Road Cycling · Public discussion

RvV

Started by Steve McGinty · · Last activity · 40 posts · 1,344 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Road Cycling
Published
4 April 2004
Last activity
7 April 2004
Original author
Steve McGinty
Posts
40
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,344
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 21–40 of 40
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Tom Kunich said:

    "Benjamin Weiner" <[email hidden]> wrote in message

    Quoted message said:

    Then Hoste handed Wesemann a gift by chasing down
    Bruylandts's attack in the final km.

    Quoted message said:

    It was clear that Hoste either chaced Bruylandts down or
    it was Dave's win. Wesseman knew that he simply could
    not chace Dave and win the sprint. Steffen performed
    like a genius.

    Dumbass,

    He did ride smartly, but in the finale, Wesemann was the
    strongest and had the most to lose. That's why Hoste could
    have waited a fraction of a second, requiring Wesemann to
    chase. That's my point. Wese probably could have chased down
    Bruylandts and still won anyway - after all Hoste had been
    in the break all day.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Not sure why (perhaps rather chase down a rival Belgian
    team, damn the consequences?)

    Quoted message said:

    No, because he was on a different team - that's why their
    jerseys were different colors. What is with this helping a
    countryman thing? Would you give away a race to someone
    from your home state if you might have a chance to win it
    yourself?

    Dumbass,

    I don't really believe that scenario, and Jeff Jones has
    refuted it, but I said the opposite of what you're replying
    to. You see the Spanish teams lead the chase of each other's
    riders all the time, for example. Rivalries are stronger
    between teams from the same country, if only because
    commentators will say things like "Lotto is having a good
    year, Domo is a disappointment" etc.

  2. Benjamin Weiner said:

    You see the Spanish teams lead the chase of each other's
    riders all the time, for example.

    That is often because of the high value Spanish teams place
    on team classification. I have heard them say it is as
    important as the individual.

  3. h squared <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>...

    Quoted message said:
    Jeff Jones said:


    "Benjamin Weiner" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    message news:40710709$1@darkstar...

    Quoted message said:

    steve robertson <[email hidden]> wrote:

    Then Hoste handed Wesemann a gift by chasing down
    Bruylandts's attack in the final km. Not sure why
    (perhaps rather chase down a rival Belgian team, damn
    the consequences?) or why Wesemann didn't react to
    Bruylandts right away (perhaps he sussed that Hoste
    would go for rivalry reasons, or because Hoste had
    been sitting on? Too complicated.) Chung, you really
    need to write up that study of game theory in cycling.


    I don't think it was rivalry. I think Hoste was feeling
    "fresh" and was also relatively inexperienced in this
    sort of a situation. Wesemann was smarter, although I
    think he still would have won had he chased down
    Bruylandts himself.

    i'm a terrible observer, but it looked to me like hoste
    did wait a bit for wessemann to chase, but maybe when
    he didn't, hoste didn't want to just give up his chance
    for a win. i don't see what bruylandts has to complain
    about really.

    You're still a better observer than Kunich.

    Hoste was sitting on the whole way, not even soft pedalling
    through. When Bruylandts pulled off Hoste actually pushed
    Bruylandts ahead of him.

    Quoted message said:

    even though hoste spent all day in front and then chased
    him down, hoste still beat him (unless he just gave up
    trying after hoste chased him down, but then he needs a
    spanking)

    If you attack with a kilo to go and you can still sprint
    when you're caught then you need to upgrade.

    -Amit

  4. "Ewoud Dronkert" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Benjamin Weiner said:

    You see the Spanish teams lead the chase of each other's
    riders all the time, for example.

    That is often because of the high value Spanish teams
    place on team classification. I have heard them say it is
    as important as the individual.

    It is (or used to be) in the grand tours, 'cos the team that
    wins gets an invite to next year's.

    Back to the topic, there's no personal rivalry between
    Hoste and Bruylandts, who were roomates when they were in
    Domo. And Wesemann (who did hesitate first) had a number of
    things in his favour: he was the quickest; he knew that
    Hoste wasn't as experienced and had relatively fresh legs,
    and would probably be happy to get second. It was smart
    riding, as I think Wesemann was on the front when
    Bruylandts attacked, so Hoste would realise that Wesemann
    wouldn't react.

    Summary: I don't think Hoste could have won, no matter what
    he did. Only Bruylandts or Wesemann.

    Bruylandts was hoping that Hoste would realise this (that he
    could only get second) and not chase him down because then
    there'd be a Belgian victory rather than a German one. But I
    don't think Hoste had that in mind.

