General fitness, health and nutrition · Public discussion

Best Forefoot Cushioning

Started by John Banks · · Last activity · 21 posts · 513 views

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
General fitness, health and nutrition
Published
23 March 2006
Last activity
1 April 2006
Original author
John Banks
Posts
21
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
513
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–20 of 21
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I have used Asics for years; either Nimbus or Kayano - both are fine,
    but I always seem to get a burning sensation under my toes on long runs
    (12+). I should not that I have always had this pain, whether running
    in Nike's, Saucony, etc., always seems to come on in the 10-14 miles
    range.

    I visited a podiatrist thinking I had nueromas - didn't. He gave me
    some metatarsal pads - I tried these, but they were so uncomfortable I
    could never get used to them - I prefered the burning sensation to it.

    I am hoping to find some shoes with better forefront cushioning to help
    delay the on-set of this pain.

    Any suggestions?

  2. when you say burning sensation, i am thinking heat generated friction,
    socks, wonder if you run in coolmax socks or the like.

    perhaps you simply need a shoe with a more roomy toe box. keep in mind
    toes/feet swell with distance/heat, etc.

    I don't wear socks (unless it's below 20 degrees). I use baby oil &
    powder to combate heat generated friction. perhaps all this time you
    should be sizing up a 1/2 as well.

  3. On 23 Mar 2006 14:26:58 -0800, "John Banks" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    I should not that I have always had this pain,
    any suggestions?

    Learn to spell moron.

  4. John Banks submitted this idea :

    Quoted message said:

    I have used Asics for years; either Nimbus or Kayano - both are fine,
    but I always seem to get a burning sensation under my toes on long runs
    (12+). I should not that I have always had this pain, whether running
    in Nike's, Saucony, etc., always seems to come on in the 10-14 miles
    range.

    I visited a podiatrist thinking I had nueromas - didn't. He gave me
    some metatarsal pads - I tried these, but they were so uncomfortable I
    could never get used to them - I prefered the burning sensation to it.

    I am hoping to find some shoes with better forefront cushioning to help
    delay the on-set of this pain.

    Any suggestions?

    My personal thoughts on this with seeing your feet is the same as the
    podiatrist. The burning sensations can be caused by numerous things
    including improperly fitted footwear (longitudinal arch lenght of foot
    should match with the shoe, proper width etc.)

    On the metatarsal pad issue, I have seen many diffrent responses to
    varying sizes of pads. If you think you can just put them in and keep
    on with your regular routine, think again. As with the running, you
    also have to allow time for your foot to adjust to the pads. However,
    if they are placed incorrectly (which I have seen abundantly) they can
    create more problems than they solve. They come in many sizes and
    varying shapes given the different foot problems, and when added
    correctly work wonders in correcting problems such as this, and other
    through correcting the biomechanincal difficiencies of the foot.

    As well I also agree with Lance about the hosiery. Proper socks can
    make a world of difference. An acrylic sock such as Thorlo would be my
    first choice. Microscopically the fibres are not as abrasive as cotton
    or other blends and provide superior cushioning and moisture wicking
    ability.

    I'd also suggest perhaps seeking the help of a Board Certified
    Pedorthist as they could be instrumental in giving you further advice
    on footwear best suited for your gait.

    I could talk for hours about this stuff, but hopefully this blurb helps
    you out. I'd be happy to answer any further questions you may have as
    well.

    Sincerely

    Sammy
    Certified Kinesiologist
    B. Sc Kin

  5. Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    I should not that I have always had this pain,
    any suggestions?

    Hey, are you the guy in the other thread who said eeveryone was
    running wrong

  6. Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    other thread who said eeveryone<<

    Nope, first post in this group. Looks like you should take your own
    advice and, "learn to spell, [censored]."

  7. I don't believe socks, sizing, etc., are the cause of the problem - I
    wear coolmax and/or other synthetic fibers, use shoes 0.5-1 full size
    bigger (have been fitted at specialty running stores).

    Perhaps the metatarsal pads were placed incorrectly or the fact that I
    tried to do "too much, too fast." Not sure, but maybe worth another
    try.

    I was told by both the running shop and the podiatrist that I am a
    forefoot striker; so, I was hoping to get shoes that offered the max
    cushioning in that area. Am I in the right shoes now - Asics Nimbus?

  8. "sammy" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
    news:[email hidden]...

    Great thorough synopsis. I also thorlo but there are a few good good
    socks like Wigwam and my recent favorite Smartwool.

