vitamin s said:okay guys,
i know this subject is like beating a dead horse at this point. this forum is filled with opinions, and trust me, i have read as much as i can. i know i need to test ride bikes to find the best fit. the problem is, i am in japan teaching english and dont speak much japanese. i have a japanese friend who is going to go to the bike shop with me to find a bike, but i wanted to get as much info as i can before i step into the shop.
i am 5'4 121 lbs, and am in decent shape. i have been looking at the felt f75, and it seems like a good bike for me (i cant go much more expensive), but id like to buy a japanese made bike since i would probably be paying for import taxes and tariffs and whatnot if i go with a felt.
i have seen some japanese bikes in a local shop, but they all use the tiagra components on bikes in my price range. do you think that i should pay the extra dough to get the 105 stuff? will it matter much? i wont be racing but did centuries periodically back home and would like to do some hard rides here in japan.
also in regards to my size, 650cc wheels, or 700? do i even have a choice in this matter?
discuss. thanks in advance!
I haven't used Tiagra, but from what I understand, it is as utilitarian as the 105 components of comparable heritage (i.e., 9-speed).
I've used 8-and-9-speed Shimano shifters (Ultegra & 105), but have found them to be unsatisfactory for most of the riding we do (i.e., mountain roads). I was briefly planning on using a pair of 9-speed Shimano 105 shifters that I had allowed to languish (for want of a bike) on a potential in-city bike where the "hills" are less severe, but I was spared the potential anguish when I sold them on eBay.
The 10-speed Shimano shifters are supposedly better than the Shimano 9-speed shifters; but, Campagnolo shifters (except XENON) are better, still, because they just shift better AND are less expensive (unless you get the high-zoot RECORD-or-CHORUS shifters)!
With the Campagnolo shifters, you can downshift to a larger cog in the rear (presuming your cassette has a larger cog than the one you are in) when under load ... with the 9-speed Shimano shifters, you pretty much have to be in the gear you want to be in before the ascent OR dump out to a granny on a triple ... but, supposedly, the 10-speed Shimano shifters are better at handling downshifting under load, but that is hearsay until I get around to testing a pair.
AFAIK, most of rural Japan is hilly/mountainous, so, presuming you're in the hinterland where the roads are generally not level, the Campagnolo shifters are something you should try to find already equipped on a bike.
So, FWIW, lacking other choices, I would get the Tiagra or 2006/9-speed 105 equipped bike -- THAT presumes that you can't find one already equipped with Campagnolo Veloce [or, better Campagnolo components] -- e.g., Bianchi, and others -- and, when the 9-speed Shimano Tiagra/105/whatever shifters failed (allow 10,000 miles +/- depending on the frequency of your shifting), I would get a pair of Campagnolo shifters for the otherwise Shimano equipped bike.
NB. The 10 speed Campagnolo shifters can be readily/easily indexed to Shimano 8-/9-speed drivetrains ... undoubedly, when using the appropriate JTEK SHIFTMATE the Campagnolo shifters can also work with the 10-speed Shimano drivetrains.
"No" to 650c wheels/tires in most circumstances for most people because the tire selection seems to be more limited than for almost-obsolete 27" wheels.
Because parts wear out OR preferences change, having wheels which are Shimano-compatible is a plus in the real world because you will have more cassette options in a broader range of prices.
BTW. If you were to buy the bike which has 9-speed Shimano 105 shifters, you could probably sell the 9-speed 105 shifters (eBay) USED for more than the replacement cost of a new pair Campagnolo CENTAUR-or-VELOCE 10-speed shifters (eBay, again). A pair of "new" take-off 9-speed 105 shifters would command a premium over the "replacement" cost of a pair of NIB Veloce shifters.
A less satisfactory option for most people is to buy ALMOST ANY used bike and install Campagnolo shifters on it as either part of a complete "group" or mixed with Shimano components.