General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Cooking with gas or electric?

Started by Austin Powers · · Last activity · 11 posts · 323 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
22 November 2007
Last activity
23 November 2007
Original author
Austin Powers
Posts
11
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
323
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–11 of 11
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I currently have an all gas oven and love cooking with gas on the stove.

    However, I'm drawn to using electricity for my oven. What are some
    thoughts/experiences on this?

    PS The oven I am thinking of buying is the KitchenAid KDSS907SSS ...I like
    the stainless stell, the digital read-out and the 'InstaWok' feature that
    lets me use a wok.

  2. Austin Powers said:

    I currently have an all gas oven and love cooking with gas on the stove.

    However, I'm drawn to using electricity for my oven. What are some
    thoughts/experiences on this?

    PS The oven I am thinking of buying is the KitchenAid KDSS907SSS ...I like
    the stainless stell, the digital read-out and the 'InstaWok' feature that
    lets me use a wok.

    Maybe expensive electric ovens are OK, but cheap ones suck. My wife
    is a baker (couldn't cook an entree to save her life), and she insists
    on gas.

    --Bryan

  3. Austin Powers said:


    I currently have an all gas oven and love cooking with gas on the stove. However, I'm drawn to using electricity for my oven. �

    Why... do you have stock in your local electric utility company?

    Quoted message said:

    What are some thoughts/experiences on this?

    Your cost for oven energy use will rise about four-fold, and for no
    benefit derived whatsoever. Not to mention that you will need a 220
    Volt - 60 Amp dedicated line installed, not inexpensive, can easily
    cost more than you pay for your new stove.

    The GE Profile gas range is available with a convection gas oven...
    just one model of many: http://tinyurl.com/32nle6

    http://products.geappliances.com/ApplProducts/Dispatcher?CHANNEL=CH0004&REQUEST=SPECPAGE&SITEID=DER&SKU=JGB915BEFBB

    Sheldon

  4. "Austin Powers" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    I currently have an all gas oven and love cooking with gas on the stove.

    However, I'm drawn to using electricity for my oven. What are some
    thoughts/experiences on this?

    PS The oven I am thinking of buying is the KitchenAid KDSS907SSS ...I like
    the stainless stell, the digital read-out and the 'InstaWok' feature that
    lets me use a wok.


    I don't like a gas oven for baking or roasting. Bread and roasts don't
    brown as nicely.
    Janet

  5. Bobo Bonobo(R) said:


    Austin Powers said:

    I currently have an all gas oven and love cooking with gas on the stove.

    However, I'm drawn to using electricity for my oven. What are some
    thoughts/experiences on this?

    PS The oven I am thinking of buying is the KitchenAid KDSS907SSS ...I like
    the stainless stell, the digital read-out and the 'InstaWok' feature that
    lets me use a wok.

    Maybe expensive electric ovens are OK, but cheap ones suck. My wife
    is a baker (couldn't cook an entree to save her life), and she insists
    on gas.

    --Bryan

    There are differences between gas and electric for sure. Electric ovens
    with typically hold a tighter temperature tolerance than gas ovens and
    gas ovens introduce humidity into the oven from the combustion that
    electric ovens do not. I don't believe either is a must have better
    than, certainly not the way the cook top burners are.

    Personally I have a dual fuel range with LP burners up top and electric
    convection main oven and electric side oven which seems to give me the
    best of everything. I've also used commercial double stack convection
    ovens in both gas and electric and not found much operational difference
    between them.

  6. Janet B. said:

    "Austin Powers" wrote:

    I currently have an all gas oven and love cooking with gas on the stove.

    Quoted message said:

    However, I'm drawn to using electricity for my oven. �What are some
    thoughts/experiences on this?

    Quoted message said:

    PS The oven I am thinking of buying is the KitchenAid KDSS907SSS ...I like
    the stainless stell, the digital read-out and the 'InstaWok' feature that
    lets me use a wok.

    I don't like a gas oven for baking or roasting. �Bread and roasts don't
    brown as nicely.
    Janet

    Nonsense... you were obviously a [censored] poor science student in JHS.
    Temperature is temperature, the same with either... and the moisture
    argument is myth. The only time condensation is present in a gas
    oven is when first lit, it's gone before 150F is reached. There is
    less water vapor produced and introduced from burning gas than their
    is coming off the cooking food itself... and in either case it all
    vents out anyway. So there is no more or less humidity present in a
    hot gas oven as in a hot electric oven. And gas ovens are actually
    more temperature accurate for the same reason gas top burners are more
    accurate, they are instant on and off... electric element temperature
    still heats after turned off from residual heat (anyone with an
    electric cooktop should know this) and tends to heat above the
    thermostat setting and then needs more time to reheat from off
    permitting the oven to cool... so the drift in either direction with
    electric is a bit wider, and that's with thermostat anticipators being
    equal for both.... but you're talking perhaps +/- 2 degrees, totally
    meaningless for cooking regardless of fuel type. If you have a
    problem with browning there is one reason and one reason ONLY, you
    don't know how to cook.

    Sheldon

  7. "Sheldon" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Janet B. said:

    "Austin Powers" wrote:

    I currently have an all gas oven and love cooking with gas on the stove.

    Quoted message said:

    However, I'm drawn to using electricity for my oven. ?What are some
    thoughts/experiences on this?

    Quoted message said:

    PS The oven I am thinking of buying is the KitchenAid KDSS907SSS ...I
    like
    the stainless stell, the digital read-out and the 'InstaWok' feature
    that
    lets me use a wok.

