General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Fish

Started by Virginia Tadrzynski · · Last activity · 69 posts · 1,088 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
18 May 2006
Last activity
27 May 2006
Original author
Virginia Tadrzynski
Posts
69
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,088
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 41–60 of 69
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Steve Pope wrote on Monday, May 22, 2006:

    Quoted message said:

    That's my experience as well, although here (California) there
    isn't any fresh wild salmon yet, and they are predicting a delayed
    season with a small harvest.

    <snip>

    I bought some (Coho) at the Campbell farmers market yesterday. Might
    have
    been from Oregon. I usually ask, but I may have forgotten in my
    eagerness to
    find shelter from the rain.

  2. KevinS said:

    Steve Pope wrote on Monday, May 22, 2006:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    That's my experience as well, although here (California) there
    isn't any fresh wild salmon yet, and they are predicting a delayed
    season with a small harvest.

    Quoted message said:

    I bought some (Coho) at the Campbell farmers market yesterday. Might
    have
    been from Oregon. I usually ask, but I may have forgotten in my
    eagerness to
    find shelter from the rain.

    I'm told there are some very limited areas being opened for
    limited times for salmon fishing along the California coast.
    Nowhere near normal levels.

    Steve

  3. Steve Pope said:

    I'm told there are some very limited areas being opened for
    limited times for salmon fishing along the California coast.
    Nowhere near normal levels.

    Good thing we have salmon farms, or wild salmon would be overfished to
    extinction.

    --Blair

  4. J said:

    Steve Pope <[email hidden]> wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    For me, salmon is one of the best fishes for eating, particularly
    if you like grilling it because it goes really well with a bit
    of smoke infused in it.

    Quoted message said:

    I agree. I love salmon. It is strong flavored, so I can
    understand why some people don't like it -- some people
    don't like dark meat chicken either.

    Funny you should mention that, tonight for dinner I made
    Chicken Cacciatore, using a pound of boneless thigh meat chicken.
    The usual ingredients, plus I put about two ounces of
    chopped pastrami into the tomato sauce. An easy recipe
    (I'll post details of it if anyone's intereseted).

    Steve

  5. Blair P. Houghton said:
    Steve Pope said:

    I'm told there are some very limited areas being opened for
    limited times for salmon fishing along the California coast.
    Nowhere near normal levels.

    Good thing we have salmon farms, or wild salmon would be overfished to
    extinction.

    --Blair

    Salmon farms are no salvation for wild salmon; in fact they pose real
    threats to the wild population.
    For North Americam locations (except Alaska and some locations in BC)
    habitat distruction is the largest factor in the stock's decline - not
    overfishing.

    Ken.

    --
    Volunteer your idle computer time for cancer research
    http//www.grid.org/download/gold/download.htm
    Return address courtesy of Spammotel http://www.spammotel.com/

  6. "Steve Pope" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:
    J said:

    Steve Pope <[email hidden]> wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    For me, salmon is one of the best fishes for eating, particularly
    if you like grilling it because it goes really well with a bit
    of smoke infused in it.

    Quoted message said:

    I agree. I love salmon. It is strong flavored, so I can
    understand why some people don't like it -- some people
    don't like dark meat chicken either.

    Funny you should mention that, tonight for dinner I made
    Chicken Cacciatore, using a pound of boneless thigh meat chicken.
    The usual ingredients, plus I put about two ounces of
    chopped pastrami into the tomato sauce. An easy recipe
    (I'll post details of it if anyone's intereseted).

    Steve

    I have a relative who frequents the best of restaurants. He will not even
    taste salmon because of the salmon cakes he ate as a kid.
    I guess I'm the same way, I will not eat dark meat of any birds, because
    when we did eat chicken, the kids never got the white meat -- I hate dark
    meat. DH loves it.
    Dee Dee

  7. Ken Davey said:
    Blair P. Houghton said:

    Good thing we have salmon farms, or wild salmon would be overfished to
    extinction.

    Salmon farms are no salvation for wild salmon; in fact they pose real
    threats to the wild population.
    For North Americam locations (except Alaska and some locations in BC)
    habitat distruction is the largest factor in the stock's decline - not
    overfishing.

    You're falling for anti-farming propaganda.

