General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Need help with Kitchen Remodel Project

Started by Shivani · · Last activity · 30 posts · 1,791 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
26 June 2005
Last activity
29 June 2005
Original author
Shivani
Posts
30
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,791
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 30
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. We plan to remodle our kitchen. I need some advise. Here's what needs
    to be done.

    Kitchen:
    6 * 12 feet kitchen needs remodeling.

    1. Demolish the existing kitchen (cabinets etc)
    2. Remove the current vinyl floor and install ceramic tiles
    3. Install new appliances (all electric)
    4. One of the kitchen walls needs a 4 * 4 feet hole to open it up. The
    job includes making this hole and finishing the wall with plaster.
    5. One pantry and one coat closet needs to be knocked off to make space
    for the cabinets and refrigerator.
    6. This project may need minor electric and plumbing work in the
    kitchen
    7. The 1300 square feet condo needs crown molding
    8. The bathroom door needs to be changed such that it opens on the
    outside (towards the room) instead of inside (towards the bathroom)
    9. The vanity, sink in one of the bathrooms need to be lifted 6 inches.

    10. The medicine closet in both bathrooms need to be replaced
    11. Master bedroom wardrobe door needs to be replaced with a glass
    door.
    12. The door for the washer dryer closet needs to be replaced with a
    sliding door
    13. Minor - change the locks of 3 doors.

    I will pay for the materials. Home depot will do the granite counter
    top installation.

    The cabinets will cost 5-6k, counter top with island, back splash and
    installation will cost about 4k, appliances 2k, floor 500$.

    Question:
    - How much should I pay for labor?
    The on sight supretendent in my complex is a handy man and knows the
    condo complex better than anyone. He is asking for 10k flat. He'll do
    everything. He'll even get the electrician and pay him. If something
    goes wrong, he'll be there.

    Is 10k$ reasonable? It sounds a lot to me.

    Is there anywhere I can cut the cost? material or labor?

    I asked other contractors to give quotes and some said 10k, 6k, too
    small a job and what not. No one except for my supretendent has done a
    on sight quote.

    Any advise? suggestions?

  2. Shivani said:

    We plan to remodle our kitchen. I need some advise. Here's what needs
    to be done.

    <snip>

    Ask around to other contractors and get additional on-site quotes. I
    would not contract with anyone who did not inspect the job first,
    up-close and personal. Contracting with the local handyman is
    dangerous - too much potential to mess up a relationship which you have
    to maintain.

    -L.

  3. $10,000 sounds reasonable for all that labor. I've heard that up to 70%
    of a remodel can be labor costs. Is the handyman qualified to do all
    this work? Has he done kitchen remodeling before? There's a lot of
    exact planning involved in redoing a kitchen, make sure he knows what
    he's doing .

  4. Ask this question over at: alt.home.repair

    WARNING: Don't let Home Depot install anything!

  5. "-L." <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Shivani said:

    We plan to remodle our kitchen. I need some advise. Here's what needs
    to be done.

    <snip>

    Ask around to other contractors and get additional on-site quotes. I
    would not contract with anyone who did not inspect the job first,
    up-close and personal. Contracting with the local handyman is
    dangerous - too much potential to mess up a relationship which you have
    to maintain.

    -L.


    I agree completely with this assessment. No one could provide an accurate
    quote without inspecting the property and discussing the details of the job.
    And the Handyman may not be so "handy" if the OP perceives any problems with
    the job. This includes the speed at which it's done, since Handyman
    obviously already has a job which would take precedent in his mind. Also,
    is he a licensed/bonded contractor or just a handy guy employed by the condo
    association to fix the occasional leak, patch holes in walls, replace a
    water heater?

    Jill

  6. "-L." <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Shivani said:

    We plan to remodle our kitchen. I need some advise. Here's what needs
    to be done.

    <snip>

    Ask around to other contractors and get additional on-site quotes. I
    would not contract with anyone who did not inspect the job first,
    up-close and personal. Contracting with the local handyman is
    dangerous - too much potential to mess up a relationship which you have
    to maintain.

    -L.


    I agree completely with this assessment. No one could provide an accurate
    quote without inspecting the property and discussing the details of the job.
    And the Handyman may not be so "handy" if the OP perceives any problems with
    the job. This includes the speed at which it's done, since Handyman
    obviously already has a job which would take precedent in his mind. Also,
    is he a licensed/bonded contractor or just a handy guy employed by the condo
    association to fix the occasional leak, patch holes in walls, replace a
    water heater?

