Assuming
Quoted post said:Originally Posted by dabac
Please realize that we are posting from two different perspectives.
You are assuming that disassembly is possible for the OP, and I'm providing an option if it's not.
And since we're assuming different conditions and limitations, our suggestions don't compete.
They are what's called "mutually exclusive".
And there is no "best" in a comparison between two mutually exclusive options. One could argue that there isn't even a valid basis for comparison.
Assuming? The only assumption is if the OP gave us the correct model of pedal, if they did then I've assumed nothing because they can be disassembled. Se my early You Tube post
Quoted post said:Originally Posted by dhk2
Speedplay pedals seem to have good weather-resistance, appearing totally sealed from the outside. Plus, they are lubed easily with a mini grease gun just by removing a grease port screw on the end of the spindle. The factory recommends lubing every 2000 miles, but in harsh conditions you could do it more often. I've had mine (the Zero SS version) for 10 years and 38K miles now, and they are still spinning smoothly.
Note however that our definitions of winter weather conditions and acceptable riding weather may differ.
I agree with this. I can attest to the importance of having the ability to grease the pedals as easily as SpeedPlay makes it. I have a set of Suntour Superbe hubs with the grease ports, and twice a year since 1984 I put in new grease and the old would ooze out, those hubs were exposed to water and yet are still good after over 160,000 miles. I can only assume that with my SpeedPlay pedals the bearings should last a long time too if I keep the grease clean.