Road Cycling · Public discussion

Freire out of Tour

Started by Claro · · Last activity · 30 posts · 1,461 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Road Cycling
Published
20 June 2004
Last activity
24 June 2004
Original author
Claro
Posts
30
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,461
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 30
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. As a practicing emergency physician for 15 years, I can tell
    you that the reason given - the doctors told him he must be
    off the bike 10 days after "a boil was removed from his
    butt" is a load of excrement. There is no "boil", unless it
    were some sort of metastatic cancer that would REQUIRE that.
    There is something foul smelling coming from that butt story
    I'll tell you. It smell like doping to me.

  2. Claro said:

    There is no "boil"

    Of course, just as There Is No Spoon. I don't know what the
    accepted medical terms are for boil / cyst / carbuncle, but
    I do know you don't want to sit on your perineum for 4 hours
    a day when it is kaputt.

  3. Claro said:

    As a practicing emergency physician for 15 years, I can
    tell you that the reason given - the doctors told him he
    must be off the bike 10 days after "a boil was removed
    from his butt" is a load of excrement. There is no "boil",
    unless it were some sort of metastatic cancer that would
    REQUIRE that. There is something foul smelling coming from
    that butt story I'll tell you. It smell like doping to me.

    I sure hope I never end up in your emergency room Sport.

    -- Boils and "in-grown hairs": Both of these are from
    bacterial infections. "In-grown hairs," or folliculitis, is
    not such a problem, occurs frequently where you have a lot
    of rubbing and a lot of hair in tight clothing, and tend to
    heal on their own without causing pain. On the other hand,
    boils, or furuncle, which look a lot like acne are from
    bacterial infections, and can become large, hard, and
    really, really hurt! You really don't want to get a boil in
    the wrong place, or your bike won't seem so friendly to you
    anymore! If this is a frequent problem, ask your physician
    about preventative treatment with anti-bacterial ointments.
    The important lesson here is to always wear clean shorts,
    and to get out of your cycling clothes as soon as you can
    after a ride.

    le Vent a Dos Davey Crockett No e-patents, pas de brevets
    logiciels Pétition contre les brevets logiciels :
    petition.eurolinux.orgpetition.eurolinux.org Six-Day site:
    members.rogers.comsixday.html Please address
    all replies to the list

  4. To Crockett and Dronkert, Ok so it hurts a bit at the time.
    After an I&D and some strong antibiotics the infection
    should clear in a day or two leaving a small incision that
    should be less painful than some road rash. Perhaps it could
    take a little longer, but in almost all typical cases, it is
    healed within a week and the pain is mostly gone well before
    that. You must remember that these guys are professional
    athletes and their career is built on participation in the
    Tour and similar big ticket events. They are not wimpy and
    have been know to complete the enite Tour with a broken
    clavicle - something FAR more painful than a zit 10 days
    after it was drained.

    As far as being my patient in the ED, I'd treat you like I
    would any other person with a boil on their butt and a very
    low tolerance for pain. I'd also realize that you were not
    World Road Race Champion or Tour De France material, but I'd
    keep that to myself.

  5. Quoted message said:

    From: "Claro"

    Quoted message said:

    To Crockett and Dronkert, Ok so it hurts a bit at the time.
    After an I&D and some strong antibiotics the infection
    should clear in a day or two leaving a small incision that
    should be less painful than some road rash. Perhaps it
    could take a little longer, but in almost all typical
    cases, it is healed within a week and the pain is mostly
    gone well before that. You must remember that these guys
    are professional athletes and their career is built on
    participation in the Tour and similar big ticket events.
    They are not wimpy and have been know to complete the enite
    Tour with a broken clavicle - something FAR more painful
    than a zit 10 days after it was drained.

    As far as being my patient in the ED, I'd treat you like I
    would any other person with a boil on their butt and a very
    low tolerance for pain. I'd also realize that you were not
    World Road Race Champion or Tour De France material, but
    I'd keep that to myself.

