"Patrick Herring" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
"]news:[email hidden]...
Quoted message said:"Pete White" <[email hidden]> wrote: ...
| Cool! I understood the "Earendel" bit being a little-bit of of a
Tolkien
Quoted message said:| buff. On the LOTR I prefer book to film, although I thought the Moria sequence (from the
| shutting of the West Gate to the fight on the Bridge)
was
Quoted message said:| FANTASTIC! I don't hold with the way Faramir has been treated, and
Elves
Quoted message said:| at Helms Deep either.
Several agreements with the above, particularly the shield-surfing bit.
Personally I waiting for the full sequence of extended DVDs before worrying about disagreeing with
the film, especially as I could never have done what PJ has.
ObOnTopic: there weren't any bikes in it, they hadn't been invented yet.
--
Patrick Herring, Sheffield, UK anweald.co.ukanweald.co.ukOpen ↗
Eala Earendel engla beorhtast ofer middangeard monnum sended.
Sorry I haven't kept up with this thread, me mum is hogging the phone line a lot lately and I
haven't been able to get on line...
PJ has done a average job at keeping the story understandable, but the errors outweigh the good
bits. Why alter Faramir? Why have the bit in TTT where Aragorn goes 'missing'? And why is Arwen
given such a big part?
Rant over, back to the bike...
Pete White