UK and Europe · Public discussion

Light review..

Started by David Martin · · Last activity · 21 posts · 749 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
UK and Europe
Published
27 October 2005
Last activity
29 October 2005
Original author
David Martin
Posts
21
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
749
Views / 30 days
0
Topics

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 21
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I succumbed. I was in Halfords to get a tin of paint for a fancy dress
    costume for my son[1] and was looking at the bike lights. I have been
    looking for something small light bright and cheap with a good run time
    to put on the road bike, so I bought one of Halfords own brand
    ultrabright ones that ahs a luxeon 1W LED. Think Cateye EL500
    equivalent. Tonight was the first chance to give it a decent test. Dark
    damp roads, wet leaves etc and a swirl of low cloud.

    The good points.

    1. The light is relatively cheap at under 30 quid for a light this
    bright. And it is bright, sufficient for riding at 18-20mph on a dark
    road and possibly faster but more on that later.
    2. The quick release mount has a swivel base so you can reposition the
    angle of the light on the fly. Quite useful.
    3. It is light, runs for ages (7hours or so according to the Audax
    list) on 4 AA batteries and is easy to operate. On ebutton on the top
    cycles between full power, reduced power, flashing and off.
    4. The beam pattern is good being relatively smooth and a good angle
    for the centre 'hot spot' for riding along, though fast cornering would
    be heading into the dark if you don't have a hand free to turn the
    light on the mount.

    The bad points.

    1. Whoever designeds the light did not try to ride with it on a dark
    road at night. The clear bezel provides so much collateral light spill
    that it dazzles the rider. I couldn't ride at any kind of speed at all
    once I left the street lights until I stopped and cabel tied a large
    puncture repair patch over the top of the bezel. Even so, there was
    enough light spilling upwards to be a serious inconvenience. I ended up
    after my hours ride with quite a stiff neck from trying to not get the
    light in my field of view.
    There was so much ligh spilling sideways that I was accompanied along
    the road by 6 foot high shadows of my STI levers and drop bars..

    2. The light is a little flimsy. A bit of duck tape over the bezel
    should also hod the to pcover (battery access and mode switch) in
    place as well as makeing the light livable.

    Overall conclusion:

    If you get one of these, invest in three inches of duck tape at the
    same time. It is not usable out of the box on unlit roads without
    masking. Otherwise it is bright, long lasting and light, and relatively
    cheap, with a good light for riding by. Definitely worth considering,
    especially if Halfords put them on sale at some point....

    ...d

    [1] 7 year old wanted to go as a robot. I despair of the many families
    who will buy fancy dress costumes (almost every other family) so we
    have discovered the way to win the 'best costume' is to get a credible
    home made one. So, large cardboard box for the body, small one for the
    head. Lots of junk (egg boxes etc) stuck on. Two pringles tubes with
    the ends cut off, bit of yellow tissue paper in one end and a couple of
    old rear lights stuck in teh other set to flash attached as jet packs.
    Spray paint matt black. Recycle all those old AOL CD's by sticking them
    all over. Last minute additions are a few 2' multicolour glowsticks.
    Way cool and as it was the only home made one, got him the first prize.

  2. David Martin said:

    I succumbed. I was in Halfords to get a tin of paint for a fancy dress
    costume for my son[1]

    Talking about fancy dress, I need some good ideas for a home-made
    Pepe-le-Pew skunk tail.
    I have a black cycling top, a Rapha hat with a white stripe,
    a black buff with white stripe, and a pair of Bikesters.
    All I need is a black and white tail to attach to my saddle pack.
    I reckon a one mtre length of twin and earth cable will keep the tail up.
    I trawled round Wilkinsons in Andover this evening, but nothing sprang to
    mind. I did get a nice 'I love my bike' bell for 99p though.
    So, thoughts on sources of pretend fur or feather boas etc?

  3. David Martin said:

    I succumbed. I was in Halfords to get a tin of paint for a fancy dress
    costume for my son[1] and was looking at the bike lights. I have been
    looking for something small light bright and cheap with a good run
    time to put on the road bike, so I bought one of Halfords own brand
    ultrabright ones that ahs a luxeon 1W LED. Think Cateye EL500
    equivalent.

    Or Smart Nova, which also costs around thirty squids, iirr.

    Thanks for the review, I didn't know Halfords has one of these. I should
    eventually get something like this for when I don't want to take my
    rechargeable system.