    Jill

  7. Did you buy your cabinets from Home Depot too? Why aren't you getting
    a quote from one of their installers?

    Where you're located will have an impact on labor costs too.

    ````````````````````````

    Shivani said:

    We plan to remodle our kitchen. I need some advise. Here's what needs
    to be done.

    Kitchen:
    6 * 12 feet kitchen needs remodeling.

    1. Demolish the existing kitchen (cabinets etc)
    2. Remove the current vinyl floor and install ceramic tiles
    3. Install new appliances (all electric)
    4. One of the kitchen walls needs a 4 * 4 feet hole to open it up. The
    job includes making this hole and finishing the wall with plaster.
    5. One pantry and one coat closet needs to be knocked off to make space
    for the cabinets and refrigerator.
    6. This project may need minor electric and plumbing work in the
    kitchen
    7. The 1300 square feet condo needs crown molding
    8. The bathroom door needs to be changed such that it opens on the
    outside (towards the room) instead of inside (towards the bathroom)
    9. The vanity, sink in one of the bathrooms need to be lifted 6 inches.

    10. The medicine closet in both bathrooms need to be replaced
    11. Master bedroom wardrobe door needs to be replaced with a glass
    door.
    12. The door for the washer dryer closet needs to be replaced with a
    sliding door
    13. Minor - change the locks of 3 doors.

    I will pay for the materials. Home depot will do the granite counter
    top installation.

    The cabinets will cost 5-6k, counter top with island, back splash and
    installation will cost about 4k, appliances 2k, floor 500$.

    Question:
    - How much should I pay for labor?
    The on sight supretendent in my complex is a handy man and knows the
    condo complex better than anyone. He is asking for 10k flat. He'll do
    everything. He'll even get the electrician and pay him. If something
    goes wrong, he'll be there.

    Is 10k$ reasonable? It sounds a lot to me.

    Is there anywhere I can cut the cost? material or labor?

    I asked other contractors to give quotes and some said 10k, 6k, too
    small a job and what not. No one except for my supretendent has done a
    on sight quote.

    Any advise? suggestions?

  8. jmcquown said:


    "-L." <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Shivani said:

    We plan to remodle our kitchen. I need some advise. Here's what needs
    to be done.

    <snip>

    Ask around to other contractors and get additional on-site quotes. I
    would not contract with anyone who did not inspect the job first,
    up-close and personal. Contracting with the local handyman is
    dangerous - too much potential to mess up a relationship which you have
    to maintain.

    -L.


    I agree completely with this assessment. No one could provide an accurate
    quote without inspecting the property and discussing the details of the job.
    And the Handyman may not be so "handy" if the OP perceives any problems with
    the job. This includes the speed at which it's done, since Handyman
    obviously already has a job which would take precedent in his mind. Also,
    is he a licensed/bonded contractor or just a handy guy employed by the condo
    association to fix the occasional leak, patch holes in walls, replace a
    water heater?


    Condos usually have several hoops that owners need to jump through,
    not the least of which is proof of insurance by the contractor.

  9. People have told me that Home Depot does not do a good job in
    insalling. That discouraged me from getting a quote from HOme depot.
    Just for the sake of comparing, I asked Home Depot to get a quote. 7
    days later, I called them to see what happend and they said "We don't
    know what happened. We give the contract to a installation company and
    they din't go out to your home to see the sight". They are stupid
    people.

  10. He has done kitchens before in the same complex. He's currently
    remodling one kitchen in the same complex. I've not seen it but i think
    i'll go and check out his work. I don't know if he has a license. I'll
    check with him.

  11. On Sun 26 Jun 2005 12:24:02p, Shivani wrote in rec.food.cooking:

    Quoted message said:

    People have told me that Home Depot does not do a good job in
    insalling. That discouraged me from getting a quote from HOme depot.
    Just for the sake of comparing, I asked Home Depot to get a quote. 7
    days later, I called them to see what happend and they said "We don't
    know what happened. We give the contract to a installation company and
    they din't go out to your home to see the sight". They are stupid
    people.

