Cycling Equipment · Public discussion

Kool Stop brake pads really do work

Started by Email address hidden · · Last activity · 20 posts · 1,058 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Cycling Equipment
Published
9 May 2006
Last activity
11 May 2006
Original author
Email address hidden
Posts
20
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,058
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 20
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. A couple of years ago, I was given a 1949 Raleigh Lenton Sport. It was
    all original except for the tires and grips.

    I slapped a new saddle on it (to replace the broken Brooks), replaced
    the shifter and cable, and removed the grease that had been injected
    into the AW hub. It then became my commuter bike.

    Being the cheapskate I am, I didn't replace the brake blocks. The
    god-knows-how-old brake pads on the steel wheels made for poor stopping
    in the dry and a positively scary trip in the rain.

    After reading Sheldon Brown's glowing comments regarding the Kool Stop
    salmon pads, I finally ordered up some Kool Stop pads from Harris
    Cyclery. Today was my first ride with them. Even in the morning rain
    they were phenomenal. I couldn't believe that just changing the pads
    would make such a big difference but I was wrong. The Kool Stop pads
    really do live up to their reputation and are just the ticket in rain
    country.

    John Thurston
    Juneau, Alaska

  2. Quoted message said:

    they were phenomenal. I couldn't believe that just changing the pads
    would make such a big difference but I was wrong. The Kool Stop pads
    really do live up to their reputation and are just the ticket in rain
    country.

    You think they are good now, try changing your steel rim for an aluminum
    alloy one. That'll make an even bigger difference.

    --
    K.

  3. Quoted message said:

    A couple of years ago, I was given a 1949 Raleigh Lenton Sport. It
    was all original except for the tires and grips.

    I slapped a new saddle on it (to replace the broken Brooks), replaced
    the shifter and cable, and removed the grease that had been injected
    into the AW hub. It then became my commuter bike.

    Being the cheapskate I am, I didn't replace the brake blocks. The
    god-knows-how-old brake pads on the steel wheels made for poor
    stopping in the dry and a positively scary trip in the rain.

    After reading Sheldon Brown's glowing comments regarding the Kool Stop
    salmon pads, I finally ordered up some Kool Stop pads from Harris
    Cyclery. Today was my first ride with them. Even in the morning rain
    they were phenomenal. I couldn't believe that just changing the pads
    would make such a big difference but I was wrong. The Kool Stop pads
    really do live up to their reputation and are just the ticket in rain
    country.

    John Thurston
    Juneau, Alaska

    My experience is to the contrary! They have embedded grit and scrape up the
    rims and cause flats, not to mention slowing me down!!!
    --
    Phil, Squid-in-Training

  4. Phil said:
    Quoted message said:

    A couple of years ago, I was given a 1949 Raleigh Lenton Sport. It
    was all original except for the tires and grips.

    I slapped a new saddle on it (to replace the broken Brooks), replaced
    the shifter and cable, and removed the grease that had been injected
    into the AW hub. It then became my commuter bike.

    Being the cheapskate I am, I didn't replace the brake blocks. The
    god-knows-how-old brake pads on the steel wheels made for poor
    stopping in the dry and a positively scary trip in the rain.

    After reading Sheldon Brown's glowing comments regarding the Kool Stop
    salmon pads, I finally ordered up some Kool Stop pads from Harris
    Cyclery. Today was my first ride with them. Even in the morning rain
    they were phenomenal. I couldn't believe that just changing the pads
    would make such a big difference but I was wrong. The Kool Stop pads
    really do live up to their reputation and are just the ticket in rain
    country.

    John Thurston
    Juneau, Alaska

    My experience is to the contrary! They have embedded grit and scrape up the
    rims and cause flats, not to mention slowing me down!!!

    Ummmm.... don't you *want* your brake pads to slow you down?

    Mark

  5. Király said:

    You think they are good now, try changing your steel rim for an aluminum
    alloy one. That'll make an even bigger difference.

    I certainly considered doing that, but I just didn't feel like spending
    the cash.
    I decided I try the $6 brake pads before the $50 wheel.

    John Thurston
    Juneau, Alaska

  6. Phil said:


    My experience is to the contrary! They have embedded grit and scrape up the
    rims and cause flats, not to mention slowing me down!!!

