Road Cycling · Public discussion

Bar Ends and Clipless Pedals

Started by Neoinventor · · Last activity · 8 posts · 475 views

This thread is locked and is currently read-only.

Thread navigation

Jump through the discussion

Go to the original post, the replies on this page, or the latest preserved contribution.

Thread details

What we know about this thread

Original section
Road Cycling
Published
5 October 2004
Last activity
6 October 2004
Original author
Neoinventor
Posts
8
Discussion status
Public discussion
Total views
475
Views / 30 days
0

The navigation and discussion metadata provide context. Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Showing posts 1–8 of 8
Posts remain in their original chronological order.

Text size
  1. I don't understand the principle of bar ends - I put a higher handlebar (about
    4 1/2"😉 on my hybrid.
    - I can acess the brakes all the time
    - also if I hold them on the inside undreneath on the "V" it gives me a poor
    mans aero position.
    Why add [censored] when you don't have too??

    Also on my 10 speed I was thinking of going to clipless - how do I try them
    out?
    It would be nice to try them inorder for me to formulate opinion.
    (Although I realize most people don't need to know much about something inorder
    to arrive at an "Expert decision" and expert status).
    One fellow in front of me on a century ride, braked for a light on wet street
    and went down - I wasn't going to ask him if he tried to get his foot out.
    Also I take an occasional crash (flip) would hate to be trapped.
    Thanks In Advance (Provided you're not an Airhead and / or thave too much time
    on your hands - Why do people crank up their computers and convey mindless
    drivel? - I hope you don't think this applies to you!)
    Rob
    New York

  2. Quoted message said:

    I don't understand the principle of bar ends - I put a higher handlebar
    (about 4 1/2"😉 on my hybrid.
    - I can acess the brakes all the time
    - also if I hold them on the inside undreneath on the "V" it gives me a poor
    mans aero position.

    They can provide a better hand position for crankin' up the hills while
    standing. They also provide more hand positions, which can be nice if you
    ever do long rides on a bike with flat bars.

    Quoted message said:

    Why add [censored] when you don't have too??

    Well, if you find they give you no advantages you shouldn't; but there's
    no real performance drawbacks in this case. The added weight is
    insignificant for almost every purpose. The only real drawback is the
    "added clutter".

    Quoted message said:

    Also on my 10 speed I was thinking of going to clipless - how do I try
    them out? It would be nice to try them inorder for me to formulate
    opinion.

    If you don't want to buy a pair first, you'll have to either find an LBS
    that will let you do a test drive and can provide compatible shoes, or find
    a similar sized friend that uses these pedals.

    Quoted message said:

    (Although I realize most people don't need to know much about
    something inorder to arrive at an "Expert decision" and expert status).
    One fellow in front of me on a century ride, braked for a light on wet
    street and went down - I wasn't going to ask him if he tried to get his
    foot out. Also I take an occasional crash (flip) would hate to be
    trapped.

    Many clipless pedals will disengage in such situations, like ski bindings.
    Once you get used to clipless, you'll find they're significantly easier to
    get in and out of than clips and straps, if you've ever used these. (At
    least, this is my experience, and the same is reported by most other people
    I've heard from).

    I've heard very few reports from people who've tried clipless and decided
    that they *didn't* like them after a sufficient trial period, although you
    may find a few if you search the archives.

    I use these or similar on all my bikes:
    http://tinyurl.com/4oaca

    They only cost $28 Canadian, and I've never had any problems with them. I
    bought my first pair thinking I might get better ones if I liked them, but
    I've never seen the need to since then.

    --
    Benjamin Lewis

    Hey! I'm only fourteen, sickly 'n' thin
    Tried all of my life just to grow me a chin
    It popped out once, but my dad pushed it in. -- FZ

  3. Neoinventor wrote:
    || I don't understand the principle of bar ends - I put a higher
    || handlebar (about 4 1/2"😉 on my hybrid.
    || - I can acess the brakes all the time
    || - also if I hold them on the inside undreneath on the "V" it gives
    || me a poor mans aero position.
    || Why add [censored] when you don't have too??