    I suppose that has more to do with which city and which HD store you deal
    with. While we didn't have HD install a kitchen, we did purchase cabinets
    and installation from them to do a rather elaborate laundry room of cabinets
    (base and overhead). They did a superb job.

    --
    Wayne Boatwright *¿*
    ____________________________________________

    Give me a smart idiot over a stupid genius any day.
    Sam Goldwyn, 1882-1974

    ---
    avast! Antivirus: Outbound message clean.
    Virus Database (VPS): 0525-5, 06/25/2005
    Tested on: 6/26/2005 12:28:27 PM
    avast! - copyright (c) 1988-2005 ALWIL Software.
    http://www.avast.com

  12. I am in Brookline (Boston)

  13. "sf" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    jmcquown said:


    "-L." <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Shivani wrote:
    > We plan to remodle our kitchen. I need some advise. Here's what


    needs

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    > to be done.

    <snip>

    Ask around to other contractors and get additional on-site quotes.


    I

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    would not contract with anyone who did not inspect the job first,
    up-close and personal. Contracting with the local handyman is
    dangerous - too much potential to mess up a relationship which you


    have

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    to maintain.

    -L.


    I agree completely with this assessment. No one could provide an


    accurate

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    quote without inspecting the property and discussing the details of the


    job.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    And the Handyman may not be so "handy" if the OP perceives any problems


    with

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    the job. This includes the speed at which it's done, since Handyman
    obviously already has a job which would take precedent in his mind.


    Also,

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    is he a licensed/bonded contractor or just a handy guy employed by the


    condo

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    association to fix the occasional leak, patch holes in walls, replace a
    water heater?


    Condos usually have several hoops that owners need to jump through,
    not the least of which is proof of insurance by the contractor.

    My point exactly and I would hope so! Hiring the guy just because he does
    routine maintenance for the condo doesn't mean he's licensed and bonded to
    be able to correct any problems, particularly if the job involves altering
    the structure to the point of load-bearing walls being affected.

    I love our apartment maintenenance guy. He's a man of few words, just comes
    in promptly and repairs whatever. If he can't do it, they have people he
    can call (like when the carpets needed replacing after a water heater leak)
    or when I needed a chimney sweep because a #$!%@! squirrel built a nest in
    the chimney cap and my apartment filled up with smoke. But I wouldn't hire
    the guy to gut my kitchen.

    Jill

  14. Good point. What if he is a licensed contractor? What if he shows me
    the kitchens he's renovated in the building?

  15. Good point. What if he is a licensed contractor? What if he shows me
    the kitchens he's renovated in the building?

  16. Good point. What if he is a licensed contractor? What if he shows me
    the kitchens he's renovated in the building?

  17. On Sun 26 Jun 2005 01:38:34p, Shivani wrote in rec.food.cooking:

    Quoted message said:

    I am in Brookline (Boston)

    When we used them we lived in NE Ohio near Cleveland.

    --
    Wayne Boatwright *¿*
    ____________________________________________

    Give me a smart idiot over a stupid genius any day.
    Sam Goldwyn, 1882-1974

    ---
    avast! Antivirus: Outbound message clean.
    Virus Database (VPS): 0525-5, 06/25/2005
    Tested on: 6/26/2005 2:22:31 PM
    avast! - copyright (c) 1988-2005 ALWIL Software.
    http://www.avast.com

  18. "Shivani" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Good point. What if he is a licensed contractor? What if he shows me
    the kitchens he's renovated in the building?

    Then it's up to you to decide if you think the bid is fair (compared to any
    other ON SITE bids you get... don't let anyone try to quote you over the
    phone without seeing what you're talking about first). And make sure you
    get whatever quote it is and then the contract from whomever you choose IN
    WRITING. We don't want to see you on one of those Judge shows with photos
    of a bad remodel job 🙂

    Jill

    Jill

  19. Is there a standard contract form that I can use? or do I just write
    the stuff up on my own and take his signature?

  20. Shivani said:

    We plan to remodle our kitchen. I need some advise. Here's what needs
    to be done.

    Kitchen:
    6 * 12 feet kitchen needs remodeling.