    --Blair

  8. Quoted message said:


    Ken Davey said:
    Blair P. Houghton said:

    Good thing we have salmon farms, or wild salmon would be overfished to
    extinction.

    Salmon farms are no salvation for wild salmon; in fact they pose real
    threats to the wild population.
    For North Americam locations (except Alaska and some locations in BC)
    habitat distruction is the largest factor in the stock's decline - not
    overfishing.

    You're falling for anti-farming propaganda.

    What I want to know is do you type all of these responses out by hand
    or is this like a perl script cron job kinda thing?

  9. tert in seattle said:

    What I want to know is do you type all of these responses out by hand
    or is this like a perl script cron job kinda thing?

    No, I just put the truth into words. It's easier than, clearly, you
    think.

    --Blair

  10. Blair P. Houghton said:
    Ken Davey said:
    Blair P. Houghton said:

    Good thing we have salmon farms, or wild salmon would be overfished
    to extinction.

    Salmon farms are no salvation for wild salmon; in fact they pose real
    threats to the wild population.
    For North Americam locations (except Alaska and some locations in BC)
    habitat distruction is the largest factor in the stock's decline -
    not overfishing.

    You're falling for anti-farming propaganda.

    --Blair

    Just where do YOU live?
    I live on the North Coast of British Columnia and this topic is of great
    importance here.
    To be sure, there is a great deal of propaganda on both sides of this debate
    but the bottom line is that farming does have several negative impacts on
    the native stocks and the enviorment. For one - the ocean floor under a farm
    becomes loaded with waste and smothers any life found there. Sea lice are
    another problem. Farms provide an unatural year-round reservoir for these
    parasites which translates into increased mortality for native stock fry.
    The inevitable escape of non-native fish are a real threat to native stocks.
    Chemicals used in the farming industry' are injurous to the enviorment and
    not conducive to human health. Collateral damage to other costal wild life
    also occurrs as farm operators try to control losses due to 'preditors'.
    Attitudes such as yours ("decreased pressure on native stocks" is one
    example) indicate that you have swallowed the propaanda of the farming lobby
    'hook line and sinker".
    I suggest that you do some basic research before mouthing off.

    Ken.
    --
    Volunteer your idle computer time for cancer research
    http//www.grid.org/download/gold/download.htm
    Return address courtesy of Spammotel http://www.spammotel.com/

  11. Blair P. Houghton said:
    tert in seattle said:

    What I want to know is do you type all of these responses out by hand
    or is this like a perl script cron job kinda thing?

    No, I just put the truth into words. It's easier than, clearly, you
    think.

    --Blair

    YOUR truth is seriously flawed.

    Ken.

    --
    Volunteer your idle computer time for cancer research
    http//www.grid.org/download/gold/download.htm
    Return address courtesy of Spammotel http://www.spammotel.com/

  12. Virginia Tadrzynski said:

    Good news.....I got a promotion. I am now the 'Seafood Leader' at the
    grocery I now work at (they call me Leader because if they called me
    department manager they'd have to pay me more). Now the big question for my
    friends the foodies......

    Always flounder, salmon, tilapia and catfish, over and over and over. I
    tried croakers but the supplier sent bad ones and I sent them back. I just
    ordered mahi-mahi and monkfish to be delivered Friday, I have an order in
    for sea bass and I am contemplating red snapper....none of these have been
    in stock before at this store. We are north of Philly and a few miles south
    of Allentown, PA. Question for the lot of you is this: I need
    suggestions. What are good 'marketable' fish? I'd love to put a whole
    squid in the case just to catch the eye, but I don't want to take the $$
    hit, because I know it won't sell. Any suggestions?
    -Ginny

    Large scallops?

  13. "dee" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    Virginia Tadrzynski said:

    Good news.....I got a promotion. I am now the 'Seafood Leader' at the
    grocery I now work at (they call me Leader because if they called me
    department manager they'd have to pay me more). Now the big question for
    my
    friends the foodies......

