General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Re: the perfect food

Started by Email address hidden · · Last activity · 6 posts · 512 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
7 October 2004
Last activity
10 October 2004
Original author
Email address hidden
Posts
6
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
512
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–6 of 6
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. There is no single thing. When scientists started looking around the
    world at food traditions they spotted food patterns, which in
    combination provided a sound nutrition. For example, the native
    american diet in many places where farming was done was based on
    beans, corn, varieties of squash and other fewer veggies and some
    meat. In some places such as the astecs in mexico meat was rare as a
    common food and used the corn/bean/squash combination almost
    exclusively. The rice, soy bean, veggie combination with little meat
    is an example in the e. asian cultural area. These provided less
    complete sources of proteins that when combined were complete and the
    veggies and other such provided vital vitamin/minerals when combined.
    Potatoes were part of such a combination in s. america and in the
    irish case. The potatoe is a fine source when all of it is used,
    excessive carbs or any other macro source only becomes a problem if
    too much of any one is used to the detriment of some vita/minerals and
    other nutritional factors such as antioxs etc.; and of course the real
    problem is eating too much such that calories eaten exceed the amount
    of energy required for a given level of physical activity.

    Quoted message said:

    I'm pretty much broke all the time and I try to get enough protein and
    carbs thru veggies and grains (and meat every once and a while). Well
    what I was wondering is -- is there a food out there that comes close
    to perfection nutritionally wise, something that you could take out in
    the woods and live on for a few months without problems? Also, are
    potatoes good or bad? I thought they were healthy but this low carb
    thing has really confused me.
    Thanks

    Gabe Elias

  2. The traditional combination thing was discussed a lot several decades ago,
    and good books and recipies came out. Search for "complete protein".
    Perhaps Adelle Davis?

    I think lentils are part of a traditional combination in India: lentils,
    kidney beans, etc, served with rice. Many of their dishes include yogurt or
    a yogurt drink is served with the meal. There are very spicy Indian dishes
    packaged in foil in boxes by Tasty Bite etc -- I take one of those and add
    plain lentils or whatever for a milder taste. The traditional spices in the
    dishes are helpful for digestion and I expect nutritionally too.

    Quoted message said:

    There is no single thing. When scientists started looking around the
    world at food traditions they spotted food patterns, which in
    combination provided a sound nutrition. For example, the native
    american diet in many places where farming was done was based on
    beans, corn, varieties of squash and other fewer veggies and some
    meat. In some places such as the astecs in mexico meat was rare as a
    common food and used the corn/bean/squash combination almost
    exclusively.

    Cheese is part of most traditinal Mexican dishes, may be needed to complete
    the protein.

    Quoted message said:

    The rice, soy bean, veggie combination with little meat
    is an example in the e. asian cultural area. These provided less
    complete sources of proteins that when combined were complete and the
    veggies and other such provided vital vitamin/minerals when combined.
    Potatoes were part of such a combination in s. america and in the
    irish case.

    What did they combine with the potatoes for complete protein?

    Skinny

  3. "Cheese is part of most traditinal Mexican dishes, may be needed to
    complete
    the protein."

    Cows were introduced by europeans, the combination of the protein of the
    beans and corn was complete.

    "What did they combine with the potatoes for complete protein?"

    Incans, corn - irish, grain; both very small amounts of animal protein
    when available.

  4. Quoted message said:

    "Cheese is part of most traditinal Mexican dishes, may be needed to
    complete the protein."

    Cows were introduced by europeans, the combination of the protein of the
    beans and corn was complete.

    Good point. But weren't there other domesticated animals, such as llamas,
    before the European cows? Goats?

    Skinny

  5. PS. I haven't compared prices much, but you might look at coconut milk as a
    source of fat. It's a sauce base for many traditional Asian dishes that
    combine rice, lentils, etc. Delicious, easy to cook with, comes in cans or
    powdered. Perhaps cheaper in Asian import shops than supermarkets.

    I use it as a soup base too. Thin like chicken broth or with pureed veg for
    'cream of' soups. Take cheap vegetable parts such as stalks of broccoli or
    asparagus and puree them in coconut milk and microwave, makes a wonderful
    quick soup.

    Or for quick drink combine half coconut milk with half V8 and add water to
    thin to taste, microwave.

    There used to be some health issues about what kind of fat is in coconut
    milk -- but lately some 'coconut oil' supplements have come out, claiming
    health benefits too.

    Skinny
    ----------------

    Skinny said:

    The traditional combination thing was discussed a lot several decades


    ago,

    Quoted message said:

    and good books and recipies came out. Search for "complete protein".
    Perhaps Adelle Davis?

    I think lentils are part of a traditional combination in India: lentils,
    kidney beans, etc, served with rice. Many of their dishes include yogurt


    or

    Quoted message said:

    a yogurt drink is served with the meal. There are very spicy Indian


    dishes

    Quoted message said:

    packaged in foil in boxes by Tasty Bite etc -- I take one of those and


    add

    Quoted message said:

    plain lentils or whatever for a milder taste. The traditional spices in


    the

    Quoted message said:

    dishes are helpful for digestion and I expect nutritionally too.

  6. Quoted message said:

    "Cheese is part of most traditinal Mexican dishes, may be needed to
    complete
    the protein."

    Cows were introduced by europeans, the combination of the protein of the
    beans and corn was complete.

    "What did they combine with the potatoes for complete protein?"

    Incans, corn - irish, grain; both very small amounts of animal protein
    when available.

    Protein completing is an hoax
    Legumes proteins and grains protein are complete by themselves
    There's no need to combine grains with legumes
    There's no need to complete or combine anything
    Although the amount of some amino acids may be low on some foods they're
    still adequate to human nutrition
    2500 calories of only beans provide all the essential amino acids one
    need without needing to complement with grains or other foods:

    -----------------------------------------------------------
    (1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
    RDA RDA BEANS BEANS
    Amino Acid mg/kg mg/70kg mg/100g mg/2000kcal %RDA
    Isoleucine 10 700 363 5299 757%
    Leucine 14 980 656 9577 977%
    Lysine 12 840 564 8234 980%
    Methionine 13 910 124 1810 199% <--
    Phenylalanine 14 980 444 6482 661%
    Threonine 7 490 346 5051 1031%
    Tryptophan 3.5 245 97 1416 578%
    Valine 10 700 430 6277 897%

    What these results show is that eating nothing but beans would result in
    obtaining a large excess of
    every essential amino acid. In spite of the fact that beans are
    _relatively_ low in methionine,
    they are not _absolutely_ low in methione. Eating nothing but beans
    would still provide 2 times the
    RDA of methionine.
    ------------------------------------------------------------------

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.