Road Cycling · Public discussion

Carpel tunnel

Started by SDB · · Last activity · 24 posts · 548 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Road Cycling
Published
16 May 2007
Last activity
19 May 2007
Original author
SDB
Posts
24
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
548
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 24
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I have been diagnosed with carpel tunnel in my right hand. I have trouble
    riding much more than 2 miles before my hand goes numb. I've tried wearing
    a glove. The glove helps a little but it still hurts after a couple miles.
    The discomfort takes all the fun out of riding plus the pain the day after
    riding is pretty bad.

    I've thought about getting aerobars so I could take some of the weight off
    my hands. I've got a mountain bike though and the only bikes I've seen with
    aerobars have drops. Are there aerobars for flat handle bars? Does anyone
    have any other suggestions?

    Thanks!

  2. SDB wrote:
    :: I have been diagnosed with carpel tunnel in my right hand. I have
    :: trouble riding much more than 2 miles before my hand goes numb.
    :: I've tried wearing a glove. The glove helps a little but it still
    :: hurts after a couple miles. The discomfort takes all the fun out of
    :: riding plus the pain the day after riding is pretty bad.
    ::
    :: I've thought about getting aerobars so I could take some of the
    :: weight off my hands. I've got a mountain bike though and the only
    :: bikes I've seen with aerobars have drops. Are there aerobars for
    :: flat handle bars? Does anyone have any other suggestions?
    ::
    :: Thanks!

    A recumbent is a good way to take the weight off your hands.

  3. In article <[email hidden]>,

    SDB said:

    I have been diagnosed with carpel tunnel in my right hand. I have trouble
    riding much more than 2 miles before my hand goes numb. I've tried wearing
    a glove. The glove helps a little but it still hurts after a couple miles.
    The discomfort takes all the fun out of riding plus the pain the day after
    riding is pretty bad.

    I've thought about getting aerobars so I could take some of the weight off
    my hands. I've got a mountain bike though and the only bikes I've seen with
    aerobars have drops. Are there aerobars for flat handle bars? Does anyone
    have any other suggestions?

    My suggestion is pretty cheap & simple: don't strangle
    the handgrips.

    I've rotated the levers on my own mountain bike up toward the
    horizontal (between 3 and 4 o'clock) and sort of lie my palms
    and fingers flat-ish across the handgrips and levers. It's
    quite comfortable, and unlike using aerobars, I always have
    braking control right at my fingertips.

    The worst thing to do is to slump weight down on your wrists
    so your hands bend up & backwards (as when pushing open a
    free-swinging door.) Best is with the wrists slightly
    elevated, or at least straight. Same idea as with those
    wrist supports for computer keyboards.

    I will confess to grasping the handgrips more tightly while
    riding on upgrades; it helps me to pull up on the handlebar.
    I think it also helps me to secure my body for applying more
    force to the pedals.

    So, before investing $$$ in stuff like aerobars, just try
    relaxing your grip, and maybe adjusting your brake lever
    angles to get a comfortable riding posture.

    cheers,
    Tom

    --
    Nothing is safe from me.
    Above address is just a spam midden.
    I'm really at: tkeats curlicue vcn dot bc dot ca

  4. SDB said:

    I have been diagnosed with carpel tunnel in my right hand. I have trouble
    riding much more than 2 miles before my hand goes numb. I've tried wearing
    a glove. The glove helps a little but it still hurts after a couple miles.
    The discomfort takes all the fun out of riding plus the pain the day after
    riding is pretty bad.

    Sorry to hear that.

    Quoted message said:

    I've thought about getting aerobars so I could take some of the weight off
    my hands. I've got a mountain bike though and the only bikes I've seen with
    aerobars have drops. Are there aerobars for flat handle bars?

    I've seen people with them certainly. I imagine most clip-ons would
    work, though you might need shims depending on your bars.

    http://www.nashbar.com/profile.cfm?sku=2609

    Quoted message said:

    Does anyone have any other suggestions?

    1. Get some bar-ends to give you some hand position options.
    2. Switch to something like albatross bars that will change the angle
    you hold your hands at.
    3. Switch to a drop bar bike.

    --
    Dane Buson - [email hidden]
    Who does not trust enough will not be trusted.
    -- Lao Tsu

  5. SDB said:

    I have been diagnosed with carpel tunnel in my right hand. I
    have trouble riding much more than 2 miles before my hand goes
    numb. I've tried wearing a glove. The glove helps a little
    but it still hurts after a couple miles.