    -DF

    Quoted message said:

    My personal thoughts on this with seeing your feet is the same as the
    podiatrist. The burning sensations can be caused by numerous things
    including improperly fitted footwear (longitudinal arch lenght of foot
    should match with the shoe, proper width etc.)

    On the metatarsal pad issue, I have seen many diffrent responses to
    varying sizes of pads. If you think you can just put them in and keep
    on with your regular routine, think again. As with the running, you
    also have to allow time for your foot to adjust to the pads. However,
    if they are placed incorrectly (which I have seen abundantly) they can
    create more problems than they solve. They come in many sizes and
    varying shapes given the different foot problems, and when added
    correctly work wonders in correcting problems such as this, and other
    through correcting the biomechanincal difficiencies of the foot.

    As well I also agree with Lance about the hosiery. Proper socks can
    make a world of difference. An acrylic sock such as Thorlo would be
    my first choice. Microscopically the fibres are not as abrasive as
    cotton or other blends and provide superior cushioning and moisture
    wicking ability.

    I'd also suggest perhaps seeking the help of a Board Certified
    Pedorthist as they could be instrumental in giving you further advice
    on footwear best suited for your gait.

    I could talk for hours about this stuff, but hopefully this blurb
    helps you out. I'd be happy to answer any further questions you may
    have as well.

    Sincerely

    Sammy
    Certified Kinesiologist
    B. Sc Kin

  9. On Fri, 24 Mar 2006 12:02:18 GMT, "Doug Freese" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    I also thorlo but there are a few good good
    socks like Wigwam and my recent favorite Smartwool.

    You shoot your goo in them?

  10. John Banks used his keyboard to write :

    Quoted message said:

    I don't believe socks, sizing, etc., are the cause of the problem - I
    wear coolmax and/or other synthetic fibers, use shoes 0.5-1 full size
    bigger (have been fitted at specialty running stores).

    Perhaps the metatarsal pads were placed incorrectly or the fact that I
    tried to do "too much, too fast." Not sure, but maybe worth another
    try.

    I was told by both the running shop and the podiatrist that I am a
    forefoot striker; so, I was hoping to get shoes that offered the max
    cushioning in that area. Am I in the right shoes now - Asics Nimbus?

    Keep in mind that extra cushioning is not always the correct answer. I
    would suggest perhaps replacing your current insoles in your shoes with
    something that has extra cushioning in it before buying new shoes. You
    may have to experiment a bit before you find what is right.

    the fact that you are a supposed forefoot striker (keep in mind people
    with metatarsal problems are often show signs of increased wear on the
    forefoot of the shoe and may not be a true forefoot striker) leads me
    to believe that the pads may be placed incorrectly. It's hard to give
    advice without seeing the problem, but I would perhaps trying placing
    them a slightly different spot. IF you take the insole out of your
    shoe you will see where you strike the hardest. Place the met pad just
    behind that area. Honestly though, if it didn't feel right the first
    time I would have went back to the Podiatrist. They should be able to
    make the adjustment for you. Client satisfaction should be on their
    list priorities (besides taking your money)!

    Hope some of my 2 cents helps

    Sammy

  11. On 23 Mar 2006 14:26:58 -0800, "John Banks" <[email hidden]>

    Quoted message said:

    I have used Asics for years; either Nimbus or Kayano - both are fine,
    but I always seem to get a burning sensation under my toes on long runs
    (12+). I should not that I have always had this pain, whether running
    in Nike's, Saucony, etc., always seems to come on in the 10-14 miles
    range.

    I visited a podiatrist thinking I had nueromas - didn't. He gave me
    some metatarsal pads - I tried these, but they were so uncomfortable I
    could never get used to them - I prefered the burning sensation to it.

    I am hoping to find some shoes with better forefront cushioning to help
    delay the on-set of this pain.

    Any suggestions?

    Asics gel Landreths. Hard to find where I am. It's more of an "old
    style" shoe with their "speva" foam construction and minimal
    engineering. Work for me (48 year old slow guy doing around 25 miles
    per week) especially on pavement.

    *But* -- this may sound strange -- have you played around with
    different types of lacing? I used to lace too tight toward the toes
    (squishing left-to-right across the wide part of forefoot) and started
    getting numbness/tingling under the middle toes.

    What "street shoes" do you wear the rest of the day? Maybe they are
    aggravating a problem that you only feel on the long runs. How old
    are you? I spent 20+ years of working life in steel toe boots and it
    took a lot of adaptation when I first started running a few years ago.
    I think my feet changed size and shape once I gave them more room and
    flexibility in my street shoes.