    How does grit scraping the rims cause flats?

    - Frank Krygowski

  7. Squid-in-Training said:


    My experience is to the contrary! They have embedded grit and scrape up the
    rims and cause flats, not to mention slowing me down!!!

    And how exactly have the brake pads caused flats?

    Jeff

  8. Jeff Starr said:
    Squid-in-Training said:


    My experience is to the contrary! They have embedded grit and
    scrape up the rims and cause flats, not to mention slowing me down!!!

    And how exactly have the brake pads caused flats?

    Jeff

    Oy... rhetorical smilies don't translate well...
    --
    Phil, Squid-in-Training

  9. Squid-in-Training said:
    Jeff Starr said:
    Squid-in-Training said:


    My experience is to the contrary! They have embedded grit and
    scrape up the rims and cause flats, not to mention slowing me down!!!

    And how exactly have the brake pads caused flats?

    Jeff

    Oy... rhetorical smilies don't translate well...

    If your original post was an attempt at humor, it failed miseably. For
    a moment I thought it might be an attempt at humor, but seeing nothing
    funny, I dismissed that idea.

    If somebody does research, at a later date, they will take your post
    as being serious. Which helps no one.

    Life is Good!
    Jeff

  10. John Thurston said:

    (snip) The god-knows-how-old brake pads on the steel wheels made for
    poor stopping in the dry and a positively scary trip in the rain.

    I finally ordered up some Kool Stop pads from Harris Cyclery. Today was my
    first ride with them. Even in the morning rain they were phenomenal.
    I couldn't believe that just changing the pads would make such a big
    difference but I was wrong. The Kool Stop pads really do live up to
    their reputation and are just the ticket in rain country.

    I put Kool Stops on a bike with steel wheels and they do seem to help,
    so I am a fan.

    However (maybe because of the .tech part of this newsgroups name) I
    just want to point out that the only thing your experience shows is
    that new Kool Stop pads work much better than god-knows-how-old (maybe
    57 years old?) pads of unknown composition and origin. I don't think
    this particular experience is any evidence that Kool Stops are any
    better than any other new pad.

    Joe LoBuglio

  11. Jeff Starr said:
    Squid-in-Training said:
    Jeff Starr said:

    On Tue, 9 May 2006 18:50:00 -0400, "Phil, Squid-in-Training"
    <[email hidden]> wrote:

    >
    > My experience is to the contrary! They have embedded grit and
    > scrape up the rims and cause flats, not to mention slowing me
    > down!!!

    And how exactly have the brake pads caused flats?

    Jeff

    Oy... rhetorical smilies don't translate well...

    If your original post was an attempt at humor, it failed miseably. For
    a moment I thought it might be an attempt at humor, but seeing nothing
    funny, I dismissed that idea.

    Interesting. So if there was nothing funny, why did you think for a moment
    it might be an attempt at humor? Brake pads = slowing down, ergo why would
    I not want it to do so?

    Quoted message said:

    If somebody does research, at a later date, they will take your post
    as being serious. Which helps no one.

    Warning! Unfunny thread!

    Hopefully that'll set 'em straight. wink wink nudge nudge chuckle

    --
    Phil, Squid-in-Training

  12. -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----

    In article <R%d8g.10469$8q.645@dukeread08>,

    Phil said:
    Jeff Starr said:
    Squid-in-Training said:


    My experience is to the contrary! They have embedded grit and
    scrape up the rims and cause flats, not to mention slowing me down!!!

    And how exactly have the brake pads caused flats?

    Jeff

    Oy... rhetorical smilies don't translate well...

    _ I got the joke and enjoyed it. Don't let the humorless stop
    you... This place could use a few more jokes and a lot less
    posturing.

