On Mon 28 Nov 2005 07:36:20p, Thus Spake Zarathustra, or was it Myraide?
Quoted message said:
Peter Aitken said:
"Myraide" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > over about a cup of ice in martini shaker: > > four oz of prime citrus vodka, like absolut or grey goose > one to two oz cointreau > *POM* pomegranate juice, to fill shaker > > makes two martinis, pour into chilled martini glasses and add: > > squeeze of lime or lemon > pomegranate fruit for bottom of glass (optional decor) > > this is the best martini i have ever had! myraide >
No matter how good, this is NOT A MARTINI! Putting some weird concoction in a martini glass does not make it a martini. A martini is gin and vermouth.
uh oh....... i better ask oprah and rachel ray about this, then...... 🙂 myraide
Well, someone needs to set them straight. It might as well be you. :-)
what would this drink be called then? i mean there are all different kinds of wine, why can't there be different kinds of martinis? myraide
Quoted message said:
-- Wayne Boatwright *¿* _____________________________________________
On Mon 28 Nov 2005 07:36:20p, Thus Spake Zarathustra, or was it Myraide?
Quoted message said:
Peter Aitken wrote: > "Myraide" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... >> over about a cup of ice in martini shaker: >> >> four oz of prime citrus vodka, like absolut or grey goose >> one to two oz cointreau >> *POM* pomegranate juice, to fill shaker >> >> makes two martinis, pour into chilled martini glasses and add: >> >> squeeze of lime or lemon >> pomegranate fruit for bottom of glass (optional decor) >> >> this is the best martini i have ever had! myraide >> > > No matter how good, this is NOT A MARTINI! Putting some weird > concoction in a martini glass does not make it a martini. A > martini is gin and vermouth.
uh oh....... i better ask oprah and rachel ray about this, then...... 🙂 myraide
Well, someone needs to set them straight. It might as well be you. :-)
what would this drink be called then? i mean there are all different kinds of wine, why can't there be different kinds of martinis? myraide
There are different kinds of wine because there are different grape varieties made into wine. This "martini" is part of the "new millenium yuppie" syndrome. Think Appletini's. Adding fruit juice to vodka does not a martini make, I don't care what Oprah and Rachel Ray say. I like vodka and cranberry juice; it doesn't make it a cranberry martini.
A Pomegranate cocktail would be my best guess without coming up with a quirky name for it. What's often served as a "chocolate martini" was until rather recently called a "chocolate shot" while a "sour apple martini" was an "apple", "sour apple" or "apple jolly rancher" shot, I imagine there are others but I'm not entirely up on the "martini" menus. The glass something is served in doesn't define what it is. In the heyday of cocktail culture what we now call a martini glass was typically called a cocktail glass.
Jessica
Still miffed about the bartender who asked what kind of vodka I wanted in my Beefeater gimlet.
No matter how good, this is NOT A MARTINI! Putting some weird concoction in a martini glass does not make it a martini. A martini is gin and vermouth.
In some places-- lots of bars in the UK-- ordering a "martini" will get you a glass of vermouth, period.
I like the name "fauxtini" for those vodka drinks. Pomegranate really is a spectacular cocktail mixer. I like to mix some with champagne (I use Knudsen's concentrate rather than Pom for better color with less dilution) and add a few fresh pomegranate seeds for a garnish. Also same but with ginger ale for a nonalcoholic alternative.
On Mon 28 Nov 2005 08:13:04p, Thus Spake Zarathustra, or was it Myraide?
Quoted message said:
Wayne Boatwright said:
On Mon 28 Nov 2005 07:36:20p, Thus Spake Zarathustra, or was it Myraide?
Quoted message said:
Peter Aitken wrote: > "Myraide" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > over about a cup of ice in martini shaker: > > > > four oz of prime citrus vodka, like absolut or grey goose > > one to two oz cointreau > > *POM* pomegranate juice, to fill shaker > > > > makes two martinis, pour into chilled martini glasses and add: > > > > squeeze of lime or lemon > > pomegranate fruit for bottom of glass (optional decor) > > > > this is the best martini i have ever had! myraide > > > > No matter how good, this is NOT A MARTINI! Putting some weird > concoction in a martini glass does not make it a martini. A martini
is
Quoted message said:
Quoted message said:
Quoted message said:
> gin and vermouth.
uh oh....... i better ask oprah and rachel ray about this, then...... 🙂 myraide
Well, someone needs to set them straight. It might as well be you. :-)
what would this drink be called then? i mean there are all different kinds of wine, why can't there be different kinds of martinis? myraide
Take a look at any bar book and you'll see that there are hundreds of unique names to define drinks that were once new inventions. If bartenders and drink promoters of those generations had been as stupid as those of the current, they'd all have been called martinis, or mabe manhattans. The best they seem to be able to do today is capitalize on the glass that a real martini is served in. What a lot of [censored]!
-- Wayne Boatwright *¿* _____________________________________________
Yup. These days, restaurants and bars use "martini" in the name of any drink served in a martini glass. It's not correct, but not worth getting your panties bunched up, either.
I recently had a "crushed kumquat martini" at The Tamarind Tree, a fine Vietnamese restaurant here in Seattle. Exquisitely tasty, even if it's not the traditional formula. So far, the best real martini that I've found in Seattle was served at the Sand Point Grill.
what would this drink be called then? i mean there are all different kinds of wine, why can't there be different kinds of martinis? myraide
Just another frou frou drink that probably tastes good, but it surely isn't a martini. How can you justify calling it a martini when nothing in it has anything to do with a classic martini? Don't buy into "dumbing" down.. you end up with Sandra Lee if you go too far.
what would this drink be called then? i mean there are all different kinds of wine, why can't there be different kinds of martinis? myraide
Just another frou frou drink that probably tastes good, but it surely isn't a martini. How can you justify calling it a martini when nothing in it has anything to do with a classic martini? Don't buy into "dumbing" down.. you end up with Sandra Lee if you go too far.
Yup. These days, restaurants and bars use "martini" in the name of any drink served in a martini glass. It's not correct, but not worth getting your panties bunched up, either.
Somebody has to stand up for the integrity of the martini; don't bastardize a classic American cultural icon. -L.
On Tue 29 Nov 2005 12:47:08a, Thus Spake Zarathustra, or was it -L.?
Quoted message said:
Julian Vrieslander said:
In article <[email hidden]>,
Wayne Boatwright said:
Interesting drink. NOT a martini.
Yup. These days, restaurants and bars use "martini" in the name of any drink served in a martini glass. It's not correct, but not worth getting your panties bunched up, either.
Somebody has to stand up for the integrity of the martini; don't bastardize a classic American cultural icon. -L.
Exactly!
-- Wayne Boatwright *¿* _____________________________________________
I'm more interested in words and word origins and the way word meanings change over time than I am in mixed drinks. I don't like corrupting the meaning of martini either. Now I'm wondering if changing it to mean any mixed drink came from advertisers and liquor salespeople in the U.S. or if it is an import from overseas. Conjecture: Maybe people in Asia and Europe saw American movies where the tourists and servicemen drank martinis, and not knowing exactly what was meant, spun off with the definition.