    Always flounder, salmon, tilapia and catfish, over and over and over. I
    tried croakers but the supplier sent bad ones and I sent them back. I
    just
    ordered mahi-mahi and monkfish to be delivered Friday, I have an order in
    for sea bass and I am contemplating red snapper....none of these have
    been
    in stock before at this store. We are north of Philly and a few miles
    south
    of Allentown, PA. Question for the lot of you is this: I need
    suggestions. What are good 'marketable' fish? I'd love to put a whole
    squid in the case just to catch the eye, but I don't want to take the $$
    hit, because I know it won't sell. Any suggestions?
    -Ginny

    Large scallops?

    Go to your supplier and look over the supply; you decide, you are now the
    'seafood leader.'
    Happy Days!
    Dee Dee

  14. Ken Davey said:
    Blair P. Houghton said:

    No, I just put the truth into words. It's easier than, clearly, you
    think.

    YOUR truth is seriously flawed.

    No doubt in many ways on many issues. But on this issue my experience
    has been that the anti-fish-farming zealots and their dupes will ignore
    their
    own ridiculous fallacies whether they are given the truth or not.

    They even managed to con a legislature into demanding that farmed fish
    be labeled "color added" because they eat the same colorant that wild
    fish do...

    --Blair

  15. Ken Davey said:

    Just where do YOU live?
    I live on the North Coast of British Columnia and this topic is of great
    importance here.

    Fallacy. Your location doesn't make you better informed.

    Quoted message said:

    To be sure, there is a great deal of propaganda on both sides of this debate
    but the bottom line is that farming does have several negative impacts on
    the native stocks and the enviorment.

    Without farming, there would be no native stocks left.

    --Blair

  16. Blair P. Houghton said:

    Without farming, there would be no native stocks left.

    That's flat-ass ridiculous.

    Steve

  17. Steve Pope said:
    Blair P. Houghton said:

    Without farming, there would be no native stocks left.

    That's flat-ass ridiculous.

    99% of the fresh salmon in American markets is farmed.

    If there were no farmed salmon, that demand would still be there.

    How long do you suppose salmon stocks would last once the nets closed
    every creek from California to Alaska?

    Here's a hint: purse-seine fishing is 80-90% efficient. I.e., 80-90%
    of the fish trying to get up that stream are caught while the nets are
    out. Convolve that with insatiable demand that leads to maximized
    fishing time and efficiency, and it's an 80-90% reduction in the
    breeding stock. Every year.

    Salmon would no longer be food. Many breeds and/or species would
    simply no longer be.

    There are ways to reduce sea-lice. There's no way to reduce demand for
    fish. Except to raise the price. Which is what the progenitors of the
    anti-farming movement are really after.

    Flat-assed ridiculous is what every "farmed salmon are bad" zealot
    turns into when the simple truth kicks their credulousness out from
    under them.

    --Blair

  18. Quoted message said:


    Steve Pope said:
    Blair P. Houghton said:

    Without farming, there would be no native stocks left.

    That's flat-ass ridiculous.

    99% of the fresh salmon in American markets is farmed.

    If there were no farmed salmon, that demand would still be there.

    How long do you suppose salmon stocks would last once the nets closed
    every creek from California to Alaska?

    Here's a hint: purse-seine fishing is 80-90% efficient. I.e., 80-90%
    of the fish trying to get up that stream are caught while the nets are
    out. Convolve that with insatiable demand that leads to maximized
    fishing time and efficiency, and it's an 80-90% reduction in the
    breeding stock. Every year.

    Salmon would no longer be food. Many breeds and/or species would
    simply no longer be.

    There are ways to reduce sea-lice. There's no way to reduce demand for
    fish. Except to raise the price. Which is what the progenitors of the
    anti-farming movement are really after.

    your tinfoil is showing

  19. Blair P. Houghton said:

    Steve Pope wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Without farming, there would be no native stocks left.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    That's flat-ass ridiculous.

    Quoted message said:

    99% of the fresh salmon in American markets is farmed.

    Quoted message said:

    If there were no farmed salmon, that demand would still be there.

    Can you wrap your head around the concept that fishing can
    be regulated so that populations are not depleted?

    S.

  20. Steve Pope said:

    Can you wrap your head around the concept that fishing can
    be regulated so that populations are not depleted?

    Not when I can wrap it around the fact that farmed fish satisfy the
    demand and the side-effects can be repaired without shutting down the
    industry.

    You feckless luddites can just go hungry.

    --Blair

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.