    ~PB

  4. John Hearns said:
    David Martin said:

    I succumbed. I was in Halfords to get a tin of paint for a fancy dress
    costume for my son[1]

    Talking about fancy dress, I need some good ideas for a home-made
    Pepe-le-Pew skunk tail.

    Fabric shop and some black and white fleece? (or black fleece and a can
    of white paint - or for a cyclist, the white paint painted like road
    centre markings with a catseye cunningly positioned..)

    Best fancy dress I ever did was a bunch of grapes. Green boiler suit
    and a large pack of green balloons stuck all over it. Bit of a hassle
    getting through doors though.

    ...d

  5. David Martin said:

    I succumbed. I was in Halfords to get a tin of paint for a fancy dress
    costume for my son[1] and was looking at the bike lights.

    Didn't really read the light review, but the costume sounds great! Where's
    the photo's? 🙂

    Graeme

  6. David Martin said:

    [1] 7 year old wanted to go as a robot. I despair of the many families
    who will buy fancy dress costumes (almost every other family) so we
    have discovered the way to win the 'best costume' is to get a credible
    home made one. So, large cardboard box for the body, small one for the
    head. Lots of junk (egg boxes etc) stuck on. Two pringles tubes with
    the ends cut off, bit of yellow tissue paper in one end and a couple of
    old rear lights stuck in teh other set to flash attached as jet packs.
    Spray paint matt black. Recycle all those old AOL CD's by sticking them
    all over. Last minute additions are a few 2' multicolour glowsticks.
    Way cool and as it was the only home made one, got him the first prize.

    Mine was covered in tin foil, but that was before the introduction of CDs
    :-)

    Roos

  7. Roos Eisma said:

    "David Martin" <[email hidden]> writes:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    [1] 7 year old wanted to go as a robot. I despair of the many families
    who will buy fancy dress costumes (almost every other family) so we
    have discovered the way to win the 'best costume' is to get a credible
    home made one. So, large cardboard box for the body, small one for the
    head. Lots of junk (egg boxes etc) stuck on. Two pringles tubes with
    the ends cut off, bit of yellow tissue paper in one end and a couple of
    old rear lights stuck in teh other set to flash attached as jet packs.
    Spray paint matt black. Recycle all those old AOL CD's by sticking them
    all over. Last minute additions are a few 2' multicolour glowsticks.
    Way cool and as it was the only home made one, got him the first prize.

    Quoted message said:

    Mine was covered in tin foil, but that was before the introduction of CDs

    My dad was always great at this: being a primary school
    teacher/headmaster in his time may have helped. The egg box trimming
    thing is very handy if your youngest happens to think a Dalek would be a
    very good thing to go as (I am the youngest of my family...)

    Pete.
    --
    Peter Clinch Medical Physics IT Officer
    Tel 44 1382 660111 ext. 33637 Univ. of Dundee, Ninewells Hospital
    Fax 44 1382 640177 Dundee DD1 9SY Scotland UK
    net [email hidden] http://www.dundee.ac.uk/~pjclinch/

  8. David Martin said:

    I succumbed. I was in Halfords to get a tin of paint for a fancy dress
    costume for my son[1] and was looking at the bike lights. I have been
    looking for something small light bright and cheap with a good run time
    to put on the road bike, so I bought one of Halfords own brand
    ultrabright ones that ahs a luxeon 1W LED. Think Cateye EL500
    equivalent. Tonight was the first chance to give it a decent test. Dark
    damp roads, wet leaves etc and a swirl of low cloud.

    Yes - I bought one of these, just last night - if you mean the Bikehut
    jobbie? Given your description of the glare off the bezel, there can be
    little doubt we are talking the same light - I had the same problem.

    I've used a strip of insulation tape; it's a shame one has to perform
    mods on a brand new item though.

    That aside though, this light is by far and away the brightest LED/AA
    combo I have seen. Whilst it doesn't rival my Smart 10w light for
    luminance, it's a good compromise given the duration and convenience of it.

    I think I paid £22.

    Chris.

  9. Chris said:
    David Martin said:

    I succumbed. I was in Halfords to get a tin of paint for a fancy dress
    costume for my son[1] and was looking at the bike lights. I have been
    looking for something small light bright and cheap with a good run time
    to put on the road bike, so I bought one of Halfords own brand
    ultrabright ones that ahs a luxeon 1W LED. Think Cateye EL500
    equivalent. Tonight was the first chance to give it a decent test. Dark
    damp roads, wet leaves etc and a swirl of low cloud.

