Edwin Pawlowski said:
"Derek Lyons" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Quoted message said:Dimitri said:We are creating a generation of misinformed idiots;
No, we are living in an age where food snobs are attempting to define
each and every term with a single meaning - even if it does not have
such in it's native enviroment.
D.
Well durruk (you don't mind me calling you durruck do you? Derek would just
seen so snobby) here is my take on the situation.
Yes, I do mind. I mind greatly that you handwave and insult rather
than discussing the issue.
Quoted message said:It is because most of those terms do have a single meaning. This morning I
drove through some deep water across the road. But my car is still a car,
not a boat.
So what? Nobody called your car a boat. But 'pot roast' covers a
wide range of braised beef dishes in the same general family for
eample. There is no 'standard' pot roast recipe. There is no such
thing as a standard 'minestrone' recipe. (There are certain general
similarities of course arising from the cuisine.) There is no such
thing as a single style of BBQ - what a Texan calls BBQ is considered
dog food in the Piedmont, and vice versa. 'Alfredo' is a sauce, not a
dish, etc... etc...
Quoted message said:The problem is that many people are too damned lazy to re-name a product and
want to hop aboard the popularity of an existing product no matter how much
they vary it. These are often the same whacko's that perpetrate political
correctness in speech, We can (and should) now call a rose by any other
name. A dead rose is now color impaired.
Certaintly. But the opposite effect (that I alluded to originally)
also occurs, misinformed people applying a general term to a specific
dish or preparation. (See the discussion on 'pesto' elsethread for
example, or BBQ.)
There's also the effect that food is a living thing - it grows and
evolves over time. It's not static.
Quoted message said:Nope, not food snobs, but people that actually learn and use the proper
names for different dishes. But we do appreciate your thoughts, Mr. Lions.
You don't think, you just insult and handwave.
D.
--
Touch-twice life. Eat. Drink. Laugh.
-Resolved: To be more temperate in my postings.
Oct 5th, 2004 JDL