I've been reading the Paula bashing with interest. Normally I can't
weigh in on the television food personalities because I haven't seen
enough of them to tell them apart. I think they're ALL horrible and
click right past. I used to say that the only one I recognized was
Julia Child. That changed with Paula Deen.
I don't know why I caught the show, but I immediately adored her as an
entertainer. I don't know what she's like off-air, but her on-air
persona is great. The recipes struck me as a tad on the salty fattening
side, but I like those now and then, and I like learning about things I
don't ordinarily make. I like good home cooking and didn't grow up in a
good home cooking house. This was catch-up.
If I were watching the show for pure instruction, I'd find it lacking as
she doesn't give enough close-up and background information for me to
make the dishes myself. You clearly need the accompanying cookbook. I
saw that right away. But as entertainment? She's great. I even recall
remarking to Jim, "I don't normally like cooking shows, but this lady is
great entertainer.
I adore the accent. As I grew up in Miami, I don't have it myself, but
I love the American Southern accent. That's what a lot of people in the
U.S. sound like! A good Southern accent has a musicality all its own.
I've never seen Oprah straight through. (There's an exception. An
online acquaintance was on the show and told everyone he knew to watch
it that day.) I don't care for the daytime t.v. format. I believe
Oprah has done some great things. That doesn't mean I have to watch her
do them.
I'd say Paula Deen was a better performer than Oprah. It's a cool thing
to watch salesmanship as performance art. Deen comes across with so
much upbeat enthusiasm that I just want to watch her all day. It's rare
to find someone whose personality comes through the t.v. like that. She
makes it look like she's talking to me personally. I'm well aware that
she doesn't know me from Adam's off ox, but pretending is part of the fun.
Our cable service got cut so I'm not getting the food network anymore,
but I'll still speak up in defense of Paula!
--Lia