    Bar-ends provide more hand positions which can make a big difference on long
    rides.

    ||
    || Also on my 10 speed I was thinking of going to clipless - how do I
    || try them out?

    You buy a pair, install them, get some shoes, and ride. Or, find a friend
    who has the same size feet as you and who rides clipless. Talk nice and
    bring beer....

    || It would be nice to try them inorder for me to formulate opinion.
    || (Although I realize most people don't need to know much about
    || something inorder to arrive at an "Expert decision" and expert
    || status).
    || One fellow in front of me on a century ride, braked for a light on
    || wet street and went down - I wasn't going to ask him if he tried to
    || get his foot out.

    I doubt if his going down had much to do with being clipped in...he was just
    likely not ready for the wet conditions.

    Also I take an occasional crash (flip) would hate
    || to be trapped.

    When I first went clipless, I crashed 3 times (on my first major ride) in 25
    miles. All three times I was barely moving. As I recall, my feet came out
    expect for the last time. In general though, it's not a big deal as you
    rarely go down unless you're an incompetent bicyclist.

    || Thanks In Advance (Provided you're not an Airhead and / or thave
    || too much time on your hands - Why do people crank up their computers
    || and convey mindless drivel? - I hope you don't think this applies to
    || you!)

    This is not a good way to elicit meaningful responses, dude.


  4. Quoted message said:


    When I first went clipless, I crashed 3 times (on my first major ride) in


    25

    Quoted message said:

    miles. All three times I was barely moving. As I recall, my feet came


    out

    Quoted message said:

    expect for the last time. In general though, it's not a big deal as you
    rarely go down unless you're an incompetent bicyclist.

    heh heh,

    fortunately, i rode clipless for the first time in deep snow (mountain
    biking).

    I think I fell to one side about 30 times that one ride. It was only a
    couple of years later, when I replaced those pedals, that I realized the
    right pedal was totally defective. I just assumed it was my fault that my
    foot kept getting stuck at a right angle (heel facing directly to my right)!

    Anyway, even though they aren't considered 'cool' nowadays, and the
    certainly look pretty dorky with riser bars, i think a small set of bar ends
    can be really helpful - especially on tough climbs.

    As far as clipless - go for it!! You'll learn quickly how to get out of the
    pedals. Now I ride anything technical I want - I can get out of the pedal
    pretty much as fast as with flats.

    They also make me feel very safe on the bike - there's no way my foot's
    gonna get knocked off.

    cheers,
    paul

  5. [email hidden] (Neoinventor) wrote in
    news:[email hidden]:

    Quoted message said:

    I don't understand the principle of bar ends

    Bar ends give you more leverage when climbing. They also move your center of
    gravity forward, which keeps your front wheel on the ground on steep hills.

    You have to be very careful of using the bar ends in traffic since fast braking
    from that hand position is very difficult. If you really want more hand
    positions, you should get a road-style handlebar with the brakes easily
    accessible from the major hand positions.

  6. In article <[email hidden]>,

    Benjamin Lewis said:

    [email hidden] wrote:

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    Also on my 10 speed I was thinking of going to clipless - how do I try
    them out? It would be nice to try them inorder for me to formulate
    opinion.

    Quoted message said:

    I've heard very few reports from people who've tried clipless and decided
    that they *didn't* like them after a sufficient trial period, although you
    may find a few if you search the archives.

    I use these or similar on all my bikes:
    http://tinyurl.com/4oaca

    They only cost $28 Canadian, and I've never had any problems with them. I
    bought my first pair thinking I might get better ones if I liked them, but
    I've never seen the need to since then.

    C$28...man that's cheap for an SPD pedal!

    I'd like to make a specific recommendation that among clipless designs,
    you go for a recessed-cleat design, which is to say a 2-hole cleat that
    fits on an SPD-compatible shoe (SPD or compatible, Eggbeaters, Ritchey,
    and many more).