    Jeff (there's way too much second guessing here, which
    qualifies 100 percent for an RBR analysis)

  5. Jeff Jones said:
    Quoted message said:

    high value Spanish teams place on team classification.

    It is (or used to be) in the grand tours,

    Right, that's what I meant.

    Quoted message said:

    'cos the team that wins gets an invite to next year's.

    I think there's more to it than that; they place an
    intrinsic value on team ranking that we (Dutch, Belgian, but
    more general probably: non-Spanish...) just don't
    understand.

  6. Robert Chung said:
    Benjamin Weiner said:

    Chung, you really need to write up that study of game
    theory in cycling.

    Yeah, right. 'Cuz, but for one or two notable exceptions,
    there's been a recent dearth of truly sphincter-tightening
    posts on rbr.

    Besides, I'm sorta stuck on the title. Here are two
    candidates:
    1. Selten, Harsanyi, and extreme payoffs: collusion and
    reneging in the world of professional cycling.

    Speaking of payoffs, was it just a bad translation or did
    Paolo Bettini really say "I paid cash for that [the chase]
    in the last 20km"?

  7. "Benjamin Weiner" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:4071923d$1@darkstar...

    Quoted message said:
    Tom Kunich said:

    "Benjamin Weiner" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    message

    Quoted message said:

    Then Hoste handed Wesemann a gift by chasing down
    Bruylandts's attack in the final km.

    Quoted message said:

    It was clear that Hoste either chaced Bruylandts down or
    it was Dave's


    win.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Wesseman knew that he simply could not chace Dave and
    win the sprint. Steffen performed like a genius.

    He did ride smartly, but in the finale, Wesemann was the
    strongest and had the most to lose. That's why Hoste could
    have waited a fraction of a second, requiring Wesemann to
    chase. That's my point. Wese probably could have chased
    down Bruylandts and still won anyway - after all Hoste had
    been in the break all day.

    Ten more seconds and Wesemann couldn't have caught
    Bruylandts. It was a big gamble on Steffen's part because if
    he had gone first Hoste could have put that same effort into
    a long sprint to the line and Wesemann would have been SOL.
    When Hoste dug in and chased down Dave, he was putting in
    some evil power to those pedals.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Not sure why (perhaps rather chase down a rival
    Belgian team, damn the consequences?)

    Quoted message said:

    No, because he was on a different team - that's why
    their jerseys were different colors. What is with this
    helping a countryman thing? Would


    you

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    give away a race to someone from your home state if you
    might have a


    chance

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    to win it yourself?

    I don't really believe that scenario, and Jeff Jones has
    refuted it, but I said the opposite of what you're
    replying to. You see the Spanish teams lead the chase of
    each other's riders all the time, for example. Rivalries
    are stronger between teams from the same country, if only
    because commentators will say things like "Lotto is having
    a good year, Domo is a disappointment" etc.

    I'll let our Belgian friends put in a comment here. But you
    should remember what happened a couple of years ago when the
    Belgian teams allowed their own personal vedettas between
    rival Belgian teams to become more important than the races
    they were in.

  8. "Amit" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    h squared <[email hidden]> wrote
    in message


    news:<[email hidden]>...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:


    i'm a terrible observer, but it looked to me like hoste
    did wait a bit for wessemann to chase, but maybe when he
    didn't, hoste didn't want to just give up his chance for
    a win. i don't see what bruylandts has to complain about
    really.

    You're still a better observer than Kunich.

    Hoste was sitting on the whole way, not even soft
    pedalling through. When Bruylandts pulled off Hoste
    actually pushed Bruylandts ahead of him.

    I have heard anyone here say anything about "the look" that
    Steffen gave Hoste which clearly said, "I ain't chasing". Is
    that because you're all so observant?

  9. Ewoud Dronkert said:

    strijkijzer.

    i'm learning dutch right and left on this group lately.
    my dictionary says flat iron, but is there more to it
    than that?

    ( also, a belgian girl this morning on a hair styling and
    makeup group taught me "ronde van frankrijk" for the tour de
    france. she also said that even if you aren't into bike
    racing, (like she isn't, boohoo), if you live in belgium you
    know about the ronde van vlaanderen, same way as if you live
    in the usa, you know about the superbowl. but she said that
    soccer is still more popular than bike racing. )

    heather

  10. in article [email hidden], Amit at
    [email hidden] wrote on 4/5/04 11:07 AM:

    Quoted message said:

    h squared <[email hidden]> wrote in
    message news:<[email hidden]>...

