General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Re: Value of sweating

Started by Lanceandrew · · Last activity · 104 posts · 2,190 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
20 December 2004
Last activity
26 December 2004
Original author
Lanceandrew
Posts
104
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
2,190
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 104
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. ig...you gotta start running man. sweat is not contingent on weather. it's a
    natural bodily function that's supposed to happen given a set of circumstances
    not unlike a BM. i ran 4 hard miles this morning.....-4 F. That's right
    DF, -4 ! Your sweat just freezes and collects on your skin where it's exposed
    to the weather.

    you're basically asking if a natural bodily function is healthy.

  2. Lanceandrew said:


    ig...you gotta start running man. sweat is not contingent on weather. it's a
    natural bodily function that's supposed to happen given a set of circumstances
    not unlike a BM. i ran 4 hard miles this morning.....-4 F. That's right
    DF, -4 ! Your sweat just freezes and collects on your skin where it's exposed
    to the weather.

    If you have bare sweaty skin (other than maybe your
    nose/lips) exposed to subzero temps and is freezing,
    you need to cover the skin. The point isn't to stay
    100% dry, since one will sweat regardless. But to
    _insulate_.

    Quoted message said:


    you're basically asking if a natural bodily function is healthy.

  3. Lanceandrew said:

    i ran 4 hard miles this morning.....-4 F. That's right DF, -4 !

    That's cold? Sort of a standard late December/January day around here.

    Neil

  4. Lanceandrew said:

    ig...you gotta start running man. sweat is not contingent on weather. it's a
    natural bodily function that's supposed to happen given a set of circumstances
    not unlike a BM. i ran 4 hard miles this morning.....-4 F. That's right
    DF, -4 !

    Bull (unless you moved without telling us). I've been outside running too, and
    it hasn't been -4. Not even close. It's less than 20, but more than 10. Are
    you counting windchill or something ?

    Cheers,
    --
    Donovan Rebbechi
    http://pegasus.rutgers.edu/~elflord/

  5. "Donovan Rebbechi" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Are you counting windchill or something ?

    We create our own windchill, don't we. Maybe he's really really fast and can
    turn a 20 degree days into -4 F :^)

  6. Donovan Rebbechi said:
    Lanceandrew said:

    ig...you gotta start running man. sweat is not contingent on
    weather. it's a natural bodily function that's supposed to happen
    given a set of circumstances not unlike a BM. i ran 4 hard miles
    this morning.....-4 F. That's right DF, -4 !

    Bull (unless you moved without telling us). I've been outside running
    too, and it hasn't been -4. Not even close.

    Maybe he's simply using proper units. ;-)

    Tim

  7. "Tim Downie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Donovan Rebbechi said:
    Lanceandrew said:

    ig...you gotta start running man. sweat is not contingent on
    weather. it's a natural bodily function that's supposed to happen
    given a set of circumstances not unlike a BM. i ran 4 hard miles
    this morning.....-4 F. That's right DF, -4 !

    Bull (unless you moved without telling us). I've been outside running
    too, and it hasn't been -4. Not even close.

    Maybe he's simply using proper units. ;-)


    or maybe he's using Celcius. he seems a bit off...that could be it.

    Quoted message said:


    Tim

  8. Quoted message said:

    you're basically asking if a natural bodily function is healthy.

    Well just keep in mind, that most of his waking hours are preoccupied by a
    particular "bodily function" that involes one arm, and no it's not typing...

  9. Quoted message said:

    Bull (unless you moved without telling us). I've been outside running too, and


    it hasn't been -4. Not even close.
    ____

    It's now 3PM and 17 F, Feels like 4F w/windchill. It's the high point of the
    day. Take a look at the hour by hour temp recorded w/the National Weather
    Service for today. When I ran it was 12F with 17 MPH Winds. That's a fact
    Donnie. Would you say your statement "it hasn't been -4. Not even close" is
    consistent with the facts?