  6. Now, *with content* (IMHO)

    Quoted message said:

    From: "Claro"

    Quoted message said:

    You must remember that these guys are professional
    athletes and their career is built on participation in the
    Tour and similar big ticket events. They are not wimpy and
    have been know to complete the enite Tour with a broken
    clavicle - something FAR more painful than a zit 10 days
    after it was drained.

    At least a couple of names come up. Merckx, Kelly. Boils,
    out of races. Also not wimps by all accounts.

    Quoted message said:

    Perhaps it could take a little longer, but in almost all
    typical cases, it is healed within a week and the pain is
    mostly gone well before that.

    Maybe the ten days was a form of quarrantine, IOW mandatory
    rest (not just a pain issue).

    Quoted message said:

    I'd also realize that you were not World Road Race Champion
    or Tour De France material, but I'd keep that >to myself.

    And the put-down. Atta boy, doc. --TP

  7. Claro said:

    To Crockett and Dronkert, Ok so it hurts a bit at the
    time. After an I&D and some strong antibiotics the
    infection should clear in a day or two leaving a small
    incision that should be less painful than some road rash.
    Perhaps it could take a little longer, but in almost all
    typical cases, it is healed within a week and the pain is
    mostly gone well before that. You must remember that these
    guys are professional athletes and their career is built
    on participation in the Tour and similar big ticket
    events. They are not wimpy and have been know to complete
    the enite Tour with a broken clavicle - something FAR more
    painful than a zit 10 days after it was drained.

    As far as being my patient in the ED, I'd treat you like I
    would any other person with a boil on their butt and a
    very low tolerance for pain. I'd also realize that you
    were not World Road Race Champion or Tour De France
    material, but I'd keep that to myself.

    Well now [censored], Davey holds Accounting Designations in
    several countries.

    What he does not do, however, is go shouting off his big
    mouth about this that or the other TaxPayer cheating on his
    Income Taxes even more so when he has no idea whether
    someone is or is not cheating.

    So please don't go shouting your big mouth off about whether
    a racer is or is not taking DRUGS

    --
    le Vent a Dos Davey Crockett No e-patents, pas de brevets
    logiciels Pétition contre les brevets logiciels :
    petition.eurolinux.orgpetition.eurolinux.org Six-Day site:
    members.rogers.comsixday.html Please address
    all replies to the list

  8. "Claro" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    To Crockett and Dronkert, Ok so it hurts a bit at the
    time. After an I&D and some strong antibiotics the
    infection should clear in a day or two leaving a small
    incision that should be less painful than some road rash.
    Perhaps it could take a little longer, but in almost all
    typical cases, it is healed within a week and the pain is
    mostly gone well before that. You must remember that these
    guys are professional athletes and their career is built
    on participation in the Tour and similar big ticket
    events. They are not wimpy and have been know to complete
    the enite Tour with a broken clavicle - something FAR more
    painful than a zit 10 days after it was drained.

    As far as being my patient in the ED, I'd treat you like I
    would any other person with a boil on their butt and a
    very low tolerance for pain. I'd also realize that you
    were not World Road Race Champion or Tour De France
    material, but I'd keep that to myself.

    Do a search for Baden Cooke on how he suffered last fall
    when there were no races on the line, simply from the flight
    back to OZ after crotch surgery.

  9. This issue is not if a boil hurts - of course it does. The
    issue is if one would confidently predict that it would put
    one out of an extremely important event 10 DAYS AFTER IT WAS
    TREATED. That, my friends, is HIGHLY UNUSUAL, especially for
    a world class athlete who has been shown to be capable of
    dealing with much more pain than that in the past. I repeat,
    10 DAYS AFTER it is treated. Think about it. Something there
    is very fishy.

    Davey, it would be reasonable for you to suspect someone of
    cheating if their books did not balance, and if they were a
    public figure such as government official in volved in
    taxation, I'd say the right thing to do would be to raise
    the issue for further exploration.