    1. Demolish the existing kitchen (cabinets etc)
    2. Remove the current vinyl floor and install ceramic tiles
    3. Install new appliances (all electric)
    4. One of the kitchen walls needs a 4 * 4 feet hole to open it up. The
    job includes making this hole and finishing the wall with plaster.
    5. One pantry and one coat closet needs to be knocked off to make space
    for the cabinets and refrigerator.
    6. This project may need minor electric and plumbing work in the
    kitchen
    7. The 1300 square feet condo needs crown molding
    8. The bathroom door needs to be changed such that it opens on the
    outside (towards the room) instead of inside (towards the bathroom)
    9. The vanity, sink in one of the bathrooms need to be lifted 6 inches.

    10. The medicine closet in both bathrooms need to be replaced
    11. Master bedroom wardrobe door needs to be replaced with a glass
    door.
    12. The door for the washer dryer closet needs to be replaced with a
    sliding door
    13. Minor - change the locks of 3 doors.

    I will pay for the materials. Home depot will do the granite counter
    top installation.

    The cabinets will cost 5-6k, counter top with island, back splash and
    installation will cost about 4k, appliances 2k, floor 500$.

    Question:
    - How much should I pay for labor?
    The on sight supretendent in my complex is a handy man and knows the
    condo complex better than anyone. He is asking for 10k flat. He'll do
    everything. He'll even get the electrician and pay him. If something
    goes wrong, he'll be there.

    Is 10k$ reasonable? It sounds a lot to me.

    Very reasonable... from perusing your list $10,000 a steal.... hurry
    before he changes his mind. The labor for installing crown moulding
    for a typical 1,800 sf living space is about $2,000. Redoing the
    flooring another $2,000. Changing a bathroom door can be very
    expensive, if there is wall tile and a marble saddle involved that job
    alone can easily run a Grand.

    My only reservation would be whether one person would possess the
    required expertise in all those trades, and is he licensed and
    insured... probably not, he works way too cheap.

    I think you will be far better off hiring a general contractor, they
    obtain the various trades person to perform each particular task. With
    some handyman you will likely end up with an abortion. Btw, regardless
    who does the job, make absolutely sure to get it all in writing.

    The fact that you are not willing to do much of that work yourself
    tells me you know nothing about home remodling. Much of what you
    listed is pretty easy for the average home owner, just requires some
    sweat. It's fairly simple to demolish kitchen cabinets and even easier
    to install new... the most difficult part is what to do with all the
    trash, you'll need to rent a dumpster and so you'll need to work
    quickly or you will be paying dumpster rent up the kazoos. Oftentimes
    if you remove the old cabinets carefully then someone else can use
    them, for storage in a garage, basement, workshop... put them out at
    the curb neatly and they'll be gone so quick you'll think it was by
    magic.

    Installing ceramic floor tile is pretty simple, especially if it's on a
    cement slab... totally uneducated Mexicans and Italians can install
    tile, you can install tile. Be sure the tile is installed on the
    entire floor, right up to the walls even under the cabinets. Most home
    builders these days cheat, they install the cabinets first, then tile
    only around the cabinets... that's a [censored] job.... especially in
    bathrooms where they don't tile under the vanity, yuck... they save a
    few bucks and figure no one will see... reminds me of folks who only
    keep the front yard neat, don't look in the back... these folks don't
    do anything no one will see, don't even wipe their ass.

    Generally the store where you purchase your appliances will for
    relatively little money do the install... the dishwasher is probably
    the most involved, Sears installed mine recently for $35. Most any
    idiot can plug in the fridge. Buy all your appliances from the same
    store and pay for the install, will cost very little and will be an
    expertly done job.

    I'm not going to run through your entire list, but many of those jobs
    can be done yourself (nothing difficult about changing door locks), and
    none of the others are contingent on each other so can be addressed
    individually at some later date... I think it's better not to contract
    the same individual to do everything all at once, wait to see how
    someone does a job before deciding to give them the next job.

    By doing most of those jobs yourself not only will you save most of
    that ten Grand, more importantly you will save yourself a lot of grief.
    Face those jobs one at a time and then it all won't look so
    overwhelming/scary.

    Even installing crown moulding is easy, if you have a quality power
    miter saw... buy one for under $200 and save two Grand, and at the end
    still have the saw. And don't use a nailing gun, use real nails... get
    the finishing nails that are coated, they glue themselves in and hold
    like forever. In fact any workmen ever shows up with a nailing gun
    immediately show them the door, do NOT let them start.

    Good luck

    Sheldon

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.