    Yes - I bought one of these, just last night - if you mean the Bikehut
    jobbie? Given your description of the glare off the bezel, there can be
    little doubt we are talking the same light - I had the same problem.

    I've used a strip of insulation tape; it's a shame one has to perform
    mods on a brand new item though.

    Probably woth writing to Halfords and pointing out the error of their
    ways.

    Quoted message said:


    That aside though, this light is by far and away the brightest LED/AA
    combo I have seen. Whilst it doesn't rival my Smart 10w light for
    luminance, it's a good compromise given the duration and convenience of it.

    I think I paid £22.

    They must have had them on discount. I paid £29.

    I find with LED and with blue tinted halogens that the illumination
    isn't as good as full panchromatic halogens. My theory is that eyes
    respond best to a spectrum of wavelengths, and coloured reflectors and
    LEDs provide only a limited spectrum.

    Also riding on wet roads doesn't do much for the visibility. I'll find
    some decent tape and mask the bezel properly. I used a large puncture
    patch and a couple of cable ties last night.

    ...d

  10. David Martin said:
    Chris said:
    David Martin said:

    I succumbed. I was in Halfords to get a tin of paint for a fancy dress
    costume for my son[1] and was looking at the bike lights. I have been
    looking for something small light bright and cheap with a good run time
    to put on the road bike, so I bought one of Halfords own brand
    ultrabright ones that ahs a luxeon 1W LED. Think Cateye EL500
    equivalent. Tonight was the first chance to give it a decent test. Dark
    damp roads, wet leaves etc and a swirl of low cloud.

    It is this one
    http://www.halfords.com/webapp/wcs/stores/servlet/ProductDisplay?catalogId=10151&storeId=10001&productId=219900&categoryId=31362&langId=-1&parent_category_rn=31362&crumb=33980-31270-31362&varient=&CarSelectorCatalogId=

    http://tinyurl.com/82h3j

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:


    Yes - I bought one of these, just last night - if you mean the Bikehut
    jobbie? Given your description of the glare off the bezel, there can be
    little doubt we are talking the same light - I had the same problem.

    I've used a strip of insulation tape; it's a shame one has to perform
    mods on a brand new item though.

    Probably woth writing to Halfords and pointing out the error of their
    ways.

    Quoted message said:


    That aside though, this light is by far and away the brightest LED/AA
    combo I have seen. Whilst it doesn't rival my Smart 10w light for
    luminance, it's a good compromise given the duration and convenience ofit.

    I think I paid £22.

    They must have had them on discount. I paid £29.

    I find with LED and with blue tinted halogens that the illumination
    isn't as good as full panchromatic halogens. My theory is that eyes
    respond best to a spectrum of wavelengths, and coloured reflectors and
    LEDs provide only a limited spectrum.

    Also riding on wet roads doesn't do much for the visibility. I'll find
    some decent tape and mask the bezel properly. I used a large puncture
    patch and a couple of cable ties last night.

    ..d

  11. Graeme Dods said:
    David Martin said:

    I succumbed. I was in Halfords to get a tin of paint for a fancy dress
    costume for my son[1] and was looking at the bike lights.

    Didn't really read the light review, but the costume sounds great! Where's
    the photo's? 🙂

    I'll post them tonight..

    ...d

  12. Chris said:
    David Martin said:

    I succumbed. I was in Halfords to get a tin of paint for a fancy dress
    costume for my son[1] and was looking at the bike lights. I have been
    looking for something small light bright and cheap with a good run time
    to put on the road bike, so I bought one of Halfords own brand
    ultrabright ones that ahs a luxeon 1W LED. Think Cateye EL500
    equivalent. Tonight was the first chance to give it a decent test. Dark
    damp roads, wet leaves etc and a swirl of low cloud.

    Quoted message said:

    Yes - I bought one of these, just last night - if you mean the Bikehut
    jobbie? Given your description of the glare off the bezel, there can be
    little doubt we are talking the same light - I had the same problem.

    Quoted message said:

    I've used a strip of insulation tape; it's a shame one has to perform
    mods on a brand new item though.

