rec.bicycles.rides · Public discussion

Panniers and Rack

Started by Guy Anderson, Sr. · · Last activity · 12 posts · 1,186 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
rec.bicycles.rides
Published
13 February 2008
Last activity
22 March 2008
Original author
Guy Anderson, Sr.
Posts
12
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,186
Views / 30 days
0
Topics

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–12 of 12
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I need to set up my mountain bike for light touring, and need advice,
    opinions and suggestions about rear racks and bags. So far the Topeak
    outfit looks pretty good, and I'd welcome any opinions re it:

    http://www.topeak.com/t8/products/bags/mtxtrunkbagdxp.php

    Thanks!

  2. Racks:

    http://www.tubus.com/index/lang/en/rubrik/Rear%20Carriers/

    Panniers:

    http://www.ortlieb.de/_browse.php?lang=en&tfile=radtasche

    these are very good

    Guy Anderson said:

    I need to set up my mountain bike for light touring, and need advice,
    opinions and suggestions about rear racks and bags. So far the Topeak
    outfit looks pretty good, and I'd welcome any opinions re it:

    http://www.topeak.com/t8/products/bags/mtxtrunkbagdxp.php

    Thanks!

  3. This page (http://www.biketouringtips.com/searchTips.html?
    country=&state=&place=&id=Bike%20Touring%20Equipment&subtopic=17.2)
    lists 14 links to information about racks and panniers. Several of
    them will be of interest to you.

    Ray

  4. You need four point fixation for panniers. i.e. if you have a FS mtb
    don't get one of these seatpost things with a rack with sidelegs as
    they'll break. A friend did and they did, if you follow me.

    Ortlieb bags are great EXCEPT that being only two compartments, it is
    a pain to find anything. After 10 years using them on multiple tours,
    I'm going back to multicompartment all-in-one bag where I can find
    things. I will need my stuff in plastic bags, but it's preferable to
    emptying everything onto the road!!

  5. I'd strongly suggest Tubus or Bruce Gordon for the rack. They are
    made of hollow chromoly steel and are stronger as well as lighter than
    solid aluminum.

    From my experience an Ortlieb bag is perfect. If you need more
    organization consider putting things into mesh organizer bags. The
    main drawback is that you really cannot put something inside that is
    wet or even damp. Everything inside get wet. But, they keep the
    water out as long as they are closed properly. The attachment system
    works very well and is secure as long as you get it attached correctly
    in the first place.

    I also use Jannd bags. They are strong, but mine are awkward to put
    on or take off. But they are not for keeping things dry in a long or
    heavy rain. So typically I have Jannd bags on the back, Ortleib on
    the front and my wife carries Ortleib on the back. The Jannd bags
    take the wet stuff and the stuff than can get wet. One of the front
    Ortleib bags on the front gets my sleeping bag and a few other
    things.

    Tom

    On Feb 13, 2:07�pm, "Guy Anderson, Sr." <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    I need to set up my mountain bike for light touring, and need advice,
    opinions and suggestions about rear racks and bags. �So far the Topeak
    outfit looks pretty good, and I'd welcome any opinions re it:

    http://www.topeak.com/t8/products/bags/mtxtrunkbagdxp.php

    Thanks!

  6. "Guy Anderson, Sr." <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    I need to set up my mountain bike for light touring, and need advice,
    opinions and suggestions about rear racks and bags. So far the Topeak
    outfit looks pretty good, and I'd welcome any opinions re it:

    http://www.topeak.com/t8/products/bags/mtxtrunkbagdxp.php

    Guy, for light touring the Performance bags and racks work very well. There
    are better things available but they are much more expensive and are
    intended for round the world tours.

  7. On Thu, 28 Feb 2008 17:01:20 -0800, "Tom Kunich" <cyclintom@yahoo.

    com said:

    Guy, for light touring the Performance bags and racks work very well. There
    are better things available but they are much more expensive and are
    intended for round the world tours.

    Thanks, Tom. AMAOF, I have already mounted up the Performance rack
    with el cheapo Nashbar Daytrecker bags. This rig will be fine for my
    purposes.

  8. On Feb 29, 1:26 am, "Guy Anderson, Sr." <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    On Thu, 28 Feb 2008 17:01:20 -0800, "Tom Kunich" <cyclintom@yahoo.

    com said:

    Guy, for light touring the Performance bags and racks work very well. There
    are better things available but they are much more expensive and are
    intended for round the world tours.

    Thanks, Tom. AMAOF, I have already mounted up the Performance rack
    with el cheapo Nashbar Daytrecker bags. This rig will be fine for my
    purposes.

    Nashbar has this neat thing that works as both a backpack and a
    pannier. I rode 250 miles in 4 days with one on only the left side. I
    packed light though.
    It took me a couple of hours to get used to weight being mostly on the
    left side. I was planning to ride completely on my own and I wanted to
    lock the bike and carry everything else into a store if necessary.

  9. Does anybody make a practical, functional hard shell "trunk" that can stay
    mounted to a bike rack at all times, rather than having to be removed every
    time you leave the bike?

  10. Papa Tom said:

    Does anybody make a practical, functional hard shell "trunk" that can stay
    mounted to a bike rack at all times, rather than having to be removed every
    time you leave the bike?


    A two minute google turned up several, such as:
    http://www.campingworld.com/browse/skus/index.cfm?skunum=37760

  11. Thanks, Guy. I guess what I SHOULD have asked was "Has anybody had good or
    bad experiences with any of the hard shell trunks on the market?"

    I realize that just about anything anyone can think of is already available
    on the Internet ad nauseum. However, there's nothing like a first-hand tip
    from a current user. For example, I guess my first questions to a person
    who has used the trunk you linked me to would be "What has the manufacturer
    done to make sure the whole trunk can't be removed from the luggage rack
    with a screwdriver?" and "Does the height of the trunk interfere with
    mounting or dismounting the bike?"

    That said, does anybody have any input?

  12. Papa Tom said:


    I realize that just about anything anyone can think of is already available
    on the Internet ad nauseum. However, there's nothing like a first-hand tip
    from a current user.

    I use a BIG Chrome (The Kremlin) messenger bag for commuting. <G>

    Quoted message said:

    For example, I guess my first questions to a person
    who has used the trunk you linked me to would be "What has the manufacturer
    done to make sure the whole trunk can't be removed from the luggage rack
    with a screwdriver?" and "Does the height of the trunk interfere with
    mounting or dismounting the bike?"

    That said, does anybody have any input?

    I do!

    Hardshell cases are great on motorcycles, because motorcycles are
    heavy. Somebody who really wanted into a bicycle rack trunk could
    either:

    1.) Steal the whole bike .

    -- or --

    2.) Cut it right off of the soft aluminum rack. How would I do that?
    Cable cutters would go through the rack rails much faster than they
    would cut a lock. If I saw you parking daily and had time to plan, a
    cordless saw or drills, as made by DeWalt, Porter Cable, Milwaukee,
    etc... and available at pawn shops everywhere, cheap! Would have me
    in your hardshell trunk in seconds.

    After all, if it looks secure, there's something inside worth
    stealing!

    The best anti-theft rack trunks come with shoulder straps, or you
    bring the bike inside.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.