Australia and New Zealand · Public discussion

Shifter hoods

Started by Brendo · · Last activity · 7 posts · 715 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Australia and New Zealand
Published
24 May 2007
Last activity
25 May 2007
Original author
Brendo
Posts
7
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
715
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–7 of 7
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Shifter hoods were obviously designed to be mounted in a particular
    location on the bars. In relation to their design, are they meant to
    be a linear extension of the top of the bar, before it curves to the
    drop section? This is not taking into account comfort or reach
    issues.

    Mine are sitting closer to the rider and as such pointing upwards at
    around 30 - 40 degrees. When riding on the hoods, most of the pressure
    is in the webbing betwixt my thumb and forefinger. I am assuming this
    is incorrect.

    Brendo

  2. Brendo said:

    Shifter hoods were obviously designed to be mounted in a particular
    location on the bars. In relation to their design, are they meant to
    be a linear extension of the top of the bar, before it curves to the
    drop section? This is not taking into account comfort or reach
    issues.

    Mine are sitting closer to the rider and as such pointing upwards at
    around 30 - 40 degrees. When riding on the hoods, most of the pressure
    is in the webbing betwixt my thumb and forefinger. I am assuming this
    is incorrect.

    Brendo

    Soumds to me like they are too far up, It should be comfortable with the pressure on the ball of your palms. Go get it checked out by your local Bike shop.

  3. "Brendo" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Shifter hoods were obviously designed to be mounted in a particular
    location on the bars. In relation to their design, are they meant to
    be a linear extension of the top of the bar, before it curves to the
    drop section? This is not taking into account comfort or reach
    issues.

    Mine are sitting closer to the rider and as such pointing upwards at
    around 30 - 40 degrees. When riding on the hoods, most of the pressure
    is in the webbing betwixt my thumb and forefinger. I am assuming this
    is incorrect.

    Brendo

    If you have broadband, have a look at the sample of Steve Hogg's "Sitty
    Pretty" DVD at this site. You might find it helpful and better than my lame
    description.

    http://www.bicyclingaustralia.com/

    Adam

  4. Brendo said:

    Shifter hoods were obviously designed to be mounted in a particular
    location on the bars. In relation to their design, are they meant to
    be a linear extension of the top of the bar, before it curves to the
    drop section? This is not taking into account comfort or reach
    issues.

    Mine are sitting closer to the rider and as such pointing upwards at
    around 30 - 40 degrees. When riding on the hoods, most of the pressure
    is in the webbing betwixt my thumb and forefinger. I am assuming this
    is incorrect.

    The usual recommendation is that the tips of the levers should be in line
    with the straight section of the drops (or tangent to the end of them). But
    I've seen quite a bit of variation from this, presumably due to personal
    preference. I have them a bit lower, because I'm comfortable stretched out.

    --
    Home page: http://members.westnet.com.au/mvw

  5. Brendo said:

    Shifter hoods were obviously designed to be mounted in a particular
    location on the bars. In relation to their design, are they meant to
    be a linear extension of the top of the bar, before it curves to the
    drop section? This is not taking into account comfort or reach
    issues.

    Mine are sitting closer to the rider and as such pointing upwards at
    around 30 - 40 degrees. When riding on the hoods, most of the pressure
    is in the webbing betwixt my thumb and forefinger. I am assuming this
    is incorrect.

    IMO it's all personal preference. My shifter hoods are placed so that they're extensions of the flat bit of the bars, effectively turning the bars in to bullhorns. I find that very comfortable, my LBS guy thinks it looks absolutely hideous but if it's right for me, it's right for me.

    I did pay some attention to hood position on the TDF, there doesn't seem to be a consensus. Some riders have the tip of the hood level with the flat, others have them as I have them and others still have variations.

    Move them to where's comfortable for you.

  6. On May 25, 8:21 am, EuanB <EuanB.2r3...@no-

    mx.forums.cyclingforums.com said:
    Brendo said:

    Shifter hoods were obviously designed to be mounted in a particular
    location on the bars. In relation to their design, are they meant to
    be a linear extension of the top of the bar, before it curves to the
    drop section? This is not taking into account comfort or reach
    issues.

    Quoted message said:

    Mine are sitting closer to the rider and as such pointing upwards at
    around 30 - 40 degrees. When riding on the hoods, most of the pressure
    is in the webbing betwixt my thumb and forefinger. I am assuming this
    is incorrect.

    IMO it's all personal preference. My shifter hoods are placed so that
    they're extensions of the flat bit of the bars, effectively turning the
    bars in to bullhorns. I find that very comfortable, my LBS guy thinks
    it looks absolutely hideous but if it's right for me, it's right for
    me.

    I did pay some attention to hood position on the TDF, there doesn't
    seem to be a consensus. Some riders have the tip of the hood level
    with the flat, others have them as I have them and others still have
    variations.

    Move them to where's comfortable for you.

    --
    EuanB

    I'm with the flat approach, but that seems to be what campag are
    aiming for, the 'normal' shimano position seems to be much higher.

    As Euan said, find a comfortable spot for you..

  7. PiledHigher said:

    On May 25, 8:21 am, EuanB <EuanB.2r3...@no-

    mx.forums.cyclingforums.com said:

    Brendo Wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Shifter hoods were obviously designed to be mounted in a particular
    location on the bars. In relation to their design, are they meant to
    be a linear extension of the top of the bar, before it curves to the
    drop section? This is not taking into account comfort or reach
    issues.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Mine are sitting closer to the rider and as such pointing upwards at
    around 30 - 40 degrees. When riding on the hoods, most of the pressure
    is in the webbing betwixt my thumb and forefinger. I am assuming this
    is incorrect.

    Quoted message said:

    IMO it's all personal preference. My shifter hoods are placed so that
    they're extensions of the flat bit of the bars, effectively turning the
    bars in to bullhorns. I find that very comfortable, my LBS guy thinks
    it looks absolutely hideous but if it's right for me, it's right for
    me.

    Quoted message said:

    I did pay some attention to hood position on the TDF, there doesn't
    seem to be a consensus. Some riders have the tip of the hood level
    with the flat, others have them as I have them and others still have
    variations.

    Quoted message said:

    Move them to where's comfortable for you.

    Quoted message said:

    --
    EuanB

    I'm with the flat approach, but that seems to be what campag are
    aiming for, the 'normal' shimano position seems to be much higher.

    As Euan said, find a comfortable spot for you..- Hide quoted text -

    - Show quoted text -

    The shimano ones seem to be shaped to sit upwards from the bars,
    whereas the Campy ones sit much flatter. Maybe there is no science
    behind it, they just design it for where it feels comfortable to the
    testing group.

    I've rolled mine forward a little (Shimano) but there is still a
    noticeable hook upwards. There is around a 40mm vertical gap between
    the bottom of the levers and the bottom of the drops. I don't think
    it's optimal, but then again it fits about as well as everything else
    on my bike.

    Brendo

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.