    _ Booker C. Bense

    -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
    Version: 2.6.2

    iQCVAwUBRGIeD2TWTAjn5N/lAQEp4gP/fmTihK8/L55ycseuOLumB1lX4Br7y2nG
    Xijypt2ZR6rZ2//s8k/62BxC6nWfxpj9fMG3wPJdu0OEBIJYPwjjxwT7x3TZOgip
    hL34LeABn1T+ZoPS0f1ahCPdaH/XTA9uCAMmgHC3LSrG7dkF7OO0RUZdXP6m325k
    duIDQWPfAAg=
    =WLm3
    -----END PGP SIGNATURE-----

  13. In article <[email hidden]>,
    [email hidden] says...

    Quoted message said:

    A couple of years ago, I was given a 1949 Raleigh Lenton Sport. It was
    all original except for the tires and grips.

    I slapped a new saddle on it (to replace the broken Brooks), replaced
    the shifter and cable, and removed the grease that had been injected
    into the AW hub. It then became my commuter bike.

    Being the cheapskate I am, I didn't replace the brake blocks. The
    god-knows-how-old brake pads on the steel wheels made for poor stopping
    in the dry and a positively scary trip in the rain.

    After reading Sheldon Brown's glowing comments regarding the Kool Stop
    salmon pads, I finally ordered up some Kool Stop pads from Harris
    Cyclery. Today was my first ride with them. Even in the morning rain
    they were phenomenal. I couldn't believe that just changing the pads
    would make such a big difference but I was wrong. The Kool Stop pads
    really do live up to their reputation and are just the ticket in rain
    country.

    Wet steel brakes poorly even with great pads. You would get better results
    if you had aluminum rims.
    -------------
    Alex

  14. quote='Phil said:

    A couple of years ago, I was given a 1949 Raleigh Lenton Sport. It
    was all original except for the tires and grips.

    I slapped a new saddle on it (to replace the broken Brooks), replaced
    the shifter and cable, and removed the grease that had been injected
    into the AW hub. It then became my commuter bike.

    Being the cheapskate I am, I didn't replace the brake blocks. The
    god-knows-how-old brake pads on the steel wheels made for poor
    stopping in the dry and a positively scary trip in the rain.

    After reading Sheldon Brown's glowing comments regarding the Kool Stop
    salmon pads, I finally ordered up some Kool Stop pads from Harris
    Cyclery. Today was my first ride with them. Even in the morning rain
    they were phenomenal. I couldn't believe that just changing the pads
    would make such a big difference but I was wrong. The Kool Stop pads
    really do live up to their reputation and are just the ticket in rain
    country.

    John Thurston
    Juneau, Alaska

    My experience is to the contrary! They have embedded grit and scrape up the
    rims and cause flats, not to mention slowing me down!!!
    --
    Phil, Squid-in-Training[/QUOTE]I have found them great, much better than othrs and much easier on rims.

  15. Alex Rodriguez said:

    Wet steel brakes poorly even with great pads. You would get better results
    if you had aluminum rims.

    Agreed. One could also say that hydraulic disc brakes would give me
    even better results.

    The point is that for a *very* small outlay of cash (1/10 the cost of
    an aluminum wheel) I was able to make a dramatic improvement in the
    braking performance.

    John Thurston
    Juneau, Alaska

  16. Squid-in-Training said:
    Jeff Starr said:
    Squid-in-Training said:

    Jeff Starr wrote:
    > On Tue, 9 May 2006 18:50:00 -0400, "Phil, Squid-in-Training"
    > <[email hidden]> wrote:
    >
    >
    >>
    >> My experience is to the contrary! They have embedded grit and
    >> scrape up the rims and cause flats, not to mention slowing me
    >> down!!!
    >
    > And how exactly have the brake pads caused flats?
    >
    > Jeff

    Oy... rhetorical smilies don't translate well...

    If your original post was an attempt at humor, it failed miseably. For
    a moment I thought it might be an attempt at humor, but seeing nothing
    funny, I dismissed that idea.

    Interesting. So if there was nothing funny, why did you think for a moment
    it might be an attempt at humor? Brake pads = slowing down, ergo why would
    I not want it to do so?


    Why, because you occasionally post nonsense. I know I'm wasting my
    time but, I'll try to explain it. It is this part of what you posted
    "My experience is to the contrary! They have embedded grit and
    scrape up the rims and cause flats".
    So, where's the humor in that part of your post? The second part about
    slowing down, doesn't dismiss the first part.