    Quoted message said:
    Jeff Jones said:


    "Benjamin Weiner" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    message news:40710709$1@darkstar...
    > steve robertson <[email hidden]> wrote:
    >
    > Then Hoste handed Wesemann a gift by chasing down
    > Bruylandts's attack in the final km. Not sure why
    > (perhaps rather chase down a rival Belgian team, damn
    > the consequences?) or why Wesemann didn't react to
    > Bruylandts right away (perhaps he sussed that Hoste
    > would go for rivalry reasons, or because Hoste had been
    > sitting on? Too complicated.) Chung, you really need to
    > write up that study of game theory in cycling.
    >
    I don't think it was rivalry. I think Hoste was feeling
    "fresh" and was also relatively inexperienced in this
    sort of a situation. Wesemann was smarter, although I
    think he still would have won had he chased down
    Bruylandts himself.

    i'm a terrible observer, but it looked to me like hoste
    did wait a bit for wessemann to chase, but maybe when he
    didn't, hoste didn't want to just give up his chance for
    a win. i don't see what bruylandts has to complain about
    really.


    You're still a better observer than Kunich.

    Hoste was sitting on the whole way, not even soft
    pedalling through. When Bruylandts pulled off Hoste
    actually pushed Bruylandts ahead of him.

    Was that what the slap on the hand was about? I was
    wondering.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    even though hoste spent all day in front and then chased
    him down, hoste still beat him (unless he just gave up
    trying after hoste chased him down, but then he needs a
    spanking)


    If you attack with a kilo to go and you can still sprint
    when you're caught then you need to upgrade.

    It takes something like 3 minutes to recharge one's ATP-PC
    system, which provides about 3 seconds of explosive power...
    so for that matter, if you can do this, you should probably
    consider being a multimillion-dollar guinea pig for a doping
    company...

    -Sonarrat.

  11. Stewart Fleming said:

    Speaking of payoffs, was it just a bad translation or did
    Paolo Bettini really say "I paid cash for that [the chase]
    in the last 20km"?

    Probably Italian -> Dutch -> English. It's an
    expression in Dutch.

  12. h squared said:
    Quoted message said:

    strijkijzer.

    my dictionary says flat iron, but is there more to it
    than that?

    No that's it.
    xs4all.nlstrijkijzers.mp3

    Quoted message said:

    if you live in belgium you know about the ronde van
    vlaanderen, same way as if you live in the usa, you know
    about the superbowl. but she said that soccer is still
    more popular than bike racing. )

    Right. It's the same with speedskating and the
    Elfstedentocht in Holland (oops, Friesland).

  13. Ewoud Dronkert said:
    Quoted message said:

    No that's it.
    xs4all.nlstrijkijzers.mp3

    alright, i'm returning my "learn dutch in 3 months" tapes
    that i bought 7 years ago and demanding a full refund. all i
    got from that (besides the proper names) was something about
    "three people" and i'm not even sure of that. i heard
    "strijkijzer" at the very end, but only because i knew to
    listen for it

    Quoted message said:


    Quoted message said:

    if you live in belgium you know about the ronde van
    vlaanderen, same way as if you live in the usa, you know
    about the superbowl. but she said that soccer is still
    more popular than bike racing. )

    Right. It's the same with speedskating and the
    Elfstedentocht in Holland (oops, Friesland).

    i had never realized. strange how something like that can
    happen, like suddenly you think, "oh, when they said it was
    popular, they meant it was popular!! now i get it..."

    heather have there been any elfstedentochts
    (elfstedentochten?) lately?

  14. Ewoud Dronkert said:
    Stewart Fleming said:

    Speaking of payoffs, was it just a bad translation or did
    Paolo Bettini really say "I paid cash for that [the chase]
    in the last 20km"?

    Probably Italian -> Dutch -> English. It's an expression
    in Dutch.


    Probably translate better to something like " I paid in big
    coin for that chase.." ie. I dug deep and worked my ass off,
    and it hurt.

  15. "h squared" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Ewoud Dronkert said:
    Quoted message said:

    No that's it.
    xs4all.nlstrijkijzers.mp3

    alright, i'm returning my "learn dutch in 3 months" tapes
    that i bought 7 years ago and demanding a full refund. all
    i got from that (besides the proper names) was something
    about "three people" and i'm not even sure of that. i
    heard "strijkijzer" at the very end, but only because i
    knew to listen for it


    Very very rough:

    Spruch is a fast man and in front of him there are three men
    riding: Tafi, Wauters (and who's the third again?)
    Serpellini. To be honest, that's a shop full of strijkijzers
    [flat irons]

    Jeff (who often sprints like a strijkijzer)

  16. h squared said:

    alright, i'm returning my "learn dutch in 3 months" tapes
    that i bought 7 years ago and demanding a full refund.

