Australia and New Zealand · Public discussion

Studies on CAR exhuberance?

Started by Jake · · Last activity · 10 posts · 759 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Australia and New Zealand
Published
9 December 2003
Last activity
11 December 2003
Original author
Jake
Posts
10
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
759
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–10 of 10
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Has anyone doen a study on what % of CAR commutations are superfluous? I mean this in the relative
    sense. The offendor may not think that driving to the supermarket to collect the shopping is
    superfluous. But I would think it more approriate to take the bicycle and a bob-trailer since this
    way I knock off my excercise and the shopping in one go.

    So has there been a hyperthetical study of say, a "bicycle economy" opposed to the "car economy",
    stripping back every commutation that could be substituted with bicycle power, accounting for
    excercise savings, health benefits. I mean I\'m not an economist, but you would want to create some
    environmental coeeficients for incorpoartion as well. Such as reduced noise and air pollution,
    reduced obesity etc.

    Thus having stripped it all back, what part of commerce is genuinely dependent on heavy machinery.
    It stikes me every single day as the most moronic icon of mankind. Majority-of -the-time Single
    passenger vehicles that weigh in at 2 tonnes. Figure that eh, 2 tonnes of metal to carry a 60kg
    person and all because we sell the idea to ourselves that it is a source of happinss to be able to
    travel at high speeds if needed. And when is it needed? Police chase?

    Tell me, how would the economy be hurt or different if freight trucks could onyl travel interstate
    at 50km an hour? How much lighter could the chassis be made then, how much less strength woudl
    they require?

    Man, everyday on my humble bicycle, I grieve the lunacy and madness of this materially exhuberant
    and obese civilisation.

  2. When is it needed to travel quickly? Ambulance? Tell me this then those who would scoff at my
    suggestion with thus, tell me, how many of those ambulance trips are to save people who were in a
    car accident? "Jake" <j@com> wrote in message "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Has anyone doen a study on what % of CAR commutations are superfluous? I mean this in the relative
    sense. The offendor may not think that driving


    to

    Quoted message said:

    the supermarket to collect the shopping is superfluous. But I would think


    it

    Quoted message said:

    more approriate to take the bicycle and a bob-trailer since this way I


    knock

    Quoted message said:

    off my excercise and the shopping in one go.

    So has there been a hyperthetical study of say, a "bicycle economy"


    opposed

    Quoted message said:

    to the "car economy", stripping back every commutation that could be substituted with bicycle
    power, accounting for excercise savings, health benefits. I mean I\'m not an economist, but you
    would want to create some environmental coeeficients for incorpoartion as well. Such as reduced


    noise

    Quoted message said:

    and air pollution, reduced obesity etc.

    Thus having stripped it all back, what part of commerce is genuinely dependent on heavy machinery.
    It stikes me every single day as the most moronic icon of mankind. Majority-of -the-time Single
    passenger vehicles that weigh in at 2 tonnes. Figure that eh, 2 tonnes of metal to carry a 60kg
    person and all because we sell the idea to ourselves that it is a source of happinss to be able to
    travel at high speeds if needed. And when is it needed? Police chase?

    Tell me, how would the economy be hurt or different if freight trucks


    could

    Quoted message said:

    onyl travel interstate at 50km an hour? How much lighter could the chassis be made then, how much
    less strength woudl they require?

    Man, everyday on my humble bicycle, I grieve the lunacy and madness of


    this

    Quoted message said:

    materially exhuberant and obese civilisation.

  3. "Jake" wrote

    Quoted message said:

    Thus having stripped it all back, what part of commerce is genuinely dependent on heavy machinery.

    Your bicycle came to you by ship and truck.

    Quoted message said:

    Tell me, how would the economy be hurt or different if freight


    trucks could

    Quoted message said:

    onyl travel interstate at 50km an hour? How much lighter could the


    chassis

    Quoted message said:

    be made then, how much less strength woudl they require?

    You would pay double the driver's wages for each trip.

    Quoted message said:

    Man, everyday on my humble bicycle, I grieve the lunacy and madness


    of this

    Quoted message said:

    materially exhuberant and obese civilisation.

    Get out of this mad technological society. WALK!

    Theo

  4. Greetings, Suggest you contact Alan A Parker, of PEST (People for Ecologically Sustainable
    Transport), who has been studying and writing papers on this collective insanity for years, and
    take another look at Ben Elton's `Gridlock', one of the better satires on the subject. We all know
    it's totally looney, but no-one does anything about. For the record, when I do drive, I drive a 1.1
    tonne car (well under average) primarily to take my wife around, who is not a bicycle person at
    all. I try to avoid sole-occupant trips wherever possible. Unfortunately, I'm also a tiny minority.
    Cheers, Ray.

    Jake said:

    Has anyone doen a study on what % of CAR commutations are superfluous? I mean this in the relative
    sense. The offendor may not think that driving to the supermarket to collect the shopping is
    superfluous. But I would think it more approriate to take the bicycle and a bob-trailer since this
    way I knock off my excercise and the shopping in one go.

