General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Broken Egg In Carton

Started by Email address hidden · · Last activity · 53 posts · 1,861 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
4 May 2006
Last activity
7 May 2006
Original author
Email address hidden
Posts
53
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
1,861
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 53
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I went to the neighborhood supermarket today, and there was only one
    carton of Jumbo eggs left. I noticed that one egg is broken. I bought
    it anyway, since I prefer the jumbo eggs. I have set aside the eggs
    stained by the egg white from the broken egg to be disposed.

    Is it safe to eat the other eggs?

    Thank you in advance ...

  2. Why on earth would you dispose of the eggs which have egg white on
    them?
    I would just wash the eggs affected and store them, certainly not throw
    them out.

    Providing the eggs are within their use-by-date, they should be
    perfectly ok.

    LadyJane
    --
    "Never trust a skinny cook!"

  3. Quoted message said:

    I went to the neighborhood supermarket today, and there was only one
    carton of Jumbo eggs left. I noticed that one egg is broken. I bought
    it anyway, since I prefer the jumbo eggs. I have set aside the eggs
    stained by the egg white from the broken egg to be disposed.

    Is it safe to eat the other eggs?

    I tell ya - Is Google Groups advertising on AOL and WebTV or
    what? This new round of Google posts are getting out of hand.

    -sw

  4. Steve Wertz said:
    Quoted message said:

    I went to the neighborhood supermarket today, and there was only one
    carton of Jumbo eggs left. I noticed that one egg is broken. I bought
    it anyway, since I prefer the jumbo eggs. I have set aside the eggs
    stained by the egg white from the broken egg to be disposed.

    Is it safe to eat the other eggs?

    I tell ya - Is Google Groups advertising on AOL and WebTV or
    what? This new round of Google posts are getting out of hand.

    -sw

    Hmmmmmm, google snobs in rec.food.cooking? I thought this was a nice
    group? Why is it that folks go off topic and put people down about
    where they post from? I have never quite understood this concept. Is
    it sort of like not wanting to spend time with people who live in
    trailer parks and only spend time with people who have large houses in
    the suburbs? How about cars? No pintos or old ramblers, but honda
    accords or suvs are okay?

    Hey, I'll be the first to admit that I"m not the sharpest tack in the
    box when it comes to understanding computers. I have the basics down
    and get around fairly well. I'm far from a computer nerd and live a
    fairly simple life as a social worker, mom, decent human being. At
    least I'm not a computer snob.

    Now....back to the broken egg in the carton. I don't eat eggs and I'd
    probably worry about contamination :-) I do buy eggs for my daughter I
    just buy the organic ones. Should eggs always be washed off before
    using them?

  5. tofuqueen said:
    Steve Wertz said:
    Quoted message said:

    I went to the neighborhood supermarket today, and there was only one
    carton of Jumbo eggs left. I noticed that one egg is broken. I bought
    it anyway, since I prefer the jumbo eggs. I have set aside the eggs
    stained by the egg white from the broken egg to be disposed.

    Is it safe to eat the other eggs?

    I tell ya - Is Google Groups advertising on AOL and WebTV or
    what? This new round of Google posts are getting out of hand.

    Hmmmmmm, google snobs in rec.food.cooking?

    We're *everywhere*. I'm particularly ornery about it, and its
    not an RFC thing, it's just part of what makes the group ...
    dynamic.

    Quoted message said:

    I thought this was a nice group?

    You have to average out the posts and consider personal quirks as
    part of it.

    Somebody will be along right after me in another thread and make
    it up to you.

    -sw

  6. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Quoted post said:

    I went to the neighborhood supermarket today, and there was only one
    carton of Jumbo eggs left. I noticed that one egg is broken. I bought
    it anyway, since I prefer the jumbo eggs. I have set aside the eggs
    stained by the egg white from the broken egg to be disposed.

    Is it safe to eat the other eggs?

    Thank you in advance ...

    Sure. It happens.
    --
    -Barb
    <http://jamlady.eboard.com> Updated 4-30-2006, Dead Spread
    latest church review, and Sam's Festival of Nations costume.
    "If it's not worth doing to excess, it's not worth doing at all."

  7. In article <[email hidden]>,

    tofuqueen said:

    Now....back to the broken egg in the carton. I don't eat eggs and I'd
    probably worry about contamination :-) I do buy eggs for my daughter I
    just buy the organic ones. Should eggs always be washed off before
    using them?

    It's probably not a bad idea, but I don't.
    --
    -Barb
    <http://jamlady.eboard.com> Updated 4-30-2006, Dead Spread
    latest church review, and Sam's Festival of Nations costume.
    "If it's not worth doing to excess, it's not worth doing at all."

  8. "Melba's Jammin'" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Quoted message said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,

    tofuqueen said:

    Now....back to the broken egg in the carton. I don't eat eggs and I'd
    probably worry about contamination :-) I do buy eggs for my daughter I
    just buy the organic ones. Should eggs always be washed off before
    using them?