    Do you consider your diagnosis to be reliable? Many of my
    friends have been cured of "carpal tunnel" and other forms of
    "repetitive stress disorder" simply by reading some of the books
    by Dr. John Sarno, e.g. _The Mindbody Prescription_. I'm in this
    category myself: biking, as well as typing, was painful, and then
    I read the book, and now I'm completely better.
    --
    Ben Pfaff
    http://benpfaff.org

  6. "Tom Keats" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...
    : In article <[email hidden]>,
    : "SDB" <[email hidden]> writes:
    : > I have been diagnosed with carpel tunnel in my right hand. I have
    trouble
    : > riding much more than 2 miles before my hand goes numb. I've tried
    wearing
    : > a glove. The glove helps a little but it still hurts after a couple
    miles.
    : > The discomfort takes all the fun out of riding plus the pain the day
    after
    : > riding is pretty bad.
    : >
    : > I've thought about getting aerobars so I could take some of the weight
    off
    : > my hands. I've got a mountain bike though and the only bikes I've seen
    with
    : > aerobars have drops. Are there aerobars for flat handle bars? Does
    anyone
    : > have any other suggestions?
    :
    : My suggestion is pretty cheap & simple: don't strangle
    : the handgrips.
    :
    : I've rotated the levers on my own mountain bike up toward the
    : horizontal (between 3 and 4 o'clock) and sort of lie my palms
    : and fingers flat-ish across the handgrips and levers. It's
    : quite comfortable, and unlike using aerobars, I always have
    : braking control right at my fingertips.
    :
    : The worst thing to do is to slump weight down on your wrists
    : so your hands bend up & backwards (as when pushing open a
    : free-swinging door.) Best is with the wrists slightly
    : elevated, or at least straight. Same idea as with those
    : wrist supports for computer keyboards.
    :
    : I will confess to grasping the handgrips more tightly while
    : riding on upgrades; it helps me to pull up on the handlebar.
    : I think it also helps me to secure my body for applying more
    : force to the pedals.
    :
    : So, before investing $$$ in stuff like aerobars, just try
    : relaxing your grip, and maybe adjusting your brake lever
    : angles to get a comfortable riding posture.
    :
    :
    : cheers,
    : Tom
    :

    Thank you very much. My leavers are 4:00ish. I've never paid attention to
    whether I've been using a death grip or not. I'll pay more attention.
    Lightening up could help it won't make it worse.

  7. "Ben Pfaff" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...
    : "SDB" <[email hidden]> writes:
    :
    : > I have been diagnosed with carpel tunnel in my right hand. I
    : > have trouble riding much more than 2 miles before my hand goes
    : > numb. I've tried wearing a glove. The glove helps a little
    : > but it still hurts after a couple miles.
    :
    : Do you consider your diagnosis to be reliable? Many of my
    : friends have been cured of "carpal tunnel" and other forms of
    : "repetitive stress disorder" simply by reading some of the books
    : by Dr. John Sarno, e.g. _The Mindbody Prescription_. I'm in this
    : category myself: biking, as well as typing, was painful, and then
    : I read the book, and now I'm completely better.
    : --
    : Ben Pfaff
    : http://benpfaff.org

    The diagnosis was with some electric shock thing they attached to my
    fingers. Two doctors read the results and independently came to the same
    conclusion. That said, I am all in of solving medical problems in a manor
    that is as non-invasive as possible. Next time I'm at the book store I'll
    take a look. Thank you!

  8. "Dane Buson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...
    : SDB <[email hidden]> wrote:
    : > I have been diagnosed with carpel tunnel in my right hand. I have
    trouble
    : > riding much more than 2 miles before my hand goes numb. I've tried
    wearing
    : > a glove. The glove helps a little but it still hurts after a couple
    miles.
    : > The discomfort takes all the fun out of riding plus the pain the day
    after
    : > riding is pretty bad.
    :
    : Sorry to hear that.
    :
    : > I've thought about getting aerobars so I could take some of the weight
    off
    : > my hands. I've got a mountain bike though and the only bikes I've seen
    with
    : > aerobars have drops. Are there aerobars for flat handle bars?
    :
    : I've seen people with them certainly. I imagine most clip-ons would
    : work, though you might need shims depending on your bars.
    :
    : http://www.nashbar.com/profile.cfm?sku=2609
    :
    : > Does anyone have any other suggestions?
    :
    : 1. Get some bar-ends to give you some hand position options.
    : 2. Switch to something like albatross bars that will change the angle
    : you hold your hands at.
    : 3. Switch to a drop bar bike.
    :
    : --
    : Dane Buson - [email hidden]