    So has there been a hyperthetical study of say, a "bicycle economy" opposed to the "car economy",
    stripping back every commutation that could be substituted with bicycle power, accounting for
    excercise savings, health benefits. I mean I\'m not an economist, but you would want to create some
    environmental coeeficients for incorpoartion as well. Such as reduced noise and air pollution,
    reduced obesity etc.

    Thus having stripped it all back, what part of commerce is genuinely dependent on heavy machinery.
    It stikes me every single day as the most moronic icon of mankind. Majority-of -the-time Single
    passenger vehicles that weigh in at 2 tonnes. Figure that eh, 2 tonnes of metal to carry a 60kg
    person and all because we sell the idea to ourselves that it is a source of happinss to be able to
    travel at high speeds if needed. And when is it needed? Police chase?

    Tell me, how would the economy be hurt or different if freight trucks could onyl travel interstate
    at 50km an hour? How much lighter could the chassis be made then, how much less strength woudl
    they require?

    Man, everyday on my humble bicycle, I grieve the lunacy and madness of this materially exhuberant
    and obese civilisation.

  5. "Jake" <j@com> wrote in message "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Has anyone doen a study on what % of CAR commutations are superfluous? I mean this in the relative
    sense. The offendor may not think that driving


    to

    Quoted message said:

    the supermarket to collect the shopping is superfluous. But I would think


    it

    Quoted message said:

    more approriate to take the bicycle and a bob-trailer since this way I


    knock

    Quoted message said:

    off my excercise and the shopping in one go.

    So has there been a hyperthetical study of say, a "bicycle economy"


    opposed

    Quoted message said:

    to the "car economy", stripping back every commutation that could be substituted with bicycle
    power, accounting for excercise savings, health benefits. I mean I\'m not an economist, but you
    would want to create some environmental coeeficients for incorpoartion as well. Such as reduced


    noise

    Quoted message said:

    and air pollution, reduced obesity etc.

    Thus having stripped it all back, what part of commerce is genuinely dependent on heavy machinery.
    It stikes me every single day as the most moronic icon of mankind. Majority-of -the-time Single
    passenger vehicles that weigh in at 2 tonnes. Figure that eh, 2 tonnes of metal to carry a 60kg
    person and all because we sell the idea to ourselves that it is a source of happinss to be able to
    travel at high speeds if needed. And when is it needed? Police chase?

    Tell me, how would the economy be hurt or different if freight trucks


    could

    Quoted message said:

    onyl travel interstate at 50km an hour? How much lighter could the chassis be made then, how much
    less strength woudl they require?

    Man, everyday on my humble bicycle, I grieve the lunacy and madness of


    this

    Quoted message said:

    materially exhuberant and obese civilisation.

    It all depends on what you class as a necessity - and whether you are talking about keeping other
    segments of our existance the same.

    For example, I ride into my office every day and keep a suit there to get changed into when I need
    to see a client. If the client is easily accessible by PT, I will take that (you cannot turn up to a
    client on the bike - I would be covered with sweat).

    If the client is not easily accessible, I will drive my car (I average about one trip every two
    weeks in my car). I could probably do without the car (through walking and PT), but this would then
    take up a much larger chunk of my day, meaning that I could service less people, my company would
    get paid less and my wages would have to go down commensurately.

    The vast majority of people who drive to work in the city every day *could* take PT - even if they
    drove to the station, but choose not to (due to status, perceptions, bias and that they may need to
    leave home 10 minutes earlier).

    But removing "non-required" transportation would require an enormous shift in our culture, society,
    governance etc.

    Tim

  6. Jake,

    You sound like the sort of guy who relishes borrowing a friend's car for a few weeks.

    A true Luddite implements reforms at home before belly-aching about the shortcomings of others.

  7. EF Schumacher makes a slightly tongue-in-cheek calculation in one of his books, where he shows that
    if you add the time taken in earning the money to pay for a car, plus time sitting at traffic
    lights, in traffic jams, washing the thing on weekends, etc to the time actually driving somewhere,
    then the average speed attained is somewhat less than walking pace...

    Nick

    "Theo Bekkers" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:HzkBb.46146$aT.30876@news-
    server.bigpond.net.au...

    Quoted message said:


    Get out of this mad technological society. WALK!

  8. "Nick Payne" wrote

    Quoted message said:

    EF Schumacher makes a slightly tongue-in-cheek calculation in one of his books, where he shows
    that if you add the time taken in earning the money


    to

    Quoted message said:

    pay for a car, plus time sitting at traffic lights, in traffic jams,


    washing

    Quoted message said:

    the thing on weekends, etc to the time actually driving somewhere, then


    the

    Quoted message said:

    average speed attained is somewhat less than walking pace...

    In response to an article in a bike magazine a loong time ago, I produced some spreadsheets
    comparing the costs (in hours worked and subsequent average speeds) of a V8 car, a small car, a
    small and a large motorcycle, and a bicycle. To my surprise they published the whole thing in a page
    and a half of print. The small motorcycle wins hands down for cost/efficiency.

    Theo

  9. google.comsearch

  10. Ah, slime, I don't know what you're talking about mate.
    "Slime" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Jake,

    You sound like the sort of guy who relishes borrowing a friend's car for a few weeks.

    A true Luddite implements reforms at home before belly-aching about the shortcomings of others.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.