    It's probably not a bad idea, but I don't.
    --

    Well, now that we're onto the subject of broken eggs, I've always wondered
    if a cracked, uncooked egg is safe to eat? I check the cartons when I
    purchase the eggs, but sometimes you get an egg that's kind of stuck to the
    bottom of the carton because of a hairline crack in the shell. You don't
    see it because it's not obvious when you buy the eggs. Is *that* egg safe
    to eat?

    kili

  9. LadyJane said:

    Why on earth would you dispose of the eggs which have egg white on
    them?
    I would just wash the eggs affected and store them, certainly not throw
    them out.

    Providing the eggs are within their use-by-date, they should be
    perfectly ok.

    LadyJane
    --
    "Never trust a skinny cook!"

    I could be wrong, but I vaguely remember what someone once explained to
    me.

    Eggshells are porous - pores on the surface - and can harbor bacteria.
    When liquid from the broken egg gets onto shells of the other eggs, it
    can potentially create an incubating environment. When you crack open
    the unbroken egg with a contaminated shell, the egg white running past
    the contaminated shell can come into contact with the shell and also
    become contaminated. This kind of contamination can cause some forms
    of food poisoning.

    I cannot substantiate it but only more of a hearsay ...

  10. Steve Wertz said:
    Quoted message said:

    I went to the neighborhood supermarket today, and there was only one
    carton of Jumbo eggs left. I noticed that one egg is broken. I bought
    it anyway, since I prefer the jumbo eggs. I have set aside the eggs
    stained by the egg white from the broken egg to be disposed.

    Is it safe to eat the other eggs?

    I tell ya - Is Google Groups advertising on AOL and WebTV or
    what? This new round of Google posts are getting out of hand.

    Many of us don't have a choice since more and more Internet providers
    refuse to carry usenet. My own provider stopped on April 1, so at home
    Google is my only resource unless I want to spend even more money. My
    provider at work still offers usenet but since all the other providers
    in the province have bailed we expect it to be only a matter of time
    before it does also.

    Gabby

  11. kilikini said:

    Well, now that we're onto the subject of broken eggs, I've always wondered
    if a cracked, uncooked egg is safe to eat? I check the cartons when I
    purchase the eggs, but sometimes you get an egg that's kind of stuck to the
    bottom of the carton because of a hairline crack in the shell. You don't
    see it because it's not obvious when you buy the eggs. Is *that* egg safe
    to eat?

    kili

    It seems obvious to me, but even though I don't wash eggs before using,
    I would NEVER use an egg that had a crack, no matter how small, and
    especially one that was stuck in the carton.

    N.

  12. kilikini said:

    Well, now that we're onto the subject of broken eggs, I've always wondered
    if a cracked, uncooked egg is safe to eat? I check the cartons when I
    purchase the eggs, but sometimes you get an egg that's kind of stuck to
    the
    bottom of the carton because of a hairline crack in the shell. You don't
    see it because it's not obvious when you buy the eggs. Is *that* egg safe
    to eat?

    I always check for signs of cracked shells, but sometimes I miss them, or
    they get cracked on the way home.

    I guess how one approaches this depends on how many uses one has for eggs.
    Since I use them for lots of different things, I can always find a use for
    them.

    Cracked or older eggs get used for glazing the tops of loaves of bread, and
    to help the seeds stick on the crust. They might also be used in other
    baking where the eggs get thoroughly cooked. I don' use them just to eat by
    themselves.

    I also tend to use the freshest, most pristine eggs for things that aren't
    cooked thoroughly, if cooked at all. Things like soft boiled eggs, or eggs
    fried sunny side up where I want a thick, high standing white.

    Yesterday I made tapioca cream pudding with very fresh eggs. The cookbook
    (Settlement) with the recipe I use is rather inconsistent on warnings about
    eggs. The egg section is rather stern in its warnings on raw or lightly
    cooked eggs. But over in the desserts section, there is no mention at all of
    a safety problem in the tapioca cream pudding recipe. The milk, tapioca, egg
    yolks, sugar, and salt are cooked fairly well. But the egg whites are beaten
    into stiff peaks and folded into the cool tapioca mixture. So the egg whites
    are raw in the finished dish. I know this is a potential problem, but
    personally I've never gotten sick from it in years of making it. But I would
    never serve this to someone with a weakened immune system. The risk is low
    but not worth taking. I also would not make this with cracked or older eggs.

    --
    ( #wff_ng_7# at #verizon# period #net# )

  13. Melba's Jammin said:

    In article <[email hidden]>,

    tofuqueen said:

    Now....back to the broken egg in the carton. I don't eat eggs and I'd
    probably worry about contamination :-) I do buy eggs for my daughter I
    just buy the organic ones. Should eggs always be washed off before
    using them?

    It's probably not a bad idea, but I don't.

    Unless purchased direct from the farmer eggs sold in the US have
    already had their shells washed, sanitized, and coated with a
    protectorate... any home washing will only help cause contamination...
    do not wash eggs.