    The reason is that these are walkable designs. Depending on the shoe,
    they range from a bit like a normal shoe to almost exactly like a normal
    shoe. Look and other large-cleat designs (SPD-SL, Speedplay, etc.) are
    worth investigating if you're a hardcore racer or have issues with "hot
    spots" using the SPD-type designs, but for everyone else a shoe you can
    happily walk in is a good thing.

    You wouldn't think this would be an issue on, oh, a club ride, but a few
    weeks back, a 20' section of our club ride was barricaded off for road
    work. As the other riders tottered around carefully on their Look
    cleats, I unclipped, hopped up onto the obstacle, and jumped down again.
    Axo Blackball shoes, by the way, have really nice soft rubber soles for
    this sort of stunt. I just like them because paid only C$20 new.

    -RjC.
    --
    Ryan Cousineau, [email hidden] http://www.wiredcola.com
    Verus de parvis; verus de magnis.

  7. Neoinventor said:

    I don't understand the principle of bar ends - I put a higher handlebar
    (about 4 1/2"😉 on my hybrid.

    Bar ends give you different hand positions. I find them helpful.

    Quoted message said:

    Also on my 10 speed I was thinking of going to clipless - how do I try
    them out?

    Most good shops would take them back if you were not satisfied with them.

    Quoted message said:

    It would be nice to try them inorder for me to formulate opinion.
    (Although I realize most people don't need to know much about something
    inorder to arrive at an "Expert decision" and expert status). One fellow
    in front of me on a century ride, braked for a light on wet street and
    went down - I wasn't going to ask him if he tried to get his foot out.
    Also I take an occasional crash (flip) would hate to be trapped.

    Clipless pedals will not trap your feet on the pedals. A sufficiently
    large force, such as happens in a crash, will release them. As far as
    whether or not I'm an "expert", that would be for you to discern. But I
    have crashed with clipless pedals, and my feet ended up separate from the
    pedals. I have also crashed when I used to use toeclips and cleats. I
    prefer clipless.

    Thanks

    Quoted message said:

    In Advance (Provided you're not an Airhead and / or thave too much time
    on your hands - Why do people crank up their computers and convey
    mindless drivel? - I hope you don't think this applies to you!) Rob New
    York

    You might get better responses if you tone down your attitude a bit.

    --

    David L. Johnson

    __o | "Business!" cried the Ghost. "Mankind was my business. The
    _`\(,_ | common welfare was my business; charity, mercy, forbearance,
    (_)/ (_) | and benevolence, were, all, my business. The dealings of my
    trade were but a drop of water in the comprehensive ocean of my
    business!" --Dickens, "A Christmas Carol"

  8. "Benjamin Lewis" <[email hidden]> wrote

    Quoted message said:
    Quoted message said:

    (Although I realize most people don't need to know much about
    something inorder to arrive at an "Expert decision" and expert status).
    One fellow in front of me on a century ride, braked for a light on wet
    street and went down - I wasn't going to ask him if he tried to get his
    foot out. Also I take an occasional crash (flip) would hate to be
    trapped.

    Many clipless pedals will disengage in such situations, like ski


    bindings.

    Quoted message said:

    Once you get used to clipless, you'll find they're significantly easier


    to

    Quoted message said:

    get in and out of than clips and straps, if you've ever used these. (At
    least, this is my experience, and the same is reported by most other


    people

    Quoted message said:

    I've heard from).

    A good friend of mine (and expert rider) shattered his leg in a slow-speed
    twisting fall this summer when his pedal (Eggbeater) didn't release. He
    presumes that his foot rotation was blocked by his heel hitting the crank.
    This may be a real problem with pedals that only release in rotation,
    particularly if they have a large release angle (float).

Active in the last 60 minutes

Active in this thread

0 users · 0 guests ·0 bots ·0 total

No signed-in users are active right now.

No known search crawlers active right now.