    Good luck!
    --
    Daniel
    [email hidden]

  12. sammy said:

    Keep in mind that extra cushioning is not always the correct answer.

    OP, this "sammy" seems to have some credentials and experience to know
    what he's talking about. I don't, I just read a lot and have made and
    learned from far more than my share of mistakes. That said, I agree
    that "more cushioning" is often an obvious yet wrong solution to the
    problem.

    Here's another suggestion to add to what you've aready got (I think
    Daniel's ideas are interesting too, FWIW) - if you think your
    discomfort comes from the impact and that more cushioning would help,
    then try running some or all of the distance (12 miles?) on a softer
    surface like grass or a dirt/gravel/sand trail or even a rubberized
    track or treadmill. This will effectively reduce the impact and you'll
    see whether it helps.

    I'd suggest running much of your weekly mileage on a softer surface
    than pavement anyhow, if practical. And if you already are running on
    a soft surface, with the ultra-cushy Nimbus, then it's hard for me to
    imagine you could conceivably require even more cushion.

  13. Quoted message said:

    this "sammy" seems to have some credentials and experience to know
    what he's talking about. I don't,

    Hopefully nobody read any further than that.

  14. Luckily, most of the time I am in some of my retired running shoes
    (usually about 300 miles old), only wear dress shoes to meetings,
    company functions, etc. 80% of the time I am in running shoes.

  15. The Nimbae.

  16. On Sat, 25 Mar 2006 09:33:24 -0500, [email hidden] (Sir

    Lancelot) said:

    I'm going to be very blunt. Having your [censored] pounded by 30 or 40 hot,
    sweaty, horny runners in heat is nothing more than feat accomplishment.

    Even by a "Mandingo man" like you Lance? I understand your concern,
    but I figure a few real men will come by and see the line, and join
    in. But all I've had in the last few years has been lesbian sex, and I
    need some REAL sex now to heal my twittering mind.

    Quoted message said:

    It bears as much resemblance to real sex as trailrunning does to road
    racing. And that burn you'll feel afterwards won't be lactic burn.

    That's ok, I already have syphillis, my syphilitic ramblings prove
    that.

    Quoted message said:

    (Errr......just a rhetorical question...... if a prospective participant
    had a BMI of 29 would that be a problem?)

  17. Someone pounced upon my computer
    While I justly slept.

    My consent,
    Unsigned.
    ~ Twittering

    Quoted message said:

    On Sat, 25 Mar 2006 09:33:24 -0500, [email hidden] (Sir

    Lancelot) said:

    I'm going to be very blunt. Having your [censored] pounded by 30 or 40 hot,
    sweaty, horny runners in heat is nothing more than feat accomplishment.

    Even by a "Mandingo man" like you Lance? I understand your concern,
    but I figure a few real men will come by and see the line, and join
    in. But all I've had in the last few years has been lesbian sex, and I
    need some REAL sex now to heal my twittering mind.

    Quoted message said:

    It bears as much resemblance to real sex as trailrunning does to road
    racing. And that burn you'll feel afterwards won't be lactic burn.

    That's ok, I already have syphillis, my syphilitic ramblings prove
    that.

    Quoted message said:

    (Errr......just a rhetorical question...... if a prospective participant
    had a BMI of 29 would that be a problem?)

  18. Twittering One said:

    Someone pounced upon my computer
    While I justly slept.

    My consent,
    Unsigned.
    ~ Twittering

    Identity theft? Hijacking? There is only one ~Twitty.~

  19. Identity theft? Hijacking? There is only one ~Twitty.~
    ~ AB

    That post was not from me.
    But this is ~

    Dr. Cynthia Pfeffer, MD:

    I DO need medicine, oothpaste, shampoo, et al,
    and vitamins. Do you know what taking stims
    for ADD and taking no vitaimins does?

    It's like NO stuff to make neurotransmitters,
    because that canned food is nutrition-void
    [sinced the the people who know me, including
    doctors, REFUSE to even speak to me now,
    much less, pay for doctor visit].

    And that is JEOPARDIZING my health,
    which unnecessary, for whatever reason.

    If you are not responsible, please tell
    whoever is.

    Being sick at 50 y/o is no joke,
    even if you can pen a few poems on usenet.

    VIrginia Hooper

  20. email hidden said:

    Identity theft? Hijacking?

    She needs [censored].

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.