Every sport has their "sacred cows". That is, ideas that researchers or practitioners have long
since refuted but just will not die.
In the World of swimming, the most sacred cow of all just has to be that lifting your head out of
the water lowers your hips and increases drag, and therefore should unquestionably be avoided.
It's getting down-right annoying. The coach of my Masters team was parroting that the other day. And
I just saw it again on the USA-Swimming website. Their latest "perfect race" entry is the Olympic
200 IM in which Summer Sanders placed second. They say,
"On her breathing strokes, she does something unconventional by today's technique standards - her
neck is completely out of the water and she looks almost straight ahead. Normally, this action would
cause a swimmer's hips to drop because your body is like a see-saw in the water - when one end goes
up, the other end goes down. That would slow someone down considerably, but Summer is able to
maintain high hip position. While Summer's technique worked very well for her, it probably would not
work for most swimmers."
And I think it's worth mentioning the very technical and very good Yanai article in which he
used a computer model of swimmers to compute the buoyant torque. The upshot of which is the
following quote,
"The average buoyant torque over the stroke cycle (mean=22Nm) was directed to RAISE THE LEGS and
lower the head, primarily because the recovery arm and a PART OF THE HEAD were lifted out of the
water and the center of buoyancy shifted toward the feet."
His article is available for free at: jbiomech.comjbiomech.comOpen ↗
In another words, your head out of the water weighs a lot more than your head in the water. And your
center of buoyancy is about at your naval. So USA-swimming did get one thing right - we are
teeter-totters in the water. Except if you push down on your head, and you keep your back arched, it
leverages your legs UP because your torso has air in it and doesn't want to sink.
But so much for complex research papers by academics. How do really fast people swim? I recently saw
for the first time a clip of one of the great Australian distance man, Kieren Perkins. He's loping,
or "galloping" and lifting his head like crazy before he breaths. Same for Grant Hackett, ditto for
Janet Evans, and Pieter VDH also drives his whole upper body up while he starts his non-breathing
side pull. All those men and women are/were World Record holders.
I'm sure head lifting ain't for everybody. But for crying out loud, would somebody please put a
bullet in this cow?
-Eric