Cycling Equipment · Public discussion

cannondale frame under stress

Started by hans · · Last activity · 10 posts · 1,131 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Cycling Equipment
Published
13 August 2003
Last activity
14 August 2003
Original author
hans
Posts
10
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,131
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–10 of 10
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. Hi,

    I got myself an F500 last year and recently I hear this "tinckling" noise whenever I shift my weight on the sadle or when I hit some small bumps in the road sitting down. I cannot pinpoint where the noise comes from but it is approx. from where the sadle bar is entering the frame.

    It sounds like trouble but since this is the first alu frame I got I'm not sure. Before I go back to the shop with it I would like some advice: is this normal behaviour of an alu frame under stress? Or am I wrong in looking at the frame?

    Thanks,

    Hans

  2. It's normal. It could be the seatpost, bb, saddle rails, just about any contact point. Greasing
    these points might get rid of it. If it's the bb, try some teflon tape. Let's not turn this into an
    alu bashing thread. "hans" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    "]news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    Hi,

    I got myself an F500 last year and recently I hear this "tinckling" noise whenever I shift my
    weight on the sadle or when I hit some small bumps in the road sitting down. I cannot pinpoint
    where the noise comes from but it is approx. from where the sadle bar is entering the frame.

    It sounds like trouble but since this is the first alu frame I got I'm not sure. Before I go back
    to the shop with it I would like some advice: is this normal behaviour of an alu frame under
    stress? Or am I wrong in looking at the frame?

    Thanks,

    Hans

    --

    Quoted message said:

    --------------------------<


    Posted via cyclingforums.com cyclingforums.comcyclingforums.com

  3. hans <[email hidden]> wrote:
    : Hi,

    : I got myself an F500 last year and recently I hear this "tinckling" noise whenever I shift my
    : weight on the sadle or when I hit some small bumps in the road sitting down. I cannot pinpoint
    : where the noise comes from but it is approx. from where the sadle bar is entering the frame.

    : It sounds like trouble but since this is the first alu frame I got I'm not sure. Before I go back
    : to the shop with it I would like some advice: is this normal behaviour of an alu frame under
    : stress? Or am I wrong in looking at the frame?

    Could be almost anything, but I'd be looking at the saddle first - the junction of the rails and
    the seat body, then the connection of the seat rails and the clamping mechanism, then the seat
    post and the frame. There are various ways of lightly lubricating these, and dissassembly is the
    most thorough.

    Hope this helps, cheerz, Lynzz

  4. hans may have said:

    Hi,

    I got myself an F500 last year and recently I hear this "tinckling" noise whenever I shift my
    weight on the sadle or when I hit some small bumps in the road sitting down. I cannot pinpoint
    where the noise comes from but it is approx. from where the sadle bar is entering the frame.

    It sounds like trouble but since this is the first alu frame I got I'm not sure. Before I go back
    to the shop with it I would like some advice: is this normal behaviour of an alu frame under
    stress? Or am I wrong in looking at the frame?

    Probably not anything significant; I've had several bikes that have made similar noises when
    mounting up. None had aluminum frames, and all of the noises eventually went away either when I was
    doing something about a different issue (just adjusting the seat angle did it once) or with time.

    --
    My email address is antispammed; pull WEEDS if replying via e-mail. Yes, I have a killfile. If I
    don't respond to something, it's also possible that I'm busy.

  5. hans said:

    Hi,

    I got myself an F500 last year and recently I hear this "tinckling" noise whenever I shift my
    weight on the sadle or when I hit some small bumps in the road sitting down. I cannot pinpoint
    where the noise comes from but it is approx. from where the sadle bar is entering the frame.

    It sounds like trouble but since this is the first alu frame I got I'm not sure. Before I go back
    to the shop with it I would like some advice: is this normal behaviour of an alu frame under
    stress? Or am I wrong in looking at the frame?