    Haha! I doubt it makes much difference for you, but a lot of
    Dutchmen (northern, from "above the Moerdijk"😉 would also
    claim not to have understood a word. It's Flemish. But hey,
    it's not the Flemish of Jef Braeckevelt, or Briek Schotte.
    Try xs4all.nlmuur.html

    Quoted message said:

    have there been any elfstedentochts
    (elfstedentochten?) lately?

    No, last three were in 1985, 1986 and 1997. (it's tochten).

  17. Quoted message said:

    It's Flemish.

    OK, I had a listen again, and Uytterhoeven really speaks
    almost accent-free Dutch. So it's not that :/

  18. Jeff Jones said:


    Spruch is a fast man and in front of him there are three
    men riding: Tafi, Wauters (and who's the third again?)
    Serpellini. To be honest, that's a shop full of
    strijkijzers [flat irons]

    Jeff (who often sprints like a strijkijzer)

    lol, at the "een winkel", i kept hearing "enrico"...my brain
    sprints like a strijkijzer sometimes.

    thank you jeff.

    hh,

  19. Sonarrat <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>...

    Quoted message said:

    in article
    [email hidden], Amit at
    [email hidden] wrote on 4/5/04 11:07 AM:

    Quoted message said:

    h squared <[email hidden]> wrote
    in message news:<[email hidden]>...

    Quoted message said:

    Jeff Jones wrote:
    >
    > "Benjamin Weiner" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    > message news:40710709$1@darkstar...
    >> steve robertson <[email hidden]> wrote:
    >>
    >> Then Hoste handed Wesemann a gift by chasing down
    >> Bruylandts's attack in the final km. Not sure why
    >> (perhaps rather chase down a rival Belgian team, damn
    >> the consequences?) or why Wesemann didn't react to
    >> Bruylandts right away (perhaps he sussed that Hoste
    >> would go for rivalry reasons, or because Hoste had
    >> been sitting on? Too complicated.) Chung, you really
    >> need to write up that study of game theory in
    >> cycling.
    >>
    > I don't think it was rivalry. I think Hoste was
    > feeling "fresh" and was also relatively inexperienced
    > in this sort of a situation. Wesemann was smarter,
    > although I think he still would have won had he chased
    > down Bruylandts himself.

    i'm a terrible observer, but it looked to me like hoste
    did wait a bit for wessemann to chase, but maybe when
    he didn't, hoste didn't want to just give up his chance
    for a win. i don't see what bruylandts has to complain
    about really.


    You're still a better observer than Kunich.

    Hoste was sitting on the whole way, not even soft
    pedalling through. When Bruylandts pulled off Hoste
    actually pushed Bruylandts ahead of him.

    Was that what the slap on the hand was about? I was
    wondering.

    After Bruylandts pulled off, Hoste left a gap behind
    Wesemann for him to move into rather than moving up behind
    Wesemann. Hoste pushed Bruylandts ahead of him and they had
    a little exchange. Hoste didn't do any work after the
    Bosberg until Wesemann forced his hand when Bruylandts
    attacked with a km to go.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    even though hoste spent all day in front and then
    chased him down, hoste still beat him (unless he just
    gave up trying after hoste chased him down, but then he
    needs a spanking)


    If you attack with a kilo to go and you can still sprint
    when you're caught then you need to upgrade.

    It takes something like 3 minutes to recharge one's ATP-PC
    system, which provides about 3 seconds of explosive
    power... so for that matter, if you can do this, you
    should probably consider being a multimillion-dollar
    guinea pig for a doping company...

    I could do this against sufficiently lame competition.

    -Amit

  20. "Tom Kunich" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:<[email hidden]>...

    Quoted message said:

    "Amit" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    h squared <[email hidden]> wrote
    in message


    news:<[email hidden]>...

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:


    i'm a terrible observer, but it looked to me like
    hoste did wait a bit for wessemann to chase, but maybe
    when he didn't, hoste didn't want to just give up his
    chance for a win. i don't see what bruylandts has to
    complain about really.

    You're still a better observer than Kunich.

    Hoste was sitting on the whole way, not even soft
    pedalling through. When Bruylandts pulled off Hoste
    actually pushed Bruylandts ahead of him.

    I have heard anyone here say anything about "the look"
    that Steffen gave Hoste which clearly said, "I ain't
    chasing". Is that because you're all so observant?

    you typically make great leaps from viewing your tapes,
    which are usually wrong, i don't know how you can say a look
    clearly says anything. wesemann's lack of respose to
    Bruylandts' attack is pretty clear.

    go back and watch your tape again. the shot cuts away to an
    aerial view when Bruylandts attacks from the back, Hoste
    looks back when he closes the gap to Bruylandts.

    ??

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.