Australia and New Zealand · Public discussion

letter from bicycling australia

Started by byron27 · · Last activity · 11 posts · 722 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Australia and New Zealand
Published
26 November 2004
Last activity
27 November 2004
Original author
byron27
Posts
11
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
722
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–11 of 11
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Im sure a lot of you may already have seen this letter though i really cant believe that bicycling australia would have the gall to write such a letter!

    bikepro.com.aubicycling australia letter b.jpg

    Surely this suggests a level of collusion and price fixing among the major bike importers and distrobutors in Australia?

    I can't open another bicycling australia magazine knowing that they are really taking the [censored] and all their reviews of goods are really tainted by their sycophantic approach to their importers and distrobutors.

    Seeing as i am on a non magazine opening crusade, can someone tell me which bike shops advertise in bicycling australia so i make a point not to go to them! 😄 😄

  2. byron27 said:

    Im sure a lot of you may already have seen this letter though i really cant believe that bicycling australia would have the gall to write such a letter!

    bikepro.com.aubicycling australia letter b.jpg

    Surely this suggests a level of collusion and price fixing among the major bike importers and distrobutors in Australia?

    I can't open another bicycling australia magazine knowing that they are really taking the [censored] and all their reviews of goods are really tainted by their sycophantic approach to their importers and distrobutors.

    Seeing as i am on a non magazine opening crusade, can someone tell me which bike shops advertise in bicycling australia so i make a point not to go to them! 😄 😄

    It's a pretty old letter... nevertheless, I wonder if there is recourse to the ACCC or someone else?

    Ritch

  3. byron27 said:

    Im sure a lot of you may already have seen this letter though i really cant believe that bicycling australia would have the gall to write such a letter!

    bikepro.com.aubicycling australia letter b.jpg

    Surely this suggests a level of collusion and price fixing among the major bike importers and distrobutors in Australia?

    I can't open another bicycling australia magazine knowing that they are really taking the [censored] and all their reviews of goods are really tainted by their sycophantic approach to their importers and distrobutors.

    Seeing as i am on a non magazine opening crusade, can someone tell me which bike shops advertise in bicycling australia so i make a point not to go to them! 😄 😄


    what was wrong with BikePro's Ads or prices?

    Were they too low for other retailers??
    Surely if a retailer decides to take less margin on his/her sales and go for volume
    (Gee, that reminds me of GIANT back in the nineties) they directly wear the consequences.

    Do BA subscribe to the 'you place X-amount of advertising with us and we will give your product a favourable review' ???

    Never buy it as it all seems too 'Andrew Peacock' (all feather and no meat!)

  4. The letter pretty much summarises what's wrong with the Australian bicycle industry. The distribution network is dominated by a small group of old ex-racers who rather than promoting cycling to get more revenue, are content to simply screw the consumer as much as possible.

    Australian bike brands (remember Speedwells and Malvern Stars?) died out twenty years or so ago due to the dropping cost of freight, and because the local brands didn't have the brains to compete with the cheap imports. Now Australian bicycle retailers are going to go the same way, again due to dropping freight prices, this time helped along by the Internet.

    Regardless of how hard the local industry tries to stop it, they'll all end up shutting shop unless they can come up with a way to compete with the overseas shops.

    Regards,

    Suzy

  5. "flyingdutch" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    message news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    byron27 said:

    Im sure a lot of you may already have seen this letter though i really
    cant believe that bicycling australia would have the gall to write such
    a letter!

    http://tinyurl.com/5p9fw

    Surely this suggests a level of collusion and price fixing among the
    major bike importers and distrobutors in Australia?

    I can't open another bicycling australia magazine knowing that they are
    really taking the [censored] and all their reviews of goods are really tainted
    by their sycophantic approach to their importers and distrobutors.

    Seeing as i am on a non magazine opening crusade, can someone tell me
    which bike shops advertise in bicycling australia so i make a point not
    to go to them! 😄 😄


    what was wrong with BikePro's Ads or prices?

    Were they too low for other retailers??
    Surely if a retailer decides to take less margin on his/her sales and
    go for volume
    (Gee, that reminds me of GIANT back in the nineties) they directly wear
    the consequences.

    Do BA subscribe to the 'you place X-amount of advertising with us and
    we will give your product a favourable review' ???

    Never buy it as it all seems too 'Andrew Peacock' (all feather and no
    meat!)

    --
    flyingdutch

    wernt bike pro the guys selling the sigma bc1600 with cadence kit for $29 a
    few months back?
    i remember cecil walker had them cheap at $59
    Only went to bike pro once even tho its not far from my place..the shop
    never seems to be open, but the guy in the store was nice enough to deal
    with when i did manage to get there..

  6. [quote="byron27"]Im sure a lot of you may already have seen this letter though i really cant believe that bicycling australia would have the gall to write such a letter!

    bikepro.com.aubicycling australia letter b.jpg

    Surely this suggests a level of collusion and price fixing among the major bike importers and distrobutors in Australia?

