Walrus said:I'm always thinking about my next bike etc. I read the article in Pro
Cycling about the Serotta Ottrott (custom built carbon) and it got be
thinking.
What would a custom built frame in Australia cost? Who makes them?
How would they compare with "off the shelf" options?
A key question here is do you need a custom frame? Some people
do (or think they do), some don't. There's a lot of different
off the shelfers out there, and a lot of nonsense and
snake oil in both off the shelf sales pitches and custom
frame designs. It pays to be skeptical about any claims made
by anyone about how they're the only ones who can make a bike fit you.
Off the shelf designs have some advantages, often they're made by
manufacturers who have some very high quality control standards, do
destructive tests, and have lifetime warranties, which not all custom
frame builders would have the resources to match. Sometimes
(and probably not often) custom frame builders don't necessarily
understand the materials they're working with too. I'd be pretty
careful with a custom built CF frame in Australia, as I doubt there's
many makers who do much more than
chop and glue pipes into lugs. We're a small market and an even
smaller one for CF custom frames. There's not a lot of opportunity to
build up a lot of experience with CF. CF composites are the best
materials to make bicycles out of, but they require more understanding
of the material and more resources than slapping a bunch of steel pipes
into a jig and welding or brazing away, and if it's done wrong it will
break. If it's done right, it won't break, ever*. I expect my CF bike
will last a very long time indeed. Good manufacturers know this and
offer serious warranties. Good manufacturers also offer serious
warranties on Al and steelies, so again, check how confident
the manufacturer is that their bikes are well made and will last.
A lot of off the shelf CF bikes also suffer from manufacturers not
really understanding the properties of CF composites (anyone here
seen or ridden any of the early Raceline CF bikes? Urgh ....are any of
them still in one, uncracked, piece?). With a bunch of manufacturers
rushing to make CF bikes these days, it's wise to carefully check how
confident they are about how long the frame will last. Check their
warranty!
For what it's worth, I saw a brand-new Cracknfail Synapse today, with a
crushed seat tube (the gelcoat was blistered at the expansion joint
under the collar), so the carbon was probably damaged). This was fresh
out of the box, untouched by the bike shop that the frame had arrived
at. CF requires more careful handling than most metals ... Perhaps
that famous manufacturer may regret farming their manufacturing out
rather than doing it in-house? You don't always get what you think
you're paying for.
* under normal conditions. Crashes don't count 🙂