    Thanks,

    Hans

    Quoted message said:

    --------------------------<


    Posted via cyclingforums.com cyclingforums.comcyclingforums.com

    My handlebars did the same once. As soon as I stood up and put some weight on them. It dissapeared
    immediately when I greased and retightened the bolts holding it.

    --
    Perre

    You have to be smarter than a robot to reply.

  6. hans said:

    Hi,

    I got myself an F500 last year and recently I hear this "tinckling" noise whenever I shift my
    weight on the sadle or when I hit some small bumps in the road sitting down. I cannot pinpoint
    where the noise comes from but it is approx. from where the sadle bar is entering the frame.

    It sounds like trouble but since this is the first alu frame I got I'm not sure. Before I go back
    to the shop with it I would like some advice: is this normal behaviour of an alu frame under
    stress? Or am I wrong in looking at the frame?

    I mostly agree with the rest. Whenever my F1000 did that, it was ususlly that the seatpost needed
    lubbing. Less often, it was the seat rails -- or even the pedals (the clamping mechanism needs lube
    where they pivot). And remember that noise travels in a frame and it's really hard to pinpoint
    where it's coming from. Other places: headset, bars, pedals where they thread into the cranks,
    cranks, etc...

    But, I broke my 1st Jekyll frame where the top tube welds to the seatpost tube (no questions asked
    replacement). It was a medium frame, I should have had a large (I wanted a little more clearance
    between my jewels and frame 🙂) so I had a very long, setback seatpost (410mm). I also ran a
    seatpost rack for a while -- so there was __ALOT__ of stress on the seatpost and frame. I would keep
    an eye on that weld if greasing doesn't take care of the problem.

    In Cannondale's favor, they could have called it abuse, and the weld held even though it was broken
    1/2 way around with I finally noticed it! The replacement's a Large and it fits much better 🙂.

    David

  7. Greasing and tighting the seatpost and seat at the seatrails might work. Don't forget to tighten the
    crank and chainring bolts also.

    Fire up MTB 03

  8. [email hidden] schreef ...

    Quoted message said:

    Hi,

    I got myself an F500 last year and recently I hear this "tinckling" noise whenever I shift my
    weight on the sadle or when I hit some small bumps in the road sitting down. I cannot pinpoint
    where the noise comes from but it is approx. from where the sadle bar is entering the frame.

    It sounds like trouble but since this is the first alu frame I got I'm not sure. Before I go back
    to the shop with it I would like some advice: is this normal behaviour of an alu frame under
    stress? Or am I wrong in looking at the frame?

    I'll add more possible source of sound: my neighbour had a "tinckling" in his bike. Turned out to be
    the front derailleur that had ever so slightly loosened......

    --
    Regards, Marten

  9. hans said:

    It sounds like trouble but since this is the first alu frame I got I'm not sure. Before I go back
    to the shop with it I would like some advice: is this normal behaviour of an alu frame under
    stress? Or am I wrong in looking at the frame?

    I've never had such a sound from either of my aluminum bikes, a GT and a Giant. You should try to
    duplicate the sound with the bike on a stand or on the floor, and see if you can locate it.

    Quoted message said:

    Thanks,

    Hans


    --
    Rick Onanian

  10. hans said:

    Hi,

    I got myself an F500 last year and recently I hear this "tinckling" noise whenever I shift my
    weight on the sadle or when I hit some small bumps in the road sitting down. I cannot pinpoint
    where the noise comes from but it is approx. from where the sadle bar is entering the frame.

    It sounds like trouble but since this is the first alu frame I got I'm not sure. Before I go back
    to the shop with it I would like some advice: is this normal behaviour of an alu frame under
    stress? Or am I wrong in looking at the frame?

    Thanks,

    Hans

    --

    Quoted message said:

    --------------------------<

    Posted via cyclingforums.com cyclingforums.comcyclingforums.com

    It could be the spokes. Check if the are properly tensioned.

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.