"Monique Y. Mudama" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Quoted message said:On 2004-08-18, Dan Volker penned:
Quoted message said:
This is not a slam by Dan Volker against cycling...Hell, mountain biking
is
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:presently my favorite sport.
What it is, is an indictment of our culture. Cultural norms lead
athletes
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:in highschool, to go out for Football if they have the ability. If they
"could" be good at football in college, the rewards for doing well in
this
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:sport far outweigh any sociological benefit they could receive through
cycling instead. A major sport like Football would mean being on the
fast
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:track to a better social existence, it would mean having the cutest
girls in
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:school far more interested in you, it would mean local companies
offering
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:you easy and good paying summer jobs, and it could mean high paying
scholarships if you are good enough to play college ball. This is a
cultural
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:issue, and one very deeply ingrained in the Western New York area---I
grew
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:up in Eden, and believe me, the only kids riding bikes competitively
then,
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:were the ones who could not make Football or one of the other major
sports.
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:What sports you participated in while in Highschool and College will
have a
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:lot to do with shaping the way you relate to people the rest of your
life...and this gets us back on track in the discussion about JD.
If you did not grow up in the Buffalo area, maybe you should ask some
local
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:kids what they think about what sports they would most like to star at.
If
Quoted message said:Quoted message said:they are a gifted athlete, it will most likely be one of the major team
sports.
So what you're saying is, mainstream people with mainstream motivations
would
Quoted message said:choose a high-profile sport if given the choice.
That's nice.
A major sport like football would mean being on the fast track to
permanent
Quoted message said:injury, blown-out knees, back, and brain. Brilliant. All of those are
distinct possibilities *before* you ever have a chance to hit the pros.
Given
Quoted message said:the extreme punishment football deals out and the extremely small chance
of
Quoted message said:making it to the big time, the only folks who would actually pin their
hopes on
Quoted message said:football are those who have no other expectation of success. Football is
live-action chess played with the bodies of those who didn't have the hope
of
Quoted message said:a less dangerous occupation.
Er, I think I got distracted. What I meant to say was, screw your
cultural
Quoted message said:norms. Just because you grew up thinking that football was hot [censored]
doesn't
Quoted message said:mean everyone else did.
They are not "my" norms. They belong to American culture. You can ridicule
them for the obvious stupidities, but they are still governing for more like
98% of the population, compared to cycling's less than 2% ( just pulled the
numbers out of thin air, but I imagine they are not far off).
Quoted message said:
Also, wtf does your growing up in Buffalo have to do with JD? Did JD grow
up
Quoted message said:in Buffalo? Or was that a round-about way of excusing your own prejudices
by
Quoted message said:explaining that you share them with the rest of NY?
This was to Corvus, who now lives in Buffalo. His comments did not sound
like they were from someone who had grown up in Buffalo, thus the question.
Quoted message said:
Jeesh. I can't believe that you've gotten my back up enough that I'm
practically defending JD.
(Hint: there are plenty of gifted athletes that don't choose football.
There
Quoted message said:are plenty of athletes whose gifts aren't suited to football. Maybe you
should turn on the TV and check out some of the Olympic competition. Are
you
Quoted message said:saying they're all just failed football players? I bet they're crying all
the
Quoted message said:way to the podium.)
Actually I was talking about the larger team sports, and Football was just
the poster child for the discussion. Working class America will watch
football or baseball and glorify the athletes--these same working class
Americans will look at us on our bikes and have something for us, closer to
contempt. Again, this is the population at large, and not my attitude or
behavior.
As it relates to JD, if he could not play a major sport well enough to
letter in Highschool or college, it would explain alot about his
disfunctional personality here. Like I said, he looks more like a "Big Dog"
from the chess club :-)
If he is careful about the groups he interacts in, maybe he can keep talking
the way he does here.
As to the military angle, if he talked like this in bars with Navy, Marines
or Army guys, its pretty likely he'd have gotten his ass kicked regularly,
and at the very least, he would have been ( would still be) visiting the
brig on a regular basis. More likely, if he does hang out with other
military types, he talks differently than he does on AMB.
Dan V
Quoted message said:
Grrr!
--
monique
"Get a bicycle. You will not regret it, if you live."
-- Mark Twain