in the
mid-1990s, he spoke of knowing of drug use early on and deciding, with the
support and encouragement of Dr. Max Testa, to redefine his goals and make
the most of his natural abilities. He did fairly well by anyone's
standards. Many of the others who go out at that time, were of "retirement
age" anyway. Certainly there has been no problem getting new blood in who
are willing to manipulate their blood.
Quoted message said:
Now, if Thomas wanted to complain because she was treated more harshly
than track and field superstars, or baseball players, guilty of similar
abuse, that might have some validity.
She has.
Quoted message said:But blaming her competitors
(anyone remember all the [censored] Witty had to put up with to get to the
Olympics?) and suing Catlin and the testing lab is BS. TT places blame
on the testers rather than on the people who introduced her to the drugs
(whom she could presumably name, which might be interesting).
Unfortunately, it's not clear that she's learned anything.
I agree with you completely. She should take responsibility for what she did
just like Virenque and Zulle and get on with life. She'll make for an
interesting courtroom presence if she makes it through law school. She made
her decisions and should just live with them.