    Look, all that matters is what it feels like when we're outside...that's what's
    important. Why would you not count the WindChill when the issue is your
    body being outside and exposed? How can you not count the WindChill? Of
    course I am including the WindChill, as does every weather report...and it was
    -4

    http://www.srh.noaa.gov/data/obhistory/KNYC.html

  10. "Donovan Rebbechi" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Lanceandrew said:

    ig...you gotta start running man. sweat is not contingent on
    weather. it's a
    natural bodily function that's supposed to happen given a set of
    circumstances
    not unlike a BM. i ran 4 hard miles this morning.....-4 F.
    That's right
    DF, -4 !

    Bull (unless you moved without telling us). I've been outside running
    too, and
    it hasn't been -4. Not even close. It's less than 20, but more than
    10. Are
    you counting windchill or something ?

    I though he was running on the same road as me in the Catskill
    Mountains. We had 5 with a 15-20 mile/hr wind and plodded for 6. To lazy
    to calculate wind-chill factor.

    What's important is he did do out in the cold regardless of his ability
    to read a thermometer(it's part of the GED curriculum <g>😉 and deserves
    an "ata Lance" award.

    -Doug

  11. Lanceandrew said:

    It's now 3PM and 17 F, Feels like 4F w/windchill.

    feels-like, schmeels-like. Cold days always come with wind, but why exaggerate
    and quote "wind adjusted" temperatures without being explicit about it ? The
    temperature is 17F, not 4F.

    Quoted message said:

    Service for today. When I ran it was 12F with 17 MPH Winds. That's a fact
    Donnie. Would you say your statement "it hasn't been -4. Not even close" is
    consistent with the facts?

    Well, it was 16F above -4F.

    Quoted message said:

    Look, all that matters is what it feels like when we're outside...that's
    what's important.

    Feels OK to me. I came close to 70 last week. Quit being such a crybaby.

    Cheers,
    --
    Donovan Rebbechi
    http://pegasus.rutgers.edu/~elflord/

  12. Donovan Rebbechi said:


    Lanceandrew said:

    ig...you gotta start running man. sweat is not contingent on weather. it's a
    natural bodily function that's supposed to happen given a set of circumstances
    not unlike a BM. i ran 4 hard miles this morning.....-4 F. That's right
    DF, -4 !

    Bull (unless you moved without telling us). I've been outside running too, and
    it hasn't been -4. Not even close. It's less than 20, but more than 10. Are
    you counting windchill or something ?

    The dewpoint was -4 🙂

  13. Ramone Cila said:


    "Donovan Rebbechi" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Are you counting windchill or something ?

    We create our own windchill, don't we. Maybe he's really really fast and can
    turn a 20 degree days into -4 F :^)

    O.K., intersting thought. What about on a day like
    today running _into_ a steady 25mph wind w/30-40mph
    (as opposed to the 98mph up in Berthod) am I adding
    to the wind chill or is the wind negating my runner's
    wind chill?

    Just windy thoughts on a windy day...

  14. Doug Freese said:


    "Donovan Rebbechi" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Lanceandrew said:

    ig...you gotta start running man. sweat is not contingent on
    weather. it's a
    natural bodily function that's supposed to happen given a set of
    circumstances
    not unlike a BM. i ran 4 hard miles this morning.....-4 F.
    That's right
    DF, -4 !

    Bull (unless you moved without telling us). I've been outside running
    too, and
    it hasn't been -4. Not even close. It's less than 20, but more than
    10. Are
    you counting windchill or something ?

    I though he was running on the same road as me in the Catskill
    Mountains. We had 5 with a 15-20 mile/hr wind and plodded for 6. To lazy
    to calculate wind-chill factor.

    -13F.

    Quoted message said:


    What's important is he did do out in the cold regardless of his ability
    to read a thermometer(it's part of the GED curriculum <g>😉 and deserves
    an "ata Lance" award.

    -Doug

    What about me? it was 54F this afternoon, but with
    a steady 30mph wind the wind chill was about 45F.