  10. Claro said:

    As a practicing emergency physician for 15 years, I can
    tell you that the reason given - the doctors told him he
    must be off the bike 10 days after "a boil was removed
    from his butt" is a load of excrement. There is no "boil",
    unless it were some sort of metastatic cancer that would
    REQUIRE that. There is something foul smelling coming from
    that butt story I'll tell you. It smell like doping to me.

    Some rather vivid imagery there.

    Steve

  11. "Claro" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    To Crockett and Dronkert, Ok so it hurts a bit at the
    time. After an I&D and some strong antibiotics the
    infection should clear in a day or two leaving a small
    incision that should be less painful than some road rash.
    Perhaps it could take a little longer, but in almost all
    typical cases, it is healed within a week and the pain is
    mostly gone well before that. You must remember that these
    guys are professional athletes and their career is built
    on participation in the Tour and similar big ticket
    events. They are not wimpy and have been know to complete
    the enite Tour with a broken clavicle - something FAR more
    painful than a zit 10 days after it was drained.

    Even a boil that is removed from the area where you must
    sit? I don't think so.

    Quoted message said:

    As far as being my patient in the ED, I'd treat you like I
    would any other person with a boil on their butt and a
    very low tolerance for pain. I'd also realize that you
    were not World Road Race Champion or Tour De France
    material, but I'd keep that to myself.

  12. On 06/20/2004 08:25 AM, in article [email hidden],

    Claro said:

    This issue is not if a boil hurts - of course it does. The
    issue is if one would confidently predict that it would
    put one out of an extremely important event 10 DAYS AFTER
    IT WAS TREATED. That, my friends, is HIGHLY UNUSUAL,
    especially for a world class athlete who has been shown to
    be capable of dealing with much more pain than that in the
    past. I repeat, 10 DAYS AFTER it is treated. Think about
    it. Something there is very fishy.

    Don't you think that being off the bike, unable to train,
    for 10-days might make you lose enough fitness that you
    would no longer be an asset to your team during an event as
    important as the Tour?

    While it is possible (or even likely) that Freire would not
    have any more pain after 10-days, the team management has a
    responsibility to its sponsors to bring the best possible
    team to the Tour, so they substitute a rider who does not
    lose 10-days of training time and thus is closer to peak
    fitness on July 3.

    Quoted message said:

    Davey, it would be reasonable for you to suspect someone
    of cheating if their books did not balance, and if they
    were a public figure such as government official in volved
    in taxation, I'd say the right thing to do would be to
    raise the issue for further exploration.

    --
    Steven L. Sheffield stevens at veloworks dot com veloworks
    at worldnet dot ay tea tee dot net bellum pax est libertas
    servitus est ignoratio vis est ess ay ell tea ell ay kay ee
    sea aye tee why you ti ay aitch aitch tee tea pea colon [for
    word] slash [four ward] slash double-you double-yew double-
    ewe dot veloworks dot com [four word] slash

  13. "Claro" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    As a practicing emergency physician for 15 years, I can
    tell you that the reason given - the doctors told him he
    must be off the bike 10 days after "a boil was removed
    from his butt" is a load of excrement. There is no "boil",
    unless it were some sort of metastatic cancer that would
    REQUIRE that. There is something foul smelling coming from
    that butt story I'll tell you. It smell like doping to me.

    Tell that to Oscar Sevilla who, if I remember correctly,
    missed most of last year because of similar problems.

  14. Quoted message said:

    From: "Claro"

    Quoted message said:

    The issue is if one would confidently predict that it
    would put one out of an extremely important event 10 DAYS
    AFTER IT WAS TREATED. That, my friends, is HIGHLY UNUSUAL,
    especially for a world class athlete who has been shown to
    be capable of dealing with much more pain than that in the
    past. I repeat, 10 DAYS AFTER it is treated. Think about
    it. Something there is very fishy.