    Everything you need to know about egg handling can be found here:
    http://www.aeb.org

    Sheldon

  14. kilikini said:


    Well, now that we're onto the subject of broken eggs, I've always wondered
    if a cracked, uncooked egg is safe to eat? I check the cartons when I
    purchase the eggs, but sometimes you get an egg that's kind of stuck to the
    bottom of the carton because of a hairline crack in the shell. You don't
    see it because it's not obvious when you buy the eggs. Is *that* egg safe
    to eat?

    kili

    Kili, to add to my previous post - you can tell if there are any stuck
    eggs, by opening up the carton and running your hand lightly over the
    top of the eggs to make sure they all move in the carton. Often, the
    cashier will do this anyway to make sure you don't have any broken
    ones. (Hmm, I guess I should wash them before using....)

    N.

  15. "Nancy2" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:

    Kili, to add to my previous post - you can tell if there are any stuck
    eggs, by opening up the carton and running your hand lightly over the
    top of the eggs to make sure they all move in the carton. Often, the
    cashier will do this anyway to make sure you don't have any broken
    ones. (Hmm, I guess I should wash them before using....)

    (laugh) That's funny, especially as you know how very disgusting
    dirty money is. Anyway, I always give each egg a little move to make
    sure it's not stuck. Got stuck (no pun/whatever intended) with broken
    eggs one too many times.

    nancy

  16. Nancy2 said:

    kilikini wrote:

    Quoted message said:


    Kili, to add to my previous post - you can tell if there are any stuck
    eggs, by opening up the carton and running your hand lightly over the
    top of the eggs to make sure they all move in the carton. Often, the
    cashier will do this anyway to make sure you don't have any broken
    ones. (Hmm, I guess I should wash them before using....)

    N.

    I've never seen a cashier open an egg carton going through checkout in
    my life. I guess they figure you're buying the eggs, you check.

    Quoted message said:


    And what Sheldon says is true.

    Unless purchased direct from the farmer eggs sold in the US have
    already had their shells washed, sanitized, and coated with a
    protectorate... any home washing will only help cause contamination.

    If I am unfortunate enough to get a cracked egg after checking the
    carton, I trash it. No telling how long it's been sitting there with a
    crack and I just don't want to take the chance of getting sick. Eggs
    are too cheap to risk it.

  17. email hidden said:

    I went to the neighborhood supermarket today, and there was only one
    carton of Jumbo eggs left. I noticed that one egg is broken. I bought
    it anyway, since I prefer the jumbo eggs. I have set aside the eggs
    stained by the egg white from the broken egg to be disposed.

    Is it safe to eat the other eggs?

    Thank you in advance ...

    Check out www.aeb.org
    It is the American Egg Board and has all the information you will ever
    need about eggs.
    --
    Susan N.

    "Moral indignation is in most cases two percent moral,
    48 percent indignation, and 50 percent envy."
    Vittorio De Sica, Italian movie director (1901-1974

  18. kilikini said:


    Well, now that we're onto the subject of broken eggs, I've always wondered
    if a cracked, uncooked egg is safe to eat? I check the cartons when I
    purchase the eggs, but sometimes you get an egg that's kind of stuck to the
    bottom of the carton because of a hairline crack in the shell. You don't
    see it because it's not obvious when you buy the eggs. Is *that* egg safe
    to eat?

    kili

    No, it's not unless you overcook the life out of it. I have gotten
    violently sick over a cracked egg that I scrambled to a "soft" stage.
    Now I throw away the cracked ones without a second thought.

    gloria p

  19. Gabby said:
    Steve Wertz said:
    Quoted message said:

    I went to the neighborhood supermarket today, and there was only one
    carton of Jumbo eggs left. I noticed that one egg is broken. I bought
    it anyway, since I prefer the jumbo eggs. I have set aside the eggs
    stained by the egg white from the broken egg to be disposed.

    Is it safe to eat the other eggs?

    I tell ya - Is Google Groups advertising on AOL and WebTV or
    what? This new round of Google posts are getting out of hand.

    Many of us don't have a choice since more and more Internet providers
    refuse to carry usenet. My own provider stopped on April 1, so at home
    Google is my only resource unless I want to spend even more money. My
    provider at work still offers usenet but since all the other providers
    in the province have bailed we expect it to be only a matter of time
    before it does also.

    There are people that know how to use Usenet anf google just
    fine. Like yoursefl. Then there's that other group of people
    who just stumble across it and post just to hear themselves talk
    (and usuaully be stupid). Then there's the other group who just
    uses to it troll or sock-puppet.

    If it was up to me, I'd block Google from posting. But then I'd
    be working as a NSP (news provider) that has some financial
    interest as well as a moral interest.

    -sw

  20. Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Is it sort of like not wanting to spend time with people who live in


    trailer parks and only spend time with people who have large houses in
    the suburbs?

    Who wants to spend their time with people who live in large suburban
    houses? Ugh!

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.