    I looked at bar-ends at the LBS and it looks like most of my weight would
    still be on my palms which is causing the pain. That's why I was
    considering the aerobars. Because of your suggestion I Googled albatross
    bars. I liked what I saw. It looks like while cruising I could rest me
    forearm on bars take the weight off my hands.

    Regarding the drop bar bike... its a fine suggestion but my bike is a good
    friend. It would be fair to toss it aside so quickly due to my
    shortcomings. 🙂

  9. "Roger Zoul" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...
    : SDB wrote:
    : :: I have been diagnosed with carpel tunnel in my right hand. I have
    : :: trouble riding much more than 2 miles before my hand goes numb.
    : :: I've tried wearing a glove. The glove helps a little but it still
    : :: hurts after a couple miles. The discomfort takes all the fun out of
    : :: riding plus the pain the day after riding is pretty bad.
    : ::
    : :: I've thought about getting aerobars so I could take some of the
    : :: weight off my hands. I've got a mountain bike though and the only
    : :: bikes I've seen with aerobars have drops. Are there aerobars for
    : :: flat handle bars? Does anyone have any other suggestions?
    : ::
    : :: Thanks!
    :
    : A recumbent is a good way to take the weight off your hands.

    Thank you but my bike has been a reliable friend for the last 6 years.

  10. SDB wrote:
    :: "Roger Zoul" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    :: news:[email hidden]...
    ::: SDB wrote:
    ::::: I have been diagnosed with carpel tunnel in my right hand. I have
    ::::: trouble riding much more than 2 miles before my hand goes numb.
    ::::: I've tried wearing a glove. The glove helps a little but it still
    ::::: hurts after a couple miles. The discomfort takes all the fun out
    ::::: of riding plus the pain the day after riding is pretty bad.
    :::::
    ::::: I've thought about getting aerobars so I could take some of the
    ::::: weight off my hands. I've got a mountain bike though and the only
    ::::: bikes I've seen with aerobars have drops. Are there aerobars for
    ::::: flat handle bars? Does anyone have any other suggestions?
    :::::
    ::::: Thanks!
    :::
    ::: A recumbent is a good way to take the weight off your hands.
    ::
    :: Thank you but my bike has been a reliable friend for the last 6
    :: years.

    And I hope it continues to be, but if not....

  11. SDB said:


    I've thought about getting aerobars so I could take some of the weight off
    my hands. I've got a mountain bike though and the only bikes I've seen with
    aerobars have drops. Are there aerobars for flat handle bars? Does anyone
    have any other suggestions?

    The aerobars don't care what your handlebar setup looks like, I have
    them on an old set of "brama bullhorn" bars (from Scott, iirc). They
    help hand problems greatly, but........

    That said, aerobars put considerable strain on one's neck, with a
    torso down position which requires more head inclination to see
    the road properly.

    They certainly make a difference, whether it's for the better or the
    worse depends very much on one's personal conformation. For me they
    certainly are a help, but not a perfect solution.

    bob prohaska

    Quoted message said:


  12. SDB said:


    The diagnosis was with some electric shock thing they attached to my
    fingers. Two doctors read the results and independently came to the
    same conclusion. That said, I am all in of solving medical problems
    in a manor that is as non-invasive as possible. Next time I'm at the
    book store I'll take a look. Thank you!

    Diagnosis sounds fine, but ...

    Years ago I lost the feeling in the two small fingers in my LEFT hand. I
    went in to Evanston Hospital for an EMG (lots of electric shocks on fingers
    and elsewhere). I got a diagnosis of carpal tunnel in my RIGHT wrist. I
    explained that this didn't match my symptoms very well. The doctor looked at
    the test results again, and explained that I definitely had carpal tunnel in
    my right wrist, and it would be surely start hurting me soon. It might
    someday, but that was in 1989 and I haven't had problems yet. [Haven't gone
    back to that doctor, either.]