    Thought about it. Only *might* be "fishy".

    Is this Walsh spillover? Dope is everywhere?

    You gonna tell me an incision heals completely in ten days?
    I had a friend who "let a boil go" and had a very nasty
    infection that could have easily killed him (according to
    the treating docs). Hence, a responsible doctor might
    "advise" staying off the bike (and out of bike shorts) until
    the skin was fully healed. Note, like the Walsh book, the
    butt in question is not in evidence here. Thank you. --TP

  15. Claro said:

    Davey, it would be reasonable for you to suspect someone
    of cheating if their books did not balance, and if they
    were a public figure such as government official in volved
    in taxation, I'd say the right thing to do would be to
    raise the issue for further exploration.

    At last. Someone willing to come out and tell the truth
    about Enron, WTC, Oklahoma, Waco, Abu Ghraib, monica, JFK,
    Nixon, Casper Hauser. The whole damn lid is gonna come off
    now I tell ya thanks to our new found friend with the
    willingness to raise all of these issues for further
    exploration.

    Next time on ER...

  16. Claro said:

    a broken clavicle - something FAR more painful than a zit
    10 days after it was drained.

    Well, there's gradations in everything, right? Just finished
    today's training of 6x 7' out of the saddle @53x13/14, 3'
    rest. Very satisfying, when back at home. Like always, it
    made me think of the story about Gert-Jan Theunisse; how he
    had such a nasty infection that he couldn't sit down for
    weeks. He still wanted to ride, so just removed the saddle
    and post and continued his regular lots-of-hours-a-day
    training. Respect. ("Madness! Madness, I say."😉

  17. "Claro" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    As a practicing emergency physician for 15 years, I can
    tell you that the reason given - the doctors told him he
    must be off the bike 10 days after "a boil was removed
    from his butt" is a load of excrement. There is no "boil",
    unless it were some sort of metastatic cancer that would
    REQUIRE that. There is something foul smelling coming from
    that butt story I'll tell you. It smell like doping to me.

    You may be an experienced physician but you seem not to
    understand the principles of aerobic performance. After 48
    hours off of a training regiment the drop in aerobic
    capacity is already measurable, and after 10 days it's
    quite serious.

    -Sonarrat.

  18. Claro said:

    You must remember that these guys are professional
    athletes and their career is built on participation in the
    Tour and similar big ticket events.

    I thought Freire's career was built on hitting top form less
    than a handful of extremely big one day events (MSR, Amstel
    Gold, World Championships) and anything that would risk that
    should be avoided.

    JT

  19. jt10000.comsut99jt1.htm

    JT

  20. "Ewoud Dronkert" <[email hidden]> schreef in bericht
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    Claro said:

    a broken clavicle - something FAR more painful than a
    zit 10 days after it was drained.

    Well, there's gradations in everything, right? Just
    finished today's training of 6x 7' out of the saddle
    @53x13/14, 3' rest. Very satisfying, when back at home.
    Like always, it made me think of the story about Gert-Jan
    Theunisse; how he had such a nasty infection that he
    couldn't sit down for weeks. He still wanted to ride, so
    just removed the saddle and post and continued his regular
    lots-of-hours-a-day training. Respect. ("Madness! Madness,
    I say."😉

    And what about Nicolas Barone in the Tour of 1957? He
    suffered from two boils and could't sit down for a moment.
    Everybody told him to abandon, but he was first in the
    classification of the most combatitive rider and that meant
    5000 francs, which was a lot of money in the '50's. So
    during five stages - among which two in the Pyrenees and a
    TT - his butt didn't touch his saddle. He finished five
    times last but every time within the time
    limit. To add to his misfortune, in the TT he lost his first
    place in the combatitive classification to Anquetil.
    But all's well that end's well: in the last stage to
    Paris his pain was much less, so he attacked all day
    and reconquered his first place.

    Benjo Maso

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.