    I can't open another bicycling australia magazine knowing that they are really taking the [censored] and all their reviews of goods are really tainted by their sycophantic approach to their importers and distrobutors.

    Seeing as i am on a non magazine opening crusade, can someone tell me which bike shops advertise in bicycling australia so i make a point not to go to them! 😄 😄

    [/QUOTE]


    Didn't Dean Woods get similar treatment from them for his advertising?


    SteveA

  7. Dej said:

    "flyingdutch" <[email hidden]> wrote in
    message news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    byron27 said:

    Im sure a lot of you may already have seen this letter though i really
    cant believe that bicycling australia would have the gall to write such
    a letter!

    http://tinyurl.com/5p9fw

    Surely this suggests a level of collusion and price fixing among the
    major bike importers and distrobutors in Australia?

    I can't open another bicycling australia magazine knowing that they are
    really taking the [censored] and all their reviews of goods are really tainted
    by their sycophantic approach to their importers and distrobutors.

    Seeing as i am on a non magazine opening crusade, can someone tell me
    which bike shops advertise in bicycling australia so i make a point not
    to go to them! 😄 😄

    what was wrong with BikePro's Ads or prices?

    Were they too low for other retailers??
    Surely if a retailer decides to take less margin on his/her sales and
    go for volume
    (Gee, that reminds me of GIANT back in the nineties) they directly wear
    the consequences.

    Do BA subscribe to the 'you place X-amount of advertising with us and
    we will give your product a favourable review' ???

    Never buy it as it all seems too 'Andrew Peacock' (all feather and no
    meat!)

    --
    flyingdutch

    wernt bike pro the guys selling the sigma bc1600 with cadence kit for $29 a
    few months back?
    i remember cecil walker had them cheap at $59
    Only went to bike pro once even tho its not far from my place..the shop
    never seems to be open, but the guy in the store was nice enough to deal
    with when i did manage to get there..

    I think Andy at Bikepro is from Singapore (or maybe HK, can't remember)
    so maybe he's got some contacts where he can buy stuff at a cheaper
    wholesale rate than the Aus distributors sell, therefore undercutting
    the local shops but still making a profit?

    --
    Nick

  8. "Dej" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    wernt bike pro the guys selling the sigma bc1600 with cadence kit for $29
    a few months back?
    i remember cecil walker had them cheap at $59
    Only went to bike pro once even tho its not far from my place..the shop
    never seems to be open, but the guy in the store was nice enough to deal
    with when i did manage to get there..

    That's right. bc1600 plus cadence kit for $29.99 & free postage.
    I ordered one from Brisbane and it arrived a few days later,
    less the packaging which I thought was strange. But maybe
    that was so they could use a smaller postpak? Way cheaper
    than anywhere else.

  9. Yup, got one. 🙂

    Dej said:

    "flyingdutch" <[email hidden]>
    wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    byron27 said:

    Im sure a lot of you may already have seen this letter though i
    really cant believe that bicycling australia would have the gall to
    write such a letter!

    http://tinyurl.com/5p9fw

    Surely this suggests a level of collusion and price fixing among the
    major bike importers and distrobutors in Australia?

    I can't open another bicycling australia magazine knowing that they
    are really taking the [censored] and all their reviews of goods are
    really tainted by their sycophantic approach to their importers and
    distrobutors.

    Seeing as i am on a non magazine opening crusade, can someone tell
    me which bike shops advertise in bicycling australia so i make a
    point not to go to them! 😄 😄


    what was wrong with BikePro's Ads or prices?

    Were they too low for other retailers??
    Surely if a retailer decides to take less margin on his/her sales and
    go for volume
    (Gee, that reminds me of GIANT back in the nineties) they directly
    wear the consequences.

    Do BA subscribe to the 'you place X-amount of advertising with us and
    we will give your product a favourable review' ???

    Never buy it as it all seems too 'Andrew Peacock' (all feather and no
    meat!)

    --
    flyingdutch

    wernt bike pro the guys selling the sigma bc1600 with cadence kit for
    $29 a few months back?
    i remember cecil walker had them cheap at $59
    Only went to bike pro once even tho its not far from my place..the
    shop never seems to be open, but the guy in the store was nice enough
    to deal with when i did manage to get there..

  10. flyingdutch said:


    Do BA subscribe to the 'you place X-amount of advertising with us and
    we will give your product a favourable review' ???

    Keep that is mind whenever you read any publication with paid
    advertising.
    Even my little business has been offered "equal advertorial space (you
    write it) to match the size of your advertisement". They were a bit
    [censored] when I said it wasn't worth advertising with them as they (local
    newspaper) didn't bring in the business. Aka - it is widespread.

  11. SteveA said:
    Quoted message said:


    Didn't Dean Woods get similar treatment from them for his advertising?

    I think that is the case yet Dean Woods still advertises in Australian
    Cyclist and the sky hasn't fallen in.

    Regards
    Bruce

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.