    Quoted message said:


    Quoted message said:

    If somebody does research, at a later date, they will take your post
    as being serious. Which helps no one.

    Warning! Unfunny thread!

    Hopefully that'll set 'em straight. wink wink nudge nudge chuckle

    I have no problem with and enjoy well written humor. It's not about
    "unfunny thread", it's about misinformation. Next time attach a smiley
    face and everyone will know it is an attempt at being funny.

    Do you get it now?

    Jeff

  17. Jeff Starr said:
    Squid-in-Training said:
    Jeff Starr said:

    On Wed, 10 May 2006 00:31:10 -0400, "Phil, Squid-in-Training"
    <[email hidden]> wrote:

    > Jeff Starr wrote:
    >> On Tue, 9 May 2006 18:50:00 -0400, "Phil, Squid-in-Training"
    >> <[email hidden]> wrote:
    >>
    >>
    >>>
    >>> My experience is to the contrary! They have embedded grit and
    >>> scrape up the rims and cause flats, not to mention slowing me
    >>> down!!!
    >>
    >> And how exactly have the brake pads caused flats?
    >>
    >> Jeff
    >
    > Oy... rhetorical smilies don't translate well...

    If your original post was an attempt at humor, it failed miseably.
    For a moment I thought it might be an attempt at humor, but seeing
    nothing funny, I dismissed that idea.

    Interesting. So if there was nothing funny, why did you think for a
    moment it might be an attempt at humor? Brake pads = slowing down,
    ergo why would I not want it to do so?


    Why, because you occasionally post nonsense.

    Gene and I share a common Floridian thread. 😉

    I know I'm wasting my

    Quoted message said:

    time but, I'll try to explain it. It is this part of what you posted
    "My experience is to the contrary! They have embedded grit and
    scrape up the rims and cause flats".
    So, where's the humor in that part of your post? The second part about
    slowing down, doesn't dismiss the first part.

    Quoted message said:


    Quoted message said:

    If somebody does research, at a later date, they will take your post
    as being serious. Which helps no one.

    Warning! Unfunny thread!

    Hopefully that'll set 'em straight. wink wink nudge nudge chuckle

    I have no problem with and enjoy well written humor. It's not about
    "unfunny thread", it's about misinformation. Next time attach a smiley
    face and everyone will know it is an attempt at being funny.

    Do you get it now?

    Yep.

    --
    Phil, Squid-in-Training

  18. Quoted message said:
    Alex Rodriguez said:

    Wet steel brakes poorly even with great pads. You would get better
    results if you had aluminum rims.

    Agreed. One could also say that hydraulic disc brakes would give me
    even better results.

    The point is that for a *very* small outlay of cash (1/10 the cost of
    an aluminum wheel) I was able to make a dramatic improvement in the
    braking performance.

    John Thurston
    Juneau, Alaska

    Would you say the benefit per dollar is the same between new brake pads and
    new rims?

    Although it's probably not appropriate, to get even better braking power, a
    BMX trick is to smear tar or Coca-Cola on the rim. This gives you
    ultra-grabby power and OTB potential with steel rims. But the drawback is
    the requirement to reapply as it wears/washes off.
    --
    Phil, Squid-in-Training

  19. "Jeff Starr" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    On Wed, 10 May 2006 10:10:42 -0400, "Phil, Squid-in-Training"
    <[email hidden]> wrote:


    SNIPPAGE

    Quoted message said:


    I have no problem with and enjoy well written humor. It's not about
    "unfunny thread", it's about misinformation. Next time attach a smiley
    face and everyone will know it is an attempt at being funny.

    Phil was doing his Jim Beam impression.

    Jim's not funny, either.

  20. In article <[email hidden]>,
    [email hidden] says...

    Quoted message said:

    Agreed. One could also say that hydraulic disc brakes would give me
    even better results.

    Only if you stayed with the steel rims. With aluminum rims, decent pads and
    decent canti's or direct pull brakes, you get great braking.

    Quoted message said:

    The point is that for a *very* small outlay of cash (1/10 the cost of
    an aluminum wheel) I was able to make a dramatic improvement in the
    braking performance.

    I know what you meant. It was more of a future upgrade path idea. Good luck.
    ---------------
    Alex

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.