    Quoted message said:

    That aside though, this light is by far and away the brightest LED/AA
    combo I have seen. Whilst it doesn't rival my Smart 10w light for
    luminance, it's a good compromise given the duration and convenience of it.

    Quoted message said:

    I think I paid #22.

    I got my Smart 4 AA 1 watt Luxeon front lamp for 24 quid in a Bike
    Chain sale (they seem to have sales quite often). It's much better
    engineered than this one sounds like. I'm very critical of engineering
    design, and the Smart lamp is one of the few where I found nothing I
    could think of as even as even a minor improvement.

    --
    Chris Malcolm [email hidden] +44 (0)131 651 3445 DoD #205
    IPAB, Informatics, JCMB, King's Buildings, Edinburgh, EH9 3JZ, UK
    [http://www.dai.ed.ac.uk/homes/cam/]

  13. Response to John Hearns:

    Quoted message said:

    So, thoughts on sources of pretend fur or feather boas etc?

    Claire's Accessories for the fur/boas; they might also have e.g. wig-
    maker's wire to stiffen it as well. While you're in there you'll find
    plenty of other material to pimp your ride! No, I haven't tried it
    myself. ;-)

    --
    Mark, UK

    "'Michael Gilhaney,' said the Sergeant, 'is an example of a man that is
    nearly banjaxed from the principle of the Atomic Theory. Would it
    astonish you to hear that he is nearly half a bicycle?'"

  14. I got a 1w headlight led from liddle which has high, lower and lowest
    settings.When the 3 batteries run low the light suddenly switches off
    completely.
    I only use it in combination with a bike mounted light.
    I am very pleased with the light, and find that being able too look
    around r point at something specifically is a great improvement.
    TerryJ

  15. Quoted message said:

    I got a 1w headlight led from liddle which has high, lower and lowest
    settings.When the 3 batteries run low the light suddenly switches off
    completely.
    I only use it in combination with a bike mounted light.
    I am very pleased with the light, and find that being able too look
    around r point at something specifically is a great improvement.

    I have one of those too. It was using one of those that convinced me
    that a 1W LED would do for a bike light.

    ...d

  16. David Martin said:
    Graeme Dods said:
    David Martin said:

    I succumbed. I was in Halfords to get a tin of paint for a fancy dress
    costume for my son[1] and was looking at the bike lights.

    Didn't really read the light review, but the costume sounds great! Where's
    the photo's? 🙂

    I'll post them tonight..

    http://www.compbio.dundee.ac.uk/~dmamartin/robot/robot.html

    ...d

  17. David Martin said:

    Best fancy dress I ever did was a bunch of grapes. Green boiler suit
    and a large pack of green balloons stuck all over it.

    Reminds me of the Michelin man I did. I wrapped myself completely in
    white 260 modelling balloons.

    Quoted message said:

    Bit of a hassle
    getting through doors though.

    ISTR I burst (and had to replace) a few balloons when I decided to ride
    a unicycle.

    I love the robot costume, BTW.

    --
    Danny Colyer (my reply address is valid but checked infrequently)
    <URL:http://www.colyer.plus.com/danny/>
    Subscribe to PlusNet <URL:http://www.colyer.plus.com/referral/>
    "He who dares not offend cannot be honest." - Thomas Paine

  18. Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    I'll post them tonight..

    http://www.compbio.dundee.ac.uk/~dmamartin/robot/robot.html

    That's brill!

  19. Mark Thompson of NTL said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    I'll post them tonight..

    http://www.compbio.dundee.ac.uk/~dmamartin/robot/robot.html

    That's brill!


    Indeed it is. Good idea from the 7 year old, and excellent execution by
    parent. Definitely deserved the first prize.
    --
    Judge: A law student who marks his own papers.
    Henry Louis Mencken
    Steph Peters delete invalid from [email hidden]
    Tatting, lace & stitching page <http://www.sandbenders.demon.co.uk/index.htm>

  20. Steph Peters said:
    Mark Thompson of NTL said:
    Quoted message said:

    > I'll post them tonight..

    http://www.compbio.dundee.ac.uk/~dmamartin/robot/robot.html

    That's brill!


    Indeed it is. Good idea from the 7 year old, and excellent execution by
    parent. Definitely deserved the first prize.

    It was based on a previous one for my daughter as a martian, done in
    pink and gold.
    That one also won.

    Top tip. Do the gluing with a hot glue gun. Makes it much easier than
    trying to use PVA.

    ...d

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.