    Others have suggested different types of bars, and I don't have much to add.
    Bar ends and clip-on aero bars are both cheap -- why not try both? Also, you
    can easily switch from a mountain bike bar to a hybrid bar, which has a
    different angle and generally is up an inch or so higher.

  13. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Mike Kruger said:
    SDB said:


    The diagnosis was with some electric shock thing they attached to my
    fingers. Two doctors read the results and independently came to the
    same conclusion. That said, I am all in of solving medical problems
    in a manor that is as non-invasive as possible. Next time I'm at the
    book store I'll take a look. Thank you!

    Diagnosis sounds fine, but ...

    Years ago I lost the feeling in the two small fingers in my LEFT hand. I
    went in to Evanston Hospital for an EMG (lots of electric shocks on fingers
    and elsewhere). I got a diagnosis of carpal tunnel in my RIGHT wrist. I
    explained that this didn't match my symptoms very well. The doctor looked at
    the test results again, and explained that I definitely had carpal tunnel in
    my right wrist, and it would be surely start hurting me soon. It might
    someday, but that was in 1989 and I haven't had problems yet. [Haven't gone
    back to that doctor, either.]

    I've heard at least 2 explanations of what CTS is.

    One is that there are tendons encased within sheathing
    tubes of tissue, extending from the wrist to the knuckles,
    and that these require some sort of bio-lubricant in there,
    and if that lubricant is depleted due to repetitive stress,
    it gets kind of like dry brake inner cable scraping against
    its outer housing.

    The other is compression of the median nerve.

    cheers,
    Tom

    --
    Nothing is safe from me.
    Above address is just a spam midden.
    I'm really at: tkeats curlicue vcn dot bc dot ca

  14. "SDB" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    I have been diagnosed with carpel tunnel in my right hand. I have trouble
    riding much more than 2 miles before my hand goes numb. I've tried
    wearing
    a glove. The glove helps a little but it still hurts after a couple
    miles.
    The discomfort takes all the fun out of riding plus the pain the day after
    riding is pretty bad.

    This sounds nuts, but it's been true for me: the best way to not have your
    hands go numb is to increase your core strength. If you have the core
    strength to hold your body up, you won't be leaning on your arms.

    Do this, and be sure to check regularly that your elbows are bent and your
    wrists are straight, and it will really make a world of difference.

    Also - are you sure it's carpel tunnel and not ulnar nerve ("handlebar
    palsy"😉? Which fingers are you having trouble with: the thumb and
    forefinger, or the pinky and ring finger?

    It'll also help, if you're using a computer at work, to consider having a
    prop for your wrists at the keyboard and maybe a trackball instead of a
    mouse.

    --
    Warm Regards,

    Claire Petersky
    http://www.bicyclemeditations.org/
    See the books I've set free at: http://bookcrossing.com/referral/Cpetersky

  15. SDB said:

    I have been diagnosed with carpel tunnel in my right hand. I have trouble
    riding much more than 2 miles before my hand goes numb. I've tried wearing
    a glove. The glove helps a little but it still hurts after a couple miles.
    The discomfort takes all the fun out of riding plus the pain the day after
    riding is pretty bad.

    I've thought about getting aerobars so I could take some of the weight off
    my hands. I've got a mountain bike though and the only bikes I've seen with
    aerobars have drops. Are there aerobars for flat handle bars? Does anyone
    have any other suggestions?

    I've had carpal tunnel, albeit a fairly mild case, so while I'm not an
    expert I do speak from experience. Each case is unique, but there are
    two fairly common things that aggravate the problem: palm pressure and
    pronation, or palms-down hand position. Sometimes pronation is the
    bigger problem even when it seems otherwise.

    Try this: Hold your hands in front of your belly button, forearms level
    with the ground and palms down. Keeping your palms down, move your hands
    out so they're in front of your shoulders. Pay close attention to your
    forearms. You should be able to feel the tension building up. Now turn
    your hands so the palms face toward each other. Feel the tension go
    away? Even if you don't have tendinitis in your wrists -- a condition
    which often accompanies and aggravates carpal tunnel syndrome -- all
    that extra tension in the tendons which make up part of the carpal tunnel
    doesn't help.

