"Jim Ranieri" <nah,> wrote
Quoted message said:"Jim" <[email hidden]> wrote
Quoted message said:
I was a manager at Home Depot for 3 years. That place is a cult. I
screwed some sexy young ladies though.
Ask me anything about flooring..lol
Okay...kitchen redo, floors on the rest of 1st floor are 70 year old oak.
Considering hardwood or tile/stone for kitchen floor.
Downsides of wood:
no way it will match the rest of the floors
susceptible to water damage
Downside of stone/tile:
cold
every time a glass is dropped it explodes into a billion shards
backer board + tile makes for a hefty step up from rest of house
Thoughts from a flooring guy?
Hey, Jim - I'm not a "flooring guy" but I have redone a few kitchen floors,
and I have oak floors in my current house.
Yes, you don't want wood in the kitchen. Since I knew nothing would match,
when I started looking for my current kitchen, I figured I would have to get
a totally different material. I considered cork and bamboo, but they shrink
over time - not good in the kitchen. Water is an issue, too.
I put a tile floor in my last kitchen and while it was lovely and really,
really easy to clean, you're right - you never have to wonder if when you
drop an egg or bowl or glass whether it's going to break. You just have to
figure out how high to jump to avoid the shards.
Another downside: if you drop something heavier, like a...errr...hammer or
metal L-square, you could chip the tile. I had some tough tile (it wasn't
stone or porcelain, but wasn't red mexican brick either) and dropped the
hammer and L-square-thingy together, and both put a little chip in the tile.
Fortunately it was behind the stove, but over time, I could see this
happening again in a more visible place.
SO, that said, what's the answer? I recommend the old-fashioned linoleum. I
just had some put in and I LOVE IT.
It has a wonderful soft velvety feel to it, much warmer than vinyl, and it
went in at the very same height as the oak floor it abuts. (I elected to
have to have the umpteen layers of existing vinyl removed to achieve this).
Stuff doesn't break when dropped (okay, an egg might, but that's why you
have dogs :-), it's a renewable resource, and there are a kajillion colors
and a few patterns to choose from. It cleans really well and nothing has
stained it yet.
The downside is that it is more expensive than vinyl (but probably
comparable to stone or wood) and I don't think you can install it yourself.
Because of all the colors, it does take a little while to settle on the one
that will work in your house. But a friend of mine got some really dark
colors and they look cool. I got a lighter, more mixed orangey-white color
which looked totally wild (like too wild) in the showroom sample, but really
works in the kitchen.
Anyway, just thought I'd pitch the material. People sort of forgot about it
with the advent of vinyl, but I really like it. If I didn't have oak (which
I also love) or newer vinyl everywhere else I'd consider putting more down.
two more cents from
Selene