    I don't like a gas oven for baking or roasting. ?Bread and roasts don't
    brown as nicely.
    Janet

    Nonsense... you were obviously a [censored] poor science student in JHS.
    Temperature is temperature, the same with either... and the moisture
    argument is myth. The only time condensation is present in a gas
    oven is when first lit, it's gone before 150F is reached. There is
    less water vapor produced and introduced from burning gas than their
    is coming off the cooking food itself... and in either case it all
    vents out anyway. So there is no more or less humidity present in a
    hot gas oven as in a hot electric oven. And gas ovens are actually
    more temperature accurate for the same reason gas top burners are more
    accurate, they are instant on and off... electric element temperature
    still heats after turned off from residual heat (anyone with an
    electric cooktop should know this) and tends to heat above the
    thermostat setting and then needs more time to reheat from off
    permitting the oven to cool... so the drift in either direction with
    electric is a bit wider, and that's with thermostat anticipators being
    equal for both.... but you're talking perhaps +/- 2 degrees, totally
    meaningless for cooking regardless of fuel type. If you have a
    problem with browning there is one reason and one reason ONLY, you
    don't know how to cook.

    Sheldon
    Or, perhaps you're just an indifferent cook and can't tell the difference?
    Janet

  8. The message <[email hidden]>
    from "Austin Powers" <[email hidden]> contains these words:

    Quoted message said:

    I currently have an all gas oven and love cooking with gas on the stove.

    Quoted message said:

    However, I'm drawn to using electricity for my oven. What are some
    thoughts/experiences on this?

    Quoted message said:

    PS The oven I am thinking of buying is the KitchenAid KDSS907SSS ...I like
    the stainless stell, the digital read-out and the 'InstaWok' feature that
    lets me use a wok.

    I learned to cook on gas and it took me a while to get used to
    cooking with electricity; but I much prefer it now . I hate cooking on
    my sons' gas cookers.

    Features I like; two glass-door, illuminated ovens, which can be
    used independently. The large one is fan-assisted and self-cleaning.
    Both can be set on a timer to turn themselves on and off automatically,
    very useful if you're out a lot. It's got a stainless steel outer shell
    which is very easy to clean. The ceramic hob is also very easy to keep
    clean (and more heat-adjustable than gas, IME).

    Janet

  9. "Sheldon" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Austin Powers said:


    I currently have an all gas oven and love cooking with gas on the stove.


    However, I'm drawn to using electricity for my oven. ?

    Why... do you have stock in your local electric utility company?

    Quoted message said:

    What are some thoughts/experiences on this?

    Your cost for oven energy use will rise about four-fold, and for no
    benefit derived whatsoever.

    For summer use consider your air conditioning bill. Fire consumes air --
    and as a result it's always pumping hot gases into the kitchen. Electric
    consumes no air, produces no pollution in your kitchen. It will not fight
    your air conditioning nearly as much. (This is also true for electric
    burners, for the die hards who prefer them.)

  10. "HiTech RedNeck" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:


    "Sheldon" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Austin Powers said:


    I currently have an all gas oven and love cooking with gas on the stove.


    However, I'm drawn to using electricity for my oven. ?

    Why... do you have stock in your local electric utility company?

    Quoted message said:

    What are some thoughts/experiences on this?


    The following text should have been quoted. It is not mine. It is
    Sheldon's.

    Quoted message said:

    Your cost for oven energy use will rise about four-fold, and for no
    benefit derived whatsoever.

    This text is mine.

    Quoted message said:

    For summer use consider your air conditioning bill. Fire consumes air --
    and as a result it's always pumping hot gases into the kitchen. Electric
    consumes no air, produces no pollution in your kitchen. It will not fight
    your air conditioning nearly as much. (This is also true for electric
    burners, for the die hards who prefer them.)

  11. NoTech RedNeck said:

    ">
    This text is mine.

    Were you HiTech you'd know how to trim posts.

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    For summer use consider your air conditioning bill. �Fire consumes air -
    and as a result it's always pumping hot gases into the kitchen. �Electric
    consumes no air, produces no pollution in your kitchen. �It willnot fight
    your air conditioning nearly as much. �(This is also true for electric
    burners, for the die hards who prefer them.)

    Do you really think cooking with electric negates the four-fold
    savings in energy costs compared with gas... not even close. And
    there is no pollution from gas cooking, cooking food in of itself is
    what produces major pollution... that's why intelligent folks use
    exhaust fans... wtf were you saying about burning up air... you'd
    produce a vacuum to match the one in your skull.

    And who cares... heat is heat regardless of fuel used... only utter
    morons, those with more dollars than brain cells, use their oven
    during hot summer periods... people with even a modicum of
    intelligence do heavy cooking outdoors, mostly with _gas_... some use
    charcaol but a relatively small minority. Hardly anyone has an
    outdoor electric grill, mainly because they are much too expensive to
    operate.

    Most people have electric cooking because mostly their living
    arrangements do not permit gas (apartments, condos, etc.), or they
    already have electric and choose not to expend the dollars to convert,
    and some miniscule proportion doesn't have the testicals to admit
    they're too cheap to convert so instead they claim they're ascared of
    gas.... which is utter foolishness because there are far more house
    fires and electricutions due to electric stoves than there are gas
    stoves that blow up... modern gas appliances are extremely safe, far
    safer than electric.

    I can't remember the last time I lit my oven during warm weather...
    it's the heat produced that negates A/C... you trying to say electric
    cooking produces no heat. duh

    Sheldon

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.