    Now, on to practical advice: yes, aero bars are the first thing I'd try.
    They'll give you a position where your hands are in a neutral position
    with no weight on them, which is ideal. I'd be very surprised if they
    didn't help. I'd reccomend bar ends as well. They're cheap, and they'll
    give you a non-pronated position that gives you easier access to the
    brake levers than from aero bars. If that setup doesn't work for you,
    something like albatross handlebars might.

    Switching to a bike with drop bars is an option, and ultimately what I
    prefer, but you should try less drastic measures first. You're dealing
    with what is hopefully a temporary problem, and a new bike that you buy
    today might put you in a rather different position than you'll want
    once you're recovered. Better to experiment with cheaper stuff until
    you know what your long-term outlook is.

  16. That sounds painful!

    Over several years I have been progressively raising the height of my
    handle bars and this has resulted in the numbness I was getting now
    completely disappearing. But I now have a fairly upright position and
    I push a lot of air but comfort is more important to me than speed.

    At one stage I did put aero bars on the flat bars of my hybrid and
    that worked well. I currently use "butterfly" bars and I like them
    but it seems you may need to keep the weight off your hands for some
    time until the problem is resolved so maybe aero bars are the go.

    Peter Damm

  17. Quoted message said:

    Regarding the drop bar bike... its a fine suggestion but my bike is a good
    friend. It would be fair to toss it aside so quickly due to my
    shortcomings. 🙂

    Don't be so keen to hold onto your friend, if it means you don't get to
    ride. I can ride 10 hours on a road bike without issue, but 30 minutes on a
    mountain bike and my hands aren't happy. It's one of those dirty little
    secrets that keeps me from wanting to ride much off-road. Guess it ain't so
    secret anymore.

    --Mike-- Chain Reaction Bicycles
    www.ChainReactionBicycles.com

  18. You shouldn't have any trouble finding aero bars to an MTB. However,
    there might be other explanations for pain in your hands and arms.
    It's not uncommon for the pressure of the riding position on the hands
    to compress nerves in your hand. Unless you've discussed this with
    your doctor, you might consider a second opinion.

    Ian

    SDB said:

    I have been diagnosed with carpel tunnel in my right hand. I have trouble
    riding much more than 2 miles before my hand goes numb. I've tried wearing
    a glove. The glove helps a little but it still hurts after a couple miles.
    The discomfort takes all the fun out of riding plus the pain the day after
    riding is pretty bad.

    I've thought about getting aerobars so I could take some of the weight off
    my hands. I've got a mountain bike though and the only bikes I've seen with
    aerobars have drops. Are there aerobars for flat handle bars? Does anyone
    have any other suggestions?

    Thanks!

  19. SDB said:

    I have been diagnosed with carpel tunnel in my right hand. I have trouble
    riding much more than 2 miles before my hand goes numb. I've tried wearing
    a glove. The glove helps a little but it still hurts after a couple miles.
    The discomfort takes all the fun out of riding plus the pain the day after
    riding is pretty bad.

    I've thought about getting aerobars so I could take some of the weight off
    my hands. I've got a mountain bike though and the only bikes I've seen with
    aerobars have drops. Are there aerobars for flat handle bars? Does anyone
    have any other suggestions?

    Thanks!


    I have severe carpal in both hands due to being a Chef for the last 40
    yrs, (carpal tunnel used to be called the "butchers disease" before
    computers made it so common)
    You do not have to change bikes to use a drop bar which does help
    considerably
    just use dia-comp 287V brake levers and bar end shifters or shifters for
    a flat bar road bike
    you will prolly have to change stems to get the correct clamp dia but
    not a big deal with threadless headsets

    Steve

  20. SDB said:

    I have been diagnosed with carpel tunnel in my right hand. I have trouble
    riding much more than 2 miles before my hand goes numb. I've tried wearing
    a glove. The glove helps a little but it still hurts after a couple miles.
    The discomfort takes all the fun out of riding plus the pain the day after
    riding is pretty bad.

    I've thought about getting aerobars so I could take some of the weight off
    my hands. I've got a mountain bike though and the only bikes I've seen with
    aerobars have drops. Are there aerobars for flat handle bars? Does anyone
    have any other suggestions?

    Thanks!

    Let me throw out another possible solution that may or may not
    interest you. My own experience is that a lot of the issues that
    riders have with weight on their hands are caused not simply by
    position but by issues with core strength. Many cyclists do not work
    on core strength and thus have "too" much wieght on their hands.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.