Bike Cafe · Public discussion

Music : version is better than the original

Started by limerickman · · Last activity · 7 posts · 1,199 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Bike Cafe
Published
14 August 2009
Last activity
1 September 2009
Original author
limerickman
Posts
7
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,199
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–7 of 7
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. You often get this.

    A version of the original song, proves better than the original.

    The wife likes that god-awful musak called Steely Dan/Donald Fagen.
    Dreadful mid-atlantic tripe, IMO.

    However, I spotted this version of IGY sung by Patti LaBelle.

    An improvement on the original, I think.

    [ame="[MEDIA=youtube]n29d02fEil4[/MEDIA]]YouTube - Donald Fagen on Night Music 1988 (2)[/ame]

    Any one esle have suggestions for improvements on the original song?

  2. I submit "Steely Sho-Dan" for your consideration. It's more of a mid-Pacific take on mid-Atlantic tripe.

    [ame="[MEDIA=youtube]bZe-Xu8QVF0[/MEDIA]]YouTube - Steely Shodan Plays "I.G.Y." (Donald Fagen)[/ame]

    I looked around for maybe a Disturbed or Mudvayne version, but sadly all I found were a bunch of other people who still sounded like Steely Dan.

  3. She has a phenomenal voice, But I'm partial to the original. (Guess I'm just old school). 😉

  4. Cipher said:

    She has a phenomenal voice, But I'm partial to the original. (Guess I'm just old school). 😉

    she has a superb voice - as have those backing singers.
    Great sound.

  5. my pops was a lead singer/lead guitarist of a pretty famous local band when we were overseas, a very, very long time ago and covered all and any songs any of you can come up with...if it involves music that incurs the origins of the gospel of true music, older and kind music.

    the gene was passed on so i guess the main point i am trying to make is that someimes, only sometimes, a cover can be better than the original, like when my pops sung them. he was a bad ass, no question about it.

    and like this song:[ame="[MEDIA=youtube]2BaksqH2YXQ[/MEDIA]]YouTube - Social Distortion- Ring of Fire[/ame]

    but i am biased as the talent is raw and natural in me. my fify cent.

    Preston.

  6. not generally something i'd agree to, thinking that more often than not, the original tends to take top honours, but...

    annie lennox covering one of my favourite bob marley songs, "waiting in vain." it's her voice, and her looks. anybody fix me up with her number?

  7. I'll take Maxi Priest's version of "Wild World" over the original, any day and everyday...although I do like the original as well...

    Continued...It's almost a toss-up for me between New Order and Orgy on "Blue Monday" - Orgy is close, but I gotta go with the original...

    Oh yeah, LOVE ME SOME Steely Dan! "Peg" - that song is off the charts for me...

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 1 guest ·0 bots ·1 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.