    Course the danger here is not frost bite but being
    blown into oncomming traffic with gusts up 100 🙂

  15. Lanceandrew said:


    Quoted message said:

    Bull (unless you moved without telling us). I've been outside running too, and


    it hasn't been -4. Not even close.
    ____

    It's now 3PM and 17 F, Feels like 4F w/windchill. It's the high point of the
    day. Take a look at the hour by hour temp recorded w/the National Weather
    Service for today. When I ran it was 12F with 17 MPH Winds. That's a fact
    Donnie. Would you say your statement "it hasn't been -4. Not even close" is
    consistent with the facts?

    Look, all that matters is what it feels like when we're outside...that's what's
    important. Why would you not count the WindChill when the issue is your
    body being outside and exposed? How can you not count the WindChill? Of
    course I am including the WindChill, as does every weather report...and it was
    -4

    http://www.srh.noaa.gov/data/obhistory/KNYC.html

    Wind chill is really only an issue if the wind is
    against bare skin, or to some degree penetrates
    clothing. The effect of wind against bare skin is
    one of the factors in calculating it.

    12F w/17 winds is nippy, unless you're Dot and
    aren't happy unless it's 0F and below.

  16. Quoted message said:

    Wind chill is really only an issue if the wind is against bare skin


    -----

    ....i think you're forgetting the role w/c can also play on the running surface.
    i find the potentiality of coming across a patch of black ice increass w/the
    increase in windchill (just my experience)... that's actually my greatest
    concern in this type of weather...hit a patch of black ice.

    i gotta figrue thousands of runners annual suffer all sorts of injuries from
    hitting black ice and i bet some on this ng have a few stories of encounters
    w/black ice.

  17. Quoted message said:

    unless you're Dot and
    aren't happy unless it's 0F and below.

    That's in her bedroom, not outside.

  18. Quoted message said:

    i bet some on this ng have a few stories of encounters
    w/black ice.

    Here weeeeee go with the "I got a boo-boo" thread....

  19. Lanceandrew said:


    Quoted message said:

    Wind chill is really only an issue if the wind is against bare skin


    -----

    ...i think you're forgetting the role w/c can also play on the running surface.
    i find the potentiality of coming across a patch of black ice increass w/the
    increase in windchill (just my experience)... that's actually my greatest
    concern in this type of weather...hit a patch of black ice.
    i gotta figrue thousands of runners annual suffer all sorts of injuries from
    hitting black ice and i bet some on this ng have a few stories of encounters
    w/black ice.

    Apparently if it's cold enough to freeze and create
    ice, the wind won't make a lot of difference.

    The old wind chill charts were much colder and thought
    unrealistic for calculating it, since the wind speeds
    used were at 33 feet above ground. New wind chills are
    calulated at 5 feet above the ground, since this is
    the average height it impacts human skin, and are much
    warmer. This is from the NWS wind chill info:

    What is Wind Chill?

    Wind Chill is the term used to describe the rate of heat loss on the
    human body resulting from the combined effect of low temperature and
    wind. As winds increase, heat is carried away from the body at a faster
    rate, driving down both the skin temperature and eventually the internal
    body temperature. While exposure to low wind chills can be life
    threatening to both humans and animals alike, the only effect that wind
    chill has on inanimate objects, such as vehicles, is that it shortens
    the time that it takes the object to cool to the actual air temperature
    (it cannot cool the object down below that temperature). Water freezes
    at 32 degrees regardless of what the wind chill is.

  20. Lanceandrew said:
    Quoted message said:


    Quoted message said:

    Wind chill is really only an issue if the wind is against bare skin


    -----

    ...i think you're forgetting the role w/c can also play on the running surface.
    i find the potentiality of coming across a patch of black ice increass w/the
    increase in windchill (just my experience)... that's actually my greatest
    concern in this type of weather...hit a patch of black ice.
    i gotta figrue thousands of runners annual suffer all sorts of injuries from
    hitting black ice and i bet some on this ng have a few stories of encounters
    w/black ice.


    and that's why i don't run outside on the winter. the risk/benefit
    ratio is topsy-turvy.
    ....thehick

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.